AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — F.M. Ibrahim Kalifulla, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant is the widow of Thiru P. Periyasamy, a line inspector employed by the respondent board, who died on 15.11.1996. The appellant first applied on 07.04.1997 for compassionate appointment for her elder son; that claim was rejected by the third respondent on 05.12.1998 on the ground that the elder son was over-aged. On 11.11.1999 the appellant made an application for compassionate appointment for her younger son; the younger son (Navamani) himself filed an application on 01.04.2000, supported by no-objection letters from his other brothers. The respondent board called for further details (communication dated 10.04.2000) and ultimately rejected the younger son's claim by communication dated 24.09.2001 (second respondent), stating that the claimant had not completed 18 years within the three-year period, had not passed the 8th standard, and that the application was not made within three years. The third respondent reiterated rejection by communication dated 12.07.2002. The appellant challenged these communications by a writ petition; a learned single Judge relied on a Supreme Court decision (National Hydroelectric Power Corporation v. Nanak Chand) and dismissed the claim as belated. The appellant appealed to the court that produced the present opinion.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellant's claim for compassionate appointment (for her younger son) was belated and therefore rightly rejected as outside the three-year period prescribed by the prevailing rules.
  2. Whether an application filed prior to the younger son's attainment of majority (and subsequently renewed after majority) could be treated as a timely application for the purposes of compassionate appointment.
  3. Whether the board's technical grounds (age within three years, educational qualification stated as pass in 8th standard, and delay) justified rejection in the factual matrix of persistent pursuit by a widow who applied first in 1997 and later for her younger son.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant had diligently pursued the claim from 07.04.1997 (application for elder son) through the subsequent application for the younger son on 11.11.1999 and the younger son's renewal on 01.04.2000; this shows continuous effort to obtain compassionate appointment and militates against treating the claim as belated.
  • The initial application in 1997 and the steps taken thereafter meant that the respondents should have adopted a sympathetic and practical approach rather than rejecting the claim on hyper-technical grounds.
  • Reliance was placed on decisions of the Division Bench and a single Judge of this Court (including Chief Engineer/Personnel, TNEB v. K. Lakshmi; P. Ravi v. Chief Engineer/Personnel, TNEB; and T. Meer Ismail Ali v. TNEB) to support the view that the appellant's claim ought to be considered despite the stated procedural objections.
  • The decision relied upon by the single Judge (National Hydroelectric Power Corporation v. Nanak Chand) was distinguishable on its facts and therefore inapplicable.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The applicable rules required that an application for compassionate appointment be made within three years from the date of death of the employee; the last application in this matter (01.04.2000) was outside that three-year period and therefore liable to be rejected as belated.
  • Even if the application dated 11.11.1999 is regarded as within time, the younger son had not attained 18 years of age by that date and therefore the application could not be deemed properly made within the three-year eligibility period.
  • The respondent relied upon the Supreme Court decision in National Hydroelectric Power Corporation v. Nanak Chand to support rejection on the ground of delay.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
National Hydroelectric Power Corporation and another v. Nanak Chand and another, AIR 2005 SC 106 : (2004) 12 SCC 487 Authority used by the learned single Judge to uphold rejection on the ground of belated claim (delay). The court distinguished this precedent on facts: in Nanak Chand the application was made nearly ten years after the death and the Corporation was not answerable to the applicant; therefore its ratio was held inapplicable to the present facts.
T. Meer Ismail Ali v. Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, Chennai and others, (2004) 4 MLJ 238 Authority relied upon by the appellant to support a less technical, more sympathetic approach in considering compassionate appointment claims where applicants have been diligent. The court treated this decision as supportive of the appellant's position and invoked it in concluding that the appellant's claim ought to have been favourably considered.
P. Ravi v. Chief Engineer/Personnel, Tamil Nadu Electricity Board and another, 2002 (4) L.L.N. 1132 (and reported references cited by counsel) Authority relied upon by the appellant for the proposition that compassionate appointment claims should be considered sympathetically where the applicant has pursued the claim diligently. The court regarded this decision as supporting the appellant's claim and relied upon it in finding that the respondents' rejections were not justifiable.
Chief Engineer/Personnel, Tamil Nadu Electricity Board and another v. K. Lakshmi, (reported references cited by counsel, e.g., 2005 WLR 256) Decision of the Division Bench of the High Court cited by the appellant to show precedents favouring consideration of compassionate appointment claims in factual situations of diligent pursuit. The court found that the Division Bench decision supports the appellant and referred to it in concluding that the claim should have been favourably considered.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by emphasizing the humanitarian purpose of compassionate appointment schemes — to extend help to a destitute widow on the death of her husband — and cautioned against defeating that purpose by adopting hyper-technical approaches.

The court then reviewed the chronological facts: death of the husband on 15.11.1996; an application on 07.04.1997 for the elder son (within five months of death); rejection of that application on 05.12.1998 because the elder son was over-aged; the appellant's subsequent application for the younger son on 11.11.1999 (filed so as to fall within the three-year window which would end on 14.11.1999); the younger son's attaining majority on 15.03.2000; and the son's renewal of the application on 01.04.2000 along with no-objection letters.

Applying the facts, the court reasoned that the appellant had been diligently pursuing the compassionate appointment claim from 1997 through 2000 and that the timing and sequence of applications (initial application in 1997, subsequent application for younger son filed on 11.11.1999 and renewed on 01.04.2000) should have prompted a sympathetic and pragmatic response from the respondents rather than outright rejection on technical grounds.

On precedent, the court accepted that the single Judge had relied on the Supreme Court decision in Nanak Chand, but it distinguished that case on its materially different facts: the application there was made nearly ten years after the death and involved a Corporation not answerable to the applicant. Because of those factual differences, the court held that the ratio of Nanak Chand did not apply to the present case. Conversely, the court found that the decisions cited by the appellant (T. Meer Ismail Ali, P. Ravi, and the Division Bench in K. Lakshmi) supported a favourable view of the appellant's persistent pursuit and should inform a more charitable approach.

On the question of eligibility and the three-year requirement, the court effectively treated the appellant's efforts (including filing on 11.11.1999 and renewal on 01.04.2000) as sufficient to require the board to consider the claim on merits rather than reject it for delay; it concluded that the respondents' rejections were not justifiable in the circumstances.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The writ appeal is allowed. The communications rejecting the appellant's claim dated 24.09.2001 (second respondent) and 12.07.2002 (third respondent) are set aside.

Directives and Immediate Consequences: The respondents are directed to entertain the appellant's application dated 11.11.1999 together with the younger son's application dated 01.04.2000 and to pass appropriate orders for granting compassionate appointment to the appellant's younger son (Navamani) expeditiously — preferably within three months from the date of receipt of a copy of the order.

No broader new legal principle or precedent was expressly formulated by the court beyond its application of existing authorities and the factual distinction of Nanak Chand; the decision's immediate effect is to require reconsideration and possible appointment in this specific factual matrix.

    P. Rajamani (Tmt.) v. Chairman, Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, 800, Anna Salai, Chennai And Others

    F.M. IBRAHIM KALIFULLA, J.

    Appellant is the wife of one Thiru.P.Periyasamy who was employed as a line inspector in the respondent board and who died in harness on 15.11.1996. After his death, an application was made by the appellant for compassionate appointment for her elder son by an application dated 07.04.1997. After calling for details through a communication dated 09.07.1997, the third respondent rejected the claim for compassionate appointment for the elder son by a communication dated 05.12.1998 on the ground that the elder son of the appellant was over aged.

    2. Thereafter, on 11. 11. 1999, the appellant applied for compassionate appointment for her younger son. The said application was forwarded to the second respondent. Her younger son by name Navamani himself made an application on 1.4.2000, along with no objection letters from his other brothers, seeking compassionate appointment. In the said application, details were again called for by the respondent board through its communication dated 10.4.2000. It is relevant to note that though appellant's younger son Navamani applied for compassionate appointment on 11.11.1999 he became major only on 15.3.2000. Nevertheless, his application dated 11.11.1999 was renewed by a personal application made by Navamani himself on 1.4.2000. The claim for such compassionate appointment came to be rejected by the second respondent by a communication dated 24.9.2001 on the ground that the present claim for compassionate appointment for the younger son cannot be considered since he had not completed 18 years within three years period and he had not satisfied the educational qualification of a pass in the 8th standard. It was also stated therein that the application was not made within three years.

    3. The third respondent also reiterated the same reasons while rejecting the claim for compassionate appointment in his communication dated 12.7.2002. The appellant preferred the present writ petition challenging the above communication and the learned single Judge of this Court, by relying upon the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court reported in National Hydroelectric, Power Corporation and another v. Nanak Chand and another National Hydroelectric, Power Corporation and another v. Nanak Chand and another National Hydroelectric, Power Corporation and another v. Nanak Chand and another AIR 2005 SC 106: (2004) 12 SCC 487: 2005-I-LLJ-240: 2005-3-L.W. 66, held that the claim of the appellant cannot be considered as it was belated in point of time.

    4. Mr. Chitharanjandas, learned counsel appearing for the appellant contended that the appellant's case cannot be construed as one of belated claim since immediately after the death of her husband, an application was preferred on 7.4.1997 for her elder son and since the same was rejected on the ground that he was over aged, the appellant made a subsequent application for her younger son on 11.11.1999, who became major only on 15.3.2000. According to the learned counsel since the appellant was diligently agitating her representation for compassionate appointment right from 7.4.1997 till the filing of the last application on 1.4.2000 for her younger son, the respondents were not justified in rejecting the said claim on the ground of delay as well as on the ground that her younger son also did not become major at the time of the second application. Learned counsel for the appellant relied upon the decisions of the Division Bench of this Court as well as that of a learned single Judge reported in Chief Engineer/Personnel, Tamil Nadu. Electricity Board and another v. K.Lakshmi Chief Engineer/Personnel, Tamil Nadu. Electricity Board and another v. K.Lakshmi Chief Engineer/Personnel, Tamil Nadu. Electricity Board and another v. K.Lakshmi , 2005 WLR 256, P. Ravi v. Chief Engineer/Personnel, Tamil Nadu Electricity Board and another P. Ravi v. Chief Engineer/Personnel, Tamil Nadu Electricity Board and another P. Ravi v. Chief Engineer/Personnel, Tamil Nadu Electricity Board and another 2002 (4) L.L.N. 1132: 2005 Writ L.R. 256: 2005-2-L.W. 62(l) S.N. and T. Meer Ismail Ali v. Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, Chennai and others T. Meer Ismail Ali v. Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, Chennai and others T. Meer Ismail Ali v. Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, Chennai and others , (2004) 4 MLJ 238. Learned counsel further contended that the decision relied upon by the learned single Judge reported in (2004) 12 SCC 1292 is distinguishable.

    5. As against the above submission, Mr.Patturajan, learned counsel appearing for the respondent Board contended that as per the rules prevailing as on date, since an application for appointment on compassionate ground should be made within three years from the date of death of the employee and since the last application was made only on 1.4.2000, the respondent Board was justified in rejecting the said application on the ground of delay. According to the learned counsel, even if the application stated to have been sent on 11.11.1999 can be held to be within time namely 14.11.1999, since the person for whom the appointment was sought for namely the last son of the appellant had not attained the age of 18 years by that date, that application cannot be said to have been made within time. Learned counsel, therefore, contended that applying the decision of the Hon ble Supreme Court reported in National Hydroelectric, Power Corporation and another v. Nanak Chand and another National Hydroelectric, Power Corporation and another v. Nanak Chand and another National Hydroelectric, Power Corporation and another v. Nanak Chand and another (supra) . the order impugned in the writ petition cannot be interfered with.

    6. Having heard the submission made by the learned counsel for the respondents, we are not able to appreciate and accept the stand of the respondents. We hasten to state that the very purport of extending a helping hand to a destitute on the death of her husband by way of compassionate appointment would get defeated if such claims are turned down on such hypher technical ground. In the case on hand, as noted earlier, after the death of the appellant's husband on 15.11.1996, an application was made on 7.4.1997 for compassionate appointment for her elder son. Therefore, there was an application for compassionate appointment within five months from the date of the death of her husband. It was unfortunate that the said application came to be rejected on the ground that her elder son was over aged. Such rejection was made only on 5.12.1998. Therefore,the appellant had to necessarily wait for some more time in order to renew her claim for appointment of her younger son who was running 18 years as on 11.11.1999. The said younger son completed his 18 years on 15.3.2000. Nevertheless, the appellant wanted to ensure that an application was made on 11.11.1999 itself for that son in order to confirm that an application for compassionate appointment was made well within time i.e. before 14.11.1999 by which time the three years period from the date of death of her husband would come to an end. Subsequently, on 1.4.2000, her younger son himself renewed the application preferred by the appellant on 11.11.1999 by making another application along with the no objection letters of his other brothers. Therefore, all the above steps taken by the appellant go to show that she was diligently pursuing her claiming for compassionate appointment over the death of her husband right from the year 1997 till 1.4.2000. In such circumstances, when the appellant being a widow and since she had no other source of livelihood, the respondents should have been much more sympathetic and practical in considering the claim of the appellant for compassionate appointment to her younger son based on the application dated 11.11.1999 and 1.4.2000. In this context, the decision relied upon by the learned counsel for the appellant reported in T. Meer Ismail Ali v. Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, Chennai and others T. Meer Ismail Ali v. Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, Chennai and others T. Meer Ismail Ali v. Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, Chennai and others (supra) and P. Ravi v. Chief Engineer/Personnel, Tamil Nadu Electricity Board and another P. Ravi v. Chief Engineer/Personnel, Tamil Nadu Electricity Board and another P. Ravi v. Chief Engineer/Personnel, Tamil Nadu Electricity Board and another (supra) as well as the decision of the Division Bench reported in Chief Engineer/Personnel, Tamil Nadu. Electricity Board and another v. K.Lakshmi Chief Engineer/Personnel, Tamil Nadu. Electricity Board and another v. K.Lakshmi Chief Engineer/Personnel, Tamil Nadu. Electricity Board and another v. K.Lakshmi (supra) , fully supports the claim of the appellant. As far as the decision reported in National Hydroelectric, Power Corporation and another v. Nanak Chand and another National Hydroelectric, Power Corporation and another v. Nanak Chand and another National Hydroelectric, Power Corporation and another v. Nanak Chand and another (supra) , is concerned, that was a case where the application came to be made nearly after 10 years after the death of the deceased employee. Further, the Hon ble Supreme Court has noted that the application was made to the appellant Corporation therein which was not answerable to the claim of the applicant for compassionate appointment. Therefore, the facts involved in that case have no application to the facts of the case on hand. The ratio laid down therein cannot, therefore, be applied to the facts of this case.

    7. For all the above reasons, we are convinced that the claim of the appellant for compassionate appointment for her younger son Navamani ought to have been favourably considered by the respondent Board. The rejection of the appellant's claim by the communication dated 24.9.2001 by the second respondent as well as the communication dated 12.7.2002 by the third respondent are therefore not justifiable and accordingly, the same are set aside. The writ appeal stands allowed. The respondents are directed to entertain the application of the appellant dated 11.11.1999 along with the application of her younger son Navamani dated 1.4.2000 and pass appropriate orders for granting compassionate appointment to the younger son of the appellant expeditiously, preferably within three months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    P. Rajamani (Tmt.) v. Chairman, Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, 800, Anna Salai, Chennai And Others
    (Nov 14, 2006)