Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • section 66(1) of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922,
  • section 23(5)(a) of the Indian Income-tax Act
  • section 23(5) and section 17. Section 17
  • sub-section (5)(a) of section 23
  • sub-section (1) of section 4,
  • sub-sections (1), (3) and (4).
  • INCOME TAX ACT
  • section 4(1)(c).
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • section 66(1) of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922,
  • section 23(5)(a) of the Indian Income-tax Act
  • section 23(5) and section 17. Section 17
  • sub-section (5)(a) of section 23
  • sub-section (1) of section 4,
  • sub-sections (1), (3) and (4).
  • INCOME TAX ACT
  • section 4(1)(c).
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This is a reference under section 66(1) of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922 arising from two questions referred by the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal of Bombay concerning assessment of the share income of a non-resident partner and the correctness of levy of tax at the maximum rate.

The assessee is a registered firm, Gnanam and Sons, Colombo, resident and ordinarily resident in the taxable territories, carrying on business in Colombo. The firm has four partners: three resident in India and one non-resident (Kumaraswamy). The non-resident partner's share income was computed at Rs. 3,667 for assessment year 1951-52 and Rs. 4,337 for 1952-53.

The Income-tax Officer, after obtaining the Commissioner's sanction, proceeded under section 34 and made assessments on the firm under the second proviso to section 23(5)(a), calculating tax by applying section 17 (maximum rate for non-residents). The firm appealed unsuccessfully to the Assistant Commissioner and the Tribunal. The Tribunal referred the two legal questions to this Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the assessment of the share income of the non-resident partner under the second proviso to section 23(5)(a) of the Indian Income-tax Act is justified in law?
  2. Whether the levy of tax at the maximum rate is correct?

Arguments of the Parties

Assessee's (Appellant's) Arguments

  • Under section 23(5)(a) for a registered firm, the share income of each partner is to be included in the total income of each partner and assessed; therefore the "total income" of the non-resident partner must be determined in the manner prescribed by the Act.
  • The definition of "total income" refers to income computed as per section 4(1). Under section 4(1)(c), income which accrues or arises to a person outside the taxable territories is not included in the total income of a person not ordinarily resident, unless certain conditions are met.
  • Therefore, the non-resident partner's share of firm income that arose wholly outside the taxable territories (in Ceylon) and was not brought into the taxable territories should be excluded by operation of section 4(1)(c), yielding nil taxable income under the second proviso.
  • It was also argued that the decision in Badridas Daga v. Commissioner of Income Tax (1949) relied upon by the authorities does not apply to the present facts (this contention is recorded and addressed by the Court).

Revenue's (Respondent's) Position as Reflected in the Opinion

  • The Income-tax Officer assessed the non-resident partner's share under the second proviso to section 23(5)(a) and computed tax under section 17, which prescribes levy at the maximum rate for non-residents; the firm paid the sum so determined.
  • The Tribunal endorsed that treatment and found that the firm's application under the proviso to section 17 was filed late (an issue noted but not decided in this reference).
  • The department treated the non-resident partner's share of the firm's income as the relevant amount for tax levy and applied section 17 accordingly.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Badridas Daga v. Commissioner Of Income Tax [1949] 17 I.T.R. 209 (P.C.) Held that a non-resident partner of a resident firm is not entitled to exclude from his share of partnership profits that portion which accrued or arose outside the taxable territories by resort to section 4(1)(c); the second proviso to section 23(5)(a) makes no provision for such a deduction. The Court relied on this decision to support the conclusion that the non-resident partner's share of the firm's income could not be reduced by section 4(1)(c) and that the share is assessable as such under the proviso; the precedent was treated as directly on point and persuasive for affirming the assessments.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court conducted a textual and contextual construction of section 23(5) together with section 17 and section 3 of the Act, and proceeded in the following steps based on the material in the opinion:

  1. Interpretation of section 23(5): The prefatory words of sub-section (5) require that the total income of the firm be determined first under sub-sections (1), (3) or (4). Sub-section (5)(a) then prescribes consequences for registered firms, bifurcating into (i) the normal case where partners are resident, and (ii) the second proviso addressing cases where any partner is non-resident.
  2. Nature of the second proviso: The Court emphasised that in the part of sub-section (5)(a) dealing with a non-resident partner, the statute provides that "his share of the income, profits and gains of the firm shall be assessed on the firm at the rates which would be applicable if it were assessed on him personally, and the sum so determined as payable shall be paid by the firm." The Court reasoned that this language makes clear that the non-resident partner's total income is not being assessed; rather, only his share of the firm's income is made liable to assessment (and payable by the firm).
  3. Consequences for applying section 4(1)(c): Because the statute requires assessment of the share of the firm (and not the non-resident's comprehensive "total income" under section 4(1)), the Court held there is no basis for computing that share by reference to section 4(1) and excluding income under section 4(1)(c). The operation of section 4(1)(c) would only arise where computation of an assessee's total income is undertaken; that is not the case under the proviso.
  4. Application of section 17 (maximum rate): Section 17 addresses tax determination for non-residents and prescribes tax at the maximum rate on "total income", subject to an option (by written notice) allowing assessment with reference to world income. The Court observed that, in the context of a non-resident partner of a resident registered firm, the expression "total income" in section 17 must be read in conformity with the method of determination under section 23(5). Consequently, the department is entitled to treat the partner's share of firm income as the "total income" for the purpose of section 17 and tax it at the maximum rate.
  5. Practical necessity and statutory purpose: The Court noted the practical difficulty and impossibility for the department to ascertain all worldwide sources of income of a non-resident partner; hence the statutory scheme appropriately permits taxation of the partner's share as assessed on the firm and to apply section 17 rates.
  6. Support from section 3: Section 3 identifies taxable entities including firms. The Court reasoned that while registered firms receive the special facility of levy upon individual partners, that concession is taken away when a partner is non-resident and not reachable by authorities; thus the proviso's requirement that the firm pay the sum determined at the rates applicable to that non-resident brings section 17 into operation.
  7. Consideration of precedent: The Court reviewed Badridas Daga (P.C.) and concluded that the Judicial Committee had previously considered and rejected the contention that a non-resident partner's share could be reduced by reference to section 4(1)(c). The Court treated that decision as directly applicable and confirmatory of the statutory construction reached.

Holding and Implications

Holding: Both questions were answered in the affirmative and against the assessee.

Direct consequences for the parties:

  • The assessment of the non-resident partner's share income under the second proviso to section 23(5)(a) was held to be justified in law.
  • The levy of tax at the maximum rate under section 17 was upheld as correct in the circumstances.
  • The assessee (the firm) was ordered to pay the costs of the respondent; counsel's fee was fixed at Rs. 250.

The opinion does not purport to create a new legal principle beyond applying the statutory text and the existing precedent (Badridas Daga). No broader implications were expressly discussed beyond the direct effect on assessment and tax liability in the present case.

    Gnanam And Sons v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax, Madras.

    The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

    Srinivasan, J.:— This is a reference under section 66(1) of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922, and the following two questions have been referred to us by the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal of Bombay:

    “1. Whether the assessment of the share income of the non-resident partner under the second proviso to section 23(5)(a) of the Indian Income-tax Act in the hands of the assessee firm is justified in law?

    2. Whether the levy of tax at the maximum rate is correct?”

    2. The facts leading to this reference are briefly these. A firm, consisting of four partners, styled Gnanam and Sons, Colombo, is carrying on business in Colombo. This firm is an admittedly resident and ordinarily resident firm in the taxable territories. Of the four partners, three are also admitted to be resident in India. One of the partners, Kumaraswamy, is a non-resident, and his share income was computed at Rs. 3,667 for the assessment year 1951-52 and Rs. 4,337 for the assessment year 1952-53. The Income-tax Officer took proceedings under section 34 of the Act after obtaining the prior sanction of the Commissioner and made orders of assessment on the firm under the second proviso to section 23(5)(a). In making these assessments, he calculated the tax payable by the application of section 17 of the Act, which provides for the levy of the tax at the maximum rate. The asseseee, the firm, appealed to the Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax and to the Tribunal unsuccessfully. Thereupon an application for reference was made with the result that the matter is now before us.

    3. It has been argued on behalf of the assessee that under section 23(5)(a), in the case of a registered firm, the share income of each partner of the firm is liable to be included in the total income of each partner and assessed; and the sum payable by such partner has to be determined on the basis of such assessment. The argument proceeds that it is the total income of the non-resident partner that has to be determined for the purpose of the application of the second proviso to the above section. Turning to the definition of “total income,” it is claimed that it is the total amount of income, profits and gains referred to in sub-section (1) of section 4, the computation of which must be made in the manner laid down in the Act. Under section 4(1)(c), however, in the case of a person not ordinarily resident in the taxable territories, the income, profits and gains which accrue or arise to him without the taxable territories shall not be so included unless they are derived from a business controlled in, or a profession or a vocation set up, in India or unless they are brought into or received in the taxable territories by him during the year. Pursuing this line of argument, it is contended that what sub-section (5)(a) of section 23 intends to tax is the total income of each partner of the firm, including therein his share of its income, profits and gains of the previous year, and this concept of the total income must be carried into the proviso relevant to a non-resident partner. It would accordingly mean that since this income arose wholly outside the taxable territories and was not brought into the taxable territories, it has to be excluded by the operation of section 4(1)(c) of the Act, with the result that the income that is liable to be taxed under the second proviso is nil.

    4. This line of argument appears to be simple, but it seems to us that on a close reading of the section, the expected result cannot possibly follow. Section 23 of the Act, which relates to assessment, provides for the assessment of the total income of the assessee, and for the determination of the tax payable by him in sub-sections (1), (3) and (4). The special case of a firm is dealt with in sub-section (5). Sub-section (5)(a) deals with registered firms and (5)(b) deals with unregistered firms. It is admitted that this firm is a registered firm. The relevant part of section 23(5) reads:

    (a) “In the case of a registered firm, the sum payable by the firm itself shall not be determined but the total income of each partner of the firm, including therein his share of its income, profits and gains of the previous year, shall be assessed and the sum payable by him on the basis of such assessment shall be determined:……

    Provided further that when any of such partners is a person not resident in the taxable territories, his share of the income, profits and gains of the firm shall be assessed on the firm at the rates which would be applicable if it were assessed on him personally, and the sum so determined as payable shall be paid by the firm.”

    5. Section 23(5) commences by saying:

    “Notwithstanding anything contained in the foregoing sub-sections, when the assessee is a firm and the total income of the firm has been assessed under sub-section (1), sub-section (3) or sub-section (4), as the case may be.”

    6. It is clear from the wording of the prefatory part of the subsection that in the case of a firm, the total income of the firm has first of all to be determined. Sub-sections (a) and (b) lay down what consequences follow according as the firm is a registered or an unregistered one. Sub-section (5)(a) falls naturally into two parts. The first part deals with the case where all the partners of the firm are resident in the taxable territories, in which event the total income of the firm as assessed is not brought to tax but the total income of each partner of the firm including therein his share of such assessment is determined. In the latter part of the section covered by the second proviso, the case where any of such partners happens to be a nonresident has been dealt with. While in the case of a partner who is a resident in the taxable territories, the earlier part of the section provides for the assessment of his total income, including therein his share of the firm's income, in the latter part of the section dealing with a non-resident, the total income of the non-resident partner does not come in for assessment at all. It is only his share of the firm's income that is made liable for assessment, and the sum so determined as payable is made payable by the firm. The argument that this proviso calls for the determination of the total income of the non-resident partner therefore fails. On the language of this proviso, there does not, therefore, appear to be any ground for computing the income of such non-resident partner with reference to section 4(1) of the Act and for excluding the income derived without the taxable territories by the operation of section 4(1)(c). It is obvious that such a course would be called for only when the computation of the total income of the assessee is undertaken.

    7. Nextly, it is claimed that the department and the Tribunal erred in holding that section 17 is applicable to the case, and that the income so assessed was liable to be taxed at the maximum rate. Section 17 deals with the determination of tax payable in certain special cases. It lays down: “(1) When a person is not resident in the taxable territories and is not a company, the tax, including super-tax, payable by him or on his behalf on his total income shall be an amount equal to—(a) the income which would be payable on his total income at the maximum rate, plus……” There is a proviso to this section which enables the assessee to declare by notice in writing to the Income-tax Officer that the tax including super-tax payable by him or on his behalf on his total income shall be determined with reference to his total world income. This proviso indicates that an option is given to a non-resident called upon to pay tax under section 17(1)(a) to agree to be assessed with reference to his total world income. He is required to indicate his option by a notice in writing to the Income-tax Officer. It is not necessary to examine whether such an option was properly exercised or not, because that matter has not been raised in this reference, and it has been found by the Tribunal that an application in this regard was made by the firm long after the due date. But the question for consideration in this connection is whether section 17(1)(a) was properly applied.

    8. It is true that section 17 refers to the total income of a non-resident, and since total income, according to the definition, would exclude the income which accrued or was derived from without the taxable territories, the argument is advanced that the incomes covered by this reference having arisen in Ceylon, and not having been received within the taxable territories, ought to be excluded. It seems to us that this argument must fail on a proper construction and upon a combined reading of section 23(5) and section 17. Section 17 deals with the special case of a non-resident, and provides that the tax payable by such non-resident should be calculated at the maximum rate. It is true that this section uses the expression “total income”, but in the case of a non-resident, who is a partner of a resident registered firm, this expression “total income” should be construed in conformity with the determination of the taxable income of such non-resident partner under section 23(5). This section specifies that the non-resident's share of the firm's income is assessable and does not render the determination of the taxable income subject to the other provisions of the Act. That being so, the department is entitled to consider his share in the firm income as the total income for the purpose of levy of tax. It is obvious that in the case of a non-resident, it is impossible for the department to be aware without information furnished by such non-resident of all his sources of income in the taxable territories or elsewhere so that the total income within the meaning of section 2(15) cannot possibly be worked out. If the total income of such a non-resident person could be assessed in the same manner as the total income of the resident partners of the firm is assessed under the first part of sub-section (5), clause (a), there would be no difficulty in making an assessment of the tax at the rates applicable to that income. But that is not the case. Nor is it open to the department to call upon the non-resident to submit a return of his total income. It seems to us, therefore, that in the special case of a non-resident partner of a resident firm, the rate which would be applicable to him if his share of the income were assessed on him personally is the rate that is laid down in section 17 of the Act.

    9. In coming to the above conclusion we are further supported in our view by section 3 of the Act as well. Under section 3 tax is payable in respect of the total income of the previous year of every individual, Hindu undivided family, company and local authority and of every firm and other association of persons or the partners of the firm or the members of the association individually. One of the taxable entities is accordingly a firm and though in the case of a registered firm, the tax payable by the firm itself is not determined, but the share income of each of these partners is assessed to tax in the hands of each such partner, including such share income in the total income of such partner, the assessee is undoubtedly the firm itself, and it is only as a special privilege for registered firms that the levy of tax is made upon the individual partners. This concession which is given by sub-section (5)(a) is taken away in a case where any partner of the firm happens to be a non-resident and cannot consequently be reached by the taxing authorities. It seems to be for that reason that the levy of tax is made on the firm itself in respect of the share income of such non-resident partner at the rate at which such a non-resident would be liable to pay tax. This part of the provision of the proviso clearly brings section 17 into operation.

    10. It was argued by Sri Srinivasan for the assessee that the decision in Badridas Daga v. Commissioner Of Income Tax [1949] 17 I.T.R 209 P.C., relying upon which the income-tax authorities have made the assessments and the Tribunal had dismissed the appeals, does not apply to the facts of the present case. A careful reading of this decision, however, inclines us to the view, that the very point that has been raised by the assessee in this case demanding the exclusion of that portion of the income which arose outside the taxable territories, viz., the share income of the non-resident partner of the assessee firm, came in for examination by the Judicial Committee, and it was clearly held that a non-resident partner of the resident firm is not entitled to exclude from his total income such proportionate share of the profits of the said firm which accrued or arose to it without British India under section 4(1)(c) of the Act. The facts of that case were that a firm had income which accrued to it both within and without the taxable territories. The firm was a resident in the taxable territories. Some partners of the firm were not resident in British India. When the whole of their shares of the firm income was included in the total income for the purpose of income-tax, they objected and claimed to be enabled to exclude a proportion of those shares corresponding to the proportion of the firm's income which arose or accrued outside British India. Their Lordships dealt specifically with the second proviso to section 23(5)(a) and observed that this section while laying down that the share of such a partner shall be assessed on the firm at the rates which would be applicable if it were assessed on him personally, makes no provision for any deduction from that share in respect of any part of the partnership profits having arisen outside British India. They proceeded to point out the difficulties that would be encountered in determining what part of the income of the firm was such that if it were income of a person not resident or not ordinarily resident in British India would not be part of his total income within the meaning of the Income-tax Act. Apart from these difficulties, such a contention, in the view of their Lordships, would involve reading into the section things which are not there, which would complicate its application and would lead to practical difficulties. But they clearly laid down that in the case of a non-resident partner of a resident firm, his share of the firm's income is not liable to be reduced in any manner by resort to section 4(1)(c).

    11. The result is that both the questions are answered in the affirmative and against the assessee. The assessee will pay the costs of the respondent. Counsel's fee Rs. 250.

    12. Questions answered in the affirmative.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Gnanam And Sons v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax, Madras.
    (Jul 28, 1960)