Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • section 2(1)(ii),
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • section 2(1)(ii),
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

These Second Appeals arise out of five suits originally filed in the Court of the District Munsif, Karur, and have been consolidated for consideration. The principal dispute concerns the character of certain inam lands: whether they were inams granted to the Jamia Masjid Mosque, Karur, or were personal inams granted to an ancestor of Kazi Syed Abdullah Batcha and burdened with the performance of Kazi service.

Syed Ahmed Batcha (father of Syed Abdullah Batcha) served as Muthawalli of the mosque and as Kazi appointed by Government from 14 December 1928 to 24 April 1948. Following disputes among Muslim residents, Ganiappa Rowther was appointed Muthawalli and Abdul Rahiman was appointed Kazi on a salaried basis.

Relevant suits and appeals:

  • O.S. No. 118 of 1960 (filed by Ganiappa Rowther in his capacity as Muthawalli) — sought recovery of arrears; gave rise to Second Appeal No. 1924 of 1962.
  • O.S. Nos. 322, 345 and 485 of 1960 (filed by Syed Abdullah Batcha) — against tenants for recovery of amounts as rent or as damages/use and occupation; gave rise to S.A. Nos. 1926, 1928 and 1925 of 1962. Defendants in these suits set up title in the mosque represented by Muthawalli Ganiappa Rowther.
  • O.S. No. 218 of 1960 (filed by Syed Abdullah Batcha) — sought a declaration that the Wakf Board notification declaring the properties to be wakf was illegal and ultra vires; gave rise to S.A. No. 1927 of 1962.

At trial, the Court dismissed O.S. No. 118 but decreed O.S. Nos. 322, 345, 485 and 218 in favour of Syed Abdullah Batcha. The District Judge of Tiruchirapalli, on appeal, allowed all five appeals brought to that court: decreeing O.S. No. 118 (in favour of the mosque/Muthawalli) and dismissing the suits instituted by Syed Abdullah Batcha. These Second Appeals challenge the judgments and decrees of the lower appellate court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the disputed inam grants are grants to the Jamia Masjid Mosque (i.e., institutional inams) or are personal inams granted to the ancestor of Syed Abdullah Batcha and burdened with Kazi service (i.e., personal inams with a condition of service).
  2. Whether the property (regardless of being institutional or personal inam) is wakf property and consequently whether the Wakf Board's notification declaring it wakf was illegal and ultra vires (as contended in O.S. No. 218 / S.A. No. 1927).

Arguments of the Parties

Jamia Masjid / Muthawalli (Ganiappa Rowther) — Principal arguments relied upon

  • The entries in the Inam Fair Register (notably column 21: "To be confirmed free in one title deed so long as the Kazi service is rendered") should be read as indicating that the grant was made in favour of the mosque — the language, it was submitted, pointed to an institutional grant.
  • The remark in the register, "This will be confirmed as inam attached to the mosque at Karur", was relied upon as strongly indicative (arguably conclusive) that the grant belonged to the mosque.
  • The use of the word "permanent" (column 10) was relied upon as consistent with institutional grants (as opposed to personal grants described as "hereditary").
  • Relied on authorities (including Madras v. Thadikonda Koteswara Rao; Sami Ayyangar v. Venkataramana; Lakshminarasimhachari v. Sri Agastheswaraswami Varu; and Hindu Religious Endowments Board v. Koteswara) to support the contention that entries like those in column 21 may indicate a grant to an institution when read in context with other entries.

Syed Abdullah Batcha (and predecessors / heirs) — Principal arguments relied upon

  • The entry "Dharmadayam" (column 2) was argued to denote a personal grant for religious/charitable purposes rather than a grant to the mosque itself; it was asserted that "Dharmadayam" is distinct from "Devadayam" (which more clearly indicates a grant to a temple or endowment).
  • The description "Kazi service inam" (column 8) and the phrasing in column 21 were said to be more consistent with a grant in favour of the person burdened with the service (a grant for service), not a grant to an institution.
  • The absence of the mosque's name as original grantee and the presence of individual names in columns 14, 16 and 17 (e.g., Namadullah; Karur Kazi Syed Ahmedsha) were relied upon to show a personal lineage of enjoyment and thus a personal grant.
  • The remark "attached to the mosque" was countered with the contention that attachment does not convert a personal grant to an institutional grant, especially given the nature of the Kazi's duties.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Bala Tripura Sundaramma v. Secretary of State Held that mere use of the word "Devadayam" does not necessarily show that a grant was to a temple or mosque; set out tests (at p.287) for distinguishing institutional grants from personal grants — if grant is not to the temple/mosque or a substantial part of income does not benefit the institution, treat as grant to the grantee; if services are mentioned, it is a grant for service. The Court applied these tests and the principle that all register entries must be read cumulatively; using that test the Court found the grant to be a personal inam burdened with service.
Mazhar Ali v. Gulam Murtujah Established that the use of the word "permanent" in column 10 of the Inam Register, though often used in grants to institutions, is not conclusive proof that the grant was to an institution. The Court cited this authority to support the proposition that the word "permanent" in the register does not by itself establish an institutional grant.
Sami Ayyangar v. Venkataramana Where column 21 read "To be confirmed to the party in column 16 as long as he continues the performance of the services" the wording was held explicit and unequivocal and, when column 16 names an individual (the archaka), indicated a personal grant burdened with service. The Court compared the present entries with those in Sami Ayyangar and observed that the presence of a named individual in column 16 in the present case similarly indicates a personal grant; but it also distinguished when necessary on factual differences.
Hindu Religious Endowments, Madras v. Thadikonda Koteswara Rao In some registers column 21 read "To be confirmed and continued so long as the service is regularly performed"; Venkata-subba Rao, J., held that such an entry was more consistent with a grant in favour of the institution (and this view was approved by the Supreme Court in a later case). The mosque relied on this decision to suggest that the column 21 wording supports an institutional grant; the Court noted the authority but emphasized that the column 21 wording must be read with the other entries and circumstances.
Lakshminarasimhachari v. Sri Agastheswaraswami Varu The Supreme Court approved the Madras High Court view and emphasized that entries in the Inam Register must be taken together; the Court drew a distinction between various formulations in column 21 and held that context and other entries determine whether a grant is institutional or personal. The Court relied on this decision to reinforce that the phraseology in column 21 is not decisive by itself and that the whole of the register must be considered; the decision was used to refuse a blanket rule that particular wording always indicates an institutional grant.
Hindu Religious Endowments Board v. Koteswara Held that entries (including the name in column 16, column 13 and column 14 identifying a deity or institution) and admissions can demonstrate that a gift was to God/institution; stressed that column 21 phrases must be read with other entries and circumstances and cannot by themselves establish institutional character. The Court relied on this case to support the proposition that the entry in column 21 cannot be treated as conclusively establishing an institutional grant without reference to the other entries; it reinforced the Court's approach of construing all entries together.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court undertook a register-focused, cumulative analysis of the entries in two certified extracts of the Inam Fair Register: Exhibit A-18 (relating to title deed No. 1555, Inam Karur Village) and Exhibit A-1 (relating to title deed No. 1285, L.M. Samudram Village). The Court repeatedly emphasised that no single entry is conclusive and that the decision must be founded on the cumulative effect of all relevant entries.

Analysis of Exhibit A-18 (Inam Karur Village)

  • Column 2: Entry reads "Dharmadayam". The Court observed that "Dharmadayam" denotes an endowment for religious/charitable purposes but is not equivalent to "Devadayam" and, by itself, is not conclusive that the grant was to a mosque or temple.
  • Column 8: Records "Kazi service inam". The Court considered this entry to be more consistent with a grant in favour of the service (i.e., a grant for the person performing the Kazi service) than for an institutional grant to the mosque.
  • Column 10: "Permanent". The Court noted authority (Mazhar Ali) that the term "permanent" is not decisive of an institutional grant; its use does not conclusively indicate a grant to the mosque.
  • Column 11 / Column 13: Grantor is entered as "Krishna Raja Udayar"; the name of the original grantee is shown as "not known". The Court accepted the submission that the grant pre-dated Company records and that the original grantee's name might have been unknown, but observed that this circumstance also tended to probabilise a personal grant.
  • Columns 14, 16 and 17: These columns record individual names (e.g., Namadullah in Fasli 1214; Karur Kazi Syed Ahmedsha, age 45, described as brother's grandson to the registry). The Court found that these entries indicated a lineage of individual enjoyment and tended to support the conclusion that the grant was personal.
  • Column 21: "To be confirmed free in one title deed so long as the Kazi service is rendered." The Court reviewed precedents interpreting various formulations of column 21 and concluded that this phrasing must be read with other register entries; it is not conclusive by itself that the grant was institutional.
  • Remarks column: "This will be confirmed as inam attached to the mosque at Karur." Although the mosque treated this remark as conclusive, the Court analysed the nature of the Kazi's duties under Muslim law (judicial and quasi-judicial functions, often exercised in the mosque but not strictly part of mosque rites) and concluded that an entry of "attached to the mosque" did not convert a personal grant to an institutional grant. The Court inferred the proper meaning was that the grant was to the person burdened with the Kazi service.

Analysis of Exhibit A-1 (L.M. Samudram Village)

  • Exhibit A-1 contained clearer indications of a personal grant: column 11 gives the grantor as Syed Karthar Ahmed; column 13 shows original grantee as Syed Ahmed; column 16 lists Karur Kazi Syed Ahmed Sahib as the owner and column 18 records that he is the grandson of the original grantee.
  • Column 21 again reads "To be confirmed free in one title deed as long as Kazi service is rendered", and importantly the remark that appeared in Exhibit A-18 ("attached to the mosque") was absent in Exhibit A-1.
  • Given the explicit identification of grantee and successor in the register, the Court concluded Exhibit A-1 was clearly a personal grant.

Overall Synthesis

Applying the tests and principles in the cited authorities (particularly the guidance in Bala Tripura Sundaramma and the other cited decisions), the Court held that the combined entries in the registers, the presence of individual names and the nature of the Kazi's duties point to a personal grant burdened with the obligation of performing Kazi service rather than an inam in favour of the mosque. The Court expressly disagreed with the view of the lower appellate Court and found that on the facts the registers indicated personal inams.

On the Wakf Issue (S.A. No. 1927 / O.S. No. 218)

  • The Court examined the statutory definition of "wakf" in Act XXIX of 1954 (as cited in the opinion) which includes, among other categories, mashrut-ul-khidmat (conditional grants on condition of service or office).
  • The Court noted that a grant to a Kazi falls within "mashrut-ul-khidmat" and that the definition of wakf (amended to include dedications for the benefit of the Muslim community and irrespective of the original grantor's religion) negates an argument that a grant made by the Maharaja of Mysore could not be wakf property.
  • Consequently, whether the grant was institutional or personal, a grant to a Kazi of the kind in question would constitute wakf under the statutory definition; therefore, the appellant's plea that the properties were not wakf was rejected.

Holding and Implications

Core holdings:

  • The Court held that the disputed grants are personal inams burdened with the obligation of Kazi service (i.e., they are personal grants with conditions of service), not institutional grants to the Jamia Masjid Mosque.
  • Consequent decree directions (as recorded by the Court): O.S. No. 118 of 1960 is dismissed; O.S. Nos. 322, 345 and 485 of 1960 are decreed. S.A. Nos. 1924, 1926, 1928 and 1925 of 1962 are allowed with costs.
  • With respect to S.A. No. 1927 of 1962 (challenge to the Wakf Board notification), the Court held that the grant to a Kazi falls within the definition of wakf (including mashrut-ul-khidmat) under Act XXIX of 1954 and accordingly dismissed S.A. No. 1927 of 1962 with costs. Leave was granted.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The Court's findings reverse the lower appellate Court's view on the character of the inams and result in dismissal or decree of the original suits as specified above.
  • On the wakf question the Court's reasoning indicates that grants to a Kazi (being conditional grants for service) fall within the statutory conception of wakf as mashrut-ul-khidmat, and thus such grants may be treated as wakf property irrespective of whether they are labelled institutional or personal inam in the register.
  • The Court applied and reiterated existing principles—particularly that entries in inam registers must be read cumulatively and contextually—and did not purport to lay down a novel legal rule beyond applying established authorities to the facts. No new broad legal principle was announced beyond these applications of existing precedent and statutory definition.

This summary is prepared strictly from the information contained in the provided opinion and does not add facts or conclusions beyond the opinion's text.

    Syed Anwar Bacha Sahib v. Jamia Masjid Mosque

    These Second Appeals arise out of five suits filed in the Court of the District Munsif, Karur, and can be dealt with together. The main question for determination in these appeals is the character of certain properties, viz., whether they are inams granted to Jamia Masjid Mosque Karur, or are personal inams burdened with Kazi service. The properties in dispute were originally granted as inams The Jamia Masjid Mosque claims that they are grants to the mosque, whereas according to Kazi Syed Abdullah Batcha, they are inams granted to his ancestors burdened with service. Syed Abdullah Batcha's father, Syed Ahmed Batcha was the Muthawalli of the mosque and was also the Kazi appointed by the Government from 14th December, 1928 to 24th April, 1948. There were disputes between the Muslim residents of Karur, and one Ganiappa Rowther was appointed the Muthawalli of the mosque, and one Abdul Rahiman as Kazi on salaried basis. Syed Abdullah Batcha claimed that the grant was a personal mam in favour of his ancestor burdened with the duty of performing the Kazi service and the Muthawalli of the mosque could have no right whatsoever regarding the properties.

    Ganiappa Rowther in his capacity as Muthawalli of the mosque filed O.S. No 118 of 1960 in the Court of the District Munsif, Karur from which Second Appeal No. 1924 of 1962 arises, impleading the heirs of Syed Ahmed Batcha and others as defendants and prayed for recovery of R. 1,157-2-0 as arrears of rent due to the mosque Syed Abdullah Batcha instituted three suits, O.S. Nos. 322, 345 and 485 of 1960 out of which S.A. Nos. 1926, 1928 and 1925 of 1962 arise, against three tenants for recovery of certain amounts either as rent or as damages lor use and occupation. The defendants in these three suits set up title m the mosque represent-ed by the Muthawalli Ganiappa Rowther. O.S. No. 218 of 1960, out of which S.a. No 1927 of 1962 arises, was filed by Syed Abdulla Batcha for a declaration that the notification issued by the Wakf Board that the properties constituted wakf, was illegal and ultra vires.

    The trial Court dismissed the suit O.S. No. 118 of 1960 filed by Ganiappa Rowther but decreed the suits, O.S. Nos. 322, 345, 485 and 218 of 1950 filed by Syed Abdulla Batcha. Appeals were preferred before the learned District Judge of Tiruchirapalli against the decrees and judgments in the above five suits, and the learned District Judge of Tiruchirapalli allowed all the five appeals, decreeing the suit. O.S. No. 118 of 1960 filed by Ganiappa Rowther and dismissing the suits, O.S. Nos. 322, 345, 485 and 218 of 1960 filed by Syed Abdullah Batcha. Against the judgments and decrees of the lower appellate Court, these Second Appeals have been preferred.

    The main question that arises in these Second Appeals, S.A. Nos. 1924, 1926,1928 1925 and 1927 of 1962 is whether the grant is in favour of the mosque or whether it is a personal grant in favour of Syed Abdullah Batcha's ancestor burdened with service. The question will have to be decided mainly on the extracts of the inam registers, Exhibits A-18 and A-1. Exhibit A-18 was riled in O.S. No. 118 of 1960, and it is a certified copy of the inam register regarding title deed No. 1555 relating to the disputed lands in Inam Karur Village, whereas Exhibit A-1 filed in O.S. No 218 of 1960 is a certified copy of the inam register regarding title deed No. 1285 in L.M. Samudram Village. The entries in the inam fair register,Exhibit A-18 may be dealt with first. In column 2 the inam is described as ‘Dharmadayam’. Column 8 describes the inam as ‘Kaji service’. In column 10 the entry is noted as ‘permanent’. Against column 11 By whom granted ‘it is entered ‘By Krishna Raja Udayar’. The name of the original grantee is noted as not known in column 13. In column 14, dealing with the name entered in the register prepared according to Regulation XXXI of 1802, it is recorded, ‘In Fasli 1214, Namadullah’. In column 15 dealing with the name entered in the survey or subsequent accounts with relationship to the predecessors, it is noted as follows:

    “In F. 1233 Mulla Kahi Inam.

    In F. 1262,

    "
    1. Syed Silaman .. son
    2. Shamsha .. brother
    3. Kadirsa .. brother
    4. NazimuHdin .. brother."
    In columns 16 and 17 dealing with the particulars regarding the then owner, it is noted, ‘Karur Kaji Syed Ahamedsha, aged 45, brother's grandson to the registry in F. 1214’. In column 21 it is noted as follows: ‘To be confirmed free in one T.D. ‘so long as the Kaji service is rendered ‘. In the remarks column it is noted as follows: ‘This will be confirmed as inam attached to the mosque at Karur. See remarks in case No. 1, Lakshminarayana Samudram. ‘Case No. 1 Lakshmi-narayana Samudram refers to Exhibit A-1.

    "It is conceded by Counsel on both sides that no particular entry by itself proves that the grant is either in favour of the mosque or in favour of the person burdened with service. The question will have to be decided by considering the cumulative effect of all the entries. It was contended on behalf of Syed Abdulla Batcha that the entry ‘Dharmadayam’ is significant and would denote a personal grant. In Wilson's Glossary of Judicial and Revenue Terms the meaning of the ‘Dharmadayam ‘is given as follows: ‘An endowment, grant of food, or lands, or funds, for religious or charitable purposes’. ‘Devadayam ‘is described as ‘a donation of lands or allowances for the support of a temple, an endowment’. Thus while Devadayam is a grant in favour of a temple or endowment, Dharmadayam is a grant for religious or charitable purposes. It was contended that the grant being Dharmadayam, the grant was for religious and charitable purposes, as distinguished from the grant in favour of a temple or an endowment. Construing the words ‘Devadayam ‘it has been held by a Bench of this Court in Bala Tripura Sundaramma v. Secretary of State that the mere use of the word, ‘Devadayam ‘does not necessarily show that the grant was to the mosque or temple, and that it is not conclusive in favour of a temple or a mosque. This view has been followed in all the subsequent decisions. Though the use of the word ‘Dharmadayam’ by itself would not conclude the question in favour of Syed Ahmed Batcha, it would have been more probable the word ‘Devadayam’ would have been used, if the grant had been in favour of the mosque, which again is not conclusive, as pointed out by the decision cited above."

    The next important entry is in column 8, where it is noted, ‘Kazi service inam’ The entry by itself is more consistent with the grant being in favour of the service rather than to the mosque. In column 10 the grant is noted as ‘permanent’. It was contended by the learned Counsel on behalf of the mosque that, if the grant was personal, the word ‘hereditary ‘would have been used and not permanent. The use of the word ‘permanent’ has again been held as not conclusive of the question that the grant is in favour of the institution. In Mazhar Ali v. Gulam Murtujah, it was held that, though the word permanent had been used in column 10, which was the word used generally in grant to an institution, the other columns showed that it was not granted exclusively to the Darga. In column 11 the name of the grantee is given as ‘Krishna Raja Udayar, and against column 13 Name of the original grantee ‘it is noted as ‘It is not known . It was contended on behalf of Syed Abdullah Batcha that, if the grant was in favour of the mosque, the name of the mosque would have been given. It was submitted that, as the grant was by the Mysore Maharajah, long before the advent of the East India Company, the name of the person to whom the grant was made was not known and hence the entry. This circumstance also probabilises the contention that the grant was a personal grant. Columns 14, 16 and 17 may be taken together. Column 14 gives the name of Namadullah in Fasli 1214. Columns 16 and 17 give the name of Karur Kaji Syed Ahamedsha, aged 45, as the brother's grandson of the registry in Fasli 1214. These three columns would indicate that Namadullah's name was entered in the Register prepared according to Regulation XXXI of 1802, and Karur Kaji Syed Ahmedsha, aged 45, as entered in columns 16 and 17, is the brother's grandson of the registry entered in column 14, Namadullah. These entries also probabilise that the grant was personal. Considerable reliance was placed by the learned Counsel on both sides on the entry in column 21, which is as follows: “ To be confirmed free in one title deed so long as the Kaji service is rendered” . It was contended on behalf of the mosque that, if the grant was a personal grant, different words would have been used, such as “To be confirmed to the party so long as he continues the performance of service” as found in Hindu Religious Endowments, Madras v. Thadikonda Koteswara Rao, and the use of the words, “ To be confirmed free in one title deed so long as the Kaji service is rendered” would probabilise that the grant was in favour of the mosque. In Sami Ayyangar v. Venkataramana, the entry in column 21 of the Inam Fair Register is as follows: To be confirmed to the party in column 16 as long as he continues the performance of the services “. It was held in that case that the words in column 21 were explicit and unequivocal. The Bench further observed as follows:-

    "If ‘the party’ referred to in that column be understood to be the deity, what would be the resultě The condition of the performing of the services cannot possibly refer to the deity and the idea of the grant being resumable on the deity failing to render the archaka service, would of course be absurd. The inam register shows that the land was continuously held at least for two generations by the family of Venkatachala, and the intention was no doubt to confirm the grant in his favour burdened with archaka service."

    In Hindu Religious Endowments, Madras v. Thadikonda Koteswara Rao, the entry in column 16 of the Inam Register was as follows:” Sri Viswaraswami (worshipper) Tangalur Venkatasivadu“. In column 21 in some of the cases the entry was:” To be confirmed and continued so long as the service is regularly performed

    ". Venkata-subba Rao, J., who delivered the judgment, held that this entry was more in conformity with the grant being in favour of the institution. This view, which was subsequently approved by the Supreme Court in Lakshminarasimhachari v. Sri Agastheswaraswami Varuwas strongly relied on behalf of the mosque. It was contended that the phraseology in column 21 in Sami Ayyangar v. Venkataramana,"
    To be confirmed to the party in column 16 as long as he continues the performance of the services,
    " and the reference to ‘the party ‘and ‘he continues ‘would necessarily refer to some individual. This contention is in accordance with the view expressed in Hindu Religious Endowments Board v. Koteswara . But as pointed out in Hindu Religious Endowments Board v. Koteswara, the entry in column 16 would make a difference, if the name of the archaka is given. Dealing with column 16 in the case the Court took the view that it was perfectly clear in the face of admissions and entries that the contention that the grant was a personal grant could not be upheld. The entry in column 16 in Sami Ayyangar v. Venkataramana was different, in that the name of the archaka was given indicating that the grant was in favour of the archaka. In the case with which we are concerned the entry in column 16 is merely the name of Karur Kaji Syed Ahamedsha, which is clearly indicative of the fact that the grant is personal in nature. On the facts the present case is more in favour of the view that the grant is personal than the one found in Sami Ayyangar v Venkataramana Ayyangar. The observations of the Supreme Court in Lakshminarasimhachari v. Sri Agastheswaraswami Varu, approving the view of the Madras High Court in Hindu Religious Endowments Board v. Koteswarathat the words"
    To be confirmed so long as the service is performed “ would not be a personal grant would have to be taken in the light of the facts in the case.

    In Hindu Religious Endowments Board v. Koteswara, the relevant entries are as follows: In column I under the heading, ‘Name of the present enjoyer ‘the name of the deity was given. In column II the deity was shown under the heading ‘Particulars of the present enjoyment’. In column 8 it was mentioned that the grant was ‘for the worship of the idol in the pagoda ‘. In column 13 the original grant was shown in the name of the deity. In column 14 the name entered in the inam register was that of the deity. Relying on the entries in these columns and the admissions, the Court came to the conclusion that the gift was to God. Column 21 in some of the cases ran as follows; ‘‘To be confirmed and continued so long as the service is regularly performed” . Reading this entry in column 21 along with the other entries the Court distinguished the decision in Sami Ayyangar v. Venkataramana, in which the words, “ To be confirmed to the party in column 16 as long as he continues the performance of the service” in column 21 were used. The decision cannot be taken as an authority for the proposition that the entry in column 21 as “To be continued so long as the service is regularly performed” should be taken as a grant to the institution, without any reference to the other entries. The entries in the Inam Register in Lakshmindrasimhachari v. Sri Agastkeswara-swami Vara, may also be referred to. In column 6 was given the name of the grantor who gave the land to the grantee and “with the income therefrom he has been performing Sri Swami Varu's Kalyanotsavam from that time” . In column II relating to the present enjoyment the entry was “ Sri Swami Varu's Kalyanotsavam” . Apart from these entries there were admissions of the predecessors of the appellant that they were dharmakarthas of the Kalyanotsavam. In construing the entry in the inam register that the grant was to continue so long as service was performed, the Supreme Court approved the distinction brought out between the words, “to be confirmed so long as service is performed” and “to be confirmed to the party so long as he continues to perform the service” made in Hindu Religious Endowments Board v. Koteswara . The two decisions in Hindu Religious Endowments Board v. Koteswara, and in Lakshminarasimhachari v. Sri Agastheswaraswami Varu, cannot be taken as authority for the proposition that whenever the words “to be confirmed to the party so long as he continues to perform the service” are used the grant can only be in favour of the institution. All the other entries should be taken as whole and construed together in arriving at a conclusion whether the grant was in favour of the institution or not.

    Very strong reliance was placed by the learned Counsel for the mosque, on the remarks made in the register, which are as follows: “ This will be confirmed as an inam attached to the mosque at Karur” . These remarks are relied on as conclusive as the grant being in favour of the mosque. On the other hand it was contended by the appellant that the words “attached to the mosque” would not make the grant one in favour of the mosque. A reference to the duties of a Kazi may be made in this connection. In Hedaya, on Mussulman laws, the duties of a Kazi are set out in detail. It is enough to notice the more important one. The office of a Kazi has its origin in Muslim law. Kazi was chiefly a judicial officer more or less corresponding to the Magistrate of the present day. It was his duty to examine the state of prisoners, and whenever any acknowledgment of right in favour of others was made by a person it was the duty of the Kazi to record it. It was requisite that the Kazi should sit openly in a mosque for the execution of his office, in order that his place might not be uncertain to travellers or to the inhabitants of the town. The Jama mosque was considered the most eligible place if it was situated within the city. It was not improper for the Kazi to sit in his own house and pass judgment. Amongst his other functions may be mentioned, the attesting and registering deeds of transfer of property, celebrating marriages, performing other rights and ceremonies, attending funerals and visiting the sick. The duties of the Kazi were, therefore, not strictly religious in character, and the office of the Kazi cannot be strictly said to form part of the mosque or religious rites of the mosque. The office of the Kazi was also not one held under the mosque, though he was expected to exercise his functions ordinarily in the mosque. From the remarks in the Inam Register, “ This will be confirmed as inam attached to the mosque,” it cannot be inferred that the grant was to the mosque. The proper inference, in my opinion, is that the grant was made to the person burdened with the service of the kazi. In determining, the question whether a grant was in favour of an institution or in favour of a person, a Bench of this Court in Bala Tripura Sundaramma v. Secretary of State laid down certain tests at page 287. Where the grant is not to temple or mosque or to a person in the capacity of muthawalli, dharmakartha, etc. or where it appears that a substantial part of the income does not go for the benefit of the institution, then the grant must be treated as a grant to the grantee named, and if services are mentioned, it is a grant for service. Taking all the entries in the Inam Fair Register into consideration and applying the test laid down in the above decision I find that the grant is a personal grant burdened with service.

    The other Inam Fair Register, Exhibit A-1 remains to be considered. The entries more clearly indicate that the grant is a personal inam. In column 11 it is stated that the grant was made by Syed Karthar Ahmed. The name of the original grantee in column 13 is given as Syed Ahmed. In column 16 dealing with the particulars of the owner the name of Karur Kazi Syed Ahmed Sahib is entered. In column 18 it is mentioned that the said person is the grandson of the original grantee. In column 21 it is entered “To be confirmed free in one title deed as long as Kazi service is rendered” . It may be noted that in Exhibit A-1 the remarks that, ‘the inam will be confirmed as attached to the mosque ‘are not found, and the name of the grantee and his successor-in-title, are mentioned. There can be no doubt, therefore that Exhibit A-1 is a personal grant. Though Exhibit B-3, a certified extract from the register Exhibit B was referred to in the course of arguments, much reliance cannot be placed on it, as it is not clear under what authority the register is being maintained. On a consideration of the entire facts in the case, disagreeing with the view of the lower appellate Court, I hold that the grant is personal in nature burdened with service. On this finding O.S. No. 118 of 1960 is dismissed and O.S. Nos. 322, 345 and 485 are decreed. S.A. Nos. 1924, 1926, 1928 and 1925 are allowed with costs.

    S.A. No. 1927 of 1962 arising out of O.S. No. 218 of 1960 filed by Syed Abdullah Batcha against the State Wakf Board, for a declaration that the notification issued by the Wakf Board was illegal and ultra vires, will have to be considered. ‘Wakf’ is defined in Act XXIX of 1954 as meaning a permanent dedication by a person professing Islam, of any movable or immovable property for any purpose recognised by the Muslim law as pious, religious or charitable and includes (i) a wakf by user, (ii) mashrut-ul-khidmat, and (iii) a wakf-alal-aulad to the extent to which the property is dedicated for any purpose recognised by Muslim law as pious, religious or charitable. The definition of wakf is amended, so as to include all dedications especially for the benefit of Muslim community, whether by a person professing Islam or not. This amendment negatives the contention of the appellant that as the original grantor was the Maharaja of Mysore, the property is not wakf property. It cannot be denied that a grant to a Kazi is a purpose recognised by the Muslim law as pious, religious and charitable. Further, it also falls within section 2(1)(ii), mashrut-ul-khidmat. Wilson's glossary gives the meaning of the word ‘mashrut’ as conditional, as applied to assignments or grants of land revenue, importing that the grant was accompanied by certain stipulated conditions’. ‘Khidmat’ means ‘service or office’. ‘Mashrut-ul-khidmat’ would mean a grant on condition of service or office. The grant to a Kazi would certainly fall within this class of the definition. Whether the grant was in favour of the institution or personal in nature, the appellant cannot contend that it is not wakf. His suit for the declaration that the property is not wakf property will, therefore, have to be dismissed. S.A. No. 1927 of 1962 is dismissed with costs. Leave granted.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Syed Anwar Bacha Sahib v. Jamia Masjid Mosque
    (Nov 26, 1965)