Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 394/397/307/34 of Indian Penal Code read with section 25 and 27 of Arms Act
  • Section 394/34 of Indian Penal Code and under Section 307/34 of Indian Penal Code
  • section 397 instead of section 398 of IPC.
  • Section 394/34 of the Indian Penal Code
  • Section 397 of the Indian Penal Code
  • section 394/34 of Indian Penal Code,
  • section 397 to section 398 of IPC.
  • section 397 of Indian Penal Code
  • Section 397 Indian Penal Code
  • section 313 of Cr. P.C.,
  • Section 464 Cr.P.C.,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 394/397/307/34 of Indian Penal Code read with section 25 and 27 of Arms Act
  • Section 394/34 of Indian Penal Code and under Section 307/34 of Indian Penal Code
  • section 397 instead of section 398 of IPC.
  • Section 394/34 of the Indian Penal Code
  • Section 397 of the Indian Penal Code
  • section 394/34 of Indian Penal Code,
  • section 397 to section 398 of IPC.
  • section 397 of Indian Penal Code
  • Section 397 Indian Penal Code
  • section 313 of Cr. P.C.,
  • Section 464 Cr.P.C.,
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Three appeals arise from a common impugned judgment and sentence in which three appellants were convicted under Section 394/34 Indian Penal Code and sentenced to rigorous imprisonment for five years and a fine of Rs. 1,000/- each. In addition, appellant Vijay was convicted under Section 397 IPC and sentenced to seven years rigorous imprisonment with a fine of Rs. 1,000/-.

The material facts as recorded are: on 16.9.1997, Sukhdev Garg (doing wholesale pharmaceutical business) was travelling in his car when it broke down near Village Gopalpur. Four persons in a three-wheeler stopped; Vijay allegedly took out a large knife and two others (Mohd. Rashid and Satish Kumar) attempted to snatch the complainant's briefcase. When the complainant objected, Vijay allegedly stabbed him in the abdomen. Inspector Sandeep Bayala witnessed the incident, intervened and gave chase; the accused fled, left the three-wheeler and dispersed. The injured complainant was taken to Hindu Rao hospital. An FIR (No. 410/97) was registered under Sections 394/397/307/34 IPC read with Sections 25 and 27 Arms Act. Investigation by ASI Jeet Singh included site plan, apprehensions, and recovery of a dagger (Ex. P-1). Satish Kumar refused to join TIP proceedings.

After investigation a charge-sheet was filed. Charges under Section 394/34 and Section 307/34 IPC were framed against all three accused; a separate charge under Section 397 IPC was framed against Vijay. The prosecution examined twelve witnesses (including the complainant PW-5 and Inspector Sandeep PW-9). The accused denied the prosecution case in their Section 313 Cr.P.C. statements and claimed false implication; no defence evidence was led. The trial court convicted and sentenced them as noted above. These appeals were filed challenging the convictions/sentences.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the substantive sentences imposed on the three appellants for the offence punishable under Section 394/34 IPC could be reduced to the period already undergone by them.
  2. Whether the conviction of appellant Vijay under Section 397 IPC should be altered to Section 398 IPC (on the basis that the factual matrix was of attempted robbery while armed) and whether his sentence could be reduced to the period already undergone despite the statutory minimum for Section 398.
  3. Whether alteration of conviction to an offence not specifically charged is permissible where the accused was aware of the basic ingredients of the offence and has not suffered prejudice (in light of Section 464 Cr.P.C. and the judicial guidance cited).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • Appellants did not press the appeals on merits except with regard to the nature of the offence and sentencing.
  • So far as the offence under Section 394/34 IPC is concerned, the appellants urged reduction of the substantive sentence to the period already undergone: Satish Kumar (three years and one month), Mohd. Rashid (four years, two months and 25 days), and Vijay Kumar (three years and eleven months).
  • Counsel emphasised that the appellants were aged 20–25 at the time of the incident, were not previous convicts, had faced trial and appeal proceedings for about twelve years, had been on bail for about eight years since suspension of sentence, and had satisfactory conduct inside and outside jail—factors said to favour sentence reduction.
  • Specific to appellant Vijay: counsel contended the case was of attempted robbery (not robbery), that the charge and conviction under Section 397 IPC were technically wrong, and relied on a decision reported at 93 (2001) DLT 377 where sentence was reduced to time undergone; counsel sought setting aside the conviction/sentence under Section 397 IPC.

State's / Respondent's Arguments

  • The Additional Public Prosecutor did not dispute the period already undergone by the appellants for Section 394/34 but addressed the legal characterisation of Vijay's offence.
  • With respect to Vijay, the State conceded the conviction under Section 397 IPC was not sustainable in form, but maintained that the material facts disclose attempted robbery while armed, which corresponds to Section 398 IPC; altering the conviction to Section 398 would cause no prejudice to Vijay.
  • The State argued the decision relied upon by Vijay (93 (2001) DLT 377) is not helpful because it drew support from an Apex Court plenary-order (2001 Cri.LJ 147) where the Supreme Court reduced sentence below statutory minima on the basis that the weapons used were not deadly; such plenary powers cannot be exercised by High Courts, and therefore reduction below the statutory minimum is not permissible by the High Court in the present case.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Dalbir Singh v. State of U.P., 2004 (4) SCALE 238 Explains that under Section 464 Cr.P.C. an appellate or revisional court can convict an accused for an offence for which no formal charge was framed, provided no failure of justice results; assessment includes whether the accused was aware of the basic ingredients and had a fair chance to defend. The court relied on this authority to justify altering Vijay's conviction from Section 397 to Section 398 IPC because Vijay was aware he was charged with attempting robbery while armed and suffered no prejudice from the incorrect statutory citation.
93 (2001) DLT 377 Reported instance where, while maintaining conviction under Section 397 IPC, the substantive sentence was reduced to the period already undergone (the cited decision involved long ordeal of trial/appeal and reduction of sentence). Raised by appellant Vijay to support reduction of sentence to period undergone; the court held this decision is not of assistance here because it relied on an Apex Court plenary power decision (2001 Cri.LJ 147) and does not override statutory minima which High Courts cannot relax in the same manner.
2001 Cri.LJ 147 (Apex Court plenary order referenced in 93 (2001) DLT 377) An Apex Court exercise of plenary powers to reduce sentence below statutory minimum in the particular circumstances where weapons used were bamboo sticks and lathis (deemed not to be deadly weapons). The court noted that such plenary powers exercised by the Supreme Court cannot be exercised by a High Court; accordingly, the High Court refused to follow the consequence of that order to reduce Vijay's sentence below the minimum prescribed for Section 398 IPC.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by separate but related analyses as to the offences under Section 394/34 IPC (for all three appellants) and the offence charged against Vijay under Section 397 IPC.

Regarding Section 394/34 IPC: the court observed that this offence carries no statutory minimum sentence. Given the period already undergone by each appellant (Satish: three years and one month; Mohd. Rashid: four years, two months and 25 days; Vijay: three years and eleven months), their youth at the time of the incident, lack of prior convictions as recorded, the long duration of trial and appeal proceedings and continued bail, and satisfactory conduct, the court found that further incarceration was unnecessary in the interests of justice. Consequently, the substantive sentence for that offence was reduced to the period already undergone. The court preserved the fine imposed by the trial court and granted three weeks for its deposit, failing which the appellants would undergo simple imprisonment for three months each.

Regarding appellant Vijay and the charge under Section 397 IPC: the court examined the prosecution evidence (complainant PW-5 and Inspector Sandeep PW-9 who apprehended Vijay and recovered the dagger). The court reproduced the third charge as framed by the trial court, which charged Vijay with attempting to commit robbery while using a deadly weapon but cited Section 397 IPC. The court concluded that:

  • The misdescription of the statutory provision (Section 397 instead of Section 398) was a bonafide omission and did not prejudice Vijay because he was aware from the outset that he faced trial for attempted robbery while armed and had the opportunity to defend himself.
  • Applying the principle in Dalbir Singh (and Section 464 Cr.P.C.), an appellate court may convict for an offence not specifically charged if no failure of justice results; here Vijay was aware of the basic ingredients of the offence and no prejudice was caused.
  • Therefore, the conviction could be formally altered from Section 397 to Section 398 IPC.

On the question of reducing Vijay's substantive sentence to the period already undergone, the court considered the precedent relied upon by Vijay (93 (2001) DLT 377) and traced it to an Apex Court plenary exercise (2001 Cri.LJ 147) that reduced sentences below statutory minima in special circumstances (weapons not deadly). The court held that the High Court lacks such plenary powers to reduce a sentence below a statutory minimum where the statute prescribes a minimum period without a proviso permitting reduction. Section 398 IPC prescribes a minimum sentence of seven years; thus, the court could not lawfully reduce Vijay's sentence below seven years and refused to apply the cited decision to obtain such a reduction.

As a result, the court altered Vijay's conviction to Section 398 IPC but maintained the substantive sentence of seven years as imposed by the trial court. The court directed cancellation of Vijay's bail bonds and ordered him to surrender to serve the remainder of the sentence; trial court to be apprised for compliance.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING:

  • The appeals are partly allowed.
  • The substantive sentence of all three appellants for the offence under Section 394/34 IPC is reduced to the period already undergone by each appellant. The fines imposed by the trial court are maintained; appellants are given three weeks to deposit the fines, failure of which will result in simple imprisonment for three months each.
  • The conviction of appellant Vijay Kumar is formally altered from Section 397 IPC to Section 398 IPC. The substantive sentence of seven years (the statutory minimum for Section 398) imposed on Vijay is maintained; his bail bonds are cancelled and he is directed to surrender forthwith to serve the remainder of the sentence.

Implications: The decision provides relief by reducing the Section 394/34 sentences to the time already served because that offence carries no statutory minimum and the court found that further imprisonment was unnecessary in the facts of this case. As to the alteration from Section 397 to Section 398, the court applied the principle that conviction for an offence not precisely charged is permissible where no failure of justice results (as explained in Dalbir Singh), but the court emphasised that it cannot reduce a sentence below the statutory minimum prescribed by Parliament where no proviso authorises such reduction. The order is directed to the trial court for compliance. The opinion does not purport to set a novel legal precedent beyond applying established authorities and statutory provisions.

Disposition: These three appeals are partly allowed and disposed of accordingly.

    Mohd. Rashid Others v. State Of Delhi

    1. Above titled three appeals arise out of a common impugned judgment and order of sentence, vide which these three Appellants have been convicted for the offence punishable under Section 394/34 of the Indian Penal Code to undergo rigorous imprisonment for a period of five years and to pay fine of Rs. 1,000/- each. In addition, Appellant Vijay has been convicted for committing offence under Section 397 of the Indian Penal Code and has been sentence to undergo rigorous imprisonment for a period of seven years with a fine of Rs. 1,000/-.

    2. The relevant facts of this case emerging from the records are as under :-

    "On 16.9.1997, Sukhdev Garg, who was doing the business of pharmaceuticals in wholesale at Bhagirath Palace by the name of Cystocham Pharma, was going to his house to Rohini from Bhagirath Palace in his Maruti Car No. DL 8CD 1239 and near Village Gopalpur his car went out of order. He came outside his car with his briefcase and in the meantime, one three wheeler scooter No. DAR 1685 stopped ahead of his car in which four persons were there. One person out of those persons, namely, Vijay Kumar took out a big knife and the other two accused namely Mohd. Rasid and Satish kumar forcibly tried to snatch the bag from the hands of Sukhdev Garg. When Sukhdev Garg objected, accused Vijay Kumar attacked and stabbed him at his abdomen in order to kill him. Inspector Sandip Bayala, who was going in his private car, saw this incident and after stopping his car, he came running from the other side of the road and gave warning to the accused persons whereupon all the three accused persons ran towards the three wheeler scooter and thereafter all the three accused alongwith the driver of the scooter fled away towards Burari Chowk. PCR van also came and Sukhdev Garg alongwith Inspector Sandip Bahayala sat in PCR van and chased the three wheeler. All the four occupants of the scooter left the three wheeler near the gate of Nirankari Sarovar and started running. Inspector Sandip Bayala and ASI Sultan Singh of the PCR van also got down from the PCR and started chasing the accused on foot. Sukhdev Garg, injured was taken to Hindu Rao hospital in PCR. MLC of injured Sukhdev Garg was procured by Head Constable Surat Singh, statement of Sukhdev Garg was recorded by Inspector Sandeep Bayala, on the basis of which FIR No. 410/97 under Section 394/397/307/34 of Indian Penal Code read with section 25 and 27 of Arms Act was registered, ASI Jeet Singh conducted the investigation, who prepared the site plan at the place of incident. Accused Vijay and Mohd. Rashid were apprehended and their disclosure statement was recorded. During investigation, accused Satish Kumar apprehended as one of the associates. Accused Satish refused to join the TIP proceedings before the learned Magistrate on 21.10.97."

    3. After the completion of investigation, the charge-sheet against the appellant/accused persons was filed and a charge under Section 394/34 of Indian Penal Code and under Section 307/34 of Indian Penal Code was framed against these three accused persons and a charge under Section 397 Indian Penal Code was also framed against accused Vijay Kumar, and claimed trial, by pleading not guilty to the aforesaid charges, framed against them by trial court.

    4. The prosecution in support of its case, had got examined twelve witnesses before the trial court and out of them, Sukhdev Garg (PW-5) is the Complainant/injured of this case and Inspector Sandip Bhayala (PW-9) had apprehended Appellant/accused Vijay, near the spot, while he was fleeing away and the knife/dagger Ex.P-1 was recovered from him. Sub-Inspector Sultan Singh (PW-8) is the Investigating Officer of this case.

    5. The plea taken by these three Appellant/accused before the trial court, in their statements under section 313 of Cr. P.C., is of denial of the prosecution case and of false implication in this case, after being lifted from their houses. No evidence in defence was led by Appellant/ accused before the trial court. After trial, Appellant/accused stood convicted and sentenced as already noticed above.

    6. Both the sides state that these three appeals can be heard together conveniently. As such, these appeals have been heard together and the evidence on record has been perused with the able assistance rendered by learned counsel for the parties and by this common order, these appeals are being decided together.

    7. At the very outset, these three Appellants present in the court, through their counsel, Mr. Sumeet Verma, do not press their appeals on merits, except regarding the nature of offence committed. Mr. Sumit Verma, learned counsel for the Appellants states that so far as the offence under Section 394/34 of the Indian Penal Code is concerned, the period already undergone by these three Appellants is as under :-

    Appellant Satish Kumar : Three years and one month
    Appellant Mohd. Rashid : Four years, two months and twenty five days.
    Appellant Vijay Kumar : Three years and eleven months.
    8. Learned counsel for Appellants has drawn attention of this court to the impugned order of sentence to highlight that these three Appellantdrawn attention of this court to the impugned order of sentence to highlight that these three Appellants were in age group of 20-25 years at the time of this incident and as is recorded in the impugned order, they are not previous convicts. It is further submitted that these three Appellants have already faced the ordeal of trial and appeal proceedings for the last twelve years and they are on bail for the last about eight years, after the suspension of their sentence in these appeals and the conduct of the Appellants, inside the jail as well as outside the jail, is satisfactory. Thus, it is prayed that the substantive sentence for the offence punishable under Section 394/34 of the Indian Penal Code imposed upon these three Appellants deserves to be reduced to the period already undergone by them.

    9. So far as the offence under Section 394/34 of the Indian Penal Code is concerned, I do find that this offence does not carry any minimum sentence and the sentence already undergone by these three Appellants/accused, for this offence, as already reflected above, would serve the ends of justice. In view of the aforesaid background, the substantive sentence imposed upon appellants/accused Mohd. Rashid son of Mohd. Yasin, Vijay son of Babu Maya Singh and Satish Kumar son of Sewak Ram, for the offence under section 394/34 of Indian Penal Code, is reduced from five years to the period already undergone by them. However, the sentence of fine is maintained and in case the fine is not deposited, these three Appellants/accused are granted three weeks time to deposit the fine as imposed by the trial court, failing which they shall have to undergo simple imprisonment for a period of three months each.

    10. So far as the offence under Section 397 of the Indian Penal Code qua Appellant Vijay Kumar is concerned, learned counsel for Appellant points out that it is evident from the last para of the impugned judgment that the case made out against Appellant Vijay Kumar is of attempted robbery and not of robbery. It is further pointed out that the charge sheet filed against this Appellant Vijay Kumar for the offence under section 397 of Indian Penal Code and the charge framed against him was also under section 397 of IPC and he has been convicted for this offence under section 397 of IPC by the trial court in a mechanical manner. Lastly, it is submitted that in a decision reported in 93 (2001) DLT 377, while maintaining the conviction under section 397 of IPC, the substantive sentence was reduced to the period already undergone as the ordeal of trial faced was for eighteen years. However, it is asserted by counsel for appellant Vijay that conviction and sentence for the offence under Section 397 of IPC deserves to be set aside. Nothing else is urged on behalf of the Appellant.

    11. Learned Additional Public Prosecutor for the State does not dispute the period of detention already undergone by appellants and fairly submits that the conviction of the Appellant Vijay Kumar for the offence under section 397 of the ipc is not sustainable but since the present case is of attempted robbery with a deadly weapon by this Appellant, therefore, the offence made out would be under section 398 of IPC and no prejudice is caused to the Appellant because the charge framed against him was of attempting to commit robbery, while causing injury with a dangerous weapon. It is pointed out that the decision relied upon on behalf of Appellant Vijay Kumar was rendered as there was no opposition from the State to reducing the sentence to the period already undergone, although minimum sentence was prescribed and there is no proviso permitting the courts for reducing the sentence, to a period less than the minimum prescribed. Thus, it is submitted that the decision relied upon is of no avail as the period undergone is not reflected in the aforesaid decision. Lastly, it is submitted that the conviction of Appellant Vijay Kumar deserves to be altered to section 398 of IPC which also carries a minimum sentence of seven years.

    12. After having perused the evidence of the Complainant/first informant (PW- 5) and the evidence of Inspector Sandeep (PW-9), who had apprehended Appellant Vijay Kumar from near the spot, while he was trying to flee away, and had recovered the knife/dagger, Ex. P-1, from him, I find that right from the beginning, this Appellant was well aware that he has been called upon to face the trial for the offence of attempted robbery, while being armed with a deadly weapon. It would be relevant to reproduce the third charge framed against this particular Appellant Vijay Kumar, by the trial court and it reads as under :-

    Thirdly

    That you Vijay Kumar on the abovesaid date, time and place while attempting to commit the robbery on Sukhdev Garg, you used a deadly weapon, that is, a dagger and caused grievous hurt to him and thereby committed an offence punishable under section 397 IPC and within the cognizance of this court.

    And I hereby direct that you be tried by this court for the abovesaid charges.

    Sd/-

    Addl. Sessions Judge, Delhi

    18.3.98

    13. It is abundantly clear from the record of this case that Appellant Vijay Kumar has not suffered any prejudice on account of being technically charged with the offence under section 397 of IPC, which pertains to the offence of robbery or dacoity, with attempt to cause death or grievous hurt. In fact, Appellant Vijay Kumar has been charged with the offence of attempting to commit robbery while being armed with a deadly weapon but the provision of the law has been wrongly mentioned as section 397 instead of section 398 of IPC. This omission appears to be a bonafide one and in any case, it does not prejudice Appellant Vijay Kumar in any manner whatsoever. Therefore, without any hesitation, the conviction of Appellant Vijay Kumar deserves to be formally altered from section 397 to section 398 of IPC. However, the substantive sentence imposed will remain the same as both these sections carry a minimum sentence of imprisonment of not less than seven years, with no proviso, leaving any discretion with the courts, to impose a lesser sentence than the minimum, for adequate or special reasons.

    14. Whether in a given case, it is possible to convict the accused for a difference offence, then the offence, with which he has been charged, is a question, which has been answered by the Apex Court in the case reported in 2004 (4) SCALE 238 titled Dalbir Singh v. State Of U.P.. in the following words :-

    "Therefore, in view of Section 464 Cr.P.C., it is possible for the appellate of revisional Court to convict an accused for an offence for which no charge was framed unless the Court is of the opinion that a failure of justice would in fact occasion. In order to judge whether a failure of justice has been occasioned, it will be relevant to examine whether the accused was aware of the basic ingredients of the offence for which he is being convicted and whether the main facts sought to be established against him were explained to him clearly and whether he got a fair chance to defend himself. We are, therefore, of the opinion that Sangarabonia Sreenu (supra) was not correctly decided as it purports to lay down as a principle of law that where the accused is charged under Section 302 IPC, he cannot be convicted for the offence under Section 306 IPC."

    15. The substantive sentence imposed upon Appellant Vijay cannot be reduced to the period already undergone by him for the offence under section 398 of IPC by relying upon decision reported in 93 (2001) DLT 377, because the aforesaid decision draws strength from a decision of the Apex Court reported in 2001 Cri.LJ 147, wherein the Apex Court while exercising its plenary powers had reduced the sentence to a period below the minimum prescribed because the weapon of offence used were bamboo sticks and lathis, which cannot be termed as deadly weapons. With respect, such plenary powers cannot be exercised by the High Courts. Therefore, the above cited decision cannot be relied upon to reduce the substantive sentence of Appellant Vijay Kumar to a period below the minimum of seven years prescribed for this offence.

    16. Resultantly, the conviction of Appellant Vijay Kumar is altered from section 397 to section 398 of IPC. However, since the offence under section 398 of IPC carries a minimum sentence of seven years, therefore, the sentence of seven years imposed upon Appellant Vijay Kumar is maintained but is for the offence under section 398 of the ipc. Appellant Vijay Kumar son of Babu Maya Singh is on bail. His bail bonds are cancelled and is directed to surrender forthwith, failing which, trial court/successor court to put him behind bars to serve out the remainder of the sentence for the offence under Section 398 of IPC.

    17. Trial court be apprised of this order, to ensure its compliance.

    18. Before parting with this order, this court would like to place on record the appreciation for the legal assistance rendered in these appeals by Mr. Sumeet Verma, learned Standing Counsel (Cri) of Delhi High Court Legal Services Committee in these matters.

    19. With directions, as aforesaid, these three appeals are partly allowed and stand disposed of as such.

    Appeals partly allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mohd. Rashid Others v. State Of Delhi
    (Apr 15, 2009)