Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 10 in Mulla's Code of Civil Procedure (13th Edition by T.L Venkatarama Aiyar):
  • CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE AMENDMENT ACT
  • Rule 10 of Order VIII in Mulla's Code of Civil Procedure, 13th Edition,
  • 9 and 10 of Order VIII before Rule 10 of Order VIII Rule 10
  • Rules 9 and 10 of Order VIII Reads thus:Rule 10
  • Order VIII Rule 5(2) C.P.C, Order VIII Rule 10
  • Rule 1 or Rule 9 in the unamended Rule 10
  • sub-rule (1) of Rule 4 of Order XX CPC.
  • founded.14. Rule 10 of Order VIII
  • decision.7. Order VIII Rule 1(1)
  • provisions of Rules 9 and 10
  • Rule 10 of Order VIII C.P.C
  • Order VIII Rule 5(2) C.P.C,
  • provisions of Rule 10.9.
  • proved.Rule 5(3) xxxx5(4):
  • Order 8 Rule 5(2) C.P.C
  • Rule 10 of Order VIII
  • provisions of Rule 10
  • Order XX Rule 4 C.P.C,
  • Sub-rule (1) of Rule 4
  • sub-rule (2) of Rule 4
  • Rule 10, that Rule 1
  • VIII Rule 5(2) C.P.C
  • Clause (2) of Rule 5
  • Order VIII Rule 10
  • Rule 4 of Order XX
  • Rule 5(2) of Order
  • Rule 1 or Rule 9,
  • rule 10 of Order
  • (1) of Rule 5
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 10 in Mulla's Code of Civil Procedure (13th Edition by T.L Venkatarama Aiyar):
  • CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE AMENDMENT ACT
  • Rule 10 of Order VIII in Mulla's Code of Civil Procedure, 13th Edition,
  • 9 and 10 of Order VIII before Rule 10 of Order VIII Rule 10
  • Rules 9 and 10 of Order VIII Reads thus:Rule 10
  • Order VIII Rule 5(2) C.P.C, Order VIII Rule 10
  • Rule 1 or Rule 9 in the unamended Rule 10
  • sub-rule (1) of Rule 4 of Order XX CPC.
  • founded.14. Rule 10 of Order VIII
  • decision.7. Order VIII Rule 1(1)
  • provisions of Rules 9 and 10
  • Rule 10 of Order VIII C.P.C
  • Order VIII Rule 5(2) C.P.C,
  • provisions of Rule 10.9.
  • proved.Rule 5(3) xxxx5(4):
  • Order 8 Rule 5(2) C.P.C
  • Rule 10 of Order VIII
  • provisions of Rule 10
  • Order XX Rule 4 C.P.C,
  • Sub-rule (1) of Rule 4
  • sub-rule (2) of Rule 4
  • Rule 10, that Rule 1
  • VIII Rule 5(2) C.P.C
  • Clause (2) of Rule 5
  • Order VIII Rule 10
  • Rule 4 of Order XX
  • Rule 5(2) of Order
  • Rule 1 or Rule 9,
  • rule 10 of Order
  • (1) of Rule 5
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This revision arises from S.C. No. 3564 of 1981 on the file of the Chief Judge, Court of Small Causes, Bangalore City. The plaintiff instituted a suit for recovery of Rs. 8,250 as arrears of rent with costs and current interest. The defendant failed to file a written statement although the case was posted finally for that purpose on 10 February 1982. The defendant and his counsel were absent on that date. The learned Chief Judge placed the defendant ex parte under Order VIII Rule 5(2) C.P.C. and decreed the suit as prayed with future interest at 6% per annum from the date of the suit till realization. The defendant filed this revision petition challenging that order dated 10 February 1982. The revision petition was listed for admission, and with consent of both parties was treated as being set down for final hearing and heard on merits.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the decree passed against the defendant without recording evidence was permissible, particularly when passed after the defendant failed to file a written statement.
  2. Whether the order under challenge should be treated as having been passed under Order VIII Rule 5(2) C.P.C. or under Order VIII Rule 10 C.P.C., having regard to the defendant's failure to file a written statement.
  3. Whether the 'judgment' recorded in the impugned order complied with the requirements of Order XX Rule 4 (C.P.C.) for judgments of a Court of Small Causes (i.e., whether it contained the points for determination and the decision thereon).
  4. Whether the earlier unreported decision in Sampa Pujari (C.R.P. No. 1092/1965) relied upon by the petitioner remains good law after the amendment to Rule 10 by Act 104/1976.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (defendant)

  • The order decreeing the suit as prayed without recording evidence was erroneous, even if the decree were said to have been passed in exercise of powers under Order VIII Rule 5(2) C.P.C.
  • Order VIII Rule 10 does not apply to the facts of this case (relying on the unreported decision in Sampa Pujari v. Mrs. A. Ramamba L.N. Rai, CRP No. 1092/1965, disposed 5-3-1967).
  • The order, which is a 'judgment' in the sense of Order VIII Rule 5(2) C.P.C., is not in conformity with Order XX Rule 4 C.P.C., and therefore is liable to be set aside.

Respondent's Arguments

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent's (plaintiff's) legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sampa Pujari v. Mrs. A. Ramamba L.N. Rai (C.R.P. No. 1092/1965) (unreported; disposed 5-3-1967) Used by the petitioner to contend that Rule 10 of Order VIII does not apply except where Rule 9 specifically required filing a written statement and time was fixed under Rule 9. The Court held that the Sampa Pujari decision was premised on the pre-1976 unamended text of Rule 10; due to the amendment by Act 104/1976 the view expressed in Sampa Pujari is no longer good law and therefore will not assist the petitioner.
Nagamma v. Venkataramu Authority for the proposition that even when judgment is pronounced on the basis of facts in the plaint (e.g., when defendant fails to plead), the court must examine the plea and facts to determine whether the plaintiff has made out a case for decree. The Court relied on this decision to support the conclusion that the impugned order did not satisfy the minimum requirements of a judgment of a Court of Small Causes (Order XX Rule 4(1)) because it did not state the points for determination and the decision thereon.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by reference to the relevant provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure and statutory definitions contained in the opinion.

  1. Definition: The Court noted that "judgment" under Section 2(9) C.P.C. means the statement given by the judge of the grounds of a decree or order.
  2. Rules Extracted: The Court set out the material portions of Order VIII—Rule 1(1) (requirement to present written statement), Rule 5 (admissions by failure to deny and Rule 5(2) permitting judgment where no pleading has been filed, with discretion to require proof), Rule 9 (court may require a written statement or additional written statement and fix time) and Rule 10 (consequences of failure to present a written statement when required under Rule 1 or Rule 9).
  3. Characterization of impugned order: The order under challenge recorded that the defendant failed to present his written statement on the final date (10-2-1982), that defendant and counsel were absent, and that the Chief Judge placed the defendant ex parte and decreed the suit as prayed with future interest. No evidence was recorded prior to the decree.
  4. Whether Rule 5(2) or Rule 10 applies: The Court reasoned that the impugned order more properly falls within the ambit of Rule 10 rather than Rule 5(2). The distinction drawn in the opinion is that Rule 5(2) permits the court to pronounce judgment on the basis of the facts contained in the plaint where no pleading has been filed, but leaves discretion with the court to require proof of facts; whereas Rule 10 (as amended) makes it obligatory on the court to pronounce judgment (or make such order as it thinks fit) when a party required to present a written statement under Rule 1 or Rule 9 fails to do so within the time permitted or fixed.
  5. Effect of 1976 amendment to Rule 10: The Court emphasized the change effected by Act 104 of 1976: the amended Rule 10 expressly refers to Rule 1 as well as Rule 9. The Court analyzed the prior unamended Rule 10 (which used the expression "so required") and explained that prior to the amendment the rule had been interpreted (in Sampa Pujari and commentary) to apply only where the court had specifically required a written statement under Rule 9 and fixed time. The 1976 amendment, however, explicitly brought Rule 1 within the scope of Rule 10 and thereby expanded the situations in which Rule 10 applies. On that basis the Court concluded Sampa Pujari's restrictive view of Rule 10 "will no more be a good law."
  6. Compliance with Order XX Rule 4 (contents of judgment): The Court then turned to whether the impugned order satisfied the requirements of Order XX Rule 4. Sub-rule (1) provides that judgments of a Court of Small Causes need not contain more than the points for determination and the decision thereon. The Court found the impugned order—which, under Rule 10, amounts to a "judgment"—did not contain the points for determination and the decision thereon as required by Sub-rule (1). The Court observed that even if the court below had power under Order VIII Rule 5(2), it was still incumbent upon the trial court to examine the plea and facts in the plaint to determine whether the plaintiff had made out a case for decree, citing Nagamma v. Venkataramu for that proposition.
  7. Conclusion of analysis: Because the impugned order failed to meet the minimum contents required of a judgment of a Court of Small Causes, the Court held the order did not satisfy the requirements of law and was liable to be set aside.
  8. Remaining contention: The Court declined as unnecessary to decide the separate contention whether decreeing the suit without recording evidence was erroneous, given the finding on the judgment's non-compliance with Order XX Rule 4.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The revision petition is allowed; the impugned order dated 10 February 1982 is set aside.

Direct consequences and directions:

  • The matter is remitted to the court below for fresh disposal in accordance with law after giving both parties an opportunity to put forward their respective contentions and be heard.
  • There is no order as to costs.
  • The lower court is directed to give notice to both parties and to dispose of the case on a top-priority basis within a fortnight from receipt of the order.

Broader implications noted by the Court:

  • The Court held that the earlier view in Sampa Pujari (that Rule 10 applied only where a written statement was required under Rule 9) is no longer good law in view of the amendment to Rule 10 by Act 104/1976 which expressly incorporated Rule 1 within Rule 10's ambit.
  • The opinion does not purport to lay down any wider precedent beyond its interpretation of the amended Rule 10 and the requirement that a "judgment" of a Court of Small Causes contain at least the points for determination and the decision thereon; the immediate effect is to set aside the specific decree and to mandate a fresh hearing consistent with the procedural requirements identified in the opinion.

    Eswara Devaru, S. v. Nagarajaiah, A.R .

    Narayana Rai Kudoor, J.:—

    This revision petition is listed for admission to this day. With the consent of the learned advocates appearing for both parties, the revision petition is demeed to have been set down for final hearing and the petition is heard on merits.

    2. The defendant in S.C No. 3564 of 1981 on the file of the Chief Judge, Court of Small Causes, Bangalore City, has presented this revision against the order dated 10th February 1982 decreeing the suit brought by the plaintiff (respondent-herein) as prayed for with future interest at 6 per cent per annum from the date of suit, till the date of realisation.

    3. The plaintiff instituted the suit against the defendant for the recovery of a sum of Rs. 8250 claiming to be the arrears of rent with costs and current interest. The defendant did not file his written statement although the case was posted for filing the written statement of the defendant finally on 10th February 1982. Since the defendant did not file his written statement, the learned Judge decreed the suit as under:

    “W.S not filed though the case is posted finally to this date. Defendant and counsel absent. Defendant placed ex-parte under Order 8 Rule 5(2) C.P.C The suit of the plaintiff is decreed against the defendant as prayed for in the plaint allowing future interest on Rs. 8,250 at 6 per cent p.a from the date of suit till the date of realisation.”

    It is this order of the learned Chief Judge, Court of Small Causes, Bangalore City, that is sought to be challenged in this revision.

    4. The learned advocate appearing for the petitioner contended inter alia that the order passed by the learned Chief Judge decreeing the suit as prayed for by the plaintiff without recording evidence is erroneous even if the suit was decreed in exercise of the powers conferred under Order VIII Rule 5(2) C.P.C, Order VIII Rule 10 does not apply to the facts of the case and in any event, the order which is a ‘judgment’ in terms of Order VIII Rule 5(2) C.P.C is not in conformity with Order XX Rule 4 C.P.C On these grounds he maintained that the impugned order is liable to be set aside. In support of these contentions, he placed reliance on the unreported decision of this Court in Sampa Pujari v. Mrs. A. Ramamba L.N Rai (C.R.P No. 1092/1965 disposed of on 5th March 1967).

    5. Before adverting to the above contentions urged by the learned counsel for the petitioner, it is useful to refer to the relevant provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure.

    6. ‘Judgment’ as defined under Section 2(9) means the statement given by the judge of the grounds of a decree or order.

    Order VIII of the Code of Civil Procedure to the extent material reads:

    Rule 1(1): “The defendant shall at or before the first hearing or within such time as the Court may permit present a written statement of his defence.”

    Rule 5(1): “Every allegation of fact in the plaint, if not denied specifically or by necessary implication, or stated to be not admitted in the pleading of the defendant, shall be taken to be admitted except as against a person under disability.

    Provided that the Court may in its discretion require any fact so admitted to be proved otherwise than by such admission.”

    Rule 5(2) where the defendant has not filed a pleading, it shall be lawful for the Court to pronounce judgment on the basis of the facts contained in the plaint, except as against a person under a disability, but the Court may, in its discretion, require any such fact to be proved.

    Rule 5(3) xxxx

    5(4): Whenever a judgment is pronounced under this rule, a decree shall be drawn up in accordance with such judgment and such decree shall bear the date on which the judgment was pronounced.”

    Rule 9: no pleading subsequent to the written statement of a defendant other than by way of defence to a set-off on counter claim shall be presented except by the leave of the Court and upon such terms as the Court thinks fit, but the court may at any time require a written statement or additional written statement from any of the parties and fix a time for presenting the same.”

    (Emphasis supplied)

    Rule 10: “Where any party from whom a written statement is required under Rule 1 or Rule 9, fails to present the same within the time permitted or fixed by the Court as the case may be, the Court shall pronounce judgment against him or make such order in relation to the suit as it thinks fit and on the pronouncement of such judgment, a decree shall be drawn up.”

    Order XX Rule: 4:

    “(1) Judgment of a Court of Small Causes need not contain more than the points for determination and the decision thereon.

    (2) Judgments of other Court shall contain a concise statement of the case, the points for determination, the decision thereon, and the reasons for such decision.”

    7. Order VIII Rule 1(1) stipulates that the defendant shall, at or before the first hearing or within such time as the Court may permit, present a written statement of his defence. This would show that the defendant is required to present a written statement setting out his defence; Rule 9 sets out the circumstances when the court may require from any of the parties, a written statement or additional written statement to be filed and fix a time for presenting the same. Rule 10 provides for pronouncing a judgment against a party from whom, a written statement is required under Rule 1 or Rule 9, when he fails to present the same within the time permitted or fixed by the Court, as the case may be, or making such order in relation to the suit as it thinks fit and on the pronouncement of such judgment, a decree shall be drawn up.

    Clause (1) of Rule 5 provides that every allegation of fact in the plaint if not denied specifically or by necessary implication or stated to be not admitted in the pleading of the defendant shall be taken to be admitted except as against a person under disability. The proviso to clause (1) provides that the court may in its discretion require any fact so admitted to be proved otherwise than by such admission. It is obvious that clause (1) provides for a situation, to take the allegation of fact contained in the plaint being admitted, where a defendant having filed a written statement or pleading fails to deny the allegation of fact made in the plaint either specifically a by necessary implication or stating to be not admitted, of course, subject to the discretion of the court requiring any of the facts so admitted to be proved otherwise than by such admission. Clause (2) of Rule 5 declares that where the defendant has not filed a pleading it shall be lawful for the court to pronounce a judgment on the basis of the facts contained in the plaint, except as against a person under disability. Here again, a discretion is left with the court requiring any of the facts stated in the plaint to be proved notwithstanding the fact of the defendant's failure to file a pleading.

    8. The order under challenge would show that the defendant did not present his written statement on 10th February 1982, Although the case was posted for presenting his written statement finally on that day. The defendant and his counsel both were absent. The learned Chief Judge decreed the suit, placing the defendant exparte under Order VIII Rule 5(2) C.P.C, as prayed for in the plaint with future interest at 6 per cent per annum from the date of the suit till the date of realisation. No evidence was recorded before decreeing the suit. This order when tested in the light of the aforesaid provisions, in my opinion, squarely fall within the ambit of Rule, 10, rather than Rule 5(2) of Order VIII, because under Rule 5(2), the Court is not bound to pronounce a Judgment on the basis of the facts contained in the plaint where the defendant has not filed a pleading but merely declares that if the judgment is so pronounced it shall be lawful; whereas under Rule 10, if the party who is required to file a written statement either under Rule 1 or Rule 9, fails to present the same within the time permitted or fixed by the court, as the case may be, the court has no discretion but to pronounce a judgment against such party or make such order in relation to the suit as it thinks fit. Since in the instant case, the defendant had failed to present his written statement which he was required to present under Rule 1 inspite of giving ample opportunities, the order passed in the suit against him attracts the provisions of Rule 10.

    9. The learned Advocate appearing for the petitioner maintained that Order VIII Rule 10 does not apply to the facts of the case placing reliance on the decision of this court in Sampa Pujari's case No. (CRP No. 1092/1965 disposed of on 5th March 1967).

    10. It is true that the learned Judge who disposed of that case, after referring to the provisions of Rules 9 and 10 and also the observation of the learned commentator on Rule 10 of Order VIII in Mulla's Code of Civil Procedure, 13th Edition, by T.L Venkatarama Iyer, has observed thus:

    “Hence it is clear that failure to file a written statement as required by the Court under Rule 9 would attract the provisions of Rule 10. Mere failure to file written statement in other cases does not come within Rule 10 and the Court will have no jurisdiction to pronounce judgment against the defendant in such a case.”

    It must be noticed that this observation was made by the learned Judge on a consideration of Rule's 9 and 10 of Order VIII before Rule 10 of Order VIII Rule 10 was drastically amended by Act 104 of 1976. As it stood prior to the said amendment reads:

    “Where any party from whom a written statement is so required fails to present the same within the time fixed by the Court, the Court may pronounce judgment against him or make such order in relation to the suit as it thinks fit.”

    11. The relevant discussion respecting the scope of the unamended Rule 10 of Order VIII after extracting both Rules 9 and 10 of Order VIII Reads thus:

    “Rule 10 states that where any party from whom a written statement is so required fails to present the same within the time fixed by the court, the Court may pronounce judgment against him. The words “so required” have obviously reference to the previous Rule, which states that no pleadings subsequent to the written statement of the defendant shall be presented except with the leave of the Court, but the Court may at any time require a written statement or additional written statement from any of the parties and fix a time for presenting the same. From a reading of Rules 9 and 10, it looks as if the Court has got jurisdiction to pronounce judgment only if the Court requires a party to file a written statement or additional written statement and fixes a time for presenting the same and if the party commits default.”

    To reinforce the above conclusion, the learned Judge made use of the following observation of the learned Commentator on the Scope of Rule 10 in Mulla's Code of Civil Procedure (13th Edition by T.L Venkatarama Aiyar):

    “This rule enables the Court to pronounce judgment against the defendant on failure to file a written statement such as is required by r. 9. Failure to file a written statement in other cases does not come within this rule, and the Court cannot in those cases pass a decree against the defendant unless the plaintiff proves his case.”

    12. A comparative reading of Rule 10 of Order VIII C.P.C as it stood prior to its amendment by Act 104/1976 and as it now stands would reveal the drastic changes brought about in Rule 10. It is specifically provided under Rule 10 that where a party from whom a written statement is required under Rule 1 or Rule 9 fails to present the same within the time permitted or fixed by the Court, as the case may be, the Court shall pronounce judgment against him or make such order in relation to the suit as it thinks fit and on the pronouncement of such judgment a decree shall be drawn up.

    The aforesaid underlined portions of Rule 10 are the changes brought about by the 1976 amendment. There was no mention either of Rule 1 or Rule 9 in the unamended Rule 10 from whom a written statement is required so as to attract the provisions of Rule 10. The expression in this respect used in the unamended Rule 10 was “where a party from whom a written statement is so required and construing this expression in the light of Rule 9, the learned Judge reached the conclusion that the Court has got jurisdiction to pronounce judgment under Rule 10 only if the Court requires a party to file a written statement or additional written statement and fixes a time for presenting the same under Rule 9 and if the party commits default, and in no other case where there is a mere failure to file a written statement by the defendant, in which case the Court will have no jurisdiction to pronounce judgment against the defendant. Now it is seen from the amendment brought to Rule 10, that Rule 1 is specifically brought within the ambit of rule 10 which makes obligatory for the defendant to present a written statement of his defence in the suit. Thus as Rule 10 now stands, where a defendant from whom a written statement is required under Rule 1 or Rule 9 fails to present the same within the time permitted or fixed by the court, as the case may be, the provisions of Rule 10 would come into play and the court shall pronounce a judgment against the defendant or make such order in relation to the suit as thinks fit. This being the correct position in law, in my considered opinion, in view of the changes brought about in the relevant provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure by the Amendment Act 104/1976, the view expressed by the learned Judge in Sampa Pujari's case (C.R.P No. 1092/1965 D.D 5th March 1967) that Rule 10 would come into play only in a case where there is a failure to file a written statement by the defendant as required under Rule 9 will no more be a good law. Hence, the aforesaid decision will not help the learned Advocate for the petitioner to sustain his first contention.

    13. Now turning to the next contention that the order under challenge is liable to be set aside as it is not in conformity with Order XX Rule 4 C.P.C, in my considered opinion, this contention appears to be well founded.

    14. Rule 10 of Order VIII provides for the Court to pronounce a judgment against a party from whom a written statement is required under Rule 1 or Rule 9 when he fails to present the same within the time permitted or fixed by the Court as the case may be and on the pronouncement of such judgment, a decree shall be drawn up. ‘Judgment’ as defined under Section 2(9) means the statement given by the Judge of the grounds of a decree or order. Rule 4 of Order XX provides for the contents of a judgment of court of small causes and judgments of other courts. Sub-rule (1) of Rule 4 provides that a judgment of a court of small causes need not contain more than the points for determination and the decision thereon whereas sub-rule (2) of Rule 4 provides that the judgments of other courts shall contain a concise statement of the case, the points for determination, the decision thereon and the reasons for such decision. The minimum that is required of a judgment of a court of small causes is that it shall contain the points for determination and the decision thereon. In the instant case, the order under challenge, which amounts to a ‘judgment’ within the meaning of Rule 10 of Order VIII, does not contain the points for determination and the decision thereon as required under Sub-rule (1) of Rule 4 of Order XX CPC. Assuming for the sake of argument that the court below had the power to act under Order VIII Rule 5(2) C.P.C even then the order under challenge is not in conformity with Rule 5(2) where it is provided that it shall be lawful for the court to pronounce judgment on the basis of the facts contained in the plaint where the defendant has not filed a pleading. Even in such a case, it was obligatory for the court below to have examined the plea and the facts set out in the plaint to find out whether the plaintiff has made out a case for passing a decree in his suit as prayed. The decision in Nagamma v. Venkataramu(1) is on the point. Thus, it seems to me that the order under challenge does not satisfy the requirements of law and, as such, is liable to be set aside.

    15. In view of my findings on the aforesaid contentions, it seems to me unnecessary to record a finding on the remaining contention canvassed on behalf of the petitioner whether the order passed by the learned Chief Judge of Small Causes, decreeing the suit without recording evidence is erroneous or not.

    16. In the result, for the reasons stated above, the revision petition is allowed. The order under challenge is set aside. The matter is remitted to the court below for fresh disposal in accordance with law after giving opportunity to both parties to put-forward their respective contentions and of being heard. There is no order as to costs. The lower court is directed to dispose of this case on top-priority basis after giving notice to both parties within a fortnight from the date of receipt of this order.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Eswara Devaru, S. v. Nagarajaiah, A.R .
    (Sep 2, 1982)