Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 22(1) of the Specific Relief Act, 1963
  • clause (a) and (b) of sub-section (1)
  • sub-section (2) of Section 22
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 22(1) of the Specific Relief Act, 1963
  • clause (a) and (b) of sub-section (1)
  • sub-section (2) of Section 22
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant sought leave from this court to institute a suit for specific performance of an agreement relating to the conveyance of two items of land, one of which was also sought to be possessed. The land in question was situated outside the jurisdiction of this court. The appellant contended that since the defendants resided within the court's jurisdiction and the agreement was entered into in Madras, leave should be granted. The court refused leave, prompting the appellant to challenge that refusal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether this court has jurisdiction to entertain a suit for specific performance and possession of land situated outside its territorial jurisdiction when the defendants reside within the court's jurisdiction and the agreement was entered into within the court's jurisdiction.
  2. The interpretation and application of Clause 12 of the Letters Patent concerning the territorial jurisdiction of the High Court in suits relating to land or other immovable property.
  3. Whether possession as a relief is inherently included in a suit for specific performance or must be specifically claimed.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The defendants reside within the jurisdiction of this court.
  • The agreement for sale was entered into in the city of Madras, within this court's jurisdiction.
  • Therefore, leave to institute the suit should have been granted.
  • Relied on the decision of Bank of Madurai Ltd v. Balramadoss and Bros, AIR 1985 Mad. 1, which analyzed Clause 12 of the Letters Patent to support the appellant’s claim.
  • Referred to observations in Babu Lal v. M/s Hazari Lai Kishore Lal (AIR 1982 SC 818) that possession is inherent in the relief of specific performance.

Court's Response to Arguments

  • Distinguished the Bank of Madurai Ltd v. Balramadoss decision based on the Supreme Court’s later ruling in Adcon Electronics Pvt. Ltd v. Daulut (2001 (7) SCC 690), which clarified the scope of Clause 12 of the Letters Patent.
  • Held that Clause 12 first refers exclusively to suits relating to land or immovable property situated within the court’s jurisdiction, and only thereafter to other cases where cause of action or defendant’s residence matters.
  • Clarified that possession as a relief must be specifically claimed as per Section 22(1) of the Specific Relief Act, 1963, relying on the Supreme Court’s ruling in Adcon Electronics Pvt. Ltd v. Daulat (2001 (7) SCC 698).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Bank of Madurai Ltd v. Balramadoss and Bros, AIR 1985 Mad. 1 Interpretation of Clause 12 of the Letters Patent regarding jurisdiction in suits involving land and other cases. The court held this decision was impliedly overruled by the Supreme Court and disagreed with its analysis of Clause 12.
Adcon Electronics Pvt. Ltd v. Daulut, 2001 (7) SCC 690 Clarification of Clause 12 of the Letters Patent of the Bombay High Court, analogous to this court’s Clause 12, defining jurisdiction in suits for land and other cases. Applied to hold that suits for land must relate to land situated within the court’s jurisdiction for the court to have jurisdiction; residence of defendant or cause of action within jurisdiction applies only to other cases.
Babu Lal v. M/s Hazari Lai Kishore Lal, AIR 1982 SC 818 Observations that possession relief is inherent in specific performance suits. Considered obiter and not binding; possession relief must be specifically claimed.
Adcon Electronics Pvt. Ltd v. Daulat, 2001 (7) SCC 698 Interpretation of Section 22(1) and (2) of the Specific Relief Act, 1963, regarding reliefs ancillary to specific performance. Held that possession relief is an enabling provision and must be specifically claimed; courts cannot grant possession relief unless specifically prayed for.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed Clause 12 of the Letters Patent, which governs the territorial jurisdiction of the High Court in original suits. It noted that Clause 12 first addresses suits relating to land or immovable property, limiting jurisdiction to cases where the property is situated within the court's local limits. Only after this does it address other cases where jurisdiction depends on the cause of action arising within the local limits or the defendant residing or working there.

Applying this principle, the court concluded that since the suit concerned land located outside its jurisdiction, the court lacked jurisdiction despite the defendants residing within the jurisdiction and the agreement being entered there. The appellant’s reliance on the Bank of Madurai Ltd decision was rejected as it had been implicitly overruled by the Supreme Court’s ruling in Adcon Electronics.

Regarding the relief of possession, the court referred to the Specific Relief Act, 1963, and the Supreme Court’s interpretation that possession relief is not automatically granted with specific performance but must be specifically claimed. The appellant’s claim for possession was noted, but since the court lacked jurisdiction to entertain the suit, the refusal of leave was justified.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is dismissed.

The plaint is to be returned to the appellant for presentation in the court having proper jurisdiction over the land in question. The appellant’s counsel is directed to receive the papers within two weeks and re-present the suit within six weeks in the appropriate court.

This decision confines the jurisdiction of this court strictly to suits relating to land situated within its territorial limits, reaffirming the binding effect of Clause 12 of the Letters Patent as interpreted by the Supreme Court. It clarifies that possession relief under specific performance claims must be expressly sought. No new precedent was laid beyond applying existing authoritative rulings.

    S.K.J Dhanasekar, No. 2 Lady Madava Road Mahalingapuram Chennai-34 v. S.V.S Jawaharlal, E-1, H.I.G Flats, Mogappair, Chennai-50

    R. Jayasimha Babu, J.

    1. The appellant is aggrieved by the refusal of leave to institute a suit in this court seeking the relief of specific performance of an agreement for the conveyance of land situated outside the jurisdiction of this court as also the possession of one of the items of the lands, subject matter of the agreement being two items of land.

    2. Learned counsel for the appellant submitted that the defendants reside within the jurisdiction of this court and that the agreement was also entered into in this city of Madras and, therefore, the leave ought to have been granted.

    3. Counsel placed reliance on the decision of a Division Bench of this Court in the case of Bank of Madurai Ltd v. Balramadoss and Bros, AIR 1985 Mad. 1 wherein the court analysed clause 12 of the Letters Patent and held that it consist of three parts, first dealing with suits for land; the second, cases where cause of action has arisen within the jurisdiction of the court; and a third category which comprises of all suits wherein the defendants, at the time of commencement of the suits shall dwell or carry on business or personally works for gain.

    4. The Supreme Court had occasion to consider clause 12 of the letters patent of the Bombay High Court in a recently reported case which is directly in point here. That is the case of Adcon Electronics Pvt. Ltd v. Daulut, 2001 (4) CTC 39: 2001 (7) SCC 690. At paragraph 7 of the judgment clause 12 of the Letters Patent of the Bombay High Court has been set out. That clause is in pan materia with clause 12 of the Letters Patent of this Court. In paragraph 9 of that judgment, the Court set out its analysis of the clause in the following terms,

    “ Thus it is clear that under Clause 12 of the Letter Patent the High Court in exercise of its ordinary original jurisdiction will have power to receive, try and determine

    (1) Suits for land or other immovable property if such property is situated within the local limits of original jurisdiction of the High Court or

    (2) all other cases,

    (a) if the cause of action has arisen wholly within the local limits of the ordinary original jurisdiction of the High Court;

    (b) if prior leave of the court has been obtained and the cause of action has arisen in part within the local limits of the ordinary original jurisdiction of the High Court; or

    (c) If the defendants dwell or carries on business or personally work for gain within such limits.”

    5. It is thus clear that clause 12 refers only to two classes of case one suits relating to lands to other immovable properties, and the second, cases other than those relating to land or other immovable property. The dwelling of the defendant within the jurisdiction of the court or the cause of action arising within the jurisdiction of the court whether in whole or in part will be relevant only in cases where the subject matter of the suit is not land or other immovable property.

    6. The decision of this court in Bank of Madurai Ltd v. Balramadoss and Bros, AIR 1985 Mad. 1 must be held been impliedly overruled by the Supreme Court by the said judgment. We may also record that we do not find ourselves in agreement with the analysis of clause 12 made in the judgment of this court reported in Bank of Madurai Ltd v. Balramadoss and Bros, AIR 1985 Mad. 1.

    7. Clause 12 of the Letter Patent clearly refers at the first instance to “in the case of suits for land or other immovable property”. It thereafter refers to “ or in all other cases”. The words “or in all other cases” refer to all cases and other than suits for land or other immovable property.

    8. In this case the appellant had sought the relief of possession in the plaint filed by it. The suit was clearly one for land, and the land not being situated within the jurisdiction of this Court, the suit was not maintainable in this Court. The decision of the learned single Judge declining to grant leave was fully justified.

    9. Learned counsel for the appellant drew our attention to certain observations of the Supreme Court in the case of Babu LaL v. M/s Hazari Lai Kishore LaL, AIR 1982 SC 818 in particular to the observations that the relief of possession is inherent in the relief for specific performance of the contract for sale. However, those observations are only obiter and cannot be regarded having laid down the law. In that case the Court only pointed out that the relief of possession may not be required in cases where the person was already in possession.

    10. The Supreme Court in the case of Adcon Electronic Pvt. Ltd v. Daulat, 2001 (4) CTC 39: 2001 (7) SCC 698 also has dealt with this aspect directly and has pointed out that Section 22(1) of the Specific Relief Act, 1963 is an enabling provision and that the plaintiff in a suit for Specific performance may ask for further reliefs mentioned in Sections (a) and (b) thereof. The Court went on to say that,

    “Clause (a) contains reliefs of possession and partition and separate possession of property in addition to specific performance. The mandate of sub-section (2) of Section 22 is that no relief on clause (a) and (b) of sub-section (1) shall be granted by the Court unless it has been specifically claimed. Thus, it follows that no Court can grant a relief for possession of land or other immovable property subject matter of the agreement for sale in regard to which specific performance is claimed, unless the possession of the immovable property is specifically prayed for.”

    11. The appeal is therefore dismissed. The plaint shall be returned to the appellant for re-presenting it in the court which has the necessary jurisdiction. Copy of this order shall be furnished to the counsel for the appellant within the next two weeks to enable him to take the papers and present it in the appropriate court which shall be done within six weeks from today.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    S.K.J Dhanasekar, No... v. S.V.S Jawaharlal, E-...
    (Apr 17, 2002)