Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion by Honniah, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from the State's challenge to the acquittal, by the First Additional Sessions Judge, Bangalore (judgment dated 31-3-1969), of four accused (A-1 to A-4) charged under Sections 120B, 489A, 489B and 489C of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) for alleged criminal conspiracy and counterfeiting of Rs. 10 currency notes between 21-3-1965 and 22-2-1966.

Briefly, the prosecution alleged that all four accused conspired to counterfeit Rs. 10 notes and ultimately counterfeited a large number of such notes. The trial court acquitted all four, principally holding that prosecution witnesses (PWs 10, 11, 12, 15, 16 and 17) were accomplices whose testimony lacked independent corroboration, and therefore could not be relied upon to establish conspiracy or the counterfeiting offences.

After the appeal was filed, the State Public Prosecutor informed the Court that the fourth respondent (A-4) had died; accordingly the appeal does not proceed against A-4. On appeal the High Court reviewed (a) the credibility and corroboration of accomplice evidence relied on to prove conspiracy; (b) the sufficiency of evidence against A-2 and A-3 (who occupied a room in a bungalow associated with A-4 where part of the premises was used as a press); and (c) the sufficiency of evidence that A-1 was in possession of forged/counterfeit notes and had the requisite knowledge/intent under S. 489-C IPC.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the prosecution proved, beyond reasonable doubt, a criminal conspiracy among A-1 to A-4 to counterfeit Rs. 10 currency notes (S. 120B IPC), given that key witnesses were held to be accomplices.
  2. Whether the trial court was correct in acquitting A-2, A-3 (and by parity A-4) where notes were recovered from a room they had occupied but they were not present at the time of recovery.
  3. Whether the seizure of 4,508 currency notes from A-1 (alleged forged/counterfeit notes) was proved and, if proved, whether these notes qualified as "forged or counterfeit" within the meaning of S. 489-C read with S. 28 IPC.
  4. Whether the possession by A-1 of a large number of forged/counterfeit notes permits a permissible inference (or presumption of fact) that A-1 knew or had reason to believe the notes were forged/counterfeit and intended to use them as genuine (elements required under S. 489-C IPC).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (State / State Public Prosecutor)

  • Contended that the acquittal of the accused was erroneous and that the prosecution had proved conspiracy and offences under S. 489A, 489B and 489C read with S. 120B IPC.
  • Persisted particularly in the case against A-1: emphasized that A-1 was found in possession of 4,508 forged notes and that this possession was conclusive evidence warranting conviction under S. 489-C IPC.
  • Relied upon the expert opinion (PW 9) and the seizure evidence (PWs 13 and 14) to establish both the physical possession and the forged/counterfeit character of the notes.

Respondents / Defence (as reflected by trial court findings)

  • The learned Sessions Judge disbelieved the prosecution's principal witnesses regarding conspiracy (PWs 10, 11, 12, 15, 16 and 17) on the ground that they were accomplices and their testimony lacked independent corroboration; accordingly the trial court held the prosecution failed to prove conspiracy or the counterfeiting offences against all accused.
  • As to A-2 and A-3, the defence position (accepted by the trial court and not seriously disputed by the State Public Prosecutor on appeal) was that although some forged notes were recovered from a room they had previously occupied, they were not present when the notes were recovered and there was no evidence that the press in that bungalow was used to manufacture counterfeit notes; hence acquittal of A-2 and A-3 was appropriate.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Public Prosecutor v. Rowthula Kondanda Rao (Madras) The number of counterfeit notes found in a person's possession and the circumstances of discovery can, by themselves, justify drawing the inference that the intention was to use them as genuine. The Court relied on this authority to support the proposition that possession of a large quantity of forged/counterfeit notes (here 4,508 notes) permits the inference that the possessor intended to use them as genuine.
In Re. Satyanarayana (Andhra Pradesh) Possession of multiple counterfeit notes (here thirty of the same type) kept locked in a trunk and produced without explanation supports the inference that the accused knew or had reason to believe the notes were counterfeit and intended to use them as genuine. The Court cited this decision as a parallel authority showing that unexplained possession of several counterfeit notes supports conviction under S. 489-C.
In re Ameerjan (former Mysore High Court) Similar treatment of cases where possession of multiple counterfeit notes led to the inference of knowledge and intent; the decision also extracts and follows the rationale in Sher Mohomed v. Emperor. The Court found Ameerjan analogous and relied on its reasoning to justify drawing an indubitable inference from the circumstances of possession in the present case.
Sher Mohomed v. Emperor (Lahore High Court) Where an incriminating article is discovered in a place hidden from public view and pointed out by the accused, it legitimately supports the inference that the accused was privy to the felony; the Court emphasized that inference drawing is fact-specific and for the judge. The High Court quoted this passage (via Ameerjan) to illustrate the proper approach to drawing inferences from discovery and possession of incriminating articles; used to support the conclusion that possession of the large bundle of notes justified the inference of guilt.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded through a sequence of focused legal analyses, applying statutory definitions and evaluating witness credibility strictly on the evidence before it:

  1. Assessment of the conspiracy evidence: The only evidence to establish conspiracy comprised testimony of PWs 10, 11, 12, 15, 16 and 17. The Sessions Judge had classified these witnesses as accomplices and declined to rely on them in the absence of independent corroboration. The High Court reviewed these witnesses' evidence and concluded that the Sessions Judge's approach to treating them as accomplices and requiring corroboration was a proper appreciation of both the facts and the law; thus the acquittal on the conspiracy counts was upheld.
  2. Evidence in respect of A-2, A-3 and A-4: The prosecution's case against A-2 and A-3 rested on proof that they occupied a room in A-4's bungalow, part of which was used as a printing press, and that forged notes were recovered from that room. The Court noted there was no evidence that the press was used to manufacture counterfeit notes and that, crucially, A-2 and A-3 were not present when the police recovered the notes. Given these facts, the Court agreed that recovery from a room previously occupied by the accused does not establish either counterfeiting or possession by those accused in the absence of stronger proof; accordingly the acquittals of A-2 and A-3 were affirmed. The evidence about A-4 was similar and, since A-4 had died, the appeal against him abated.
  3. Seizure and characterization of notes in A-1's possession: The Court accepted the evidence of PWs 13 and 14 that 4,508 Rs. 10 notes (marked M.O.1) were seized from A-1 on 22-2-1966. It accepted the expert evidence of PW 9 (Claude D'Souza) who examined the notes (Ex. P-3), concluded they were forged, and explained they could be passed off as genuine in dim light and in bundles. Applying S.28 IPC (definition of "counterfeit"), the Court emphasized that counterfeiting does not require exact imitation — it is sufficient that the resemblance is such that deception might be practised. The Court found the Sessions Judge erred in discarding the seizure evidence and the expert's conclusions and in failing to apply S.28 along with S.463 and S.489-C.
  4. Mens rea and drawing the factual presumption under S.489-C: The Court set out the legal burden under S.489-C — the prosecution must prove facts that lead "clearly, indubitably and irresistibly" to the inference that the accused knew or had reason to believe the notes were forged/counterfeit and intended them to be used as genuine. Having found the physical seizure and expert opinion established the forged character of the notes, the Court examined surrounding circumstances: A-1 was found sitting on a bench with a bundle tied in a towel containing a dealwood box in which the 4,508 notes were found; A-1 offered no reasonable explanation. From these circumstances the Court held that the only plausible inference was that A-1 possessed the notes for trafficking and intended to use them (or facilitate their use) as genuine. The Court treated this as a permissible presumption of fact, supported by the cited authorities.
  5. Conclusion as to guilt: On the combined findings (seizure proved, expert opinion that notes were forged, the factual circumstances of possession, and absence of satisfactory explanation), the Court concluded the prosecution had discharged its onus and that the trial judge had erred in failing to draw the appropriate inference. Accordingly, the Court set aside A-1's acquittal on the S.489-C charge and convicted him.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The appeal is allowed in part. The High Court set aside the trial court's acquittal of A-1 and convicted him for an offence under Section 489-C IPC; A-1 was sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for two years. The appeals against A-2 and A-3 are dismissed. The appeal as to A-4 abates because he is dead.

Direct consequences and orders:

  • A-1: Convicted under S.489-C IPC and sentenced to rigorous imprisonment for two years.
  • A-2 and A-3: Acquittals by the trial court are affirmed; the State's appeal as to them is dismissed.
  • A-4: Appeal abates on account of death.
  • The order concerning disposal of property made by the learned Sessions Judge remains undisturbed.

Broader implications: The opinion relied on established authorities to justify drawing a factual inference of knowledge and intent from unexplained possession of a substantial number of forged/counterfeit notes. The Court did not purport to lay down a new legal principle beyond applying S.28 and S.489-C IPC and the cited precedents to the facts before it.

    State Of Mysore v. Sthapathi Natarajan & Others

    Honniah, J.:— This is an appeal by the State against the acquittal of respondents (Accused 1 to 4 in the trial Court) of the offences under Ss. 489A, 489B & 489C read with S. 120B IPC. A-1 was a resident of Uttarakosamangai in Ramnad District, A-2 was a resident of Velur Satrapatti in Dindigai Taluk, and A-3 was a resident of Salem all belonging to Tamil Nadu. A-4 was a Matadipathi of Kudali Sringeri Mutt, in the District of Shimoga. After the appeal was filed, the learned State Public Prosecutor submitted, the 4th respondent died. Therefore, we are not concerned in this appeal with the case against A-4.

    2. The case for the prosecution, briefly stated is that between 21-3-1965 and 22-2-1966 all the four accused entered into a criminal conspiracy to counterfeit currency notes of the denomination of Rs. 10 and for that purpose they adopted various means and in fact ultimately they counterfeited large number of currency notes of the denomination of Rs. 10. Under these circumstances, the prosecution alleged that they had committed offences under Ss. 120B, 489A, 489B and 489C IPC. All these four accused were tried by the First Additional Sessions Judge, Bangalore, who, by his judgment dated 31-3-1969, acquitted all of them holding that the prosecution had failed to prove the charge of conspiracy, much less the charges under Ss. 489A, 489B and 489C IPC. As regards the case against the accused that they conspired, during the period stated above, to counterfeit currency notes of the denomination of Rs. 10 the only evidence placed on record is that of PWs. 10, 11, 12, 15, 16 and 17. All these witnesses no doubt have stated the various parts taken by each of the accused in order to achieve their object. The learned Sessions Judge, after scrutinising the evidence carefully, was of the view that they were accomplices and in the absence of any independent corroboration to support their version, it was not desirable to rely upon the testimony of the accomplices and in that view he disbelieved all these witnesses. We have gone through the evidence of these witnesses and we have no doubt that the conclusion reached by the learned Sessions Judge is based upon proper appreciation of evidence and the law on the point.

    3. So far as the case against A-2 and A-3 is concerned, the only evidence relied upon by the prosecution is that at a particular point of time during the relevant period they were occupying a room in the bungalow called “Sachidananda Prasad” belonging to A-4 at Bangalore near Lalbagh, a portion of which was used as a printing press. There is no evidence worth the name that the printing press was made use of for the purpose, namely manufacturing counterfeit currency notes. But, however, the learned State Public Prosecutor relied upon one circumstance that from the room A-2 and A-3 had occupied certain currency notes were recovered and that according to the opinion of the Expert, they were found to be forged notes.

    4. It is no doubt true, there is the evidence of one Subba Bhatta (PW. 11), who was the manager of the press, which establishes that A-2 and A-3 were occupying the room in question and from that room some forged currency notes were recovered by the Police. But at the time when the notes were recovered, it is in the evidence of the Police Officer as well as PW. 11 Subba Bhatt that A-2 and A-3 were not present. In these circumstances, recovery of certain forged notes from a room which had been previously occupied by A-2 and A-3, it cannot be said that they either counterfeited the notes or they were in possession of those notes. The learned State Public Prosecutor did not seriously dispute the conclusion of the learned Sessions Judge, rightly, that A-2 and A-3 had not committed any offence with which they were charged. Although A-4 is dead, the evidence so far as A-4 is concerned, is also similar to the evidence against A-2 and A-3 and therefore the acquittal of A-4 cannot, in our opinion, be said to be wrong.

    5. However, the State Public Prosecutor strenuously urged that the evidence against A-1 that he was found in possession of 4508 forged notes of the denomination of Rs. 10 is conclusive and that the learned Sessions Judge was wholly wrong in acquitting him of the offence punishable under S. 489-C of IPC. on the ground that they were not counterfeit currency notes. S. 489-C reads as follows:

    “Whoever, has in his possession any forged or counterfeit Currency note or banknote, knowing or having reason to believe the same to be forged or counterfeit and intending to use the same as genuine or that it may be used as genuine, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to seven years, or with fine, or with both.”

    6. Section 28 of IPC, defines the expression “counterfeit” in the following terms:

    “A person is said to “counterfeit” who causes one thing to resemble another thing, intending by means of that resemblance to practise deception or knowing it to be likely that deception will thereby be practised.

    Explanation: 1. It is not essential, to counterfeiting that the imitation should be exact.

    Explanation: 2. When a person causes on thing to resemble another thing, and the resemblance is such that a person might be deceived thereby, it shall be presumed, until the contrary is proved, that the person so causing the one thing to resemble the other thing intended by means of that resemblance to practise deception or knew it to be likely that deception would thereby be practised.”

    7. Under this section it is not necessary to show that deception actually took place. Intention to practise deception by causing one thing to resemble another is quite sufficient. It is clear from a reading of the section that the word ‘counterfeit’ does not connote an exact reproduction of the original counterfeited. The difference between the counterfeit and the original is not therefore limited to a difference existing only by reason of faulty reproduction. There can be counterfeiting even though the imitation is not exact and though there are differences in detail between the original and the imitation so long as the resemblance is so close that deception may thereby be practised. Reliance was placed on the evidence of P.W 14 Hanumanth Devisineh Nandedkar, who was then the Inspector of Police at Basavangudi, P.W 13 K.M Lingam, owner of an Engineering Firm in Bangalore and P.W 9 Claude D'Souza, Supervisor and Expert in detection of forged Currency and Bank-notes, who was working in the Indian Security Press at Nasik.

    ******

    8. The evidence of P.Ws 13 and 14, conclusively and positively establishes that on 22-2-66 at about 5-30 P.M currency notes of the denomination of Rs. 10 numbering 4508 (marked as M.O 1) were seized from the possession of A-1.

    9. The next question is whether these notes were forged notes or counterfeit notes. On this question we have the evidence of the Expert, P.W 9 Claude D'Souza. He examined the notes in question and submitted his report Ex. P-3 giving reasons and according to him these notes were forged notes but they did not bear any number. He has given several reasons to come to the conclusion that these notes were forged. He has stated that it was possible to pass off these notes as genuine ones in dim light and also in bundles. We are of the view that the evidence of P.Ws 13 and 14 taken along with the evidence of P.W 9 conclusively establishes that A-1 was found in possession of forged or counterfeit notes numbering 4508. The learned Sessions Judge, in spite of the conclusive evidence of P.Ws 13 and 14, was in error in coming to the conclusion that the seizure of these notes from A-1 had not been proved although A-1 himself admits that at the relevant time he was present and some articles at least were seized from him under Ex. P-46. The approach of the learned Sessions Judge in discarding the evidence of these witnesses is far from satisfactory. If he had really applied his mind properly and examined the evidence in the normal course, he would not have come to the conclusion that he has now arrived at. Again we have got to observe here that the learned Sessions Judge was wholly wrong, in spite of the evidence of PW. 9 who is an expert on this point, in holding that the notes in question are not counterfeit notes. He appears to have no applied his mind to the provisions of S. 28 much less the provisions of S. 463 and 489-C of IPC. The prosecution in this case has placed very satisfactory and conclusive evidence that A-1 was found in possession of notes, either counterfeit or forged ones, and that they were seized on 22-2-1966 under Ex. P-45 by P.W 14 in the presence of P.W 13.

    10. This takes us to the question whether A-1 possessed these notes knowing or having reason to believe the same to be forged or counterfeit and intending to use the same as genuine or that it may be used as genuine. Under S. 489-C the onus lies on the prosecution to prove circumstances which lead clearly, indubitably and irresistibly to the inference that the accused had an intention to foist the currency-notes on the public. The prosecution must, therefore, call relevant evidence to lay foundation for a presumption to be drawn that the accused was in possession of the notes knowing or having reason to believe the same to be forged or counterfeit and intending to use the same as genuine or that it may be used as genuine. On the facts of this case, it has got to be said affirmatively that the prosecution have discharged their burden for more than one reason. To recapitulate, the accused (A-1) was sitting on a bench with a bundle tied in a towel, in which there was dealwood box, which contained 4508 currency notes of 10 rupees denomination. These notes were proved to be forged notes. In the circumstances, therefore, in the absence of any reasonable explanation tendered by the accused, this case must give rise to the presumption that possession of such notes was for trafficking in currency notes. That presumption, no doubt, is a presumption of fact, which can be drawn from the circumstances of the case. The fact that A-1 was found in possession of such large number of notes leads to the inevitable inference that he intended to use the same as genuine or that it may be used as genuine. This view of ours is supported by two decisions, one of Madras and another of Andhra Pradesh High Courts. In Public Prosecutor v. Rowthula Kondanda Rao(1) the accused was found in possession of 38 counterfeit ten rupee currency notes, 30 of which had been tied up in a piece of cloth worn by him on his person and the remaining 8 were produced by him from a box in his house soon afterwards on being questioned by the Police. A mere look at those notes revealed that every one must have known them to be counterfeit ones. Dealing with the question whether possession of such notes was punishable under S. 489-C IPC., this is what the Court observed:

    “The number of counterfeit notes found in a man's possession and the circumstances in which they were so found may by themselves constitute a sufficient ground for drawing the inference that the intention was to use them as genuine or that they may be used as genuine.”

    and in that view of the matter, the learned Judge set aside the judgment of acquittal and convicted the accused. This view has been followed by the High Court of Andhra Pradesh In Re. Satyanarayana(2). In that case, the accused was found to have thirty counterfeit currency notes, all of the same type. He had kept them safely locked in a steel trunk in his house with the key in his possession and had produced them before the Police in pursuance of his statement to the Police. When confronted with the large body of evidence about his possession, he denied having made the statement and produced the notes without any explanation whatsoever about his possession of the same. On the said facts it was held that on the facts and circumstances of the case, the accused must have known or at least must have had reason to believe that the notes were counterfeit and also had the intention of using the counterfeit currency notes as genuine or that they might be used as genuine. Similar view has been taken by the former Mysore High Court In re Ameerjan(3).

    11. The story of the accused obviously being untrue and having regard to the conclusive nature of the evidence adduced by the prosecution regarding possession of large number of notes, numbering 4508, it is really impossible to conceive of any other intention than the intention of using the notes as genuine or that they may be used as genuine, and no other intention can even be suggested. In Ameerjan's case referred to above, their Lordships were dealing with a similar case and in that case they have extracted a portion of the decision of the Lahore High Court in Sher Mohomed v. Emperor(4). The relevant part of the said extract is quoted below:

    “…….. The true position is that it is for the Court in each case to draw any such inference as may be legitimate or reasonable in the circumstances. The question what inference from a relevant fact may be drawn as to the existence or otherwise of a fact in issue and with what degree of certainty is in each case a matter for the Judge to determine on the facts of that case and cannot be regulated by a generalization. The outstanding fact in such cases is that the discovery of the incriminating article from a place which is hidden from public view but is pointed out by the accused unmistakably shows that the accused was in some way privy to the felony…………”

    12. On examining the entire evidence we are satisfied that the prosecution have proved satisfactorily beyond reasonable doubt that A-1 has committed an offence punishable under S. 489-C of IPC. The learned trial Judge in our opinion, erred in failing to draw a clear indubitable and irresistible inference from the facts established by the prosecution. We, therefore, allow this appeal in part and set aside the judgment of acquittal of A-1 and convict him for an offence under S. 489-C and sentence him to undergo rigorous imprisonment for two years. So far as the appeal against A-2 and A-3 is concerned it is dismissed. The appeal against A-4 abates as he is dead. The order regarding the disposal of property made by the learned Sessions Judge stands.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State Of Mysore v. Sthapathi Natarajan & Others
    (Mar 18, 1971)