Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The original plaintiff brought a suit for taking accounts and redemption of a mortgage deed dated 24-6-1879 under Section 15(D) of the Deccan Agriculturists Relief Act, 1879. The property in question originally belonged to four brothers who executed an usufructuary mortgage deed in favor of certain mortgagees. After the death of one mortgagor, the remaining three executed an unregistered sale deed in favor of one mortgagee, Nabisaheb, who continued possession. The plaintiff, a successor in interest of the original mortgagors, sought redemption of the mortgage and accounts, asserting the mortgage was still subsisting.

The defendants, heirs of the original mortgagees, resisted the suit claiming they perfected title by adverse possession based on the unregistered sale deed dated 26th May 1890. Both the trial and appellate courts accepted the defendants' contention that their title was perfected by adverse possession, extinguishing the plaintiff's equity of redemption, and dismissed the suit. The plaintiff challenged the appellate decree by way of a second appeal under Section 100 of the Civil Procedure Code.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the defendants, heirs of the original mortgagees, had perfected their title by adverse possession, thereby extinguishing the plaintiff's equity of redemption.
  2. Whether the unregistered sale deed dated 26th May 1890 (Ext. 69) could be used as evidence to prove the character of possession and thereby support the claim of adverse possession.
  3. Whether the courts below erred in relying upon the unregistered sale deed for ascertaining the character of possession despite its inadmissibility for want of registration.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The finding that defendants perfected title by adverse possession was not in accordance with law.
  • The unregistered sale deed Ext. 69 was inadmissible as evidence because the consideration exceeded Rs. 100 and the deed was not registered as required by law.
  • The courts below erred in relying on the unregistered sale deed to determine the character of possession.
  • Relied on the precedent in K. Thimmiah v. B.H Nanjappa to contend that unregistered documents cannot be used to prove character of possession, invoking Sections 49 of the Registration Act and 54 of the Transfer of Property Act.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondents' arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
K. Thimmiah v. B.H Nanjappa Unregistered sale deed cannot be used to prove character of possession under Sections 49 Registration Act and 54 Transfer of Property Act. The Court examined the judgment and found the headnote inaccurate; the original judgment did not prohibit use of unregistered documents for collateral proof of possession character.
Padina Vithoba Chakkayya v. Mohd. Multani Possession by mortgagee cannot ripen into adverse possession unless there is a transaction changing possession character; unregistered documents inadmissible to prove title but admissible to show character of possession. Supported the Court's view that the unregistered sale deed could be used to prove change in possession character, enabling adverse possession claim.
N. Varada Pillai v. Jeevarathnamma Unregistered documents inadmissible to transfer title but admissible to show character of possession. Reinforced the principle that unregistered sale deeds can be used for collateral purposes like proving possession character.
Karnam Kandasmamy Pillai v. Chinnabha Unregistered sale cannot transfer interest but can show nature of transferee's possession; possession as owner can ripen into title by adverse possession. Approved by Supreme Court and applied to justify use of Ext. 69 to prove possession as owner, supporting adverse possession claim.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the appellant's contention regarding inadmissibility of the unregistered sale deed Ext. 69. It found that the headnote relied upon by the appellant from K. Thimmiah v. B.H Nanjappa was an inaccurate summary of the actual judgment, which did not expressly prohibit using unregistered documents to ascertain the character of possession.

The Court distinguished the cited case as dealing with immovable property worth less than Rs. 100, where delivery of possession suffices for sale completion, and where the question of collateral use of unregistered documents was not considered.

Relying on authoritative Supreme Court decisions, including Padina Vithoba Chakkayya v. Mohd. Multani, the Court held that while unregistered documents cannot transfer title, they are admissible for collateral purposes such as proving the nature of possession.

The Court emphasized that the unregistered sale deed Ext. 69 could be used to show that possession changed from mortgagee to owner from the date of the deed. Since the mortgagee remained in possession for over 12 years thereafter, the defendants perfected title by adverse possession, extinguishing the plaintiff's equity of redemption.

Thus, the Court agreed with the findings of the lower courts and dismissed the appeal.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is dismissed.

The Court upheld the decree of the lower courts confirming that the defendants perfected title by adverse possession, extinguishing the plaintiff's equity of redemption. The unregistered sale deed, though inadmissible to transfer title, was admissible for the collateral purpose of proving the character of possession. The parties are to bear their own costs. No new precedent was set beyond affirming established principles regarding adverse possession and evidentiary use of unregistered documents.

    Raoji Appaji Kulkarni By Lrs. v. Badibi & Others

    1. This is a second appeal by the legal representatives of the original plaintiff against the decree passed by the Civil Judge, Belgaum in C.A No. 434 of 1965, confirming the decree passed by the Joint Civil Judge, JD., Chikodi in RCS. No. 599 of 1950.

    2. The plaintiff brought the suit for taking accounts and redemption of the mortgage deed dated 24-6-1879, produced in this case as Ext. 65 under S. 15(D) of the Deccan Agriculturists Relief Act, 1879.

    3. The property originally belonged to four brothers. Sakharam, Antaji, Appaji and Melgiri. They executed an usufructuary mortgage deed in favour of Nabisaheb, Khonmirasaheb and Imamsaheb on 24th June, 1879. Subsequently, one of the mortgagors Melgiri died and his line became ??? The remaining three mortgagors executed a sale deed on 26th May ??? in favour of one of the mortgagees, viz., Nabisaheb for a sum of Rs. 600 which document has been produced in this case as Ext. 69. The sale deed was, however, not registered. Nabisaheb continued in possession in pursuance of the sale deed Ext. 69. The plaintiff is one of the successors in interest of the original mortgagors. The plaintiff brought the suit for redemption of mortgage and for accounts under S. 15(D) of the DAR. Act, on the basis that the mortgage evidenced by Ext. 65 is still subsisting.

    4. Defendants 1 to 6, the heirs of the original mortgagees, resisted the suit on various grounds. The principal contention taken by them was that they have perfected their title by adverse possession, as a result of which the equity of redemption in favour of the plaintiff has been extinguished long back. In support of this contention of theirs, they relied upon the unregistered sale deed Ext. 69 dated 26th May, 1890. They contended that from the date of the said sale deed, the character of the possession was altered from that of mortgagees in possession to that of owner. They further contended that after the expiry of a period of 12 years from the date of the sale deed Ext. 69, they perfected their title, by adverse possession. Both the Courts accepted the contention of defendants 1 to 6 and held that they have perfected their title by adverse possession and that the equity of redemption in favour of the plaintiff has been extinguished long back. Consequently, both the Courts dismissed the plaintiff's suit.

    5. It is the legality of the decree passed by the learned Civil Judge in appeal, that is challenged by the plaintiff in this second appeal under Section 100 of the Civil Procedure Code.

    6. Shri N.A Mandgi, learned Counsel appearing for the appellant, contended that the finding recorded by the learned Civil Judge that defendants 1 to 6 have perfected their title by adverse possession is not in accordance with law. Shri Mandgi's principal compaint is about making use of the recitals in Ext. 69, the unregistered sale deed dated 26th May, 1890. Shri Mandgi contended that, as the consideration for the sale was more than Rs. 100 the sale deed was compulsorily registrable. As the document is unregistered, Shri Mandgi contended that the same is inadmissible in evidence. The Courts below, having held that the document Ext. 69 is inadmissible in evidence for want of registration, have all the same relied upon the Said document for ascertaining the character of possession of Nabisaheb from the data of the said transaction. Relying upon a decision of this Court in K. Thimmiah v. B.H Nanjappa(1) Shri Mandagi contended that the unregistered document Ext. 69 cannot be used to prove the character of possession. Shri Mandagi read to me the first portion of the head note, which reads as follows:

    “The fact that under Section 54 Transfer of Property Act, a sale of property of the value of less than Rs. 100 could be effected by mere delivery of possession does not mean that when parties choose to write out an instrument of sale, such an instrument need not be registered. The unregistered document cannot be used to make out the character of the possession. Such use is prohibited by S. 49 Registration Act and S. 54 Transfer of Property Act.”

    7. Shri Mandgi particularly relied upon the last two sentences of the head note extracted above. Prima facie, the head note does support Shri Mandgi's contention. But, on going through the judgment of Justice Narayana Pai, as he then was, I do not find any statement made by his Lordship to the effect that an unregistered document cannot be used to make out the character of possession. There is no statement by his Lordship that the making use of an unregistered document for proving the character of possession is prohibited by S. 49 of the Registration Act. The head note on which Shri Mandgi relied upon is not an accurate or correct summary of the statement of law nude in the said decision. There was no occasion also for the Court to go into the question as to whether an unregistered document can be made use of for ascertaining the character of possession. In the case dealt with by his Lordship Justice Narayana Pai, there was a sale deed Ext. P-2, executed in respect of an immovable property worth less than Rs. 100. S. 54 of the Transfer of Property Act requires that in order to complete a sale of an immoveable property of the value of less than Rs. 100 it is enough if there is delivery of possession. If the parties, however, choose to reduce such a transaction into writing, then the document becomes compulsorily registrable. The document has to be registered in order to evidence the sale transaction, even if the value of the subject matter is less than Rs. 100. What was sought to be done in that case was to prove delivery of possession by making use of the recitals in the unregistered sale deed Ext. P-2. That was, therefore not at all a case where the Court was required to consider as to whether the recitals in the unregistered document can be made use of for a collateral purpose, viz., proving the character of possession. That is ??? from what his Lordship observed, after, considering the contention of the parties, as follows:

    “If, therefore, an unregistered document of sale can be looked into for the purpose of showing that the property has been ??? and the fact of that delivery is going to be depended upon ??? party to show that there has been such delivery as is required under S. 54 of the Transfer of Property Act to complete the sale, the receiving of the document into evidence will be receiving it as ??? the transaction of delivery of the property which is one of the cements for transfering title therein.”

    8. It is clear from this observation of his Lordship that his Lordship laid down that in respect of sale of immoveable property worth less ??? Rs. 100, the delivery of possession cannot be proved by making ??? the recitals in an unregistered sale deed. It is nowhere laid down in the said decision that an unregistered sale deed in respect of immoveable property of the value of more than Rs. 100 cannot be made use of for a collateral purpose of proving the character of possession. The Supreme Court had occasion to consider this question in the decision in Padina Vithoba Chakkayya v. Mohd. Multani(2), their Lordships laid down that:

    “When a person gets into possession of properties as mortgagee, he cannot by any unilateral act or declaration of his prescribe for a title by adverse possession against the mortgagor, because in law his possession is that of the mortgagor. But if the mortgagor and mortgagee subsequently enter into a transaction under which the mortgagee is to hold the properties thereafter not as a mortgagee but as owner that would be sufficient to start adverse possession against the mortgagor if the transaction is for any reason inoperative under the law.”

    9. Their Lordships further held that a document which is inadmissible for want of registration, is admissible in evidence to show the character of possession, relying on the earlier decision of the Privy Council in N. Varada Pillai v. Jeevarathnamma(3). Their Lordships approved the decision of the Madras High Court in Karnam Kandasmamy Pillai v. Chinnabha(4). In the said decision of the Madras High Court, approved by their Lordships of the Supreme Court, it has been laid down as follows:

    “An unregistered sale cannot be set up as a transaction having effect of itself to transfer any interest in the property; but it is permissible to consider it, as showing the nature of transferee's subsequent possession, e.g, when the sale is of mortgaged property to the mortgagee that it was not as a mortgagee, but as full owner, that being established it would after the expiry of 12 years ripen into a full title and bar mortgagor's right of redemption.”

    10. In view of the authoritative pronouncement of the Supreme Court, it cannot be contended with any justification that Ext. 69, the unregistered sale deed dated 26th May, 1890, cannot be used for the collateral purpose of proving the nature or character of possession. The possession of the mortgagee from the date of the sale deed Ext. 69 was in his own right as owner and not as a mortgagee. The said document can, undoubtedy, be made use of to prove that there was change in the character of possession with effect from the date of the sale deed Ext. 69. There is no dispute that the mortgagee, in whose favour the sale deed was executed, remained in possession for well over the statutory period of 12 years in order to acquire title by adverse possession. I have, therefore, no hesitation in agreeing with the conclusion of the Court below that defendants 1 to 6 have perfected their title by adverse possession and that the equity et redemption of the plaintiff has been extinguished long back.

    11. For the reasons stated above, this appeal fails and the same is dismissed. In the circumstances, the parties shall bear their respective costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Raoji Appaji Kulkarni By Lrs. v. Badibi & Others
    (Jan 7, 1971)