AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule I of Order VIII of the Code of Civil Procedure (for short CPC)
  • Order VIII Rule 1-A(3) of the Code of Civil Procedure,
  • suit.6. Rules 1-A and 1-A(3) of Order VIII CPC,
  • Rule 1-A(3) of Order VIII CPC,
  • Rule 1-A of Order VIII CPC,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule I of Order VIII of the Code of Civil Procedure (for short CPC)
  • Order VIII Rule 1-A(3) of the Code of Civil Procedure,
  • suit.6. Rules 1-A and 1-A(3) of Order VIII CPC,
  • Rule 1-A(3) of Order VIII CPC,
  • Rule 1-A of Order VIII CPC,
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This civil revision petition challenges an order dated 1.6.2011 in IA No. 177 of 2011 in OS No. 52 of 2001 before the Senior Civil Judge, Suryapet. The petitioner, who is the plaintiff in the suit for recovery based on promissory notes, had completed his evidence on 11.2.2011. The respondents-defendants subsequently filed an affidavit and an application to admit seven promissory notes into evidence on 8.4.2011. The petitioner opposed this application, alleging the respondents created the notes and failed to provide valid reasons for their late filing. The trial court allowed the application, finding the respondents' reasons adequate, prompting the present revision petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the trial court erred in permitting the respondents to produce documents (promissory notes) beyond the time stipulated under Order VIII Rule 1-A(3) of the Code of Civil Procedure without sufficient reasons for the delay.
  2. What constitutes adequate explanation or sufficient cause for a defendant to file documents after submitting the written statement under the amended procedural rules.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The discretion under Order VIII Rule 1-A(3) CPC to allow late production of documents must be exercised only if the defendant provides a proper explanation for not filing them with the written statement.
  • The respondents failed to show valid and sufficient reasons for the late filing of the promissory notes.
  • Relied on the precedent set in Ravi Satish v. Edala Durga Prasad, 2009 (3) ALT 236, which held that leave to file documents late is not automatic and requires sufficient cause.

Respondents' Arguments

  • Reason for late filing was that the documents were not traced earlier.
  • The trial court correctly exercised its discretion in allowing the documents to be admitted.
  • The impugned order should not be interfered with by the revisional court.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ravi Satish v. Edala Durga Prasad, 2009 (3) ALT 236 Discretion under Order VIII Rule 1-A(3) CPC to admit documents late requires proper explanation; leave not granted as a matter of course. The Court relied on this precedent to emphasize that the discretion to admit documents after the written statement must be exercised cautiously and only upon sufficient cause.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the provisions of Order VIII Rule 1 and Rule 1-A of the Code of Civil Procedure, particularly the amendments introduced by Act 46 of 1999 effective from 1.7.2002. These rules mandate that a defendant must file a written statement within 30 days and produce all documents relied upon at that time, with limited allowance for late production only upon sufficient cause. The Court noted that although Rule 1-A(3) appears to vest broad discretion, it must be interpreted to prevent delay and ensure timely disposal of suits.

Examining the respondents' affidavit, the Court found no specific plea of due diligence or explanation for the delay, nor any indication of when the documents were traced. The respondents did not file the application to admit documents at or near the time the documents were confronted to the plaintiff’s witness (11.2.2011), but waited until 8.4.2011. This belated approach was held to be insufficient to justify the delay.

The Court concluded that the trial court erred in accepting the respondents' reasons as adequate and allowing the documents to be admitted late, thereby frustrating the legislative intent behind the procedural amendments aimed at curbing delays.

Holding and Implications

The Court set aside the impugned order dated 1.6.2011 and allowed the civil revision petition, holding that the respondents failed to provide proper and sufficient reasons for the belated production of documents.

As a direct consequence, the application for interim relief filed by the petitioner became infructuous and was disposed of accordingly. The decision impacts the parties by disallowing the late admission of the promissory notes, but the Court did not establish any new precedent beyond affirming the strict interpretation of procedural rules under Order VIII CPC.

    Voruganti Narayana Rao v. Bodla Rammurthy And Others

    1. This civil revision petition is filed against order, dated 1.6.2011, in IA No. 177 of 2011 in OS No. 52 of 2001 on the file of the learned Senior Civil Judge, Suryapet.

    2. The petitioner is the plaintiff in the above mentioned suit filed for recovery of suit amount from the respondents on the basis of the promissory note. On 11.2.2011, the petitioner, who was examined as PW1, was cross-examined by the learned Counsel for the respondents-defendants. After closure of the evidence on the plaintiff's side, defendant No. 3 filed his affidavit in lieu of chief-examination on 22.3.2011 On 8.4.2011, the respondents filed IA No. 177 of 2011 for receiving seven pronotes into evidence. This application was resisted by the petitioner by filing a counter-affidavit. It is averred by the petitioner in the said counter-affidavit that the respondents have created and brought into existence the pronotes and that, they failed to show any valid and sufficient reasons for not filing them earlier. The Court below, however, while accepting the plea of the petitioner that the respondents failed to file the pronotes at the earlier stage of the case, allowed the application by holding that the respondents have mentioned adequate reasons for not filing them earlier. At the hearing, Sri V. Raghu, learned Counsel for the petitioner, submitted that even though under Order VIII Rule 1-A(3) of the Code of Civil Procedure, a discretion is vested in the Court to permit the defendant to produce any document beyond the time stipulated other than at the time of filing the written statement, such discretion can be exercised only if the defendant comes out with proper explanation for not filing them along with the written statement. In support of his submission, learned Counsel for the petitioner placed reliance on the judgment of this Court in Ravi Satish v. Edala Durga Prasad, 2009 (3) ALT 236.

    3. Learned Counsel for the respondents stated that in the affidavit, the respondents have assigned the reason that the documents were not traced earlier and therefore, they could not be filed and that, the Court below having exercised its jurisdiction in favour of the respondents, the impugned order is not liable for interference by this Court.

    4. I have carefully considered the respective submissions of the learned Counsel for the parties. Rule I of Order VIII of the Code of Civil Procedure (for short ‘CPC’) mandates that the defendant shall, within 30 days from the date of service of summons on him, present a written statement of his defence. Proviso to the said Rules, however, envisages that where the defendant fails to file the written statement within the said period of 30 days, he shall be allowed to file the same on such other day as may be specified by the Court, for reasons to be recorded in writing, but, which shall not be later than 90 days from the date of service of summons. Rule 1-A of Order VIII CPC, enjoins on the defendant to produce in the Court any document in his possession upon which he bases his defence or relies in support of his defence or claim for set off or counter-claim.

    5. When the written statement is presented by him, he shall at the same time, deliver the documents thereof to be filed with the written statement. Rule 1-A(3) of Order VIII CPC, postulates that a document which ought to be produced in the Court by the defendant under this Rule, is not so produced shall not, without the leave of the Court, be received in evidence on his behalf at the hearing of the suit.

    6. Rules 1-A and 1-A(3) of Order VIII CPC, were substituted by Act 46 of 1999 with effect from 1.7.2002, The object with which those Rules were amended was to curb the phenomenal delays in the procedural aspects leading to procrastination of the proceedings before the civil Court. The Parliament has thought it fit to stipulate time limits for the parties to file their defence and produce the documents along with the defence so that the cases can be disposed of without avoidable delays. This being the avowed object with which the above noted provisions are amended, Rule 1-A(3) of Order VIII CPC, which on a literal interpretation appears to vest unlimited discretion with the Court, requires to be interpreted so as to advance the intendment of the legislation. The Court before which the defendant produced the said documents after filing of the written statement, therefore, needs to be circumspect in examining whether proper reasons are assigned by the defendant for not producing the documents along with the written statement. Unless the reasons assigned by the defendant discloses sufficient cause for his failure to produce the documents within the time stipulated in Rule 1-A of Order VIII CPC, the Court shall not permit the defendant to file such documents later. Undoubtedly, unduly liberal approach in this regard would frustrate the purpose for which the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure are amended. This Court in Ravi Satish's case (supra), held that grant of leave by the Court is not for the mere asking nor is the Court a mere Post-Office to receive documents even in the absence of any reasons furnished for failure to file the said documents along with the written statement.

    7. In his affidavit, respondent No. 3 stated that they could not file the documents earlier even though they were confronted to the witnesses immediately after they were traced.

    8. In the first place, there is no specific plea by the respondents that those documents were misplaced. The respondents have not also pleaded that despite their due diligence, the documents could not be traced. They have also not stated as to when the documents were traced. Even assuming that those documents were misplaced, it is the admitted case that those documents were confronted to PW1 during his cross-examination on 11.2.2011 After closure of evidence on the plaintiffs side, respondent No. 3, who is defendant No. 3, has filed his affidavit in lieu of his chief-examination on 22.3.2011 The respondents have leisurely filed the I.A for receiving the documents much thereafter i.e, on 8.4.2011 If the respondents' plea that the documents could not be traced was correct, nothing prevented them from filing the application either before or at least at the time when those documents were confronted to PW1 on 11.2.2011 From these admitted facts, I am of the opinion that the respondents failed to furnish proper and sufficient reasons for receiving the documents at a far too belated stage.

    9. The Court below has, therefore, committed a serious error in failing to notice these glaring shortcomings in the case of respondents and holding that the reasons given by the respondents for belated production of the documents are adequate.

    10. For the above mentioned reasons, the order under revision is set aside and the civil revision petition is, accordingly, allowed.

    11. As a sequel to disposal of the civil revision petition, CRPMP No. 3164 of 2011 filed by the petitioner for interim relief is disposed of as infructuous.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Voruganti Narayana Rao v. Bodla Rammurthy And Others
    (Aug 5, 2011)