Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion — M. Karpagavinayagam, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The opinion concerns two connected matters arising from a single trial regarding an alleged offence under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act (the Act). The petitioners were accused of issuing a cheque for Rs. 2,12,000/- in favour of the complainant, which was presented and returned unpaid on 28.8.1995 for insufficiency of funds. The complainant issued a statutory notice and, after the petitioners' reply, filed a complaint alleging offences under Sections 138 and 141 of the Act.

At trial (E.C. No. 6560 of 1995 on the file of VIII Metropolitan Magistrate, George Town, Chennai), the petitioners were convicted under Section 138 and sentenced to imprisonment till the rising of Court and to pay a fine of Rs. 30,000/-, of which Rs. 28,000/- was directed to be paid as compensation to the complainant. The petitioners appealed (C.A. No. 83 of 1997), but the conviction was confirmed by the Sessions Court. Separately, the complainant filed a revision (Crl. R.C. No. 19 of 1997) challenging the inadequacy of sentence; the Sessions Judge enhanced the fine from Rs. 30,000/- to Rs. 1,44,000/- (twice the Sessions Judge's finding of the balance of the cheque) and awarded compensation of Rs. 1,00,000/-. The petitioners challenged the appellate/revisional orders by filing the present revisions (Crl. R.C. Nos. 625 & 627 of 1997) and the complainant filed Crl. O.P. No. 17795 of 1995 under Section 482 Cr. P.C. seeking to set aside certain findings of the Sessions Judge concerning payments alleged to have been made prior to presentation.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioners had, before presentation of the cheque, repaid the cheque amount (in full or in part) as alleged, and whether the courts below correctly evaluated the evidence (Exs. D-1, D-2 and Ex. P-10) on that point.
  2. Whether the presumption under Section 139 of the Negotiable Instruments Act applied and, if so, whether the accused discharged that statutory presumption by proving the alleged prior payments.
  3. Whether the Sessions Judge, in revisional jurisdiction, had the power to enhance sentence in a private complaint and whether enhancement by the Sessions Court in the facts of this case was lawful.
  4. Whether the Sessions Court correctly ordered a fine equal to twice the alleged balance of the cheque (i.e., the legality of imposing twice the balance rather than twice the cheque amount specified in Section 138).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments (Counsel: Mr. Govindarajan)

  • Both Courts below erred in not properly considering that the entire cheque amount had been paid by the petitioners before presentation; Exs. D-1 and D-2 and two reply notices demonstrate pre-presentation payments.
  • The lower Appellate Court's finding that Rs. 1,40,000/- had been paid should have been accepted; the petitioners had referred to receipts on multiple occasions even before the complaint was presented.
  • The Sessions Court (in revisional jurisdiction) lacked power to entertain a revision for enhancement of sentence filed by a private complainant — reliance placed on Assistant Collector of Central Excise v. V. Krishnamoorthy (1997 SCC (Cri) 430) and Krishnamoorthy and Elumalai, In re, 1983 LW (Crl) 166 to support this contention.

Respondent's Arguments (Counsel: Mr. T. Munirathina Naidu)

  • The prosecution established that the accused was liable to pay the entire cheque amount and the Sessions Court was correct in exercising revisional power; the power for enhancement in revision cannot be questioned.
  • The Sessions Judge's factual finding that Rs. 1,40,000/- had been paid was not supported by the evidence — the receipts (Exs. D-1 and D-2) did not establish payment in respect of the cheque amount.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Assistant Collector of Central Excise v. V. Krishnamoorthy, 1997 SCC (Cri) 430 Held that an appeal for enhancement in a private complaint (in that case) could only be filed by the Central Government and not by the complainant under Section 377(2), Cr. P.C. The Court observed this decision does not deal with revisional powers and therefore does not assist the petitioners' contention that revision for enhancement cannot be entertained when filed by a private party.
Krishnamoorthy and Elumalai, In re, 1983 LW (Crl) 166 Relied upon by petitioners to support the proposition that enhancement of sentence in a private complaint could only be pursued by State/Centre (as argued by petitioners). The Court recorded that petitioners relied on this decision but also noted that earlier Apex Court decisions on revisional enhancement were not referred to; it did not accept this precedent as foreclosing revisional enhancement in all circumstances.
Pratap v. State of U.P., (1973) 3 SCC 690 : AIR 1973 SC 786 Earlier Apex Court decision cited as holding that powers for enhancement under revisional jurisdiction are not affected merely because the revision petition was filed by a private person and not by the Government. The Court noted this line of Apex Court authority (including this case) had not been referred to in the Division Bench decision relied upon by petitioners; it supports the view that revisional powers to enhance are available even if the revision is by a private party.
Eknath v. State of Maharashtra, (1977) 3 SCC 25 : AIR 1977 SC 1177 Part of the Apex Court decisions cited as authority that revisional enhancement powers are not affected by the fact that the revision is filed by a private party. The Court relied on this authority (together with Pratap and Nadir Khan) for the proposition that the High Court (or a revisional court) can, in an appropriate case, enhance sentence even suo motu when exercising revisional powers.
Nadir Khan v. State, (1975) 2 SCC 406 : AIR 1976 SC 2205 Another Apex Court decision cited alongside Pratap and Eknath establishing that revisional enhancement powers are not negated merely because the revision is by a private person. The Court treated this precedent as supporting its conclusion that revisional powers to enhance sentence are available notwithstanding that the revision originates from a private complainant.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court conducted a factual and legal reassessment along two main strands: (A) whether the accused had proved prior payment of the cheque amount, and (B) whether the Sessions Court's enhancement order was legally sustainable.

A. On the factual dispute regarding payment of the cheque amount:

  • The facts admitted by the parties include: cheque for Rs. 2,12,000/- issued on 30.5.1995; cheque presented and returned unpaid on 28.8.1995; statutory demand notice served and no payment made within the statutory period.
  • The defence relied on receipts (Exs. D-1 and D-2) and alleged three instalment payments of Rs. 50,000/-, Rs. 90,000/- and Rs. 75,000/-. Exs. D-1 and D-2 were receipts for Rs. 50,000 and Rs. 90,000 respectively; the receipt for Rs. 75,000 was not produced though claimed to exist.
  • PW-1 (complainant) admitted receipt of Rs. 50,000 and Rs. 90,000 on the respective dates but maintained those payments were for other transactions and not in respect of the cheque amount; PW-1 produced Ex. P-10 (statement of account) to show those receipts were not for the cheque liability.
  • The Trial Court accepted PW-1's evidence (corroborated by Ex. P-10) and concluded the accused had not paid any amount towards the cheque amount; the accused was convicted accordingly. The Sessions Judge, however, relied on Exs. D-1 and D-2 and concluded Rs. 50,000 and Rs. 90,000 were paid towards the cheque.
  • The Court held the Sessions Judge's finding that part of the cheque amount was paid was incorrect for two reasons explicitly stated in the opinion:
    1. There was evidence (PW-1 corroborated by Ex. P-10) showing the receipts (Exs. D-1 and D-2) were not in respect of the cheque amount; thus the complainant had in fact demonstrated those amounts related to other liabilities.
    2. Section 139 of the Negotiable Instruments Act creates a presumption that a cheque-holder received the cheque for discharge of debt or liability; once that presumption exists, the accused bears the burden of proving the contrary — which the accused did not do. Further, PW-1's evidence on Ex. P-10 was not effectively challenged on cross-examination.
  • On this basis, the Court concluded the prosecution had established the offence under Section 138 beyond reasonable doubt and that the Trial Court's original analysis was correct on this factual point.

B. On the legal question of enhancement and the Sessions Court's order:

  • The Court analysed the law under Section 138 of the Act: punishment may extend to one year imprisonment, or fine which may extend to twice the amount of the cheque, or both. The Act does not contemplate imposing a fine twice the balance of the cheque as found by the Sessions Judge.
  • The Court examined authorities relied upon by the parties. It noted the Assistant Collector decision (1997 SCC (Cri) 430) held that an appeal for enhancement in a private complaint could only be prosecuted by the Central Government under Section 377(2), Cr.P.C., but that decision did not address revisional powers. Earlier Apex Court decisions (Pratap, Eknath, Nadir Khan) had held that revisional enhancement powers are not negated merely because the revision is filed by a private person; the High Court could enhance sentence suo motu in an appropriate case.
  • Applying these principles, the Court found one illegality in the Sessions Judge's order: directing payment of twice the alleged balance (Rs. 1,44,000/- being twice Rs. 72,000/-) is not authorised by Section 138. The statutory ceiling is twice the amount of the cheque itself; there is no provision for imposing twice the balance amount determined by the appellate court.
  • Accordingly, while upholding conviction, the Court set aside the Sessions Court's sentence order to the extent that it directed payment of twice the balance amount, and, exercising revisional powers, enhanced the fine from Rs. 30,000/- to Rs. 75,000/-, directing Rs. 72,000/- as compensation to the complainant subject to amounts already deposited and paid.
  • The Court gave specific directions about deposits and payments: Rs. 30,000/- had already been deposited (of which Rs. 28,000/- had been paid to the complainant); the petitioners must deposit the balance Rs. 45,000/- in the lower Court, and on deposit Rs. 44,000/- shall be paid to the complainant (consistent with the compensation sum ordered).

Holding and Implications

Holding: Revisions dismissed. The Court upheld the conviction under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act but set aside the Sessions Court's order insofar as it directed imposition of a fine equal to twice the balance of the cheque (Rs. 1,44,000/-), a relief not contemplated by Section 138. Instead, the Court enhanced the fine from Rs. 30,000/- to Rs. 75,000/- and directed compensation of Rs. 72,000/- to the complainant with implementation directions regarding deposits and payments.

Implications / Consequences:

  • Direct effect on parties: The petitioners remain convicted under Section 138; they are required to deposit the balance sum ordered (Rs. 45,000/-) and, upon deposit, Rs. 44,000/- is to be paid to the complainant. The complainant has already received Rs. 28,000/- and is entitled to the balance in accordance with the Court's directions.
  • On the question of revisional enhancement by a private party: The Court treated prior Apex Court authority as indicating that revisional powers to enhance sentence are not necessarily unavailable merely because the revision originates from a private complainant; the Assistant Collector decision limiting an appeal to the State/Centre did not address revisional powers and therefore did not preclude enhancement in revision.
  • On precedent/novelty: The Court did not purport to lay down a new precedent beyond applying existing authorities to the facts; it corrected an illegality in the Sessions Judge's order and exercised revisional power to impose an appropriate fine within the statutory framework of Section 138.
  • On Crl. O.P. No. 17795 of 1995: In view of the findings in revision, the Court stated no separate order was necessary in that criminal original petition.

Outcome succinctly: Conviction under Section 138 upheld; Sessions Court's sentence ordering twice the balance set aside as unauthorized by Section 138; fine enhanced by the High Court to Rs. 75,000/- with Rs. 72,000/- directed as compensation and procedural directions for deposit and payment; revisions dismissed.

    J.S Agencies v. Namakkal South India Transports .

    M. Karpagavinayagam, J.:— Both the revision and criminal original petitions are being disposed of by this common order, as the parties are the same and these arise out of a single trial.

    2. The petitioners in Crl. R.C No. 627 of 1997 were convicted for the offence under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, hereinafter referred to as “the Act”, in E.C No. 6560 of 1995 on the file of VIII Metropolitan Magistrate, George Town, Chennai. As against the said conviction, the petitioners filed an appeal in C.A No. 83 of 1997 on the file of VII Additional Sessions Judge at Chennai. The said conviction was confirmed and the appeal was dismissed. Hence, this revision. The petitioners in Crl. R.C No. 625 of 1997 were convicted under Section 138 of the Act in C.C No. 6560 of 1997 on the file of VIII Metropolitan Magistrate, George Town, Chennai and sentenced to undergo imprisonment till the raising of the Court and to pay a fine of Rs. 30,000/-. Having aggrieved over the inadequacy of sentence, the complainant, the respondent herein filed a revision in Crl. R.C No. 19 of 1997 on the file of VII Additional Sessions Judge at Chennai. The learned Sessions Judge, after hearing the parties, enhanced the sentence of fine from Rs. 30,000/- to Rs. 1,44,000/-. As against the order of enhancement, the petitioner have filed this revision.

    3. The complainant filed a petition in Crl. O.P No. 17795 of 1995 under Section 482 Cr. P.C before this Court praying to set aside the findings rendered in C.A No. 83 of 1997 and Crl. R.C No. 19 of 1997 on the file of VII Additional Sessions Judge, to the effect that out of the cheque amount of Rs. 2,12,000/-, Rs. 1,40,000/- was already paid and that there is only a balance of Rs. 72,000/-.

    4. The facts are these: The petitioners, on 30.5.1995 issued a cheque for Rs. 2,12,000/- in favour of the respondent towards the discharge of arrears of hire charges. The said cheque presented on 26.8.1995 was returned on 28.8.1995 as there was no sufficient funds in the account of the petitioners in the Bank. On 1.9.1995, the respondent sent a statutory notice to the petitioners. In reply to the demand notice, on 13.9.1995 the petitioners sent a notice stating that the petitioners were not liable to pay the cheque amount. In order to refute the contents of the reply notice dated 13.9.1995, the respondent again sent another notice on 30.9.19.95 giving the details about the liability to be discharged by the petitioners. This was received by the petitioners. Thereupon again the petitioner sent a reply. Since the cheque amount was not paid by the petitioners despite demand within the statutory period, the respondent filed a complaint against the petitioners for the offence under Sections 138 and 141 of the Act.

    5. To prove the case of prosecution, on the side of the respondent, PWs 1 to 3 were examined and Exs. P-1 to P-13 were filed.

    6. The plea of defence is that already entire cheque amount was paid by the petitioners to the complainant even before the presentation of the said cheque in the Bank. In order to establish this factor, Exs. D-1 and D-2 were marked.

    7. On conclusion of trial, the petitioners were found guilty for the offence under Section 138 of the Act and they were sentenced to undergo imprisonment till the rising of the Court and to pay a fine of Rs. 30,000/-. It was further directed that out of the said sum of Rs. 30,000/-, Rs. 28,000/- is to be paid to the complainant, the respondent herein, as compensation.

    8. The lower Appellate Court, though found the petitioners guilty, concluded on the strength of Exs. D-1 and D-2 that out of the cheque amount of Rs. 2,12,000/-, Rs. 1,14,000/- were already paid and that, therefore, the petitioners are liable to pay only the balance amount of Rs. 72,000/-. On the basis of this conclusion, the lower Appellate Court allowed the revision for enhancement of sentence filed by the complainant by enhancing the fine from Rs. 30,000/- to Rs. 1,44,000/- viz, twice the balance of the cheque amount. It is further directed by the lower Appellate Court that the complainant is entitled to compensation of Rs. 1,00,000/-.

    9. The above impugned orders have been challenged in these revisions and criminal original petition.

    10. I have heard Mr. Govindarajan, the Counsel appearing for the petitioners in the revisions and Mr. T. Munirathina Naidu, the Counsel appearing for the respondent in the revisions and for the petitioner in Crl. O.P No. 17795 of 1997.

    11. The main thrust of the argument by the Counsel for the petitioners in the revisions is that both the Courts below have failed to consider that the entire cheque amount was paid to the complainant and the same was established by the petitioners by producing Exs. D-1 and D-2 and two reply notices sent by them. It is also contended that the lower Appellate Court having given a finding that Rs. 1,40,000/- was paid put of the cheque amount of Rs. 2,12,000/-, ought to have acquired by the petitioners, since even before the presentation of the complaint the petitioners sent a reply referring about the receipts issued by the complainant of the cheque amount on three occasions. At any rate, according to the Counsel for the petitioners in the revisions, the lower Appellate Court cannot entertain revision against sentence and enhance the same from the fine of Rs. 30,000/- to Rs. 1,44,000/- as there is no power vested in the Sessions Court for doing the same.

    12. In reply to the said submissions, Mr. Munirathina Naidu, in equal vehemence would contend that the prosecution has established that the accused was liable to pay the entire cheque amount and the powers for enhancement in revision cannot be questioned. He would further contend that the finding of the Sessions Court that out of the cheque amount of Rs. 2,12,000/-, Rs. 1,40,000/- were also returned by virtue of Exs. D-1 and D-2 and that the accused was liable to pay only the balance amount of Rs. 72,000/-, was wrong, as it is not supported by the evidence.

    13. I have carefully considered the merits of the rival contentions.

    14. There is no dispute with regard to the fact that the cheque was issued by the accused in favour of the complainant for the sum of Rs. 2,12,000/- towards the discharge of his liability, that the said cheque on presentation was returned as unpaid on 28.8.1995 and that despite the receipt of the statutory notice no payment was made by the accused as per the demand within the stipulated time.

    15. It is also not debated over the aspect that before filing the complaint; all the requisites as envisaged by the provisions under Sections 138 to 141 for the Negotiable Instruments Act have been complied with by the complainant. But, the controversy is over the repayment of the entire cheque amount by the accused to complainant even before the presentation of the cheque as pleaded by the accused.

    16. According to PW-1, the complainant, towards the hire charges of Rs. 5,55,000/- the accused issued a cheque on 30.5.1995 for Rs. 2,12,000/- and the said cheque was returned on 28.8.1995 as unpaid on presentation in the Bank. The plea of the defence is that the cheque amount was paid back on three occasions by instalments, that is, the first amount of Rs. 50,000/- was on 3.6.1995, the second amount of Rs. 90,000/- was on 13.6.1995 and Rs. 75,000/- was on a later date. In order to establish his case, Exs. D-1 and D-2, the receipt issued by the complainant wore marked. However, the accused did not choose to file any receipt with regard to the payment of Rs. 75,000/- though it was claimed that the receipt was available with him.

    17. PW-1 would admit in the cross-examination that the amounts of Rs. 50,000/- and Rs. 90,000/- were received by the complainant on the respective dates, though he would deny the receipt of Rs. 75,000/-. However, PW-1 clarified in the cross-examination that those amounts were in respect of the discharge of liability for some other transaction. It must be noted that while the accused in the reply notice stated that he has already paid the cheque amount, the rejoinder notice was sent by PW-1stating that those amounts were paid toward some other liability and not in respect of cheque amount. In the said notice he has also given details of the statement of account. When PW-1 was examined, he marked Ex. P-10, statement of accounts to show that the receipt of two other amounts was not towards the cheque amount. So, on the basis of this evidence, the Trial Court correctly concluded that the accused has not paid any amount towards the cheque amount and as such the accused was liable to be convicted and sentenced to undergo imprisonment till the rising of the Court and to pay a fine of Rs. 30,000/- out of which Rs. 28,000/- were directed to be handed over to the complainant as compensation.

    18. However, in the appeal filed by the accused, the learned Sessions Judge-had come to the conclusion, on the strength of Exs. D-1 and D-2 that out of the cheque amount of Rs. 2,12,000/-, Rs. 50,000/- and Rs. 90,000/- were paid on 3.6.1995 and 13.6.1995 respectively and, as such, he was liable to pay only the balance of Rs. 72,000/-.

    19. The learned Sessions Judge would observe that the complainant has not proved that those amounts, namely, Rs. 50,000/- and Rs. 90,000/- were not towards the cheque amount. The relevant observation is this:

    (Matter in other language not printed)

    20. The above finding rendered by the Sessions Judge in my view, is quite wrong for two reasons: (1) There is evidence of PW-1 which is corroborated by Ex. P-10, the statement of accounts, that there was a total liability of Rs. 5,55,000/- and out of that he has given cheque for Rs. 2,12,000/-. Moreover, on the strength of Ex. P-10, PW-1 would specifically state that. Exs. D-1 and D-2, the receipts given by the complainant, were not issued in respect of receipt of the amount towards the cheque amount. Whether there is evidence available, it cannot be said that the same was not proved by the complainant (2) under Section 139 of the Act, it shall be presumed, unless the contrary is proved, that the holder of a cheque received the cheque for the discharge in whole or in part, or any debt or other liability. So, in that view of the matter, in the light of the presumptive section it is also for the accused to establish that the said amount was given towards the discharge of liability in respect of the cheque amount. This has not been done by the accused, Moreover, the evidence of PW-1 with reference to Ex. P-10 has not been challenged in the cross-examination.

    21. In these circumstances, though the conclusion by the Sessions Judge that the accused is liable to be convicted for the offence under Section 138 of the Act, is correct, the finding that portion of the cheque amount was paid is not correct. On a perusal of the judgment of the Trial Court, it is clear that the Trial Court has correctly analysed his aspect and come to the conclusion that the transaction relating to Exs. D-1 and D-2 are entirely different from the transaction involving Ex. P-1 the cheque.

    22. In these circumstances, I am of the view that the prosecution has established its case beyond reasonable doubt.

    23. Regarding the power of enhancement of sentence, Mr. Govindarajan, placing reliance on the decisions in Assistant Collector of Central Excise v. V. Krishnamoorthy, 1997 SCC (Cri) 430 and Krishnamoorthy and Elumalai, In re, 1983 LW (Crl) 166, would contend that even in the private complaint which ended in conviction, the appeal could be filed for enhancement of sentence only by the State or the Centre, not by the private party.

    24. It is true that in 1983 LW (Cri) 430, a Division Bench of this Court would take such a???ew.

    25. But in the said decision, as pointed out by Mr. Munirathina Naidu the decisions earlier rendered by the Apex Court in Pratap v. State of U.P, (1973) 3 SCC 690 : AIR 1973 SC 786; Eknath v. State of Maharashtra, (1977) 3 SCC 25 : AIR 1977 SC 1177, the Nadir Khan v. State, (1975) 2 SCC 406 : AIR 1976 SC 2205, in which it is held that the powers for enhancement under revisional jurisdiction are not affected merely because the revision petition was filed by a private person and not by the Government, have not been referred to.

    26. With reference to the decision of the Apex Court in 1997 SCC (Cri) 430 (supra), it is true that the Apex Court would hold that the appeal for enhancement in a private complaint filed by the Assistant Collector of Central Exercise, Madras, could only be filed by the Central Government and not by the complainant under Section 377(2), Cr. P.C This decision also would not help the Counsel for the accused, as it does not deal with the revisional powers.

    27. However, I could see one illegality committed by the Sessions Court. As stated above, the learned Sessions Judge had come to the conclusion that the accused is liable to pay only the balance of the cheque amount and directed the petitioners to pay the amount of Rs. 1,44,000/- viz., twice the balance of the cheque amount. This is not contemplated under Section 138 of the Act.

    28. Section 138 provides that the person who committed the offence under this Act shall be punished with imprisonment for a term which may extend to one year, or with fine which may extend to twice the amount of the cheque or with both. It does not provide for the imposition of the fine twice the balance amount of the cheque.

    29. The discretion is that the Court on consideration of the facts and circumstances of the case, could impose imprisonment up to, one year or sentence of fine to the extent of twice the amount of the cheque. Therefore, in my view, the order directing the accused to pay twice the amount of alleged balance of the cheque amount, may not be correct.

    30. In this context, it is relevant to note that in the decisions in (1973) 3 SCC 690 : AIR 1973 SC 786 (supra) and (1977) 3 SCC 25 : AIR 1977 SC 1177 (supra) it is held that the High Court in an appropriate case, can enhance sentence even by exercising revisional powers, suo motu.

    31. So, in view of the matter, I deem it fit to set aside the order of the Sessions Court regarding sentence and instead, I enhance the sentence of fine from Rs. 30,000/- to Rs. 75,000/-, out of which the complainant, in my view, is entitled to get, Rs. 72,000/- as compensation. It is brought to my notice that already Rs. 30,000/- were deposited, out of which Rs. 28,000/- were given to the complainant as compensation. So, the balance amount of Rs. 45,000/- has to be deposited by the petitioners in the lower Court. Thereupon, on such deposit, Rs. 44,000/- are directed to be paid to the complainant.

    32. With the above observations, the revisions are dismissed and in view of the findings in the revision, no order is necessary in Crl. O.P No. 17795 of 1997.

    33. Revisions dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    J.S Agencies v. Namakkal South India Transports .
    (Sep 25, 1998)