Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 51 of Chapter XIV-A of the K.E.R Sub-section (2) of Section 7 of the Kerala Education Act
  • Rule 51A of Chapter XIV-A of the Kerala Education Rules (for short, K.E.R)
  • provisions of the Kerala Education Act and the Rules, Rule 9(1)
  • provisions of this Act and the rules thereunder. Rule 9
  • provisions of the Kerala Education Act and the Rules
  • sub rule (4) of the Rule..6.
  • R6(a) order and Rule 51
  • sub-rule (1) of Rule 1
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 51 of Chapter XIV-A of the K.E.R Sub-section (2) of Section 7 of the Kerala Education Act
  • Rule 51A of Chapter XIV-A of the Kerala Education Rules (for short, K.E.R)
  • provisions of the Kerala Education Act and the Rules, Rule 9(1)
  • provisions of this Act and the rules thereunder. Rule 9
  • provisions of the Kerala Education Act and the Rules
  • sub rule (4) of the Rule..6.
  • R6(a) order and Rule 51
  • sub-rule (1) of Rule 1
Smart Summary

Neutral Summary of the Opinion — Balakrishnan Nair, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant (sixth respondent in the underlying writ petition) had been appointed as an Upper Primary School Assistant ("U.P.S.A") to fill a maternity leave vacancy from 6.6.2002 to 17.10.2002. A regular vacancy in the U.P.S.A. cadre arose on 2.9.2002 by reason of promotion. The first respondent (the writ petitioner) was appointed to that regular vacancy. The District Educational Officer ("D.E.O.") approved the first respondent's appointment by an order dated 20.5.2003.

The appellant made a representation on 10.7.2003 seeking accommodation in the regular vacancy. Pursuant to a direction of this Court in Writ Petition (Civil) No. 17296 of 2004 dated 15.6.2004, the D.E.O. considered the appellant's claim and rejected it by Ext. P4 order dated 5.10.2004, taking the view that the appellant's appointment to the leave vacancy had been approved only on 12.6.2003 and so any claim under the relevant rule arose only thereafter. In the meantime the first respondent had been promoted to H.S.A. on 9.6.2003, and the appellant was later appointed as U.P.S.A. in the resultant vacancy.

The appellant challenged Ext. P4 before the Deputy Director of Education by an appeal (referred to as Ext. P5/Ext. P5 appeal). The Deputy Director allowed the appeal by Ext. P6 order dated 11.12.2006 and directed the D.E.O. to regularise U.P.S.A. appointments made by the Manager and to accommodate the appellant in the regular vacancy of 2.9.2002. The first respondent challenged Ext. P6 before the Director of Public Instruction by petition dated 17.8.2007; the Director dismissed that petition by Ext. P7 order dated 31.10.2007, upholding the Deputy Director's order. The Manager filed a revision before the Government; the Government forwarded the revision back to the Director by Ext. P8 letter dated 26/11/2007 directing reconsideration after hearing all parties. The Director reconsidered and by Ext. P9 order dated 3.7.2008 affirmed Ext. P7.

The first respondent then filed the present writ petition challenging Exts. P6, P7 and P9. The sixth respondent (appellant) filed a counter-affidavit supporting the impugned orders and produced Ext. R6(a), a Government order dated 9.11.1999 clarifying that "services of leave substitutes will be regularised against the first arising permanent/regular vacancy in the respective schools in the order of seniority." The Manager supported the first respondent. The Single Judge allowed the writ petition and quashed Exts. P6, P7 and P9. The sixth respondent (appellant) appealed to the Court which delivered the present opinion.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellant (a leave substitute appointed to a maternity leave vacancy) should have been accommodated in the regular vacancy that arose on 2.9.2002, instead of appointing a fresh hand (the first respondent) to that regular vacancy.
  2. Whether the Manager's appointment of a fresh hand to the regular vacancy was lawful in view of Rule 51 of Chapter XIV‑A of the Kerala Education Rules ("K.E.R.") and the Government clarification Ext. R6(a) that leave substitutes are to be regularised against the first arising permanent vacancy in order of seniority.
  3. Whether the delay contentions raised by the first respondent (that the appellant delayed in prosecuting the appeal) should have precluded the appellant's claim, and whether the first respondent's own delay in challenging the Deputy Director's order affected that contention.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (sixth respondent)

  • Ext. R6(a) (Government order dated 9.11.1999) together with Rule 51 of Chapter XIV‑A of the K.E.R. required that incumbents working in leave vacancies be accommodated in the first arising regular vacancy in order of seniority; therefore the appellant should have been accommodated in the vacancy of 2.9.2002.
  • The Manager committed an illegality by inducting a fresh hand (the first respondent) into the regular vacancy; although the D.E.O. approved that induction, the Deputy Director and the Director of Public Instruction correctly set aside that approval.
  • Any contention of delay on the part of the appellant in prosecuting remedies was answered by pointing out that the first respondent also delayed in challenging the Deputy Director's order before the Director of Public Instruction and did not raise the delay point before the Deputy Director.

First Respondent's Arguments (writ petitioner)

  • Supported the impugned orders (i.e., the Single Judge's order quashing Exts. P6, P7 and P9).
  • Asserted that there was considerable delay in filing the appeal (Ext. P5) dated 27.9.2005 against Ext. P4 (dated 5.10.2004) and therefore the Deputy Director should not have entertained that appeal.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Joshi v. Krishna P. Raian, 2006 (4) KLT SN 63 (Case No. 85) Principle that a Manager cannot deny promotion or re‑appointment on the ground that the original appointment (e.g., to a leave vacancy) has not yet been formally approved. The Court relied on this Division Bench decision to support the proposition that the Manager could not refuse to accommodate the appellant in the regular vacancy on the ground that her leave vacancy appointment had not yet been approved; thereby reinforcing the finding that the Manager's action was impermissible.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded by reference to the statutory and rule framework and the Government clarification produced in the record.

First, the Court identified Rule 51 of Chapter XIV‑A of the K.E.R. as the governing rule on retrenchment and seniority: "When a vacancy in any category of post terminates necessitating the relief of a teacher, senior hands shall ordinarily be retained in preference to junior hands..." The Court noted that for U.P.S.As there is no subject requirement applicable to appointment or retrenchment.

Second, the Court relied on Ext. R6(a) (Government order dated 9.11.1999) which mandates that incumbents working in leave vacancies "shall be accommodated in the regular vacancies having regard to their seniority." The Court treated this as a clarification of Rule 51 and as an instruction that managers of aided schools must follow in making appointments.

Third, the Court referred to Rule 9 of Chapter III of the K.E.R., which makes it a mandatory duty of the Manager to conduct the school in strict accordance with the Kerala Education Act and the Rules and to abide by Government and Departmental orders. From these provisions the Court concluded that the Manager was bound to appoint or regularise staff in conformity with Rule 51 and Ext. R6(a).

Fourth, the Court rejected the Manager's contention that because the appellant's leave‑vacancy appointment had not been formally approved at the moment the regular vacancy arose, the appellant could be bypassed. The Court observed that the Manager knew (a) that the appointment was to a maternity leave vacancy sanctioned under the Staff Fixation Order, and (b) that the appellant was qualified and that approval was only a matter of time. Hence the Manager should have accommodated the appellant in the regular vacancy and, if necessary, filled only the residual portion of the maternity leave vacancy with a fresh hand.

Fifth, the Court applied Rule 7A(3) of Chapter XIV‑A (as it stood at the relevant time) which provided that vacancies of two months or less should not be filled by appointment. The Court noted that the remaining period of the maternity leave vacancy did not exceed two months, and therefore the first respondent could not have been validly appointed as U.P.S.A. to that short remainder even leaving aside the seniority/regularisation rule.

Sixth, the Court found support in the cited Division Bench decision (Joshi v. Krishna P. Raian) to hold that the Manager could not deny promotion/re‑appointment on the ground that the original appointment had not yet been approved.

Finally, on the procedural objection of delay: the Court found the first respondent's delay contention to be untenable because the first respondent himself had delayed in challenging the Deputy Director's order before the Director of Public Instruction and had not raised the delay point before the Deputy Director when the matter was earlier considered.

Holding and Implications

Core holding: The Writ Appeal is allowed. The judgment under appeal (the Single Judge's order quashing Exts. P6, P7 and P9) is reversed, the writ petition is dismissed, and Exts. P6, P7 and P9 orders (which had directed accommodation/regularisation of the appellant in the 2.9.2002 vacancy) are restored.

Direct consequences for the parties:

  • The Court held that the appointment of the first respondent to the regular vacancy of 2.9.2002 was illegal and that the D.E.O. should not have approved that appointment.
  • The orders of the Deputy Director of Education and the Director of Public Instruction in favour of the appellant (Exts. P6, P7 and P9) are restored and thereby the appellant is to be accommodated in the regular vacancy of 2.9.2002 as directed in those orders.

Broader implications and precedent: The opinion proceeded by application of existing rules (Rule 51, Rule 9, Rule 7A(3)) and the Government clarification Ext. R6(a), and it relied on an earlier Division Bench decision (Joshi v. Krishna P. Raian). The Court did not purport to create a new principle of law beyond applying these authorities to the facts. Therefore the effect is the application and enforcement of existing rule‑based duties of Managers and departmental authorities rather than the establishment of a novel precedent.

    Geetha S. v. Smt. Geo Thomas K. & Others

    Balakrishnan Nair, J.:— The appellant was the sixth respondent in the Writ Petition, She was appointed as Upper Primary School Assistant (for short, “U.P.S.A”) in the fifth respondent's High School, in a maternity leave vacancy from 6.6.2002 to 17.10.2002 While so, a regular 2.9.2002, in which the first respondent/Writ Petitioner was appointed. The point that arises for decision in this case is, whether the appellant should have been accommodated in the regular vacancy which arose on 2.09.2002 or a fresh hand like the first respondent could have been inducted, as was done in this case. The brief facts of the case are the following:

    2. As mentioned earlier, the appellant was appointed as U.P.S.A in a maternity leave vacancy from 6.6.2002 to 17.10.2002 The said appointment was approved by the District Educational Officer (for short, ‘D.E.O’) on 12.6.2003 While so, a regular vacancy in the cadre of U.P.S.A arose, as a result of promotion of one of the U.P.S.A's. on 2.09.2002 The first respondent/writ petitioner was appointed in that vacancy. The D.E.O, by order dated 20.5.2003, approved the said appointment of the first respondent from 2.09.2002 to 31.3.2003 and from 2.7.2003 onwards without any time limit. On approval of the first respondent's aforementioned appointment, the appellant/sixth respondent moved the D.E.O by filing a representation on 10.7.2003, and this Court by judgment dated 15.6.2004 in Writ Petition (Civil) No. 17296 of 2004 directed the D.E.O to consider the claim of the appellant/sixth respondent. There was some dispute between the parties as to whether the appellant has submitted the representation dated 10.7.2003 Anyway, pursuant to the direction of this Court, the appellant's claim for appointment in the regular vacancy which arose on 2.9.2002 was considered by the D.E.O and rejected by Ext. P4 order dated 5.10.2004 The D.E.O took the view that since the appointment of the appellant in the leave vacancy was approved only on 12.6.2003, she could have raised a claim far any appointment under Rule 51A of Chapter XIV-A of the Kerala Education Rules (for short, ‘K.E.R’) only thereafter. The said Rule recognises the right of a retrenched teacher for re-appointment. In the meantime, the first respondent was promoted as H.S.A on 9.6.2003 and in the resultant vacancy, the appellant was appointed as U.P.S.A

    3. The appellant challenged Ext. P4 order before the Deputy Director of Education, by filing Ext. PS appeal. The Deputy Director by Ext. P6 order dated 11.12.2006 allowed the appeal. The D.E.O was directed to regularise the appointments of U.P.S.As made by the Manager. As per that order, the appellant was to be accommodated in the regular vacancy of U.P.S.A which arose on 2.9.2002 The first respondent challenged Ext. P6 order before the Director of Public Instruction, by filing a petition dated 17.8.2007 The Director of Public Instruction, by Ext. P7 order dated 31.10.2007 dismissed the said petition and upheld the order of the Deputy Director of Education, Ext. P6. The Manager, in the meantime, challenged the order of the Deputy Director of Education before the Government, by filing a Revision on 19.11.2007 The Government by Ext. P8 letter dated 26/11, 2007 forwarded the said Revision to the Director of Public Instruction, directing him to reconsider the matter, after hearing all concerned parties, including the Manager. Based on the said communication of the Government, the Director of Public Instruction reconsidered the matter and by Ext. P9 order dated 3.7.2008, affirmed his decision contained in Ext. P7 order dated 31.10.2007 Challenging Exts. P6, P7 and P9 orders, the first respondent filed the present Writ Petition. The sixth respondent/appellant filed a counter affidavit, supporting the impugned orders. Ext. R6(a) order of the Government dated 9.11.1999 was also produced along with the said counter affidavit. That said order says that, “Government are pleased to clarify that the services of leave substitutes will be regularised against the first arising permanent/regular vacancy in the respective schools in the order of seniority”. The Manager filed a counter affidavit, supporting the first respondent/writ petitioner. The learned Single Judge after hearing both sides, allowed the Writ Petition and quashed Exts. P6, P7 and P9 orders. Feeling aggrieved by the judgment of the learned Single Judge, this appeal is preferred by the sixth respondent.

    4. The learned counsel for the appellant submitted that in view of Ext. R6(a) order and Rule 51 of Chapter X. IV-A of the K.E.R, the appellant should have been accommodated in the regular vacancy which arose on 2.9.2002, even though at the relevant time, her appointment was not approved. The Manager committed an illegality in inducting a fresh hand in the regular vacancy of U.P.S.A The said illegality was approved by the D, E, O, but the Deputy Director of Education and the Director of Public Instruction took the correct view in law and there was no valid ground for interfering with those orders in the Writ Petition. The learned counsel for the first respondent, on the other hand, supported the impugned orders. He also pointed out that there was considerable delay in filing Ext. P5 appeal dated 27.9.2005 against Ext. P4 order dated 5.10.2004 Therefore, the Deputy Director should not have entertained that appeal. In answer, the learned counsel for the appellant submitted that the first respondent/petitioner challenged Ext. P6 order dated 11.12.2006 of the Deputy Director of Education by filing a petition only on 17.8.2007, before the Director of Public Instruction. So, there is delay on the part of the first respondent also to challenge the order adverse to him. It is also pointed out that as evident from Ext. P7, the first respondent did not raise such a contention of delay against the appellant before the Deputy Director.

    5. We considered the rival submissions made at the Bar and also the materials on record. The rule governing retrenchment of teachers is Rule 51 in Chapter XIV-A of the K.E.R, which reads as follows:

    “51. When a vacancy in any category of post terminates necessitating the relief of a teacher, senior hands shall ordinarily be retained in preference to junior hands with due regard to the requirement of subjects determined by the Director under sub-rule (1) of Rule 1 and to the instructions issued by him under sub rule (4) of the Rule.”.

    6. As far as U.P.S.As are concerned, there is no question of subject requirement in making the appointment or ordering retrenchment We have already quoted the relevant portion of Ext. R6(a) order, which mandates that incumbents working in leave vacancies shall be accommodated in the regular vacancies having regard to their seniority. The said order further explains or clarifies Rule 51 of Chapter XIV-A of the K.E.R Sub-section (2) of Section 7 of the Kerala Education Act says that, The Manager shall be responsible for the conduct of the school in accordance with the provisions of this Act and the rules thereunder”. Rule 9 of Chapter III of the K.E.R, makes it one of the mandatory duties of the Manager to comply with the orders issued by the Government and the Department in conformity with the provisions of the Kerala Education Act and the Rules, Rule 9(1) of Chapter III of the K.E.R reads as follows:

    “9. Duties and powers of the managers of Aided Schools.— (1) The Manager shall be responsible for the conduct of the school strictly in accordance with the provisions of the Kerala Education Act and the Rules issued thereunder. He shall also abide by the orders that may be issued from time to time by the Government and the Department in conformity with the provisions of the Act and the rules issued thereunder.”.

    7. In the light of the above provisions, the Manager could have made the appointments/retrenchments only in accordance with Rule 51 of Chapter XIV-A of the K.E.R quoted above and Ext. R6(a) order mentioned above, The Manager could not take shelter behind the plea that when the regular vacancy arose, the appointment of the appellant in the maternity leave vacancy was not approved. The Manager knew that the appointment was in a maternity leave vacancy which arose in a post sanctioned as per the Staff Fixation Order of that year, that the appellant was qualified for appointment as U.P.S.A also and therefore, even if there is delay, the appellant's appointment was going to be approved, Therefore, when the regular vacancy arose, the appellant should have been accommodated in that vacancy and a fresh hand could have been appointed only in the remaining portion of the maternity leave vacancy, in which the appellant was working. As a matter of fact, as the remaining period of the said leave vacancy does not have a duration of two months, the first respondent could not have been appointed at all, as U.P.S.A, in view of Rule 7A(3) of Chapter XIV-A of the K.E.R, which says that, the vacancies which have duration of two months or less period shall not be filled up by any appointment. The said two months period has since been amended with effect from 16.4.2005, but, when the appointment of the first respondent was made, the unamended rule was remaining in force. The legal position that the Manager cannot deny promotion or re-appointment for the reason that original appointment was not yet approved, is covered by the Division Bench decision of this Court in Joshi v. Krishna P. Raian. 2006 (4) KLT SN 63 (Case No. 85).

    8. In view of the above legal position, the decision of the learned Single Judge cannot be sustained. As held by the Deputy Director and the Director, the Manager should have appointed the appellant in the regular vacancy which arose on 2.9.2002 The appointment of the first respondent in that vacancy was illegal. The D.E.O should not have approved the said respondent's appointment We notice that the contention of delay from the part of the appellant raised by the first respondent cannot be accepted, as he was equally guilty of delay in challenging the order (Ext. P6) of the Deputy Director before the Director of Public Instruction. Further, that point is also seen not canvassed before the Director, when the said officer considered the challenge against Ext. PS order.

    9. In the result, the Writ Appeal is allowed. The judgment under appeal is reversed and the Writ Petition is dismissed. Exts. P6, P7 and P9 orders are restored.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Geetha S. v. Smt. Geo Thomas K. & Others
    (Sep 30, 2009)