Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, S. Thiyagarajan, filed a petition under section 482 of the Criminal Procedure Code seeking to set aside an order passed by the learned Sessions Judge, Kanyakumari, in Criminal Revision Petition 22/81. The respondent, Ayyamperumal, had initially filed a complaint against the petitioner and 14 others for alleged offences under section 500 read with sections 34 and 109 of the Indian Penal Code before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Kanyakumari at Nagercoil. The magistrate recorded the complainant's sworn statement but dismissed the complaint under section 203 of the Criminal Procedure Code, holding that no case was made out and noting the absence of other witnesses.

Aggrieved, the respondent filed a revision petition before the Sessions Judge without making the petitioner and others parties to the petition. The Sessions Judge, relying on the concession of the learned public prosecutor, allowed the revision petition and directed the magistrate to take the complaint on file, leading to summons being issued to the petitioner and others. The petitioner received the summons only on 24th July 1982 and contended that the Sessions Judge's order allowing the revision petition without notice to him was illegal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the learned Sessions Judge erred in allowing the revision petition without giving notice to the petitioner, thereby violating principles of natural justice.
  2. Whether notice to the accused is necessary before a Sessions Judge can set aside an order dismissing a complaint under section 203 of the Criminal Procedure Code.
  3. Whether the dismissal of the complaint under section 203 amounts to discharge of the accused within the meaning of section 436 of the Criminal Procedure Code, thereby triggering the requirement of notice.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The complaint and sworn statement did not make out a case against the petitioner, justifying dismissal under section 203 CrPC by the magistrate.
  • The Sessions Judge's order allowing the revision petition without giving notice to the petitioner violated the principles of natural justice.
  • Relied on multiple precedents to argue that reasonable opportunity to be heard must be given before taking action prejudicial to an individual.

Respondent's Arguments

  • Rules of natural justice are not absolute and apply only where not excluded by statute.
  • The statutory provisions under the CrPC do not mandate notice to the accused before setting aside an order dismissing a complaint under section 203.
  • Relied on precedents holding that no notice is necessary to the accused in such revision proceedings as the accused is not yet discharged within the meaning of section 436 CrPC.
  • Argued that no rule of natural justice was violated in the present case.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mankha Gardei v. Union of India Implied duty to give reasonable opportunity to be heard before punitive or damaging action affecting individual rights. Supported petitioner's contention on natural justice requiring notice.
State of Orissa v. Dr. (Miss) Minapani Dei and Others Administrative orders with civil consequences must comply with natural justice. Reinforced petitioner's argument on fair hearing.
State Bank v. R.K. Singh Even if statute silent, law implies right to be heard before adverse orders. Used to argue necessity of notice despite statutory silence.
Amarnath and Others v. State of Haryana and Others No order prejudicial to a person should be made without notice as per natural justice. Supported petitioner's arguments on notice requirement.
Shri Bhagwan and Another v. Ram Chand and Another; Mahmood Hasan v. State; K. Nithyanandam v. B. Radhamani; K. Balakrishnan Rao v. Haji Abdulla General principles of natural justice requiring notice before adverse orders. Further buttressed petitioner's submissions.
Gopalakrishnan v. Ramosuhramania Raja Revision petition procedure and necessity of notice to affected parties. Held that notice should be given before disposing revision petition; supported petitioner.
Union of India v. Col. I.N. Sikra and Another Natural justice rules apply only where not excluded by statute; courts must respect legislative intent. Supported respondent's argument that natural justice is not absolute and may be excluded.
Captain Harish Uppal v. Union of India and Others Application of natural justice rules depends on facts, law framework, and necessity for just decision. Used by respondent to argue no violation of natural justice in present case.
A.K. Kraipak v. Union Principles of natural justice and their application. Referenced by respondent to reinforce point on natural justice limitations.
Emperor v. Gajraj Singh and Others No notice to accused necessary before further enquiry after dismissal under sections 203 or 204 CrPC. Supported respondent's contention that notice was not required before Sessions Judge's order.
Vellopandi alias Maruthian Thevar and Others v. Annathaimmal and Another Order setting aside dismissal under section 203 CrPC without notice to accused is valid. Supported respondent's argument on procedural validity.
Jalaludeen v. Syed Ibrahim and Another Accused has no right of audience before court in revision against dismissal under section 203 CrPC. Supported respondent's stance on absence of notice requirement.
Thanikachala Mudali v. Ponnappa Mudali Accused not discharged under section 436 CrPC when complaint dismissed without process; no notice necessary in revision. Followed by court to hold no notice needed before Sessions Judge's order.
Appa Rao v. Janaki Ammal Notice to accused not necessary before ordering further enquiry after dismissal under section 203 CrPC. Applied by court to support dismissal of petition.
Chandra Deo v. Prakash Chandra High Court's limited intervention in subordinate criminal court proceedings; natural justice principles apply with limitations. Referenced in discussion on natural justice and procedural rights in criminal revisions.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court acknowledged the petitioner's contention that natural justice requires notice before an order prejudicial to a person is made. It recognized the general principle that reasonable opportunity to be heard is implied unless explicitly excluded by statute. However, the court emphasized that natural justice has inherent limitations and cannot override clear legislative intent or established procedural frameworks. The court referred to the 41st Law Commission Report and various precedents holding that in revision proceedings against dismissal of a complaint under section 203 CrPC, the accused is not considered discharged under section 436 CrPC, and therefore, no notice is required before the Sessions Judge orders further inquiry.

The court further noted that no vested right exists in any course of procedure and that courts must interpret statutes according to legislative intent rather than extend natural justice to create new procedural safeguards not contemplated by law. After considering the material and precedents, the court preferred to follow the line of authority holding that no notice to the accused is necessary before a Sessions Judge disposes of a revision petition challenging an order of dismissal under section 203 CrPC.

The court refrained from expressing any opinion on the merits of the complaint, leaving that to the discretion of the Chief Judicial Magistrate.

Holding and Implications

The court DISMISSED the petition filed under section 482 CrPC.

The direct effect of this decision is that the Sessions Judge's order allowing the revision petition without giving notice to the petitioner is held to be lawful and in accordance with established legal principles and statutory provisions. The court did not establish any new precedent but reaffirmed existing jurisprudence that no notice to the accused is required before a Sessions Judge sets aside an order dismissing a complaint under section 203 CrPC. The merits of the complaint remain to be independently adjudicated by the Chief Judicial Magistrate.

    S. Thiyagarajan v. Ayyamperumal And Another

    M.N.Moorthy J.:-

    (1) This is a petition filed by s. Thiyagarajan, a8, under section 482, criminal procedure code set aside the order passed by the learned sessions juqge, kanyakumari, in criminal r. P. 22/81.

    (2) The petition arises under the following circumstances. The respondent ayyamperumal had filed a complaint against the petitioner and 14 others for alleged offences under section 500 read with sections 34 and 109, indian penal code before the learned chief judicial magistrate, kanyakumari at nagercoil. The learned magistrate recorded the sworn statement from the complainant and dismissed the complaint under section 203, criminal procedure code holding no case is made out under section 500, indian penal code and that the complainant had not brought any other witness for examination on that day.

    (3) Aggrieved by the said order of the learned magistrate, the respondent filed criminal r. P. 22 of. 1981 before the learned sessions judge, kanyakumari at nagercoil without making the petitioner and the other accused as part its. The learned sessions judge, after hearing the respondent and on the basis of the concession made by the learned public prosecutor, allowed the revision petition and directed the learned magistrate to take the complaint on file. Accordingly, the magistrate numbered the complaint as c. C. No. 265. Of 1982 and issued summons to the petitioner herein and the other accused.

    (4) The petitioner received the summons on 24th july, 1982. Till then, the petitioner was not aware of the proceedings. The present petition is filed on the ground, the order of the learned sessions judge, allowing the revision petition without giving notice to the petitioner is illegal.

    (5) Mr. N. T. Vanamamalai, learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that even as per the complaint and the sworn statement, no case is made out against the petitioner and the learned magistrate was right in dismissing the complaint under section 203, criminal procedure code. He further contended that the order of the learned sessions judge is against the principles of natural justice and against law, as he has allowed the revision petition without giving notice to the petitioner.

    (6) In support of the contention, mr. Vanamamalai drew my attention to a number of decision. He relied on the decision in mankha gardei v. Union of india1 for the proposition, when there is at specific provision in a statute or rules made there under for showing cause against action to be taken against an individual which affect the right of that individual the duty to give reasonable opportunity to be heard will be implied from the nature of the function to be performed by the authority which has the power to take punitive or damaging action.

    (7) He relied on the decision in state of orissa v. Dr. (miss) minapani dei and others2 to show that even an administrative order which involves civil consequences should be made consistent with the rules of natural justice. The person concerned must be informed of the case of the state and the evidence in support thereof and he must be given a fair opportunity to meet the case before an adverse decision is taken.

    (8) Next, he drew my attention to the decision in state bank v r. K. Singh3 and relied on the following passage: it is true that the statute does not expressly require a notice to be issued, or a hearing to be given to the parties adversely affected. But, though the statute is silent and does not expressly require issue of any notice there is in the eye of law a necessary implication that the party adversely affected should be heard before the court makes an order for return of the seized property. In other words, if there are no positive words in a statute requiring that the party shall be heard yet the justice of the common law will supply the omission of the legislature. Amarnath and others v. State or haryana and others4 is another decision relied on to support the argument that no order prejudicial to a person should be made without giving notice to him, as it is against the principles of natural justice. To butt cress up the same contention the decisions in shri bhagwan and another v. Ram chand and another,5 mahmood hasan v. State,6 k. Nithyanandam v. B. Radhamani7 and k. Balakrishnan rao v. Haji abdulla8 were placed before me.

    (9) Mr. Vanamamalai strenuously con tended that the decision in gopalakrishnan v. Ramosuhramania raja9, supports his stand that the order of the learned sessions judge passed without giving notice to the petitioner is bad in law. In that case a revision petition was filed against the order of dismissal of a complaint preferred by the petitioner before the sub - divisional magistrate. At the time of admission the court issued notice to the public prosecutor and to the complainant as well. On the contention that the public prosecutor and the learned counsel for the complainant cannot actively participate in the enquiry, the learned judge made the following observations in page 42 - 43: mj am of the view that the proceedings under section 436. Criminal procedure code, are peculiar in nature and they have an import of their own which is not covered by the ordinary process of criminal law. This is a case where the high court is called upon to scrutinise the orders of sub - ordinate criminal courts who in the exercise of their judicial discretion dismissed the private complaint as one for which in their opinion and judgment there was no sufficient ground for proceeding. At that stage and after the high court has issued notices to the learned public prosecutor (evidently because some of the respondents are police officers) and to the other respondents, it cannot be said that the ban in the rule in chandra dec v. Prakash chandra, to applies in toto to the facts and circumstances of this case. The respondents are undoubtedly entitled to come to the court to state that the order which in sought to be challenged in this court is sustainable because it satisfies the various limbs of sections 200 to 203, cr. P. C. And on the other legal grounds. To that extent at least they have a right of audience. Therefore, the right of presence which looms large in the rule in chandra deo v. Prakash chandra,1 gets itself relaxed in the circumstances of this case not only to the right of presence but also to the entitlement being heard for the limited purpose stated above. If this is not so, i am of view that the principles of natural 4ustice would be violated. For ought i know the doctrine of natural justice is not eliminate because the matter is one concerning crimes. In the absence of any specific provision in the criminal procedure code, which puts a total ban on such persons or counsel making a representation to the court that the impugned order of the magistrate or sessions judge is not in accordance with law or otherwise there is nothing which prevents this court as a high court to hear them on that aspect only and i propose to hear them on that aspect only and i propose to hear them, though for a very limited purpose. Two unreported decisions. Criminal procedure code 460 of 1980, dated 22nd december, 1981 by ratnavel pandian, j. , and cr1. M. P. No. 6915 of 1980, dated 28th june, 1982 by singaravelu, j. Also supported the view that the learned sessions judge should have given notice to the petitioner before disposing of the revision petition.

    (10) Mr. Asokan, learned counsel for the respondent, countered the arguments advanced by the learned counsel for the petitioner, drawing my attention of the decision in union of india v. Col. 1. N. Sikra and another,11 wherein it is held as follows: rules of natural justice are not embodied rules nor can they he elevated to the position of fundamental rights. As observed by this court in kraipaks case,2 these rules can operate only in areas not covered by any law validly made. If a statutory provision can be read on sisterly with the principles of natural justice, the courts should do so because it must be presumed that the legislatures and the statutory authorities intend to act in accordance with the principles of natural justice. But on the other hand when a statutory provision either specifically or by necessary implication excludes the application of any or all the principles of natural justice, then the court cannot ignore the mandate of the legislature or the statutory authority and read with the concerned provision the principles of natural justice. Whether the exercise, of a power conferred should be made in accordance with any of the principles of natural justice or not depends upon the express words of the provisions conferring the power, nature of the power conferred, the purpose for which it is conferred and the effect of the exercise of the power. 10. He also relied on the decision in captain harish uppal v. Union of india and others,12 and contended that what particular rule of natural justice should apply to a given case must depend to a great extent on the facts and circumstances of the case, and the framework of the law under which the enquiry is held. The court has to decide whether the observance of the rule of natural justice is necessary for a just decision to hold the enquiry in good faith and without bias and not arbitrarily or unreasonably. In the present case, he argued no rule of natural justice has been violated. Reliance is also placed on the decision in a. K. Kraipak v. Union.

    (11) The learned public prosecutor, relying on the decision in emperor v. Gajraj singh and others,13 contended that the order of the learned sessions judge without giving notice to the petitioner is correct. According to the decision cited by him, where a complaint has been dismissed under section 203 or section 204 of the criminal procedure code in contradiction to an accused person being discharged, no notice to the person against whom the complaint was made is necessary before further enquiry into the case can be ordered. In a case reported in vellopandi alias maruthian thevar and others v. Annathaiammal and another14, ratnavel pandian j. Has held that the order of the district magistrate setting aside the order of the sub - divisional magistrate dismissing the complaint under section 203, criminal procedure code without giving notice to the accused, is valid. In jalaludeen v. Syed ibrahim and another. 15 paul j. Has held that in a revision against the order of dismissal of the complaint under section 203, criminal procedure code the accused does not come into the picture at an and as such has no right of audience before court, when the dismissal of the complaint under section 203, criminal procedure code, is challenged.

    (12) In an earlier decision of our high court in thanikachala mudali v. Ponnapa, mudali,16 yahya ali, j. Has held, where a magistrate dismisses a complaint without issuing process to tile accused, the accused person cannot be said to have been discharged within the meaning of the proviso to section 436, criminal procedure code and therefore, no notice is necessary to him when the sessions judge directs further inquiry into the complaint. To the same effect is a bench decision of the high court reported in appa rao v. Janaki ammal,17 where it is held, when a complaint is dismissed under section 203, criminal procedure code, notice to accused is not necessary before ordering further enquiry as he is not dischargedt within section 436, criminal procedure code.

    (13) In view of the order i propose to make, as regards the contention on the merits of the complaint, refrain from giving a finding except to say that it is for the learned chief judicial magistrate to come to his own independent judicial discretion.

    (14) As regards the contention that natural justice requires that the petitioner should have been given notice by the learned session judge before disposing of the criminal revision petition, i am aware that even if there is no specific provision for notice in the statute, provision must be read into the law in certain circumstances. The concept of natural justice has got its own natural limitations. It cannot be too vague and stretched to an extent of breaking of systems of recognised law. No person has a vested right in any course of procedure. It is for the legislature at any time to change the mode of procedure. In construing a statute the court is not at liberty to stretch to square with the theory or that theory. The court has no power to go behind the intention of the legislature on the pretext of natural justice. Courts are to interpret the laws and not make them and must firmly refuse to fill in a lacuna even though the refusal may work hardship an individual case. Coming to the case on hand, it is relevant to note the 41st report of the law commission on the subject: 32 10. One suggestion made to us regarding section 436 was that before an order dismissing a complaint under section 203 is disturbed, notice should go to the accused person so that he can urge what he likes in support of the dismissal order. This was sought to be supported by the principles of natural justice. We do not however, see how such an accused person can be called, a party to the proceedings at that, stage, and the supreme. Court has ruled at chandra deo v. Prakash chandra that it is hardly proper to intervene in the proceedings. Further, in a number of cases, it will happen that notice to him will seem unnecessary trouble and expense to a person who may be wholly innocent. If a magistrate has, on considering the facts found that there is no ground for proceeding against any person and therefore, dismissed the complaint summarily there is hardly any reason for the revision court to call anyone to court as an accused, or as a respondent until, of course, after a further inquiry has been made, and that inquiry justifies the issuing of process. The above passage makes it abundantly dear that the guideline for the statute is that in a revision against the order of dismissal of a complaint under section 203. Criminal. Procedure code, no notice need be - given to the accused. No restraints an a conditions which the legislature itself did not - think proper or necessary to impose can be brought in by the backdoor on the concept of natural justice. Thus, on a consideration of the entire materials placed before me and the discussion made above, i prefer to follow the rulings of our high court in appa roo v. Janakiammal thanikachala mudali v. Ponnappa mudali vellapandi alias muruthian thewar and others v annathaimmal and another and jalaludeen v. Syed ibrahim and another and hold that in a revision filed against an order of dismissal under section 203, criminal procedure code the learned sessions judge need not give notice to the accused. The petition stands dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    S. Thiyagarajan v. Ayyamperumal And Another
    (Jan 20, 1983)