Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitions were filed by Bharath Overseas Bank Limited, the complainant in a criminal case (Tx Cr. No. 790 of 1986) pending investigation against Ramalingam, an accused who was an officer of the bank. The complaint alleged that Ramalingam fraudulently collected large sums of money from bank branches by opening accounts in fictitious names and forging bank documents. The investigation revealed that the accused had deposited the fraudulently obtained money into various accounts held by himself and his family members. The police issued instructions to freeze these accounts. The accused and his wife (the first respondent) filed applications under Section 451 of the Criminal Procedure Code (Cr.P.C.) before the trial court seeking release of the funds and permission to operate the accounts. The trial court held that the police had no power to freeze bank balances and ordered the release of the amounts. The bank challenged these orders by filing applications under Section 482 Cr.P.C. to set aside the magistrate's orders.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether money in a bank account constitutes "property" under Section 102 of the Criminal Procedure Code, which a police officer can seize during investigation.
  2. Whether the police have the power to freeze bank accounts by prohibiting the account holders from operating them as a mode of seizure.
  3. Whether the failure of the investigating officer to report the seizure of bank balances to the magistrate under Section 102(3) Cr.P.C. invalidates the seizure.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner (Bharath Overseas Bank Limited)

  • The magistrate erred in holding that police have no power to seize bank balances.
  • The powers of seizure under Section 102 Cr.P.C. must be read with Chapter 34 of the Code, which contemplates seizure and custody of property during investigation and trial.
  • If money in a bank account is obtained through commission of a crime, police have the right and duty to freeze such accounts to preserve evidence and enable court orders under Section 452 Cr.P.C.

First Respondent and Accused (Ramalingam and wife)

  • Funds in a bank account are not "property" within the meaning of Cr.P.C., but represent a chose in action, i.e., a debt owed by the bank to the customer.
  • The relationship between banker and customer is that of debtor and creditor; money deposited loses its character and cannot be seized as property.
  • The police failed to comply with mandatory reporting requirements under Section 102(3) Cr.P.C., rendering the seizure invalid.

Second Respondent (Investigating Officer)

  • The accused committed large-scale fraud, depositing illicitly obtained money into various accounts.
  • The investigating officer was obliged to seize these amounts as evidence and to preserve them for trial.
  • Freezing the accounts by prohibiting operation was the only practical mode of seizure of bank balances.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
R. K. Dalmia and others v. Delhi Administration Money in bank accounts is "property" under IPC sections relating to offences against property; bank balances are chose in action but still property. The court relied on this to hold that bank balances are property for purposes of seizure under Section 102 Cr.P.C., rejecting the argument that money in bank accounts is not property.
Prafulla Kumar Deb v. Suresh Chandra Deb Order to stop payment in a civil context was struck down as attachment before judgment; presumption of innocence in criminal cases. The court distinguished this case as having no analogy to the present facts involving seizure of bank balances in a criminal investigation.
Re Lloyda Bank Limited Money in bank account could not be produced in court as property; credit is a chose in action. The court noted this decision but found it did not preclude seizure by freezing accounts as a mode of seizure.
Makkan Lal Chatterjee v. Emperor Relationship of banker and customer is debtor-creditor; magistrate cannot pass an order preventing operation of accounts without proof of connection to proceeds of crime. The court acknowledged this principle but distinguished it based on the facts of fraudulent diversion of funds.
K. P. Menon and another v. Punithavathi Manian Reiterated the debtor-creditor relationship between banker and customer. Referenced to acknowledge the legal nature of bank accounts but not to deny property status for seizure purposes.
Attorney General of Canada v. Quebec Province Money deposited in bank is lent to the bank; bank's obligation is to repay a like sum, not trust money. Used to support the debtor-creditor nature of bank deposits.
Dr. Gurcharan Singh v. State of Punjab Money in bank accounts is property capable of seizure under Section 102 Cr.P.C.; freezing accounts is a valid seizure method. The court adopted this as reflecting the correct legal position on seizure of bank balances.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the legal meaning of "property" under Section 102 Cr.P.C., noting that while the term is not defined in the Code, it is to be read in light of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) definitions and judicial interpretations. The Supreme Court in R. K. Dalmia held that bank balances, though a chose in action, are property within the meaning of offences against property in the IPC. The court reasoned that excluding bank money from the ambit of "property" would frustrate the investigation of white-collar crimes and bank frauds, which are increasingly prevalent.

The court further analyzed the method of seizure applicable to bank balances. Unlike tangible movable property that can be physically seized, bank balances can only be seized by restricting the account holder's power to operate the account, i.e., by freezing the account through a prohibitory order. This method effectively prevents the accused from exercising ownership rights over the bank balance, analogous to physical seizure of movable property.

The court acknowledged the contention regarding non-compliance with Section 102(3) Cr.P.C. reporting requirements but held that such procedural lapses do not automatically invalidate the seizure. The investigating officer was directed to comply forthwith, and any prejudice to the accused could be raised during trial.

In conclusion, the court held that money in bank accounts is property within the meaning of Section 102 Cr.P.C. and may be seized by freezing the accounts. The orders of the magistrate directing release of the funds were set aside accordingly.

Holding and Implications

The petitions filed by Bharath Overseas Bank Limited under Section 482 Cr.P.C. are allowed, and the orders of the magistrate directing release of the frozen bank balances are set aside.

The direct effect of this decision is that police officers have the legal authority to seize money in bank accounts by issuing prohibitory orders freezing the accounts during investigation of offences involving such money. This facilitates preservation of evidence and enables courts to pass consequential orders at trial. The ruling clarifies the interpretation of "property" under Section 102 Cr.P.C. to include bank balances. No new precedent beyond this case's facts is established, but the decision reinforces the investigative powers in white-collar crime cases involving bank frauds.

    Bharath Overseas Bank v. Minu Publication

    Padmini Jesudurai, J.:-

    (1) The two petitions, are by the bharath overseas bank limited, which is the complainant in tx cr. No. 790 of 1986, pending investigation with the second respondent, registered against one ramalingam (hereinafter referred to as accused) who is the husband of prema ramalingam, the first respondent in cri. M. P. No. 8865 of 1987 (hereinafter referred to as the first respondent and are directed against the orders passed under s. 451, cri. P. C. By the additional chief metropolitan magistrate, egmore. Madras, in m. P. Nos. 184 of 1987 and 208 of 1987, respectively holding the second respondents seizure of the amounts in the accounts of the accused and the first respondent in the petitioner bank as illegal, and directing the release of the amou nts.

    (2) Facts briefly are on a complaint by the petitioner to the second respondent, alleging that accused ramalingam, who was employed as an officer in the petitioner bank, had fraudulently collected large some of money from the branches of the bank at george town and thiyagaraya nagar, through accounts opened in the naesm of the fictitious persons, by forging credit advices and other bank records, a case in cr. No. 790 of 1986 for offence under ss. 467, 468, 471 and 420, i. P. C. Was registered. During investigation accused ramalingam when examined gave details of the transactions carried on by him. Investigation revealed that the accused had opened accounts in the different branches of the bank, in the names of fictitious persons, had forged credit advices and other documents and collected large sums of money from the bank. To deploy the funds so collected, the accused had opened several accounts in the names of himself and his family members in banks and other institutions. These monies totalling rs. 5,70,000 routed though different banks, were ultimately paid to. The accused, who deposited the same in the accounts opened by him in his name and in the names of his family members. The second respondent, therefore, issued instructions to the bank not to permit the accused and his family members to operate these accounts. The amounts, in the above accounts, were freezed.

    (3) The accused and his wife, the first respondent filed applications under s. 451, cri. P. C. Before the trial court, for releasing the funds and for directing the bank authorities to permit them to operate their accounts. In both the petitions, the learned magistrate, holding that under the cri. P. C. The police have no right to issue such prohibitory orders regarding bank balance, directed their release. Aggrieved with the above orders, the petitioner has filed the present applications under s. 482, cri. P. C. To have the orders of the magistrate, set aside.

    (4) Thiru k. Ashokan learned counsel for the petitioner contended that the learned magistrate erred in holding that the police had no powers, to seize bank balance. The powers of seizure under s. 102, cri. P. C. , ought to be read in conjunction with the provisions contained in chapter 34 of the code. According to the learned counsel, if during investigation, the police find, that money in a bank was obtained through the commission of a crime or that a crime was committed regarding that money, then it is not only the right, but also the duty of a police officer, to freeze the bank accounts, since that money has to be made available to the court, for an order under 5. 452, cri. P. C. , for restoration to the person entitled to it. Learned counsel placed reliance upon certain decisions, which i shall refer to presently.

    (5) Per contra thiru s. Srinivasan, learned counsel for the first respondent and for the accused ramalingam contended, that the bank funds are not property and that under the criminal procedure code, the police have no right to freeze bank funds, since the relationship between the bank and its customer, is that of a debor and a creditor and the bank is under an obligation to pay back the money, to the customer, as and when required by the customer and once the money is deposited in the bank, the money loses its character and becomes unidentifiable, and the customer has only a chose in action, to get back the amount and that, therefore, money in a bank cannot, be seized. Learned counsel also contended that in the instant case, the second respondent had not intimated about the seizure to the magistrate, as is required under s. 102 (3) , cri. P. C. And that, therefore, there is no valid seizure and the order of the learned magistrate has to be sustained.

    (6) Learned counsel also placed reliance upon several decisions, which i shall refer to presently. Learned public prosecutor for the second respondent contended that investigation disclosed that the accused had played fraud on a large scale on the petitioner bank, and the amounts collected through the commission of this offence, were deposited in the different accounts, standing in the names of the accused and his family members and since these amounts were really obtained through the commission of a came, the investigating officer had to seize the same, as they were required not only as evidence of the commission of the crime, but also for enabling the trial court to pass consequential orders regarding them, at the conclusions of the trial. The investigating officer, therefore, wrote to the bank, not to permit the holders of the above accounts to operate on them, since that was the only mode in which such bank balances, could be seized and preserved for trial.

    (7) The short question that arises for consideration is whether money in a bank account is tproperty under s. 102, cri. P. C. Which a police officer could seize during investigation?

    (8) 5. 102, cri. P. C. Dealing with the powers of the police to seize property, could be usefully extracted for an easy appreciation of the legal issue: s. 101. Cri. P. C. - power of police officer to seize certain property: (1) any police officer may seize any property which may be alleged or suspected to have been stolen, or which may be found under circumstances which create suspicion of the commission of any offence. (2) such police officer, if subordinate to the officer - in - charge of a police station, shall forthwith report the seizure to that officer, (3) every police officer acting under sub - s (1) shall forthwith report the seizure to the magistrate having jurisdiction and whether the property seized is such that it cannot be conveniently transported to the court, he may give custody thereof, to any person on his executing a bond undertaking to produce the property before the court as and when required and to give effect to the further orders of the court as to the disposal of the same.

    (9) The first contention of the learned counsel for the second respondent and the accused is that the money in a bank is not property within the meaning of s. 102, and chapter 34 of the criminal procedure code. The word property has not been defined in the criminal, procedure code. However, 5. 2 (y) of the code assigns to works expressed and not defined, in the criminal procedure code, but defined iii the, indian penal code, the meanings assigned to them in the indian penal code. Even in the penal code the word property as such, has not been defined, though the term t1moveable property has been defined in 5. 22. I. P. C. As follows: the words t1moveable property ire intended to include, corporeal property of every description, except land and things attached to the earth or permanently fastened to anything, which is attached to the earth. This definition is of only inclusive nature but is not exhaustive. It merely indicates what would be included in the term moveable property. The supreme court in r. K. Dalmia and others v. Delhi administration1 found it possible to hold that the word property occurring in ss. 405 and 409, i. P. C. , should be given a wider meaning, since the word property is not qualified in those sections, by any other expression like moveable. In the above case, the accused were prosecuted and convicted inter alia for offences under ss. 405 and 409, i. P. C. , in that accused dalmia, in his capacity as chairman of the board of directors and the principal officer of the bharath insurance company ltd. , and being entrusted with the funds of the above company, standing in the accounts of the various banks in which the company had current accounts, diverted the above funds to another concern, the bharath union agencies, which was practically owned by him. To cover up this un - authorised transfer, of funds, other offences had also been committed, a contention, therefore, was raised on behalf of the accused, that the funds of the bharath insurance company in the chartered bank, bombay which were alleged to have been misappropriated, were not t1property within the meaning of ss. 405 and 409, i. P. C. Since t1propertyt1, would refer only to moveable property arid not to immovable property or to a chose in action. Rejecting the above contention, the supreme court held that the meaning of the word t1property in the indian penal code, cannot be restricted to moveable property alone and would include other kinds of property, depending upon the context in which it occurs. After quoting the following passage from an earlier decision of the same court in delhi cloth and general mills company ltd. V. Hernam singh on the character of money in a bank. That a debt is property is we think, clear, it is a chose in action and is heritable and assignable and it is treated as property in india under the transfer of property act, which calls it an actionable claim. The suprcme court finally held in dalmias case, that the expression funds in the charge means, the amounts credited to the bharath insurance company ltd. In the accounts of the bank and this was 'property' within the meaning of s. 405, i. P. C. The above decision is an authority for the proposition, that a bank balance which is a chose in action; is nevertheless property, with the reference to which offences against property found in chapter 17 of the indian penal code, could be committed.

    (10) The provisions of chapter 34 of the criminal procedure code, dealing with disposal of the property seized, wilt also have a bearing on the interpretation of the term 'property' in s. 102, cri. P. C. While 5. 457 of the code, deals with orders that could be passed with reference to property, during investigation and before the commencement of any trial or enquiry, 5. 451, cri. P. C. , deals with orders that could be passed for custody and disposal of property, pending trial or inquiry, and section 452, cri. P. C. With orders to be passed, after the conclusion of trial. The limited reimbursement to persons, who had purchased stolen property without knowing or having reason to believe that the same was stolen, is provided for, in 5. 453, cri. P. C. In that if any money was taken from the possession of the convicted person at the time of his arrest, the court could order, that out of such money , a sum not exceeding the price paid by such purchaser, be delivered to him. 5. 456 of criminal procedure code, provides for restoration of possession of immovable property to any person, who has been dispossessed, by commission of an offence, in which criminal force was used.

    (11) It would now be useful to refer to the object behind investing the police with powers of seizure. Seizure and production in court of any property, including those regarding which an offence appears to have been committed or which appears to have been used for the commission of any offence or any other property will have a two - fold effect. Production of the above property may be necessary as evidence of the commission of the crime. Seizure may also have to be necessary, in order to preserve the property, for the purpose of enabling the court, to pass suitable orders under s. 452 of the criminal procedure code at the conclusion of the trial. This order would include destruction of the property, confiscation of the property or delivery of the property to any person claiming to be entitled to possession thereto. It cannot be contended that the concept of restitution of property to the victim of a crime, is totally alien to the criminal procedure code. No doubt, the primary, object of prosecution ispunitve, however, criminal procedure code, does contain several provisions, which seek to re - imbrues or compensate victims of crime, or bring about restoration of property or its restitution as 5. 452, cri. P. C. , itself indicates, one of the modes of disposing property at the conclusion of the, trial, is ordering their return to the person entitled to possession thereto. Even interim custody of property under ss. 451 and 457, cr. P. C. , recognises the rights of the person entitled to the possession of the properties. An innocent purchaser for value is sought to be reimbursed by s. 453, cri. P. C. Restoration of immovable property under certain circumstances - s dealt with under 5. 456, cri. P. C. Even, monetary compensation to victims of crime or any bona fide purchaser of property, is provided for under 5. 357. Cri. P. C. Wherein when a court while convicting the accused imposes fine the whole or any part of the fine, if recovered, may be ordered to be paid as compensation to any person, for any loss or injury, caused by the offence or to any bona fide purchaser of any property after the property is restored to the possession of the person entitled thereto. This two - fold object of investing the police with the powers of seizure, have to be borne in mind, while setting these legal issues.

    (12) Reference can now be made, to some of the decisions relied upon by the learned counsel for the second respondent. In prafulla kumar deb v suresh chandra deb3, wherein, on a complaint for an offence under ss. 420 and 406, i. P. C. , on the allegation, that the accused received from the complainant a sum of rs. 7025 on a promise that he would pay him half the profits of a contract which he had obtained, and when contrary to the promise, the accused got payments from the p. W. D. And did not pay the amount to the complainant and had therefore, committed the offence under ss. 406 and. 420, i. P. C. , and the trial court, by an order directed the executive engineer, p. W. D. To stop payment of pending bills to the accused, to the extent of rs. 7,025 the high court struck down the above order on the groun4, that the order was in the nature of an attachment before judgment and in a criminal case the accused was presumed to be innocent till he was adjudged guilty. The above facts, have no analogy to the present case.

    (13) In re lloyda bank umited,4 a division bench of the bombay high court, quashed the order passed by the trial court issuing a search warrant and recovering rs. 4000 from the bank on a complaint alleging that the accused had stolen a bank cheque, forged the signature of the complainant and had withdrawn rs. 6,000 and had deposited rs. 5000 in the savings bank account of the bank. Here again the court found that the money was no part of the proceeds of the offence and had no real connection with the subject matter of the charge. No doubt, the court has also observed, that the accused had a credit for rs. 4,000 an actionable claim for that amount, and that claim could be proved, but it could not be produced in court.

    (14) Similarly, in makkan lal chatterjee v. Emperor, a division bench of the calcutta high court, set aside a stop - order served by the magistrate on the bank, to prevent the accused from operating on the account, on the ground that there was nothing to show that the money in the bank, was partf the proceeds of the cheating or breach of trust and also because the relationship of a banker and a customer, is that of a debtor and the creditor and the magistrate therefore could not pass such an order.

    (15) The principle that the relationship between a banker and a customer is that of a debtor and a creditor has been reiterated by a single judge of this court in k. P. Menon and another v. Punithavathi manian. The learned judge has referred to several other decisions, which bring out the above principle.

    (16) In attorney general of canada v. Quebec province, the privy council held, that money deposited with the bank is not trust money, on the contrary, it is money that is lent for use to the bank, and the only obligation under which the bank lies, is to repay a like sum in the like currency.

    (17) In view of the decision of the supreme court, in r. K. Dalmia and others v. Delhi administration, already discussed above, the ruling relied on by the learned counsel for the second respondent, would have little or no bearing on the issue.

    (18) A division bench of the punjab and haryana high court in dr. Gurcharan singh v. The state of punjab, upheld the prohibitory order issued by the superintendent of police, vigilance, investigating into an offence under s. 5 (1) (e) of the prevention of corruption act, 1947, prohibiting the accused from operating his account in a bank and freezing his fixed deposit amount in another bank, holding that money in a bank account is property capable of being seized under. 5. 102, cri. P. C. This, i feel, reflects the correct position of law.

    (19) In modern days, where commission of white collar crimes and bank frauds, are very much on the increase and banking facilities, have been extended to the remotest rural areas, interpreting the term property in 5. 102, cri. P. C. In a way, as to exclude money in a bank, would have the effect of placing legal hurdles, in the process of investigation into these crimes, which could never have been the intent of the framers of the criminal procedure code. In view of the wide meaning given to the term property in 5. 4:2 (5) , cri. P. C. As including, in the case of property regarding which an offence appears to have committed, not only such property as was originally in the possession, but also any property into which it might have been converted or exchanged and also anything acquired by such conversion or exchange, whether immediately or otherwise, to put too narrow a construction on the term property occurring in s. 102 cri. P. C. Would be against the very spirit of the criminal procedure code.

    (20) Expanding the ratio of r. K. Dalmias case8 and reading it in the light of 5. 2 (y) , and the provision of chapter xxxiv of the cri. P. C. , i feel no difficulty in holding that money in an account in a bank, is property for the purpose of 5. 102, cri. P. C.

    (21) The next consideration would be whether such a bank balance, is capable of being seized by the investigating officer. The only act of ownership, which the customer of the bank exercises over his bank balance is operating the amount, either by making deposits or by withdrawing the same, in any mode made available to him by the bank. When corporeal tangible property is seized by taking physical possession and producing it in court, the seizure is intended to have the effect, of preventing the person from whom it is seized, from exercising any acts of ownership or possession over that property. The property, therefore, is physically removed from his possession and is produced before the court. The court takes possession of the property and thus prevents the person, from exercising acts of ownership or possession over them. The only way, in which such an effect can be brought about, regarding bank balance, is to issue a prohibitory order, restraining the customer from operating his account in the bank, either by remittance or by withdrawal. This act of preventing the customer from exercising any right over the bank balance constitutes seizure of the bank balance, which in ordinary parlance is described as freezing. The consequences that flow from freezing a bank balance, following a prohibitory order, are the same, as those that flow from the physical removal of any moveable property, following a seizure.

    (22) It therefore follows that money in an account in a bank is property within the meaning of s. 102, cri. P. C. , which could be seized by prohibiting the holder of the account, from operating it.

    (23) The learned counsel for the first respondent also contended that the seizure of the bank balance by the second respondent is illegal, since the latter has not reported about the seizure to the court, as required under s. 102 (3) , cri. P. C. Not every blow in investigation would invalidate proceedings. It would be premature now, to judge prejudice caused to the accused. If the second respondent has not reported about the seizure to the court yet, he shall do the same forthwith. In the event of a trial, it would be open to the accused to put forward this plea of prejudice in the light of the facts available.

    (24) In the result the orders passed by the learned magistrate in m. P. 184 of 1987 and m. P. No. 208 of 1987 are set aside. The petitions are ordered accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bharath Overseas Bank v. Minu Publication
    (Feb 9, 1988)