Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • SECTION 16 RESTRICTION OF HABITUAL OFFENDERS PUNJAB ACT 1918
  • Sections 109 and 110 of the Code, Clause (c) of Sub-Rule (3) of Rule 23.4 of the 1934 Rules
  • SECTION 16 RESTRICTION OF HABITUAL OFFENDERS PUNJAB ACT 1918
  • Section 110 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (in short "the Code")
  • Section 307 IPC Police Station Civil Lines, Patiala. (2)
  • Punjab Police Rules, 1934 (in short "the 1934 Rules")
  • Section 109 or 110, Code of Criminal Procedure; (d)
  • Sub-Rule (3) of Rule 23.4 of the 1934 rules
  • Section 87, Code of Criminal Procedure. (b)
  • Rules 23.4 and 23.5 of the 1934 Rules
  • SECTION 401 CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE
  • Rule 23.4(2)(a) to (d) of the 1934 Rules
  • Section 565, Criminal Procedure Code,
  • Sections 457/380 IPC. Police Station
  • Rule 23.4(3)(b) of the 1934 Rules.
  • Rule 23.4 of the 1934 Rules
  • clause (b) of sub-rule (3)
  • Rule 27.29; (b) persons
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • SECTION 16 RESTRICTION OF HABITUAL OFFENDERS PUNJAB ACT 1918
  • Sections 109 and 110 of the Code, Clause (c) of Sub-Rule (3) of Rule 23.4 of the 1934 Rules
  • SECTION 16 RESTRICTION OF HABITUAL OFFENDERS PUNJAB ACT 1918
  • Section 110 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (in short "the Code")
  • Section 307 IPC Police Station Civil Lines, Patiala. (2)
  • Punjab Police Rules, 1934 (in short "the 1934 Rules")
  • Section 109 or 110, Code of Criminal Procedure; (d)
  • Sub-Rule (3) of Rule 23.4 of the 1934 rules
  • Section 87, Code of Criminal Procedure. (b)
  • Rules 23.4 and 23.5 of the 1934 Rules
  • SECTION 401 CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE
  • Rule 23.4(2)(a) to (d) of the 1934 Rules
  • Section 565, Criminal Procedure Code,
  • Sections 457/380 IPC. Police Station
  • Rule 23.4(3)(b) of the 1934 Rules.
  • Rule 23.4 of the 1934 Rules
  • clause (b) of sub-rule (3)
  • Rule 27.29; (b) persons
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, Musa Khan, sought a direction to the respondent police to delete his name from Surveillance Register No. 10 maintained at Police Station Kotwali, Patiala (under the Punjab Police Rules, 1934), and to direct removal of his name and photograph from the police station notice board on the ground that such display amounted to interference with his life and liberty.

The petition recounts that Musa Khan had been a weightlifter in 1989-90, is presently a property dealer and contractor, and pays income tax since 1996-97. He alleges police harassment: an application under Section 110 CrPC by an earlier Station House Officer was dismissed on 20.3.2001; a later Station House Officer, Inspector Didar Singh, repeatedly required him to attend the police station, displayed his name and photograph on the notice board labelling him a habitual offender, and demanded Rs. 10,000 for removing the display. The petitioner also alleged that entries required by Rule 23.4 of the 1934 Rules had not been complied with (no conviction or other preconditions).

The petitioner earlier moved Civil Writ Petition No. 4340 of 2003, which was disposed of by a Division Bench with a direction to make a representation to the Senior Superintendent of Police, Patiala. The representation was rejected by the Senior Superintendent's office, which produced a list of cases registered against the petitioner (Annexure P-13). The petitioner maintained he had been acquitted in those matters and that no material justified retention of his name.

The State filed an affidavit (by the Deputy Superintendent of Police, City-I, Patiala) acknowledging the earlier court direction, asserting that 15 cases had been registered (with acquittals by compromise in many), and listing three more recent FIRs (one FIR where the petitioner was declared innocent, one sent up as untraced, and one pending). The State contended, on the basis of this record, that retention of the name in the Surveillance Register was justified.

The writ petition was heard and disposed of by the Court with directions detailed below.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner’s name should be deleted from Surveillance Register No. 10 maintained at the relevant police station under the Punjab Police Rules, 1934.
  2. Whether the action of the Station House Officer in displaying the petitioner’s name and photograph on the police station notice board as a “habitual offender” amounted to interference with the petitioner’s life and liberty (implicating Articles 19 and 21 of the Constitution).
  3. Whether there was lawful authority (under Rule 23.4/23.5 of the 1934 Rules and related statutory provisions) to include the petitioner’s name in Part I or Part II of Surveillance Register No. 10.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner alleged that his name and photograph were displayed on the police station notice board labelling him a habitual offender though the preconditions for such treatment (as set out in Rule 23.4 of the 1934 Rules) were absent.
  • He pointed to an earlier application under Section 110 CrPC that was dismissed (Sub-Divisional Magistrate order dated 20.3.2001), arguing that this showed there was no lawful basis for treating him as requiring surveillance or security.
  • The petitioner asserted that in the list produced (Annexure P-13, described by him as 14 cases), he had been acquitted in all listed cases and that he had not been involved in crime for more than five years, thus there was no material to justify retention of his name in the Surveillance Register.
  • He alleged extortion/harassment by Inspector Didar Singh who demanded Rs. 10,000 for removal of the photograph and name from the notice board.

State's Arguments

  • The responding affidavit (Deputy Superintendent of Police, City-I, Patiala) acknowledged compliance with the Division Bench's direction and stated that 15 cases had been registered against the petitioner, many ending in acquittal by compromise.
  • The State admitted that a calendra (proceeding) under Section 110 CrPC was presented and dismissed, but argued on the basis of the overall record and the registered FIRs that a case was made out to retain the petitioner’s name in the Surveillance Register.
  • The State specifically listed three FIRs registered against the petitioner (FIR No. 629/14.12.2000 under Section 307 IPC; FIR No. 408/19.10.2002 under Sections 457/380 IPC; FIR No. 399/31.10.2003 under Sections 323/149 IPC), noting varied outcomes (one declared innocent, one untraced, one pending) and contending these facts justified retention in the register.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded from the statutory and rule framework governing Surveillance Register No. 10 under Chapter XXIII of the Punjab Police Rules, 1934, specifically Rules 23.4 and 23.5. The Court considered the textual requirements of these provisions and then applied them to the factual record before it.

Key steps in the Court's reasoning:

  1. The Court noted that Rule 23.4 prescribes the classes of persons whose names may be entered in Part I and Part II of Surveillance Register No. X. Part I is for specified classes (e.g., persons proclaimed under Section 87 CrPC, released convicts under Section 565 CrPC, convicts with conditional remission under Section 401 CrPC, persons restricted under Section 16 of the Restriction of Habitual Offenders (Punjab) Act, 1918). Part II permits certain discretionary entries but only in tightly defined circumstances (for example, repeated convictions under certain rules, persons reasonably believed to be habitual offenders, persons under security under Sections 109 or 110 CrPC, or certain prematurely released convicts).
  2. Applying these rules, the Court observed that the State did not assert that any of the Part I conditions (Rule 23.4(2)(a)–(d)) were satisfied in the petitioner’s case: there was no proclamation under Section 87 CrPC, no order under Section 565 CrPC, no conditional remission under Section 401 CrPC, and no restriction order under Section 16 of the 1918 Act.
  3. The Court further examined Sub‑Rule (3) (Part II) and concluded that the petitioner did not fall within its subclauses: there was no record of any convictions (subclause (a)), no recorded order under subclause (b) that the Superintendent had formed the requisite belief that the person was a habitual offender, no security proceedings under Sections 109/110 CrPC (subclause (c)), and nothing to suggest release before sentence expiration under subclause (d).
  4. The Court emphasized the procedural safeguards in Rule 23.5, including the requirement that entries in Part II be made only by order of the Superintendent (who cannot delegate that authority) and that Part I entries be made only by order of a gazetted officer. The Court noted that the State had not produced any order of the Superintendent authorizing inclusion of the petitioner’s name under Rule 23.4(3)(b).
  5. Given the absence of the statutory preconditions for entry and the absence of any Superintendent's order, the Court concluded that retention of the petitioner’s name in the Surveillance Register was unjustified.
  6. The Court also considered fundamental rights, explicitly stating that the act of respondent No. 3 (displaying the petitioner’s name and photograph) transgressed Articles 19 and 21 of the Constitution of India, and that the inaction of respondent No. 2 in relation to the petitioner’s representation could not be condoned.

The Court therefore applied the textual requirements of the Rules and the absence of supporting material from the State to reach the conclusion that there was no lawful basis for inclusion or continued retention of the petitioner’s name in Register No. 10 or for public display of his photograph and fine at the police station.

Holding and Implications

PETITION ALLOWED

Holding (core ruling):

  • The Court accepted the petition and directed the State to remove the petitioner’s name from Surveillance Register No. 10 because, on the material before the Court, there was no basis to include his name in either Part I or Part II of the register.
  • The Court also directed removal of the petitioner’s photograph and the amount of fine shown on the police station notice board in relation to the petitioner.

Immediate consequences and directions ordered by the Court:

  • The State must ensure deletion of the petitioner’s name from Register No. 10 and removal of the photograph and fine from the police station notice board.
  • A copy of the judgment is to be sent to the Director Generals of Police for Punjab and Haryana and the Inspector General of Police, Union Territory, Chandigarh. They were directed to forward the judgment to District Police Chiefs with instructions to re-examine the Surveillance Registers maintained in police stations of their districts and to bring them into conformity with the observations in the judgment.
  • The Court hoped this process would be completed within two months.

Broader implications: The Court’s directions require administrative re-examination of Surveillance Registers across districts to ensure compliance with the procedural and substantive constraints in Rules 23.4 and 23.5. The opinion, as provided, does not state that it is laying down any precedent beyond its application of the statutory rules to the facts of this case; it issues specific corrective and supervisory directions to the police administration.

Disposition: Petition allowed.

    Musa Khan v. State Of Punjab And Others

    Amar Dutt, J. - Musa Khan has filed this petition for issuance of a direction to the respondent to delete his name from Register No. 10 maintained by the Police Station Kotwali, Patiala under the Punjab Police Rules, 1934 (in short "the 1934 Rules") as also to issue a direction that the action of the Station House Officer of the aforesaid Police Station displaying his name and photograph on the notice board of the Police Station amounts to interference with the life and liberty of the petitioner.

    2. The relevant facts pleaded for decision of the petition are that Musa Khan had participated in the National Weightlifting Championships in the year 1989-90 and secured first place in those Junior Inter State Weightlifting Championships and was declared best weightlifter of the Union Territory of Chandigarh (wrongly mentioned as Chandigarh State). He is presently running a business of property dealer at Uday Street, Adalat Bazar, Patiala and is also having contractorship of Cycle Stands in Civil Secretariat, Patiala. He claims that he is paying income tax since 1996-97. According to him, Inspector Varinder Singh, Station House Officer, Police Station Sadar, Patiala had on 21.12.2000 moved an application under Section 110 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (in short "the Code") before the Sub Divisional Magistrate, Patiala praying that the petitioner be asked to execute a security bond for good behaviour. This application was dismissed on 20.3.2001. According to the petitioner, the order of Sub Divisional Magistrate, Patiala indicates that the police was harassing the petitioner in one way or the other. Inspector Varinder Singh was replaced by Inspector Didar Singh, who took charge of Police Station, Sadar, Patiala in January, 2003 and started requiring the petitioner to come to Police Station time and again. The petitioner had apprised him about the outcome of the calendra under section 107 of the code on account whereof the Inspector made it his prestige issue to harass and implicate the petitioner. To achieve his purpose, the Inspector evolved a novel idea and put the name and photograph of the petitioner on the notice board of the Police Station Sadar, Patiala indicating that he was habitual offender. When the petitioner came to know of this fact he asked the Inspector to remove his name and the photograph. Inspector Didar Singh had required the petitioner to pay a sum of Rs. 10,000/- for removing the same. On the basis of these assertions, Musa Khan submits that Inspector Didar Singh is out to harass him for obvious reasons.

    3. It is in this background that the petitioner apprehended that his name must have been entered in a Surveillance Register maintained under Rule 23.4 of the 1934 Rules for displaying the name of a person on the notice board as a habitual offender requires (a) that his name must have been entered in the Surveillance Register No. 10 as per Rule 23.4, and (b) he must have been convicted in the cases registered against him and none of these conditions are available in the case of the petitioner. Aggrieved by these actions of the Patiala Police, Musa Khan had approached this court through Civil Writ Petition No. 4340 of 2003 and the same was disposed of by a Division Bench of this Court directing the petitioner to move a representation before the Senior Superintendent of Police, Patiala pointing out his grievances whereafter the Senior Superintendent of Police, Patiala was directed to decide the representation expeditiously in accordance with law.

    4. The representation, which was moved, was rejected by the office of the Senior Superintendent of Police, Patiala by mentioning a list of 14 cases which had been registered against the petitioner. Musa Khan submits that for the last more five years, he has not been involved in any crime and in all the cases, which have been mentioned in the list, Annexure P-13, he has been acquitted. He also asserts that request of the police to initiate proceedings under section 110 of the code had been rejected and, therefore, a case was made out for removal of the name of the petitioner from Register No. 10 and prayed that the requisite directions be issued.

    5. The response of the State to the averments contained in the petition is available in the affidavit of Shri Bhupinder Singh, Deputy Superintendent of Police City-I, Patiala. In the reply, the respondents admit the issuance of direction in Civil Writ Petition No. 4340 of 2003 and submit that 15 cases were registered against the petitioner in which he has been acquitted due to a compromise. It was admitted that calendra under section 110 of the code was presented and their request had been dismissed. It was submitted that it was on the basis of this record that the representation made by the petitioner had been rejected by the Deputy Superintendent of Police, City-I, Patiala. The assertion that in the last five years, no case has been registered against the petitioner was denied and it was mentioned that following three cases have been registered against the petitioner :-

    (1) FIR No. 629 dated 14.12.2000 under Section 307 IPC Police Station Civil Lines, Patiala.

    (2) FIR No. 408 dated 19.10.2002 under Sections 457/380 IPC. Police Station Kotwali, Patiala.

    (3) FIR No. 399 dated 31.10.2003 under Sections 323/149/149 IPC Police Station Kotwali, Patiala.

    Although it was also admitted that in first case the petitioner had been declared innocent, the second case has been sent up as untraced while third case is still pending, in view of the details given in the petition about the criminal propensities of the petitioner it was asserted that a case was made out to warrant retention of the name of Musa Khan in Surveillance Register No. 10 and, therefore, the writ should be dismissed.

    6. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.

    7. It is the admitted case of the parties that the maintenance of the Surveillance Register No. 10 is warranted by the provisions of Chapter XXIII of the 1934 Rules. These spell out what was required to be done by the members of the Police Force for ensuring the prevention of offences. Rules 23.4 and 23.5 of the 1934 Rules read as under :-

    "23.4 Surveillance Register No. X. - (1) In every police station, other than those of the railway police, a Surveillance Register shall be maintained in form 232.4(1).

    (2) In part I of such register shall be entered the names of persons commonly resident within or commonly frequenting the local jurisdiction of the police station concerned, who belong to one or more of the following classes :-

    (a) All persons who have been proclaimed under Section 87, Code of Criminal Procedure.

    (b) All released convicts in regard to whom an order under Section 565, Criminal Procedure Code, has been made.

    (c) All convicts the execution of whose sentence is suspended in the whole, or any part of whose punishment has been remitted conditionally under Section 401, Criminal Procedure Code.

    (d) All persons restricted under Rules of Government made under Section 16 of the Restriction of Habitual Offenders (Punjab) Act, 1918.

    (3) In Part II of such register may be entered at the discretion of the Superintendent -

    (a) persons who have been convicted twice, or more than twice, of offences mentioned in Rule 27.29;

    (b) persons who are reasonably believed to be habitual offenders or receivers of stole property whether they have been convicted or not;

    (c) persons under security under Section 109 or 110, Code of Criminal Procedure;

    (d) convicts released before the expiration of their sentences under the prisons act and remission rules without the imposition of any conditions

    Note. - This must be strictly construed, and entries must be confined to the names of persons falling in the four classes named therein.

    23.5(1) The Surveillance Register shall be written up by the officer in charge of the police station personally or by an Assistant Sub-Inspector in a clear and neat script. No entry shall be made in Part II except by the order of the Superintendent, who is strictly prohibited from delegating this authority. No entry shall be made in part I except by the order of a gazetted officer. Entries shall be made either under the personal direction of, or on receipt of a written order from an officer authorised by this rule to make them. In the latter case original orders shall be attached to the register until the entry has been attested and dated by a gazetted officer.

    (2) Ordinarily, before the name of any person is entered in Part II of the Surveillance Register a history sheet shall be opened for such person. If, from the entries in the history sheet, the Superintendent is of opinion that such person should be subjected to Surveillance he shall enter his name in Part II of the Surveillance Register, provided that the names of persons who have never been convicted or placed on security for good behaviour shall not be entered until the Superintendent has recorded definite reasons for doing so.

    The record of such reasons shall be treated as confidential and the person concerned shall not be entitled to a copy thereof."

    8. Rule 23.4 of the 1934 Rules gives the details of how names of the persons commonly resident within or commonly frequenting the local jurisdiction of the police station concerned would be incorporated in Part I of Surveillance Register No. X Part II thereof spells out the details of the persons whose names may be entered in the register at the discretion of the Superintendent of Police. A perusal of the aforesaid Rule makes it clear that the same specifies the type of persons, whose names can be entered in the Surveillance Register. The case of the petitioner, in our opinion, does not fall within Rule 23.4(2)(a) to (d) of the 1934 Rules as it is not the case of the State that the petitioner has been declared a proclaimed offender under section 87 of the code or that after his conviction any order under section 565 of the code has been made or the sentence imposed upon him in any of the trial has been remitted conditionally under section 401 of the code or that any order under Section 16 of the Restriction of Habitual Offenders (Punjab) Act, 1918 (in short "the 1918 Act") had been passed. A perusal of Sub-Rule (3) of Rule 23.4 of the 1934 Rules shows that the case of the petitioner does not fall under any of the sub-clauses as admittedly there is no conviction recorded against him nor is there any order under clause (b) of sub-rule (3) for recording the belief of the competent authority that he is habitual offender or receiver of stolen property. Since there is no assertion regarding any security proceedings initiated against the petitioner under Sections 109 and 110 of the Code, Clause (c) of Sub-Rule (3) of Rule 23.4 of the 1934 Rules would also not cover the case of the petitioner nor it would fall in clause (d) thereof because there is nothing on the record to show that he has been released before the expiration of his sentence under the prisons act and remission rules without the imposition of any conditions. The proceedings initiated against the petitioner under the 1918 Act were unsuccessful and, therefore, in the case of the petitioner, no material has been produced before us which could justify the retention of his name in the Surveillance Register.

    9. The State has also not made available for perusal of this Court any order of the Superintendent of Police to warrant the inclusion of the name of the petitioner under Rule 23.4(3)(b) of the 1934 Rules.

    10. Looked at from any angle, the retention of the name of the petitioner in the Surveillance Register cannot be justified and as the act of respondent No. 3, transgresses the fundamental rights as enshrined under Articles 19 and 21 of the Constitution of India, there is no warrant for condoning the same as also the inaction of respondent No. 2 on the representation of the petitioner.

    11. For the reasons recorded above, we accept the petition and direct the State to ensure that the name of the petitioner is removed from Register No. 10 as till date, there is no material, which would warrant the inclusion of his name in either Part I or Part II of the aforesaid register. As name of the petitioner cannot be included in Register No. 10, therefore, a direction is also issued to the State to ensure that the photograph and amount of fine that had been imposed upon the petitioner be removed from the notice board of the police station.

    12. Before parting with the judgment, we direct that a copy of the same be sent to the Director Generals of Police, Punjab and Haryana and Inspector General of Police, Union of Territory, Chandigarh, who in turn would forward the same to the District Police Chiefs with a direction to re-examine the Surveillance Registers maintained in the Police Stations of their districts and to bring in conformity with the observations contained in this judgment. The process, it is hoped, would be completed within two months.

    Petition allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Musa Khan v. State Of Punjab And Others
    (Dec 15, 2004)