Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from a suit instituted by a pleader practising in Habiganj (the Plaintiff) for damages for malicious prosecution and defamation. In an earlier civil suit in which one Bholanath was a defendant, the Plaintiff filed a written statement with a vakalatnama dated (and shown as accepted on) 7 February 1923; the written statement and vakalatnama were filed on 16 February 1923. On 28 February 1923 the Plaintiff reported to the Court that his client Bholanath had died.

In May 1923 the Defendant in the present suit applied to the Munsif for sanction under section 195 of the Criminal Procedure Code to prosecute the Plaintiff, the Plaintiff's clerk and two other persons, alleging that the signatures of Bholanath on the written statement and the vakalatnama were forgeries because Bholanath had died on 3 February 1923. The application was registered as a miscellaneous case and the Plaintiff was directed to show cause.

On 9 June 1923 the Plaintiff produced certain papers from the Criminal Court purporting to show that Bholanath was alive on 7 February 1923. Subsequent hearing dates include 30 June 1923 (application for time to summon witnesses by the Defendant), 21 July 1923 and 4 August 1923 (applications for time to file certified copy of the death register). The latter application was rejected and the miscellaneous case was dismissed.

Thereafter the Plaintiff instituted the present suit claiming damages for malicious prosecution and defamation. One defence point was that the defamation claim was not maintainable; a preliminary issue was framed and the Munsif held that the Plaintiff was not entitled to recover damages for defamation. The same Munsif later decreed the Plaintiff's malicious prosecution suit for Rs. 250 with costs. On appeal the Subordinate Judge confirmed the decree, and the Defendant prosecuted a second appeal to the Court whose judgment is summarized here.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the making of an application to a Munsif for sanction under section 195, Criminal Procedure Code, in respect of alleged forgery (i.e., an application for sanction to prosecute) constitutes a "prosecution" sufficient to give rise to a civil action for malicious prosecution.
  2. Whether, on the facts found by the trial and appellate courts, the Defendant acted without reasonable and probable cause and with malice (including the question whether continuation of proceedings after knowledge of exculpatory facts can render an otherwise bona fide prosecution malicious).
  3. Whether the Plaintiff's separate claim for damages for defamation was maintainable (this issue had been decided at the preliminary stage by the Munsif in the Plaintiff's disfavor).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (Defendant)

  • The principal point argued on behalf of the Appellant was that there was no "prosecution" within the legal meaning required to sustain a claim for malicious prosecution — specifically, that a mere application for sanction to prosecute is not a prosecution.
  • It was also argued (in reliance on a finding in an earlier judgment by the Munsif on the defamation issue) that the Defendant had no ground for believing the information he received (that Bholanath had died on 3 February 1923) was false; on that assumption the Appellant contended there could be no finding that the action taken by him was without reasonable and probable cause.

Respondent's/ Plaintiff's Position (as reflected in the record)

  • The Plaintiff produced Criminal Court papers on 9 June 1923 showing that Bholanath was alive on 7 February 1923, undermining the Defendant's allegation of forgery.
  • The Plaintiff's pleading and evidence alleged that the Defendant maliciously and without reasonable and probable cause sought sanction to prosecute and thereby obliged the Plaintiff to defend the sanction proceedings; this claim formed the basis of the suit for malicious prosecution.
  • Evidence before the courts (as summarized by the lower courts and accepted on appeal) showed that the Defendant persisted in pressing for sanction and took steps (applications for time to summon witnesses and to file a death register) after the Plaintiff had placed exculpatory Criminal Court papers on record, supporting the Plaintiff's contention of malicious continuation of proceedings.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Golap Jan v. Bholanath Khetri Held that dismissal of a complaint under section 203, Cr.P.C. does not give rise to a right to claim compensation for malicious prosecution. Cited as an authoritative view that a mere dismissal or preliminary dismissal does not automatically create a cause of action for malicious prosecution; used to introduce the authorities on when prosecution is deemed to commence.
DeRozario v. Gulab Chand Anandajee Supportive opinion aligning with the view that mere filing of a petition which leads to no action may not constitute a prosecution actionable in malicious prosecution. Referenced as supporting authority among cases that find a mere petition or application without subsequent prosecutorial action need not constitute a prosecution.
Yates v. The Queen Observation (by Brett, M.R. and Cotton, L.J.) that laying information before a Magistrate may not commence a prosecution until a summons or warrant is issued. Quoted to show an English judicial view that prosecution ordinarily begins with the issuing of process (summons or warrant), illustrating divergence in authority about when a prosecution is said to commence.
W.H. Nurse v. Rustomji Dorabji Madras decision adopting a view similar to Yates that prosecution does not commence until process is issued. Cited as an instance of consistent authority taking the view that prosecution begins with active judicial process rather than mere laying of information.
C.H. Crowdy v. O'Reilly Authority (as cited) holding that a prosecution for the purposes of malicious prosecution begins as soon as information is laid before the Magistrate. Placed among authorities representing the contrary view (that laying information itself may constitute commencement); the Court noted varying authorities on the point.
Bishun Prasad v. Phulman Singh Expressly lays down that a prosecution for malicious prosecution begins when information is laid before a Magistrate. Used to illustrate that some decisions treat the laying of information as commencement of prosecution—part of the authorities surveyed in reaching a conclusion on the meaning of "prosecution."
Ahmadbhai v. Framji Edulji Expresses the same view (as Crowdy/Bishun Prasad) regarding commencement upon laying information. Cited among cases showing divergent positions on the commencement of prosecution.
Rayan v. South London Tramways Company Considered the meaning of "criminal charge" and whether fare-evading proceedings were criminal; used to explain the use of the term "criminal charge" in defining prosecution. Quoted to support the careful use of the expression "criminal charge" when defining "prosecution" and to show that some proceedings, though regulatory, may fall within the term.
Quartz Hill Gold Mining Company v. Eyre Defines "criminal charge" to include all indictments involving reputation or possible loss of property; supports that civil actions may sometimes be subject of malicious prosecution suit. Relied on to show that the concept of prosecution can extend beyond strict criminal proceedings and may include actions affecting reputation or property; used to support the proposition that sanction proceedings could ground a malicious prosecution action.
Balbhadra Singh v. Badri Shah Holds that giving information to authorities which naturally leads to prosecution is equivalent to setting the law in motion; prosecution need not be private for action to lie. Used to support the broader definition that informing a judicial tribunal which has the power to take criminal action can constitute prosecution for purposes of malicious prosecution.
Narendra Nath De v. Jyotis Chandra Pal Holds that allegations that a defendant maliciously instituted proceedings for sanction (and thereby obliged the plaintiff to defend) can be sufficient to disclose a cause of action for malicious prosecution. Cited as a recent decision of the same Court supporting the proposition that an application for sanction to prosecute may be actionable and that sanction proceedings can give rise to malicious prosecution claims.
Shama Bibi v. Chairman of Baranagore Municipality Adopted the view that a prosecution may become malicious if continued after the prosecutor acquires knowledge of the accused's innocence. Cited as a domestic authority consistent with the proposition (from Fitzjohn v. Mackinder) that continuation of proceedings after knowledge of innocence may render prosecution malicious.
Fitzjohn v. Mackinder Dictum (Cockburn, C.J.) that a prosecution which began bona fide may become malicious if the prosecutor, having acquired positive knowledge of the accused's innocence, perseveres in prosecution with bad intent. Relied upon as the doctrinal foundation for concluding that continuation of proceedings after awareness of exculpatory facts can convert an otherwise bona fide prosecution into a malicious one.
Municipality of Jambusar v. Girija Sankar Narsiram Adopted the view that a prosecution may become malicious upon continued prosecution after knowledge of the accused's innocence. Cited in support of the proposition that continuation of proceedings after awareness of exculpatory facts can constitute malicious prosecution.
Gay a Prasad v. Bhagat Singh Judicial Committee authority referenced for the same doctrine regarding continuation of prosecution becoming malicious. Used among authorities to support the court's view that continuation after knowledge may render prosecution malicious.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in two principal analytical stages corresponding to the main contentions on appeal.

  1. Meaning of "Prosecution" and whether application for sanction under s.195 Cr.P.C. constitutes a prosecution:

    The Court noted divergence in authority on whether mere filing of a petition or laying information before a magistrate amounts to the commencement of a prosecution actionable in malicious prosecution suits. It surveyed English and Indian authorities, including decisions that support both narrower and broader definitions of "prosecution."

    The Court relied on definitions from Halsbury's Laws of England and cited Rayan v. South London Tramways Co. and Quartz Hill Gold Mining Co. v. Eyre to emphasize that "prosecution" may include charges before any judicial officer or tribunal capable of inflicting criminal consequences. The Court observed that an application to the Munsif under section 195 moved a judicial tribunal to consider whether sanction should be granted; had sanction been granted the Plaintiff would have been liable to prosecution.

    Taking a purposive view, and having regard to a recent decision of the same Court (Narendra Nath De v. Jyotis Chandra Pal) which held that allegations of maliciously instituting sanction proceedings may disclose a cause of action, the Court concluded that proceedings for sanction before the Munsif fall within the ambit of what can amount to a "prosecution" for malicious prosecution purposes. The Court also noted that even if those proceedings were regarded as civil in form, they could still sustain an action for malicious prosecution insofar as they involved imputations affecting the Plaintiff's professional reputation.

    On that basis the Court overruled the Appellant's first objection that no prosecution occurred.

  2. Findings on reasonable and probable cause and malice (continuation after knowledge):

    The Appellant relied on an earlier observation by the Munsif in the defamation issue stage that the Defendant had no ground for believing the information he received was false. The Court distinguished that observation from the findings reached by the same Munsif when trying the malicious prosecution claim: the Munsif expressly found that the Defendant was not actuated by honest belief in making the application for sanction and that, even if initially honest, his subsequent conduct amounted to malicious continuance of the prosecution after he became aware of the true facts.

    The Court recited the evidence supporting that conclusion: the Plaintiff produced Criminal Court papers on 9 June 1923 showing Bholanath alive on 7 February 1923; despite those papers the Defendant sought time on 30 June to summon witnesses and on later dates to file a death register, indicating intent to press the application. The Defendant did not prove that his case in the sanction matter was correct and, in his deposition, admitted lack of knowledge implicating the pleader and admitted becoming aware from the criminal papers that the information of death was not true.

    Invoking Fitzjohn v. Mackinder and subsequent authorities, the Court underlined the well-established principle that a prosecution begun bona fide may become malicious if the prosecutor, having acquired positive knowledge of the accused's innocence, persists in the prosecution with malicious intent. The lower courts' findings — that the Defendant continued to press the sanction application despite exculpatory material and that he displayed malice (including boasting that he had "caught the pleader in a trap") — were treated as findings of fact supported by the record and therefore not open to reversal in second appeal.

    Accordingly, the Court held that the findings of lack of reasonable and probable cause and malice were supported by evidence and were properly made by the courts below.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The appeal is dismissed with costs. The courts below correctly concluded that the Defendant's application for sanction under section 195, Cr.P.C. could give rise to an action for malicious prosecution and that, on the facts, the Defendant acted without reasonable and probable cause and with malice (including continuation of the prosecution after knowledge of exculpatory facts). The decree for Rs. 250 with costs in favour of the Plaintiff was therefore affirmed.

Implications:

  • The direct legal consequence is that the decree in favour of the Plaintiff for Rs. 250 and costs stands confirmed by this Court and the Defendant's appeal fails.
  • The Court's reasoning adopts and applies existing authorities to hold that sanction proceedings before a judicial officer (here the Munsif under s.195 Cr.P.C.) may, in appropriate circumstances, constitute the basis for an action for malicious prosecution — particularly where the proceedings are pressed after exculpatory material is placed on record.
  • The opinion does not purport to lay down a novel or sweeping new rule beyond the application of surveyed authorities and the facts of the case; its effect, as decided, is the vindication of the Plaintiff's claim on the record facts rather than the announcement of an entirely new precedent.

Judge Garlick, J. concurred with the judgment.

    Robindra Nath Das v. Jogendra Chandra Deb .

    The Judgment of the Court was as follows:—

    Suhra Wardy, J.:— This appeal arises out of a suit for damages for malicious prosecution upon the following facts. In a previous suit in which one Bholanath was a Defendant, the Plaintiff who is a pleader practising in Habiganj in the District of Sylhet filed a written statement accompanied by a vakalatnama on the 16th February 1923 purported to have been signed by Bholanath and some other Defendants. The vakalatnama showed that it was accepted by the Plaintiff on the 7th February 1923 which was the date of the vakalatnama. On the 28th February 1923 the Plaintiff reported to the Court that his client Bholanath had died. In May 1923 the Defendant applied to the Munsif for sanction under sec. 195 of the Criminal Procedure Code to prosecute the Plaintiff, his clerk and Defendants Nos. 30 and 33 on the allegation that the signatures of Bholanath on the written statement and the vakalatnama were forgeries since he had died on the 3rd of February 1923. The application was registered as a miscellaneous case and the Plaintiff was directed to show cause. On the 9th June 1923—the date of the hearing of the case — the Plaintiff filed certain papers from the Criminal Court to show that Bholanath was alive on the 7th February 1923. On the next date of the hearing, that is the 30th June 1923, the Defendant applied for time to summon his witnesses. On the 21st July 1923 he again applied for time to file certified copy of the death register; and again on the 4th of August he applied for time for the same purpose but his application was rejected and the case dismissed. Thereafter the Plaintiff instituted the present suit for recovery of damages for malicious prosecution and defamation. One of the points of law raised by the defence was that the suit for damages for defamation was not maintainable. A preliminary issue was framed and the Munsif who heard it decided that the Plaintiff was not entitled to recover damages for defamation. The case was again finally heard by the same Munsif and the Plaintiff's suit was decreed for Rs. 250 with costs. On appeal by the Defendant the learned Subordinate Judge confirmed the decree and hence this second appeal by the Defendant.

    The first point raised by the learned Advocate on behalf of the Appellant is that there was no prosecution within the meaning of the law such as to give rise to the Plaintiff's claim for damages for malicious prosecution. It is argued that a mere application for, sanction to prosecute is not a prosecution. No authority has been cited in support of this proposition. But several cases have been placed before us in which it has been held that a mere filing of a petition in a Criminal Court for necessary action on which no action was taken or which was dismissed is not prosecution giving rise to the Plaintiff's claim for damages. The view expressed in the reported cases is not consistent on this point and so far as this Court is concerned, it was authoritatively laid down by Jenkins, C.J, in Golap Jan v. Bholanath Khetri (1) that dismissal of a complaint under sec. 203, Cr. P.C does not give rise to a right to claim compensation for malicious prosecution. This view is supported by the opinion expressed by Fletcher, J., in DeRozario v. Gulab Chand Anandajee (2) and by the English authorities and by most of the text writers on the law of Torts. In Yates v. The Queen (3) on which reliance has been placed by a decision of this Court upon this point, Brett, M.R, observed, apparently by way of an obiter, at page 657:— “For my own part I consider that laying the information before a Magistrate would not be the commencement of the prosecution because the Magistrate might refuse to grant a summons, and if no summons, how could it be said that a prosecution against anyone ever commenced?” Cotton, L.J, in the same case expressed his opinion thus: “It cannot be said that prosecution commences before a person is summoned to answer a complaint.” The law has thus been laid down in Clarke and Lindsell on Tort, 7th Edition, at page 637, where the dictum of Brett, M.R, in Yates v. The Queen has been approved and quoted: “A justice of the peace can only take action on an information laid before him. If he thinks that it discloses ground for believing that an offence has been committed, he either issues a warrant for the arrest of the incriminated party or a summons commanding his attendance. But until he issues such summons or warrant the prosecution cannot be said to begin. The gist of the action for malicious prosecution is that the Defendant set the Magistrate in motion.” The same view has been taken in Madras in the case of W.H. Nurse v. Rustomji Dorabji (4). In C.H Crowdy v. O'Reilly (5) and Bishun Prasad v. Phulman Singh (6), it is expressly laid down that a prosecution for the purpose of a suit for damages for malicious prosecution begin? as soon as information is laid before the Magistrate. The same view has been expressed in Ahmadbhai v. Framji Edulji (7). It is not necessary to pursue this matter further as the question raised in those cases does not affect that which presents itself for determination in the present case. It is accordingly necessary to determine the meaning of “prosecution.” In Halsbury's Laws of England, Vol. 19, page 670 “prosecution” is thus defined: “A prosecution exists where a criminal charge is made before a Judicial Officer or Tribunal, and any person who makes or is actively instrumental in the making or prosecuting of such a charge is deemed to prosecute it and is called the prosecutor.” The expression “criminal charge” has been used in view of the decision in Rayan v. South London Tramways Company (8). In that case the question was whether proceedings taken against any person for having travelled in a carriage or in tramways and avoiding or attempting to avoid payment of fare, thus rendering himself liable to a penalty not exceeding 40 shillings are proceedings in respect of a criminal offence so that a suit for damages for malicious prosecution could lie against the accuser. Lord Esher, M.R, decided that the proceedings were in respect of a criminal offence so that an action for criminal prosecution would lie. The learned Master of the Rolls, however, cautiously observed: “Now there can be no doubt that if what was done to her was to take criminal proceedings against her and if the criminal process was carried on without reasonable and probable cause and maliciously, then her action would lie. I am not prepared to say that, if the proceedings taken against her in this case were not criminal proceedings, the action would not lie if those proceedings were taken without reasonable and probable cause and maliciously.” In Quartz Hill Gold Mining Company v. Eyre (9) “criminal charge” has been defined as including all indictments involving reputation or possible loss of property to the person. In Balbhadra Sing v. Badri Shah (10), Viscount Dunedin in pronouncing the judgment of the Judicial Committee observed: “In any country where, as in India, prosecution is not private, an action for malicious prosecution in the most literal sense of the word could not be raised against any private individual. But giving information to the authorities which naturally leads to prosecution is just the same thing. And if that is done and trouble caused, the action will lie.” The definition of prosecution is not confined to prosecution before a Magistrate or a Criminal Court. If a Judicial Tribunal is moved which has the power to take criminal action against the person charged the requirement of law is satisfied and a claim for damages for malicious prosecution will arise. In Clerk and Lindsell on Tort at page 637 there will be found the following passage: “To prosecute is to set the law in motion and the law is only set in motion by an appeal to some person clothed with judicial authority in regard to the matter in question.” In the present case the application was made to the Munsif for sanction under sec. 195, Cr. P.C The Court was moved to grant sanction to prosecute the Plaintiff in this case and if that application were granted, the Plaintiff would have been liable to prosecution. Some difficulty in applying the law as laid down arises in this case owing to the fact that after obtaining such sanction the Defendant might or might not have gone to the Criminal Court and prosecuted the Plaintiff. But the proceedings relating to the granting of the sanction though they may not lead to imposition of fine or imprisonment, render the person charged liable to fine or imprisonment and therefore come within the meaning of the term. It is with diffidence that I venture to take this view and if the matter were res integra I am not sure what opinion I might form upon this point; but the question was raised and decided in a very recent case of this Court in Narendra Nath De v. Jyotis Chandra Pal . In that case the Defendant had impugned the genuineness of the copy of the will filed by the Plaintiff and applied for sanction to prosecute. It was said following the dictum of Mookerjee, J., in Crowdy v. O'Reilly that the maintainability of a suit for malicious prosecution does not depend on there having been a prosecution in the sense in which the term is used in the Code of Criminal Procedure. It was further observed: “We hold that in the present case the allegations in the plaint that the Defendant maliciously and without just, reasonable and probable cause instituted proceedings for sanction and that the Plaintiff was obliged to defend the case are sufficient to disclose a cause of action.” Even if the proceedings for sanction to prosecute before the Munsif are regarded as civil proceedings, they may sustain an action for malicious prosecution as involving false imputations touching the Plaintiff's business reputation as a professional man. Quartz Hill Gold Mining Co. v. Eyre , per Bowen, L.J, at page 691. “The word ‘prosecution’ includes such civil actions as may be the subject of a suit for malicious prosecution.” Bigelow on Torts, p. 204. The first objection of the Appellant must therefore be overruled.

    The next ground on which the appeal is based is that it has been found in the first judgment by the Munsif that the Defendant had no ground for believing to be false the information he had received that Bholanath died on the 3rd February 1923. It is contended that there was on this assumption no ground for holding that the action taken by the Defendant was without reasonable and probable cause. There is no doubt that observation was made in the judgment of the Munsif when he was trying the issue relating to the Plaintiff's claim for damages for defamation. But when the same officer came to try the suit for damages for malicious prosecution he came to the conclusion that the Defendant was not actuated by honest belief in making the application for sanction and the reason given by him apparently supports his opinion. The learned Munsif after discussing the evidence enters another finding that the conduct of the Defendant even if it was honest amounted to a continuance of the prosecution maliciously after he became aware of the real state of things. The learned Subordinate Judge on appeal has endorsed that finding in these words: “It appears to me to be clear in this case that the Defendant rushed to Court with the false accusation never believing that there was any truth in the same and even when there was unimpeachable evidence on the record to show the nature of his indictment he persisted in pressing the charge.” These findings are on the face of them findings of fact and we cannot say in second appeal that they are not supported by the facts found by the Courts below. It is well-established that a prosecution may not be entirely mala fide; but the continuance of such prosecution after it was discovered that the facts upon which it was based are not true may give rise to a claim for damages for malicious prosecution. This doctrine is based upon the dictum of Cockburn, C.J, in Fitzjohn v. Mackinder , where he says: “a prosecution though in the outset not malicious, as having been undertaken at the dictation of a Judge or Magistrate or if spontaneous from having been commenced under a bona fide belief in the guilt of the accused, may nevertheless become malicious in any of the stages through which it has to pass if the prosecutor having acquired positive knowledge of the innocence of the accused perseveres malo animo in the prosecution, with the intention of procuring per nefas a conviction of the accused.” This view has been adopted in the Town Municipality of Jambusar v. Girija Sankar Narsiram (13) and by the Judicial Committee in Gay a Prasad v. Bhagat Singh and also by this Court in Shama Bibi v. Chairman of Baranagore Municipality . It has been found by both the Courts below that the papers of the Criminal Court were produced by the Plaintiff in the sanction matter on the 9th of June 1923 which clearly showed that Bholanath who was the Defendant was alive on the 7th February 1923 on which date the written statement and the vakalatnama were purported to have been signed. Inspite of those documents the Defendant applied for time on the 30th June 1923 for summoning his witnesses thereby giving a clear indication that he meant to press his application for sanction. On two subsequent days he wanted time to file a certified copy of the death register presumably for the purpose of proving that Bholanath was not alive on the 7th February. In this case, however, the Defendant has not attempted to prove that his case in the sanction matter was correct. In his deposition he says that he had no idea that the pleader and his clerk were in the conspiracy and also if Bholanath was not known to them, they might have been deceived by any one falsely personating Bholanath before them. He admits that he came to know from the papers of the criminal case that the information that Bholanath was dead was not true. His subsequent conduct therefore amounted to continuing the prosecution maliciously though it might have been originally started under a bona fide mistake. With regard to the finding of malice and want of probable and reasonable cause, the findings of the Court below are clear and supported by the evidence in the case. Whatever ground of suspicion the Defendant might have had against the other persons against whom he applied for sanction he could have no ground for asking for sanction to prosecute the Plaintiff who is a respectable pleader as observed by the Munsif and who is not expected to have personal knowledge of matters relating to the identity of clients. The endorsement on the back of the vakalatnama showed that he had received it through another person. There cannot therefore be any reasonable or probable cause for asking permission to prosecute the pleader. As regards malice the finding of the Courts below is that at the time when he made the application and after it the Defendant went about bragging that he had caught the pleader in a trap. One must not forget that in the original title suit the Defendant was a Plaintiff and for some purpose or other he thought it to be to his advantage to implicate the pleader.

    Considering all the facts and circumstances of this case I think that the Courts below have taken a correct view of the matter and the appeal is therefore dismissed with costs.

    Garlick, J.:— I agree.

    P.C

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Robindra Nath Das v. Jogendra Chandra Deb .
    (Jul 10, 1928)