Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Second Appeal concerning s. 33-A, Succession Act)

Factual and Procedural Background

This is a second appeal concerning the application and construction of s. 33-A of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 (as amended by Act 40 of 1926). The testator, Arulandu Nadan, described in the opinion as an Indian Christian, died (the opinion records the year as 1936 in one paragraph and as 1986 in another paragraph of the text). The parties and relevant facts as stated in the plaint and subsequent proceedings are:

  • Primary parties: the plaintiff (a sister of the deceased), defendant 1 (the widow), defendant 2 (a brother), and defendants 3 and 4 (daughters of a deceased sister of the intestate).
  • The plaint stated the property left by the deceased was worth Rs. 6,725-14-0.
  • The plaintiff conceded that defendant 1 (the widow) was entitled exclusively to Rs. 5,000 and interest thereon; after deducting that sum she sought a one-sixth share of the balance, quantified in the plaint as Rs. 159-13-10-2/3. The plaint treated defendants 3 and 4 as entitled to a like sum and defendant 2 was alleged to be similarly entitled.
  • Defendants 3 and 4 submitted to a decree on the basis of the shares described in the plaint; defendant 1 did not contest the plaintiff's claim; defendant 2 claimed entitlement to a one-sixth share in the entire estate (not merely in the surplus after setting aside Rs. 5,000).
  • The trial Court held for defendant 1 (the widow) and decreed Rs. 159-13-10-2/3 to each of three sets of claimants (the plaintiff, defendant 2, and defendants 3 and 4). The plaintiff and defendants 3 and 4 did not appeal against this decree.
  • Defendant 2 appealed to the appellate Court. The appellate Court agreed with defendant 2's contention that he was entitled to a one-sixth share in the whole estate and varied the decree — giving a one-sixth in the whole property to the plaintiff and to defendants 3 and 4.
  • Defendant 1 (the widow) filed this second appeal (the present proceeding) challenging the appellate Court's ruling and urging that the trial Court's view was correct and that the appellate Court should not have varied the decree in favour of the plaintiff and defendants 3 and 4.
  • There were earlier proceedings (O.S. No. 78 of 1934, District Munsif's Court, Sivaganga) in which a Commissioner valued the estate at over Rs. 6,000 and the brother was brought on record as a legal representative; the present Court considered whether those earlier proceedings precluded defendant 2's claims.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the provisions of s. 33-A(1) of the Succession Act (as introduced by Act 40 of 1926) apply to benefit the appellant (the widow, defendant 1) to the extent of property worth Rs. 5,000.
  2. How s. 33-A(5)(b), the phrase “unless the deceased dies intestate in respect of all his property,” should be construed — i.e., whether that phrase is part of cl. (a) (and thus governs and limits the exclusion in cl. (a)) or whether it is a separate and independent clause of cl. (5).
  3. Whether the appellate Court was entitled to enhance the decree in favour of the plaintiff and defendants 3 and 4 when the plaintiff had claimed and paid court-fee only on a smaller sum and had not appealed or filed a memorandum of objections.
  4. Whether defendant 2 (the brother) was precluded from claiming a share of the estate by reason of the earlier District Munsif proceedings (O.S. No. 78 of 1934) and the Commissioner's valuation and subsequent proceedings in that suit.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's (defendant 1 / widow) Arguments

  • The appellant's counsel (identified in the opinion as Mr. Umamaheswaram) argued that the plaintiff had claimed only the smaller sum (about Rs. 159) and had paid court-fee only on that amount; she had not amended the plaint or filed a memorandum of objections when the widow asserted a larger claim, and had not appealed from the trial Court's decree. Therefore, the appellate Court had no valid ground to enhance the amount granted to the plaintiff or to vary the decree in her favour.
  • The appellant further argued a particular textual construction of s. 33-A(5)(b): that the phrase “unless the deceased dies intestate in respect of all his property” should be read as part of cl. (a) and should govern the three classes listed in cl. (a), so that the exclusion in cl. (5)(a) would not apply if, and only if, the deceased had died intestate in respect of all his property. Under that construction, an Indian Christian who died intestate with respect to all his property would not be excluded by cl. (5)(a)(i) from the operation of s. 33-A.
  • The appellant also contended that defendant 2 was precluded from asserting a claim to a share by virtue of the District Munsif proceedings (the earlier suit and valuation), implying there had been an effective decision or concession adverse to the brother on the point.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents (or their counsel, in particular Mr. Venkatarama Iyer for the respondents as recorded) relied on the text of s. 33-A and on the preamble to the amending Act (Act 40 of 1926). It was argued that the amending Act and its preamble show the Legislature's purpose was to provide a more liberal provision to the surviving widow or husband “in the case of a total intestacy.”
  • On the point of construction, the respondents argued (and the Court records their position approvingly) that the phrase in cl. (5)(b) is a separate and independent clause; it is not grammatically or contextually part of cl. (a). Thus the exclusion in cl. (5)(a) (which lists classes such as Indian Christians) operates independently of cl. (5)(b).
  • Respondents also suggested a policy reason: where a deceased made a will and omitted or insufficiently provided for a widow, that omission indicates an intention not to benefit the widow; hence the special, liberal provision in s. 33-A was intended for total intestacy situations, not to intrude on testamentary dispositions.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by examining the language of s. 33-A as introduced by the amending statute and by giving weight to the amending Act's preamble. The key steps in the Court's reasoning were:

  1. Textual analysis of cl. (5): The Court observed that the phrase “unless the deceased dies intestate in respect of all his property” appears in the statute as a separate sub-clause (cl. (b)) rather than as a continuation of cl. (a). The Court reasoned that if the Legislature intended the phrase to qualify the three classes specified in cl. (a), it would have been placed in continuation of those sub-clauses and not separately as cl. (b). On this grammatical and structural basis the Court rejected the appellant's construction that cl. (b) is part of cl. (a).
  2. Use of the preamble: The Court referred to the preamble of the amending Act, which expressly states the object as providing more liberally for the surviving widow or husband “in the case of a total intestacy.” The Court quoted Maxwell on Interpretation of Statutes for the principle that a preamble is a legitimate aid to resolve ambiguity and to fix meaning when the enacting part is open to doubt.
  3. Policy consideration consistent with the preamble: The Court accepted the respondents' submission that the Legislature may have intended that where a man made a will and omitted or inadequately provided for his widow, that omission might indicate the testator's desire not to benefit the widow; the statutory liberal provision was intended primarily to operate in complete intestacy.
  4. Conclusion on construction: For these reasons the Court held that the lower appellate Court's construction (as aligning with the preamble and treating cl. (5)(b) as an independent clause) was correct, and it rejected the appellant's argued construction.
  5. On the procedural/contention about enhancement of the plaintiff's decree: The Court accepted the appellant's contention that the plaintiff had claimed and paid court-fee only on the lesser sum and had not appealed or filed a memorandum of objections; the Court held the appellate Court erred in enhancing the decree in favour of the plaintiff and in similarly interfering for defendants 3 and 4 who had been content with their shares as stated in the plaint.
  6. On the earlier District Munsif proceedings: The Court reviewed the facts of O.S. No. 78 of 1934 and the Commissioner's valuation (which exceeded Rs. 6,000), and refused to infer any adjudication or concession by the brother that would preclude his claim. The Court found no implied decision in those earlier proceedings that the brother would have no share if the property was worth below Rs. 5,000; consequently that preclusion argument failed.
  7. Outcome reasoning: Combining the constructional conclusion (treating cl. (5)(b) as independent and giving effect to the preamble) with the procedural conclusion about the appellate Court's modification of decrees for parties who had not appealed or objected, the Court reached its final orders described below.

Holding and Implications

The Court delivered the following operative holdings and consequences:

  • DISPOSITION AS TO RESPONDENT 1 (the widow): The second appeal is dismissed as against respondent 1; respondent 1 is awarded costs payable by the appellant. (This preserves the trial Court's treatment in favour of the widow as restored elsewhere in the order.)
  • DISPOSITION AS TO RESPONDENTS 2–4: As regards respondents 2 to 4, the appeal is allowed; the appellate Court's decree in their favour is set aside and the trial Court's decree is restored as to them. The balance (remaining property or balance of shares as determined by the trial Court's decree) will go to the appellant. There is no order as to costs against respondents 2, 3 and 4.
  • The Court rejected the appellant's textual construction that would have made cl. (5)(b) govern cl. (5)(a), and endorsed the lower appellate Court's construction of the preamble and the section; the Court emphasized the amending Act's focus on total intestacy in explaining statutory purpose.

The opinion does not record any statement that it establishes a novel legal precedent beyond these dispositions, and it does not cite judicial authorities as precedent. The decision applies the statute's text and the preamble to the facts and restores the trial Court's distribution for respondents 2–4 while dismissing the appeal as regards respondent 1.

Final procedural note: The written order concludes with the operative mandate described above (and records "No leave").

    Arulayi v. Antonimuthu Nadan And Others

    1. The main question arising for decision in this second appeal is whether the provisions of s. 33-A(1) of Act 39 of 1925, the Succession Act apply to this case so as to benefit the appellant to the extent of property worth Rs. 5000. The appellant is the widow of one Arulandu Nadan who was an Indian Christian. He died in the year 1936 leaving his widow defendant 1, a sister the plaintiff, a brother defendant 2 and two daughters by a deceased sister, defendants 3 and 4. The property left by the deceased Arulandu Nadan is stated in the plaint to be worth Rs. 6725-14-0. The plaintiff conceded that defendant 1 was entitled exclusively to Rs. 5000 and interest thereon. Deducting this sum she claimed a sixth in the balance and that was mentioned to be Rs. 159-13-10-2/3. It was also stated that defendants 3 and 4 who were her sister's daughters were entitled to a like sum of Rs. 159-13-10-2/3. Defendant 2 was stated to be also entitled to a similar sum and the balance of the excess was stated to be the share of defendant 1, i.e, this is in addition to the sum of Rs. 5000 and interest thereon which was conceded in favour of defendant 1. Defendants 3 and 4 submitted to a decree apparently content with the share allotted to them in the plaint. Defendant 1 did not contest the plaintiff's claim. Defendant 2, however, put forward a claim that he was entitled to a sixth not merely in the surplus remaining after setting apart Rs. 5000 and interest for the sole benefit of defendant 1 but in the entire assets left by Arulandu Nadan. To this claim defendant 1 naturally took objection. The fight was between defendant 1 whose priority to the sum of Rs. 5000 and interest was conceded by the plaintiff and defendant 2 who did not concede this right. The trial Court held in favour of defendant 1 the widow and decreed Rs. 159-13-10-2/3 to each of the three sets of claimants, namely the plaintiff, defendant 2 and defendants 3 and 4. The plaintiff was content as she got what she wanted in her plaint, that being the amount on which she paid the court-fee. Defendants 3 and 4 did not file any appeal; they were also apparently content with what they got. Defendant 2, however, took the matter on appeal to the appellate Court. That Court agreed with his contention and held that he was entitled to a sixth share in the entire property and did not uphold the exclusive right to Rs. 5000 and interest put forward by defendant 1. While allowing the appeal, the appellate Court varied the decree in favour of the plaintiff and defendants 3 and 4 by giving a sixth in the whole of the property to them. Defendant 1 has filed this appeal and urges that the correct view of the law is the one taken by the trial Court and that, at any rate, the appellate Court should not have varied the decree which had been passed in favour of the plaintiff and defendants 3 and 4.

    2. Mr. Umamaheswaram urges that the plaintiff claimed in her plaint only Rs. 159 odd, paid court-fee only on that. But, did not ask for an amendment of the plaint even after defendant 1 appeared and put forward a larger claim and that after the decree of the trial Court, she did not prefer an appeal or even a memorandum of objections as she would be entitled to file as a respondent under O. 41, R. 22 of the CPC. Under that rule one respondent can file a memorandum of objections against another respondent and not merely against the appellant. That being so, it is said that there was no valid ground for the appellate Court enhancing the amount granted to the plaintiff and for varying a decree in which she acquiesced. Section 33-A was introduced into the Succession Act by Act 40 of 1926. Arulandu Nadan died in 1986. So the amending Act applies to this case. Under S. 33-A(1) where the intestate has left a widow but no lineal descendants and the net value of his property does not exceed five thousand rupees, the whole of his property shall belong to his widow. Under cl. (2), where the net value of the property exceeds the sum of five thousand rupees, the widow shall be entitled to five thousand rupees thereof and shall have a charge upon the whole of such property for such sum of the five thousand rupees, with interest thereon from the date of the death of the intestate at four per cent, per annum until payment. Clause (3) says:

    “The provision for the widow made by this section shall be in addition and without prejudice to her interest and share in the residue of the estate of such intestate remaining after payment of the said sum of five thousand rupees, with interest as aforesaid, and such residue shall be distributed in accordance with the provisions of S. 33 as if it (residue) were the whole of such intestate's property.”

    3. Clause (4) is not material. Clause (5) which has given rise to the trouble runs, as follows:

    “This section shall not apply—

    (a) to the property of: (i) any Indian Christian; (ii) any child or grandchild of any male person who is or was at the time of his death an Indian Christian, or (iii) any person professing the Hindu, Buddhist, Sikh or Jaina religion the succession to whose property is, under Section 24 of the Special Marriage Act, 1872, regulated by the provisions of this Act;

    (b) unless the deceased dies intestate in respect of all his property.”

    4. The contention put forward by the appellant which found acceptance in the trial Court is that the expression “unless the deceased dies intestate in respect of all his property” occurring in cl. (b) is really part of cl. (a) and governs the three classes which are mentioned in cl. (a). According to the learned advocate, the section will not apply to the property of an Indian Christian unless the deceased died intestate in respect of his property; similarly as regards the persons mentioned in cls. (ii) and (iii). If this is the correct construction, then the provisions of cl. (5) which provide that the section shall not apply to certain cases will exclude only those cases of Indian Christians who die leaving a will in respect of any sum or all his properties. But if the Indian Christian died intestate in respect of all his property, then the provisions in cl. (5) will not come into operation and therefore the right of exclusion enacted in cl. (5) would not apply.

    5. This construction ignores the fact that the expression “unless the deceased dies intestate in respect of all his property” is put in as a separate and independent clause and it is not made part of cl. (a). If the Legislature intended that it should be a clause governing the three classes of cases mentioned in clause (a), then it ought not to have been put as cl. (b) at all; it should be put in continuation of sub-cls. (i), (ii) and (iii) of cl. (a). If this construction is correct, then in the case of persons who are not Indian Christians or any other persons mentioned in cls. (ii) and (iii) of sub-cl. (a) of cl. (5), the section will apply whether the deceased died intestate in respect of all his property or whether he left a will disposing of some of his property. If an Anglo Indian or an Englishman domiciled in India or any of the other persons to whom Chap in would apply other than those mentioned in cls. (i), (ii) and (iii) of cl. 5(a) leaves a will which does not dispose of his property, and who is therefore to be deemed to be intestate with respect to the property of which there was no testamentary disposition which was capable of taking effect, the provisions of S. 33-A(1) would apply because cl. (5)(b) only qualifies cl. (5)(a)(i), (ii) and (iii) and is not an independent clause. In this connexion the preamble to the amending Act is very helpful. The preamble states:

    “Whereas it is expedient to amend the provisions of Section 33 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925, so as to provide more liberally for the surviving widow or husband where there are no lineal descendants in the case of a total intestacy.

    6. It is hereby enacted as follows. As stated on p. 10 of Maxwell's Interpretation of Statutes:

    “The preamble of a Statute has been said to be a good means of finding out its meaning, and, as it were, a key to the understanding of it; and as it usually states, or professes to state, the general object and intention of the Legislature in passing the enactment, it may legitimately be consulted to solve any ambiguity, or to fix the meaning of words which may have more than one or to keep the effect of the Act within its real scope, whenever the enacting part is in any of these respects open to doubt.”

    7. Of course the preamble cannot be used in order to control the plain meaning of provisions of the enacting part. In this case, as the preamble states, the amending Act was passed to provide for a liberal provision in the case of the widow or the husband of the person where there are no lineal descendants “in the case of a total intestacy.” For these reasons, I hold that the construction placed upon the preamble by the lower appellate Court is correct and I do not accept this argument of the learned advocate for the appellant. As Mr. Venkatarama Iyer, the learned advocate for the respondents has suggested, it may be that the Legislature thought that if a person set about making a will, he might well have made a provision if he wanted to benefit his widow and if he did not provide for his widow at all or sufficiently well, the Legislature might well have thought that was not a case in which the Legislature ought to interfere by way of giving this preferential right to the widow. In a case where a person dies intestate, the Legislature might make a provision for the widow, but where the husband has left a will not making a sufficient provision or any provision in favour of the widow, that is an indication that he does not want her to benefit and that might be the reason why the condition of a total intestacy is mentioned in the preamble of the amending Act.

    8. The next argument is that the sister and the sister's children are not entitled to anything more than a sixth in the surplus which alone the plaint claimed. The plaintiff did not claim anything more than Rs. 159 odd and paid court-fee only on that sum. She got a decree for that sum and was content with it. Even after she got notice of the appeal filed by defendant 2, she did not choose to come up by way of an independent appeal or if the time for an independent appeal had elapsed by a memorandum of objections. Under these circumstances, the lower appellate Court clearly erred in giving the plaintiff a decree for a sum in excess of that upon which she paid court-fee. Even in the case of defendants 3 and 4, they were content apparently with the sum that was stated in the plaint to belong to them. As in the case of the plaintiff, they did not file an appeal or a memorandum of objection and there is no justification for the appellate Court to have interfered in their favour either.

    9. Another contention was raised by the learned advocate for the appellant that defendant 2 is precluded from setting up a claim to a half of the whole by virtue of certain proceedings that took place in O.S No. 78 of 1934, District Munsif's Court, Sivaganga. That was a suit which was filed by the deceased Arulandu Nadan who died during the pendency of that suit, and the brother applied in I.A No. 232 of 1932 to be brought on record along with the widow as a legal representative. The widow contested this claim and stated that the whole of the property was not worth more than three thousand rupees and that therefore she was entitled under Section 33-A of the Succession Act, to the whole of the property. The Court evidently put a question to the counsel appearing for the widow whether in the event of the property being found ultimately to be worth more than Rs. 5000, the brother would not have a share. That could not but be conceded and it was so done. Evidently in order to avoid a decision on the question which has been agitated in this Court for several hours, the District Munsif appointed a Commissioner to fix the valuation of the estate left by the deceased Arulandu Nadan. Evidently the view was that in case the property was found to be worth more than Rs. 5000, the brother would be admittedly entitled to a share and would therefore be entitled to come in as a legal representative along with the widow.

    10. The Commissioner found that the property was worth over Rs. 6000. Objection was filed, the Court considered the objection and found that the property was worth over Rs. 6000 and it accordingly brought the brother as one of the legal representatives. I fail to see how there is any decision against the brother in these proceedings which can be made the foundation for the argument now advanced before me. Mr. Umamaheswaram urges that there is an implied decision that in case the property was worth below Rs. 5000, the brother would not be entitled to a share in it. I do not agree. There is no concession by the brother that in case the property was worth below Rs. 5000, he would not be entitled to any share in it; nor is there any such finding by the Court. I therefore decline to accept this argument. In the result the second appeal is dismissed as against respondent 1 with his costs payable by the appellant. As regards respondents 2 to 4, the appeal is allowed, the decree of the lower appellate Court as regards them is set aside and that of the trial Court restored; the balance will go to the appellant. There will be no order as to costs against respondents 2, 8 and 4. (No leave).

    C.R.K/G.N

    11. Order accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Arulayi v. Antonimuthu Nadan And Others
    (Jul 25, 1944)