Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 91A of Part I of Kerala Service Rules
  • Rules 82 and 88 of K.S.R5.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 91A of Part I of Kerala Service Rules
  • Rules 82 and 88 of K.S.R5.
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent, holding a B.Sc (Physics) and B.Ed, was appointed as an Upper Primary School Assistant (UPSA) on 3.8.1999. After five years' service he applied for leave under Rule 91A of Part I, Kerala Service Rules to pursue M.Sc (Physics). Leave was granted by Ext. P4 dated 16.7.2005, but under Rules 82 and 88 (which do not carry service benefits) rather than under Rule 91A as applied for. Another teacher in the same school received leave under Rule 91A (Ext. P3). The respondent completed the M.Sc, returned to service, later passed the SET and was promoted by transfer to Higher Secondary School Teacher on 23.7.2011. He filed W.P.(C) challenging Ext. P4 and seeking leave and consequential benefits under Rule 91A. The learned Single Judge allowed the writ petition; the State filed this Writ Appeal challenging that judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the respondent was eligible for leave under Rule 91A of Part I, K.S.R. or whether the grant of leave under Rules 82 and 88 (Ext. P4) was correct.
  2. How Rule 91A must be applied — in particular, whether postgraduate study by a teacher in the respondent's circumstances qualifies as "useful to the public service" required by the Rule.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' (State) Arguments

  • For performance of duties as a U.P. School teacher the respondent's existing qualifications (B.Sc and B.Ed) were sufficient; postgraduate qualification was not required.
  • Acquisition of the M.Sc did not produce benefit to the State or public service warranting leave under Rule 91A.

Respondent's Arguments

  • Subsequent developments — completion of M.Sc, benefit to the respondent, State and community, and promotion to Higher Secondary School Teacher — should be considered in assessing eligibility under Rule 91A.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined Rule 91A, which it quoted and interpreted to permit leave for post-graduate courses to officers with continuous officiating or temporary service of five years or more, provided the higher studies are "primarily of benefit to the State" and granted with regard to their usefulness to public service.

The court noted that persons lacking the requisite service or not satisfying Rule 91A's public-service usefulness requirement may only be granted leave under Rules 82 and 88 (which do not carry service benefits). The core issue was the correctness of converting the respondent's Rule 91A application into leave under Rules 82 and 88 in Ext. P4.

The court rejected the State's narrow contention that postgraduate study was irrelevant because the respondent's immediate duties as a U.P. teacher did not require it. It held that assessment of usefulness must consider not only the post held at application but also the applicant's prospects of promotion, age, likely period of service after studies, and the potential to serve the community in higher positions. The court observed that Rule 91A presumes postgraduate study will be useful to public service (and there is no statutory requirement of a post-study service bond or minimum post-study service period).

Applying these factors, the court found that the respondent (aged 36, with five years' service and already B.Sc B.Ed) satisfied the tests: he had potential for promotion (which he later achieved), sufficient remaining service life, and the postgraduate qualification would enhance his effectiveness in higher teaching posts. Consequently, the conversion to Rules 82 and 88 in Ext. P4 was incorrect and the respondent was entitled to leave under Rule 91A.

The court upheld the learned Single Judge's conclusion and directed the appellants to grant the respondent all benefits under Rule 91A. The court also recommended that the Government issue guidelines for grant of leave under Rule 91A addressing reasonable duration of post-study service, potential for promotion, usefulness of the higher education in promoted positions, and the option of a bond where necessary.

Holding and Implications

Writ Appeal dismissed; the judgment of the learned Single Judge is upheld, and the respondent is entitled to leave and all service benefits under Rule 91A.

Direct effect: The State is directed to grant the respondent all benefits to which he is entitled under Rule 91A. The court additionally asked the Government to formulate guidelines addressing factors to be considered when granting leave under Rule 91A and the possibility of bonds to secure reasonable post-study service.

    State Of Kerala & Ors. v. M.D Mahesh

    C.N Ramachandran Nair, J.:— This Writ Appeal is filed by the State challenging the judgment of the learned Single Judge declaring respondent's eligibility for leave for higher studies under Rule 91A of Part I of Kerala Service Rules (K.S.R) and granting consequential service benefits to him. We have heard Government Pleader appearing for the appellants and counsel appearing for the respondent.

    2. The respondent with B.Sc degree in Physics and B.Ed was appointed as Upper Primary School Assistant on 3.8.1999 based on his selection by the PSC. After serving five years as a UPSA, the respondent applied for leave under Rule 91A for Post-graduate studies i.e M.Sc Physics. Though theleave wasi applied for under Rule 91A, it was granted after the respondent joined M.Sc course vide Ext. P4 dated 16.7.2005 wherein it is seen that leave applied for under Rule 91A was granted under Rules 82 and 88 of Part I, K.S.R While leave granted under Rules 82 and 88 do not entail any service benefits to the respondent, he would have got all benefits if the leave was granted under Rule 91A in terms of his application.

    3. In fact, another teacher in the High School section of the same school applied for leave under Rule 91A and the same was allowed by the Government in terms of the request vide Ext. P3. The respondent successfully completed his M.Sc course, returned and joined as UPSA and thereafter based on the higher educational qualification and the State Eligibility Test passed by him after M.Sc, he was promoted by transfer as Higher Secondary School Teacher on 23.7.2011 In between he filed W.P(C) challenging Ext. P4 and for direction to respondents to grant leave in terms of his request under Rule 91A and to allow all service benefits. The learned Single Judge allowed the writ petition against which this appeal is filed.

    4. There is no dispute with regard to respondent's entitlernent for leave and the same was in fact granted for the purpose for which he applied for and the respondent has accomplished his mission by completing the course study in M.Sc and he has successfully passed out in the post-graduate examination and later passed the SET examination entitling him for promotion by transfer to the post of Higher Secondary School Teacher which in fact he got later. However, question to be considered is whether respondent was in fact eligible for leave under Rule 91A or whether his eligibility is rightly decided vide Ext. P4 granting leave under Rules 82 and 88 of K.S.R

    5. After hearing both sides, what we notice is that Rule 94A is a provision for granting leave for higher studies to those with minimum service of 5 years but on condition that higher studies including Post-graduate studies is in the interest of public service. On the other hand persons without the required period of service and whose claims do not satisfy the requirements of Rule 91A are entitled to leave under Rules 82 and 88. Since all service benefits are available during the leave granted under Rule 91A, certainly leave has to be granted for higher studies under, Rule 91A itself. So much so, the question to be considered is the correctness of Ext. P4 where under leave applied for by the respondent under Rule 91A was converted into an application for leave in terms of Rules 82 and 88 and in granting the same. Since the controversy is only on eligibility for leave under Rule 91A, we have to necessarily examine the scope of the said Rule and it's application to the respondent. Rule 91A is extracted here under.

    “Rule 91A. Officers with a continuous officiating or temporary service of 5 years or more may be granted in addition to any leave to which they are eligible for, leave for undergoing Post-Graduate Courses in the sphere of their duties which are primarily of benefit to the State, such as Post-Graduate Courses for Teachers, Engineers and Doctors. The leave shall be granted only with due regard to the usefulness of the higher studies to the public service.”

    6. Government Pleader challenged the findings of the learned Single Judge contending that for performing the duties of U.P School teacher which respondent was at the time of submission of application for leave, Post-Graduation is not required and the qualification the respondent already had namely, B.Sc with B.Ed was sufficient qualification. In other words, according to the appellants, higher qualification namely, Post-Graduate studies in the same subject and acquisition of wider knowledge for the respondent does hot lead to any benefit to the State or to public service entitling hjm for the leave. The learned Single Judge, however, rejected this contention and held that acquisition of Post-Graduate Degree for a teacher in the same subject certainly will improve his faculties in imparting, education to the student community and, therefore, it will benefit the State and public service as referred to in the Rule. Before us, counsel for the respondent submitted that the subsequent developments i.e the benefit the respondent as well as the State and the community received with the higher qualification i.e M.Sc and the fact that he became a Higher Secondary School Teacher also should be reckoned while considering his eligibility for leave under Rule 91A. There can be no dispute that objective of Rule 91A providing for leave for higher studies to employees in service is to benefit the State and public service and just not for the personal benefits of the employees. Thjs certainly presupposes that employee after acquiring higher qualification while in service on leave granted under Rule 91A should be available in the service of the State for the benefit of the public. However, there is nothing in the Rule to Indicate that after acquiring the Post-Graduate Degree the person should serve for a minimuni period of years and not even a bond is collected undertaking to be in service atleast for a minimum period after acquiring the higher qualification. Probably the learned the Single Judge taking note of the presumption stated in the Rule itself held that Post-Graduate study for teachers will intrinsically make them more efficient to discharge their duties leading to benefit to the State and to the public service. Even though study for Post-Graduate courses only is stated as the ground for applying for leave for teachers and Doctors, the only condition in the Rule for eligibility for leave is that the higher studies should be useful to the public service. So much so, what is required, to be considered is the nature of service rendered by the applicant not only in the post he was holding at the time of applying for leave but the eligibility for promotion on acquiring higher educational qualification and the potential in him to serve the community in higher positions to which he is likely to be promoted. Even though Post-Graduate studies in Physics for the respondent would not have benefited the Students he was teaching in the elementary classes in the Upper Primary School, considering his eligibility for promotion by transfer as High School Teacher and later as Higher Secondary School Teacher which he really got, we feel the Post-Graduate degree in Science acquired by him will make him a better teacher. Further, as already stated, we feel while considering leave under Rule 91A what the Government has to consider is the age of the applicant, the period of service he is likely to render after completion of higher studies, the higher positions he is likely to get and unless there is likelihood of his continuing in service after acquiring the higher educational qualification and there is a sufficient duration of service and usefulness of the education in the nature of employment, there-will be no justification to grant leave under Rule 91A. All the tests are satisfied in the case of the respondent because he was aged only 36 years of age with 5 years of experience as teacher in the Upper Primary School and he was already B.Sc B.Ed, in Physical Science when he went for Post-graduate studies on leave. Therefore, his long service and potential for promotion to the post of High School Assistant and later as Higher Secondary School teacher should have been in the contemplation of appellants while considering bis application for leave under Rule 91A. Since the above tests stated by us apply to the facts of the respondent's case, nobody should hesitate to grant leave to him under Rule 91A which respondent was eminently entitled to. We, therefore, uphold the judgment of the learned Single Judge and dismiss the Writ Appeal filed by the State directing the appellants to grant all benefits entitled to the respondent under Rule 91A. We also feel that Government should issue guidelines for grant of leave under Rule 91A attaching significance for reasonable duration of service after acquiring higher educational qualification, potentials of applicants for promotion and the usefulness of higher education in promoted positions and if required, a Bond can be provided for ensuring continued service for a reasonable period.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State Of Kerala & Ors. v. M.D Mahesh
    (Jun 20, 2012)