Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Article 134-B of the Limitation Act.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Article 134-B of the Limitation Act.
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant is the trustee of the Sri Lakshminarayana Perumalswami temple at Pallapalayam, appointed in 1933, displacing the first defendant. He sued in the Court of the District Munsiff of Udumalpet for a declaration that: (a) a mortgage by the first defendant of properties described as items 1 and 2; (b) a sale by the first defendant of item 3; and (c) a sale by the Court of item 4 were not binding on the trust, and for recovery of possession from the alienees. Items 1 and 2 were mortgaged on 12 May 1928 to the fourth defendant; item 3 was sold two days later to the fourth defendant; item 4 was sold at a Court auction on 10 January 1921 after attachment as the first defendant's private property. The District Munsiff upheld the suit except as to item 4. On appeal the Subordinate Judge of Coimbatore held the fourth-item sale not binding and decreed for the plaintiff in full. The alienees appealed; Somayya, J. considered the case governed by prior judgments (Alam Khan Sahib v. Karuppannaswami Goundan and Venkatasubramania v. Sivagurunatha) and dismissed the suit as barred by limitation. The present appeal is from that judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the alienations (mortgage of items 1 & 2, sale of item 3, and Court sale of item 4) are binding on the religious trust.
  2. Which Limitation Act article (Article 134-A, Article 134-B or Article 144) governs the right of the manager/trustee to set aside each alienation.
  3. If Article 144 applies to item 4, when does the period of limitation (adverse possession) commence — from the date of sale or from the date the manager ceases to hold office?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The decisions relied on by Somayya, J. (Alam Khan Sahib v. Karuppannaswami Goundan and Venkatasubramania v. Sivagurunatha) do not apply because they concerned alienations made more than twelve years before the insertion of Article 134-B.
  • The case is governed by Article 134-B of the Limitation Act (inserted by the 1929 amendment), which gives a 12-year period from the death, resignation or removal of the transferor; the plaint (filed 31 July 1940) was within twelve years of the appellant taking office in 1933.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Alam Khan Sahib v. Karruppannaswami Goundan (1938) 1 M.L.J. 113 Earlier decision relied on by Somayya, J.; referred to alienations by trustees made more than twelve years before insertion of Article 134-B. Court held those decisions need not govern here because the alienations in the present case were within twelve years of the 1929 amendment, so Article 134-B applies.
Venkatasubramania v. Sivagurunatha A.I.R. 1938 Mad. 60 Earlier decision relied on by Somayya, J.; concerned pre-Article 134-B alienations and limitation. Court rejected applicability for the present facts because alienations occurred within twelve years of the amendment; Article 134-B applies.
Vidya Varuthi v. Balu-swami Aiyar (1921) 41 M.L.J. 346 : L.R. 48 I.A. 302 : I.L.R. 44 Mad. 831 (P.C.) Established that Article 134-A does not apply to certain sales (here relevant to item 4) and that limitation is governed by Article 134-B or Article 144. Court accepted that Article 134-A does not apply to item 4 and that the period of limitation is governed by Article 134-B or Article 144; proceeded to determine the more appropriate article.
Venkateswara v. Venkatesa (1941) 1 M.L.J. 644 : I.L.R. (1941) 599 (F.B.) Mad. Full Bench considered whether Article 134-B or Article 144 applied to an alienation by the head of a math and held that if Article 144 applied, limitation commenced from the death/resignation/removal of the manager who effected the alienation. Court followed this decision to hold that, for item 4, adverse possession did not start from the date of Court sale but from the date the first defendant ceased to hold office as trustee.
Mahanth Ramcharan Das v. Naurangi Lal 64 M.L.J. 505 : I.L.R. 12 Pat. 251 : 60 I.A. 124 (P.C.) Privy Council principle that where a Mahanth has alienated math property, the possession of the alienee does not become adverse during the tenure of the Mahanth; limitation begins when the Mahanth ceases to hold office. Principle cited and applied (via Venkateswara) to treat the commencement of limitation for item 4 as the date the alienating trustee ceased to hold office.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the applicable Limitation Act articles separately for each item of property:

  • Items 1 & 2 (mortgage of 12 May 1928): Article 134-A (inserted 1929) governs setting aside an alienation by a manager of a religious endowment; it prescribes twelve years from the date when the transfer became known to the plaintiff. The plaintiff did not know of the mortgage until filing suit, so the claim is within time.
  • Item 3 (sale two days after 12 May 1928): Article 134-B applies (twelve years from death/resignation/removal of transferor). The plaintiff, appointed in 1933, filed within seven years, so the claim is within time.
  • Item 4 (Court sale 10 January 1921): Both sides accepted Vidya Varuthi establishes that Article 134-A does not apply and that Article 134-B or Article 144 governs. The appellant conceded the sale does not fall within the literal wording of Article 134-B; the Court found Article 144 more appropriate but observed that under either article the suit was within time. Relying on Venkateswara v. Venkatesa and the Privy Council in Mahanth Ramcharan Das, the Court held that adverse possession for item 4 began only when the first defendant ceased to be trustee, not from the date of the Court sale.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The appeal is allowed and the decree of the Subordinate Judge is restored with costs here and before Somayya, J.

Implications: The plaintiff (trustee) is entitled to a decree in respect of the disputed items (the decree of the Subordinate Judge in his favour is restored) and costs were awarded. The opinion does not purport to create a new legal precedent beyond applying existing authorities concerning which Limitation Act article governs such alienations and when limitation begins.

    Sri Lakshminarayana Perumalswami By Agent Appayyan Alias Muthukumaran Chettiar v. Kasthuri Naicker And Others.

    1. The appellant is the trustee of the Sri Lakshminarayana Perumalswami temple at Pallapalayam in the Uudmalpet taluq. He was appointed to the office in 1933, displacing the first defendant. He sued in the Court of the D1strict Munsiff of Udumalpet for a declaration that a mortgage created by the first defendant of properties described in the plaint as items 1 and 2, that a sale by the first defendant of item 3 and a sale by the Court of item 4 were not binding on the trust and that he was entitled to recover possession from the alienees. The first and second items were mortgaged by the first defendant to the fourth defendant on the 12 th May, 1928. The first defendant had then been appointed the trustee. The property was mortgaged as belonging to the first defendant and his two brothers, who joined in the mortgage. Two days later the first defendant sold the third item to the fourth defendant, again treating the property as belonging to himself and his brothers. The fourth item was sold in a Court auction on the 10th January, 1921. It had been attached as the private property of the first defendant, who allowed the sale to proceed on that basis. The auction purchaser was one Palani Goundan, who purported to sell the property to the father of the seventh defendant on the 24th September, 1925. During the pendency of the present litigation, the seventh defendant purported to sell it to the eighth defendant.

    2. The D1strict Munsiff held that the suit was well founded, except as regards the fourth item. To this extent he dismissed the action. On appeal by the plaintiff, the Subordinate Judge of Coimbatore held that the sale by the Court on the 10th January, 1921 of the fourth item was also not binding on the trust and consequently the plaintiff was entitled to a decree in full. The alienees then appealed to this Court. The appeal was heard by Somayya, J., who considered that the case was governed by the judgments of this Court in Alam Khan Sahib v. Karruppannaswami Goundan (1938) 1 M.L.J. 113 and Venkatasubramania v. Sivagurunatha A.I.R. 1938 Mad. 60. Consequently he dismissed the suit as being barred by the law of limitation. The present appeal is from this judgment.

    3. The learned Counsel for the appellant contends that the decisions relied upon by Somayya, J., do not apply and the case is governed by Article 134-B of the Limitation Act. That article was inserted in the statute by the amending Act of 1929. Under it the period of limitation for a suit by the manager of a Hindu, Mahomedan or Buddh1st religious or charitable endowment to recover possession of immovable property comprised in the endowment which has been transferred by a previous manager for valuable consideration is twelve years from the death, resignation or removal of the transferor. Both the decisions in Alam Khan Sahib v. Karuppannaswami Goundan 1938 1 M.L.J. 113 and Venkatasubramania v. Sivagurunatha A.I.R. 1938 Mad. 60 had reference to alienations by trustees of religious endowments which had been made more than twelve years before the insertion of Article 134-B.

    4. We do not need to pause to consider the correctness of the principle there applied, because in the present case the alienations were made within twelve years of the amendment, which therefore applies. The plaint was filed on the 31st July 1940, seven years after the plaintiff had taken over the office of trustee from the first defendant.

    5. It is clear that in so far as the mortgage of the first and second items is concerned, the governing article is Article 134-A which was also inserted in 1929. That fixes a period of twelve years for the setting aside of an alienation made by the manager of a Hindu, Mahomedan or Buddh1st religious or charitable endowment, the time commencing from the date when the transfer became known to the plaintiff. It is not suggested that the plaintiff had any knowledge of the mortgage until he filed the present suit. It is equally clear that Article 134-B applies to the sale of the third item. The plaintiff had twelve years from 1933 to institute the suit and he instituted it within seven years.

    6. The position with regard to the fourth items is different. It is admitted by both sides that in view of the decision of the Privy Council in Vidya Varuthi v. Balu-swami Aiyar (1921) 41 M.L.J. 346 : L.R. 48 I.A. 302 : I.L.R. 44 Mad. 831 (P.C.). Article 134-A, does not apply and that the period of limitation is governed by Article 134-B or Article 144. The learned Counsel for the appellant has to concede that the alienation of item 4 does not fall within the actual wording of Article 134-B, but he says that there is no difference in principle between a direct alienation by a fraudulent manager and a fraudulent manager allowing trust property to be attached and sold as his private property. We find some difficulty in accepting the proposition that this part of the case falls within Article 134-B. In our opinion the more appropriate article is Article 144, but in either case the suit is within time.

    7. The decision of the Full Bench in Venkateswara v. Venkatesa (1941) 1 M.L.J. 644 : I.L.R. (1941) 599 (F.B.) Mad is here in point. In that case there had been an alienation by the head of a math. The question for decision was whether Article 134-B or Article 144 applied. The Court considered that on the facts of that case Article 134-B applied, but that if it did not, the article applicable was Article 144 and the period of limitation commenced from the death of the Mahanth who had alienated the property. In Mahanth Ramcharan Das v. Naurangi Lal 64 M.L.J. 505 : I.L.R. 12 Pat. 251 : 60 I.A. 124 (P.C.), the Privy Council had held that where a Mahanth has alienated math property, the possession of the alienee does not become adverse during the tenure of office of the Mahanth and limitation only begins to run from the time when the Mahanth ceases to hold office. That principle was applied in Venkateswara v. Venkatesa (1941) 1 M.L.J. 644 : I.L.R. (1941) 599 (F.B.) and consequently the Court held that if Article 144 was the governing article, the date of the starting point of adverse possession was the date of the death, resignation or removal of the manager who effected the alienation and not the date of the election of his successor.

    8. In accordance with the Full Bench decision we hold that in respect of the fourth item adverse possession did not start from the date of the Court sale, but only from the date when the first defendant ceased to hold the office of trustee.

    9. The result is that the appeal is allowed and the decree of the Subordinate Judge is restored with costs here and before Somayya, J.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sri Lakshminarayana ... v. Kasthuri Naicker And...
    (Apr 22, 1946)