AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • O. 9, R. 13 Civil Procedure Code. Again S, 17 of the Provincial Small Causes Courts Act
  • Art. 15 of the Stamp Act. Now Art. 15 of the Stamp Act
  • S. 17 of the Provincial Small Causes Courts Act
  • Art. 6 of Sch. II of the Court-Fees Act
  • Provincial Small Causes Courts Act
  • Art. 40 of the Stamp Act
  • Art. 57 of the Stamp Act.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • O. 9, R. 13 Civil Procedure Code. Again S, 17 of the Provincial Small Causes Courts Act
  • Art. 15 of the Stamp Act. Now Art. 15 of the Stamp Act
  • S. 17 of the Provincial Small Causes Courts Act
  • Art. 6 of Sch. II of the Court-Fees Act
  • Provincial Small Causes Courts Act
  • Art. 40 of the Stamp Act
  • Art. 57 of the Stamp Act.
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion arises from a reference by the Additional District Munsif of Nellore concerning a dispute with the Court-fee Examiner regarding the proper stamp duty applicable on a security bond. The background facts are that an ex parte small cause decree for Rs. 155-10-0 was passed. The defendant filed a petition to set aside this ex parte decree and submitted a security bond executed by a surety. Initially, the bond was unstamped, but the Court ordered the petitioner to affix an 8 annas Court-fee stamp to it, following the Court's practice. The ex parte decree was set aside and the suit restored. The Court-fee Examiner contended that the security bond required a higher stamp duty of Rs. 1-4-0 under Article 15 of the Stamp Act, rather than the 8 annas stamp under Article 6 of Schedule II of the Court Fees Act.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Article 6 of Schedule II of the Court Fees Act or Article 15 of the Stamp Act applies to the security bond executed for the performance of the decree.
  2. Whether the order setting aside the ex parte decree is an order passed under the Code of Civil Procedure or only under Section 17 of the Provincial Small Causes Courts Act.
  3. The proper interpretation and application of Section 17 of the Provincial Small Causes Courts Act in relation to the procedure for setting aside an ex parte decree and the requirement for deposit or security.

Arguments of the Parties

Court-Fee Examiner's Arguments

  • The stamp duty payable on the security bond should be Rs. 1-4-0 under Article 15 of the Stamp Act, not 8 annas under Article 6 of Schedule II of the Court Fees Act.
  • The order setting aside the ex parte decree was made under the proviso to Section 17 of the Provincial Small Causes Courts Act, and not under the Code of Civil Procedure.

Court's Observations and Counterpoints

  • The order setting aside the ex parte decree is also an order under the Civil Procedure Code, which is a general procedural law applicable to Civil Courts including Small Causes Courts.
  • The Provincial Small Causes Courts Act is supplemental to the Civil Procedure Code and does not exclude its applicability except where specifically stated.
  • The proviso to Section 17 only limits the discretion of the Court rather than changing the procedural basis of the order.
  • The bond is given in pursuance of an order of the Court and thus falls under the scope of Article 6 of Schedule II of the Court Fees Act.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Re The District Munsif of Tiruvallur (Full Bench decision) A bond given in pursuance of rules made under the Code should be deemed to be given in pursuance of an order made by the Court. The Court relied on this precedent to support that the security bond was given pursuant to a Court order and thus subject to the Court Fees Act.
Amirthammal v. Ramalinga Goundan Interpretation related to applicability of the Court Fees Act on bonds given under Court orders. The Court found the conclusion in this case similar and supportive of applying the Court Fees Act.
Reference from the Munsif, Habiganj, Re (3) Similar conclusion regarding the applicability of Court Fees Act provisions to bonds given under Court orders. The Court cited this precedent to reinforce its interpretation.
Madras High Court Circular (P. Dis. 265 of 1929 dated 23rd March 1929) Practical adoption of the conclusion that bonds given under Court orders are subject to Court Fees Act stamp duties. The Court noted that this circular had been overlooked by the Court-fee Examiner and supported its conclusion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by examining the statutory framework governing the procedure for setting aside an ex parte decree in Small Causes Courts. It identified that although the order was passed under Section 17 of the Provincial Small Causes Courts Act, the Civil Procedure Code (CPC) also applies as a general procedural law to such courts. The Court noted that the Provincial Small Causes Courts Act is supplemental and does not exclude the CPC except where expressly provided.

The Court analyzed Order 9, Rule 13 of the CPC, which governs setting aside ex parte decrees, and found that the discretion to impose terms such as security or deposit arises under this provision. The proviso to Section 17 of the Provincial Small Causes Courts Act only restricts this discretion but does not change the procedural foundation.

The Court addressed the procedural ambiguity arising from the language of Section 17 relating to the timing of deposit or security, concluding that the application to set aside an ex parte decree can be seen as two parts: a preliminary application to seek directions and a subsequent compliance with those directions before the final application is considered.

Applying this understanding, the Court found that the security bond was given pursuant to a Court order and thus falls within the scope of Article 6 of Schedule II of the Court Fees Act, which prescribes an 8 annas stamp duty. The Court rejected the Court-fee Examiner's contention that Article 15 of the Stamp Act applied, noting that Article 15 does not apply if the Court Fees Act applies.

The Court further supported its conclusion by reference to precedents and a relevant circular from the Madras High Court, which had been overlooked by the Court-fee Examiner.

Holding and Implications

The Court answered the reference in favor of applying Article 6 of Schedule II of the Court Fees Act, holding that the security bond should be stamped with an 8 annas Court-fee stamp rather than a higher duty under the Stamp Act.

The direct effect of this decision is that the security bond executed in connection with setting aside the ex parte decree is subject to the lower Court-fee stamp duty as per the Court Fees Act. No broader precedent beyond the immediate parties was established, and the ruling clarifies the interplay between the Court Fees Act and the Stamp Act in this procedural context.

    Kalapati Peda Pitchamma And Another Petitioners. v. Chiruvella Pedamuneyya (Minor) And Another

    JUDGMENT*

    Ramesam, J. — This matter comes up on reference by the Additional District Munsif of Nellore on account of a difference of opinion between him and the Court-fee Examiner.

    The facts out of which this reference arises are these. A small cause decree was passed ex parte for Rs. 155-10-0. The defendant then put in a petition to set aside the ex parte decree and filed along with it a security bond executed by a surety for the performance of the decree. It looks as if the security bond was not originally stamped at all, but, when the petition came on before the Court, the Court ordered the petitioner to affix the usual Court-fee stamp of 8 annas to the security bond which was the practice of that Court. The decree has been set aside and the suit restored.

    The Court-Fee Examiner now thinks that the stamp to be affixed to the security bond is not 8 annas stamp under Art. 6 of Sch. II of the Court Fees Act but a stamp of Rs. 1-4-0 under Art. 15 of the Stamp Act. Now Art. 15 of the Stamp Act does not apply if the Court Fees Act applies. So we have first to see whether Art. 6 of Sch II of the Court Fees Act applies or not. For the Court Fees Act to apply, two conditions must be satisfied: (1) the order setting aside the ex parte decree must be an order passed under the Code of Civil Procedure and (2) the bond must be given in pursuance of an order made by a Court. It is true that the order was passed under S. 17 of the Provincial Small Causes Courts Act but it seems to me that nevertheless it is also an order passed under the Civil Procedure Code. The Civil Procedure Code is a general Act of procedure applicable to the Civil Courts in India. The Provincial Small Causes Courts Act is a kind of supplemental Act indicating the special procedure to be followed in Small Causes Courts which are Civil Courts. O. 50, Civil Procedure Code, gives a list of certain provisions of that Code which are not applicable to Provincial Small Causes Courts. This indicates two things: first that the Civil Procedure Code itself governs the procedure of Small Cause Courts to some extent and secondly that the provisions not included in the list apply to Small Cause Courts and one of them is O. 9, R. 13. So, when a Small Cause Court sets aside an ex parte decree, it is really under O. 9, R. 13 Civil Procedure Code. Again S, 17 of the Provincial Small Causes Courts Act itself makes the procedure under the Civil Procedure Code applicable to Small Cause Courts. Either way we come to the conclusion that the Provincial Small Causes Courts Act is supplemental to the Civil Procedure Code. But it is said by the Court-fee Examiner that this order is under the proviso to S. 17 and not under the first part of the section. The proviso does not add to the section but only cuts down the very wide discretion which Courts have under O. 9, R. 13, Civil Procedure Code in setting aside an ex parte decree, and in imposing terms upon the petitioner. Under the proviso the petitioner should either deposit the decree amount or give security. No other alternative such as that no condition need be imposed at all is allowed.

    I am therefore clearly of opinion that the order passed is an order under the Civil Procedure Code.

    On account of the somewhat inconsistent and therefore obscure language of S. 17 of the Provincial Small Causes Courts Act there is some difficulty as to the exact procedure to be followed by a petitioner. This obscurity has been caused by the words

    “shall, at the time of presenting his application, either deposit in Court ………as the Court may direct.”

    The section contemplates some direction of the Court and the petitioner obeying that direction. The earlier part says that the petitioner shall deposit money or give security at the time of presenting the application. There is an apparent difficulty in obeying both these directions. This obscurity has been noticed by most Courts which deal with this section and deserves being cleared up by the Legislature. Most Courts have attempted a practical solution. It is unnecessary to discuss this matter at great length in this case but it seems to me that when a party applies to set aside an ex parte decree it may be regarded as consisting of two parts; first a preliminary application to get a direction of the Court with a view to get the ex parte decree set aside and secondly after obeying the direction of the Court the actual application to set aside the ex parte decree. The second part follows only after obeying the directions of the Court. Looked at in this way the party first applies. Where he deposits money, there is no further difficulty; but where he is unable to do so he seeks the direction of the Court. The Court may now direct the party either to deposit money or to give security in some form. He should now obey the direction and when the matter again comes up before the Court it is then we have the actual application to set aside the decree and it may be said that he has either deposited money or given security with the application. However, in whatever form the Court's direction is obtained and complied with, the bond would be in pursuance of an order made by Court within the meaning of Art 6 of Sch. II of the Court Fees Act.

    I have indicated the general construction of the Article without reference to the particular facts of this case. In this particular case it would appear that the Court actually asked the petitioner to supply a Court-fee stamp of 8 annas. That would certainly be an order of the Court. Even in cases where the petitioner tenders a security along with the very first application without a previous order of the Court, if the Court orders notice on it to the opposite party and passes final orders setting aside the ex parte decree having found sufficient cause, it amounts to an order of Court. The acceptance by the Court of a bond previously furnished is equivalent to an order of the Court followed by compliance with it.

    In my opinion, therefore, Art. 6 of Sch. II of the Court-Fees Act applies to the case and the bond should be stamped with an 8 annas stamp.

    So far I have arrived at the conclusion without referring to any decision. My conclusion is in accordance with the Full Bench decision in Re The District Munsif of Tiruvallur , where it was held that a bond given in pursuance of rules made under the Code should be deemed to be given in pursuance of an order made by the Court. The conclusion in Amirthammal v. Ramalinga Goundan , is also similar so far as the Court-Fees Act is concerned. The question of the application of Art. 40 of the Stamp Act does not arise in the present case. The conclusion in Referrence from the Munsif, Habiganj, Re (3), is also similar. But no question now arises with reference to Art. 57 of the Stamp Act. There is a circular of the Madras High Court (P. Dis. 265 of 1929 dated 23rd March 1929) which practically adopts the above conclusion. This must have been overlooked by the Court-fee Examiner.

    I answer the reference accordingly.

    The Chief Justice.—I agree.

    King J:—I agree.

    N. R. R.Reference answered.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Kalapati Peda Pitchamma And Another Petitioners. v. Chiruvella Pedamuneyya (Minor) And Another
    (Dec 13, 1934)