AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges

    K.V. Periya Miyana Marakayar & Sons v. P.K. Subramania Iyer

    The Chief Justice. — This is an appeal from an order made by Kumaraswami Sastri, J., under O. 37 of the Civil Procedure Code, the suit being a suit on hundis given by the defendants to the plaintiffs or their predecessors. Long affidavits were put in on both sides, and a large body of correspondence, by no means complete, is exhibited to those affidavits.

    The question to be considered on application under O. 37, R. 3 is whether or not a triable issue is disclosed on affidavit or otherwise by the defendant. By triable issue is meant a plea which is at least plausible. It is not enough for instance to say: ‘I have got a good defence; but the defendant must say what the defence is, and as a rule, bring something before the Court, to show that it is a bona fide defence and not a mere attempt to gain time, by getting leave to defend. There is not a great, difference between those cases, where it is right to give judgment and those where it is right to give leave to defend, on paying the amount into Court, or on giving security; but there are cases in which the defendants set up some sort of defence, which does not bear the stamp of truth; as for instance, when it is contradicted by documents, when the Court may well say that he should only be allowed to come and put that defence before the Court, if he is prepared to give security for the amount claimed. I think the principle applicable here has been laid down clearly in similar applications, under O. 14, R. 1 of the Rules of the supreme Court in England by the House of Lords in Jacobs v. Booth's Distillery Company, Codd v. Delap and Jones v. Stone.

    In this case, I do not think that the learned judge turned his mind to the consideration of the question whether or not there is a triable issue in this case. He seems to have taken the view that here are hundis, on the face of which prima facie the defendants would be liable, and therefore they must, as a condition of leave to defend, pay the money into Court or give security. We have before us the same materials as he had, and on a study of the correspondence, which in these matters, is always the most important thing to look at, explained as it is by affidavits on both sides, it seems to me that the relationship between the parties had been so complicated that there may well have been transactions, which are referred to in certain of the letters, in which the plaintiffs' predecessors and the defendants were signing bills and hundis for each other's accommodation. There is an absence of books on the part of the plaintiffs. There is on the other hand a statement on oath that the defendants' books, which of course could have been made available by the plaintiffs, if they had so chosen, to show that the amounts sued for in this suit were not, as between the plaintiffs and the defendants, due from the defendants to the plaintiffs. I think it is quite impossible on the facts of this case to say that there is not a triable issue. We express no sort of view as to whether the defence is good or bad: that will be a matter for the trial judge. But having come to the conclusion that there is a triable issue in this case, it will not be right to say that, as condition of being heard at all, these defendants should find money or security; because, if they are not able to do so, it will be depriving them altogether of a right that they have got of having their case tried. It is only in exceptional cases that the exceptional provisions of O. 37 come into operation, to the extent of depriving a man of this right. In cases of this sort, the Court has to find, if there is any plausible defence and where there is one, effect must be given to that fact and leave to defend should be granted and it should be made conditional, only in cases, where there appears to be so grave a suspicion that the Court comes to the conclusion that the defence is put in, only in order to obtain further time.

    In these circumstances, this appeal must be allowed and leave to defend the suit must be granted. I think the proper order in this case is that the costs of the Original Application and of this Appeal shall be costs in the cause. Written statement in 14 days.

    Ramesam, J.—I agree.

    C.KAppeal allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    K.V. Periya Miyana Marakayar & Sons v. P.K. Subramania Iyer
    (Nov 5, 1923)