Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Provided Legal Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The question referred to the court was whether, on the facts of the case, any presumption as to the receipt of profits can be raised and, if it can, whether that presumption has been rebutted.

The assessee carried on a business in Rangoon and was sole proprietor of a business in Ipoh; he was also a partner in another money-lending business. In 1926 sums totalling Rs. 4,10,000 were sent from Ipoh to the petitioner in Rangoon. The Income-tax authorities assessed that sum of Rs. 4,10,000 as a remittance of foreign profits to British India and levied income-tax of approximately Rs. 91,262. The assessment remained in place and the petitioner paid about Rs. 91,262 to the Income-tax authorities.

In February–March 1927 the Rangoon business remitted nearly the same total (Rs. 4,08,662) back to Ipoh. To pay the income-tax, the assessee sent Rs. 91,262-14-0 from Ipoh by telegram on 27 April 1928; the receipt was entered in Rangoon books on 28 April 1928 and debited to suspense account on 9 May 1928.

The assessee's claim was that the Rs. 91,262 used to pay tax in Rangoon came from a fund which had already been subjected to tax (i.e., the Rs. 4,10,000 previously sent and taxed), and therefore could not be taxed again. The Income-tax Commissioner concluded that the funds remitted from Rangoon to Ipoh had been re-invested with constituents and were not available when the tax payment was made.

The reference to the court was answered in favour of the Income-tax Commissioner; costs of Rs. 250 were awarded to the Commissioner. The opinion is delivered by Sundaram Chetty, J., with Burn, J. and another Judge agreeing.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether on the facts any presumption as to the receipt of profits can be raised (i.e., whether a remittance received in British India from another country should presumptively be treated as being out of profits).
  2. If such a presumption arises, whether that presumption has been rebutted by the particulars of this case (notably the assessee's own book entries showing reinvestment and timing of payments).

Arguments of the Parties

Assessee's Arguments

  • The assessee contended that tax had already been paid on the Rs. 4,10,000 remitted from Ipoh to Rangoon in 1926, so that that fund was a tax-paid (or "tax-free" for present purposes) fund in his hands at Ipoh when money later moved back from Rangoon to Ipoh.
  • On that basis the assessee argued that, where a person has two funds — one already subjected to income-tax and another still liable to income-tax — there is a presumption that payments will be made out of the fund already subjected to tax rather than out of the fund still liable to tax. The assessee relied on this "overriding" presumption and asked the court to hold it unrebutted here.
  • The assessee also relied upon a passage in Sugden v. Leeds Corporation (6 T.C. 211) (a Lord Chancellor's observation) to the effect that if payments properly payable out of profits are in fact defrayed out of some other source of income, that does not affect the right to retain the amount of tax deducted; this passage was invoked to support the assessee's position that book entries showing payments from one source do not necessarily prove the payments were actually made from that source for tax purposes.

Income-tax Commissioner's Position (as reflected in the opinion)

  • The Income-tax Commissioner found on the assessee's own books that the sums remitted from Rangoon to Ipoh (total Rs. 4,08,662) were, when received, re-invested with constituents and thus were not in the hands of the assessee at the time the tax payment (Rs. 91,262) was made.
  • On the Commissioner's view, the book entries showed that with the exception of a very small amount, the whole of the Rs. 4,08,662 was re-invested by 28 March 1927 and therefore could not have provided the Rs. 91,262 paid on 27 April 1928.
  • Implicitly, the Commissioner relied upon the assessee's own ledger entries as adequate to rebut any presumption that the later remittance was from a previously taxed fund, and thereby to sustain the assessment treating the remittance as arising from profits liable to tax.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sugden v. Leeds Corporation, 6 T.C. 211 The passage relied on: if payments properly payable out of profits are defrayed out of some other source of income, that does not affect the right to retain the amount of tax deducted (Lord Haldane's observation). The court considered the passage but held it inapplicable to the facts of this case. The court rejected the contention that the passage prevents the Income-tax authorities from relying on the assessee's books to show the payments did not come from the taxed fund.
Subbiah Aiyar v. The Commissioner of Income-tax (Quilon), Madras (1930) 58 M.L.J. 602 (F.B.) Book entries showing the remittance was of capital (and where the genuineness of those entries is not challenged) can rebut the ordinary presumption that a remittance to British India was out of profits. The court cited this case as authority supporting the proposition that book entries can rebut the ordinary presumption. The opinion used the Quilon case to show that if entries are genuine and unchallenged they are circumstances properly relied upon to rebut the presumption that a remittance is out of profits.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by accepting the ordinary presumption: when money is received in British India from another country, there is an ordinary presumption that the remittance is out of profits. The narrow question was whether that presumption arose here and, if it did, whether it had been rebutted.

Key factual findings (based on the assessee's own ledger entries) drove the court's legal analysis:

  • Detailed ledger entries recorded remittances from Rangoon to Ipoh on specific dates in February–March 1927 (totalling Rs. 4,08,662).
  • On each of those same dates the books showed virtually identical sums were advanced or lent to constituents (re-invested) so that by 28 March 1927, with negligible exceptions, the entire Rs. 4,08,662 was re-invested and no longer in the hands of the assessee.
  • The tax payment (Rs. 91,262) was made on 27 April 1928, at which time, according to the books, the money remitted earlier remained invested and therefore could not have been the source of the tax payment.

From these facts the court reasoned as follows:

  1. Although an ordinary presumption arises that remittances to British India are from profits, that presumption is not irrebuttable. It can be rebutted by adequate evidence.
  2. The assessee's own ledger entries constituted admissions which directly contradicted the assessee's contention that the tax payment came out of the previously taxed remitted fund. Those entries therefore rebuffed any presumption favouring the assessee's theory.
  3. The court rejected the attempt to treat an asserted presumption in favour of using a taxed fund for payments (i.e., that a taxpayer will always choose a taxed fund over an untaxed fund) as an overriding or irrebuttable presumption. Accepting such an irrebuttable presumption would be contrary to law.
  4. The court held that the passage from Sugden v. Leeds Corporation did not assist the assessee on these facts and could not be applied to negate the probative effect of the assessee's own book entries.
  5. The Quilon case (Subbiah Aiyar) was cited as consistent authority for the proposition that unchallenged book entries can rebut the ordinary presumption that remittances are out of profits; the court treated that authority as supportive of permitting the Income-tax authorities to rely on the assessee's own books to rebut the presumption advanced by the assessee.

Accordingly, the court concluded that, on the evidence of the ledger entries and the timing, the Rs. 91,262 paid to discharge the assessment did not come out of the fund which the assessee alleged had already been taxed.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court answered the reference in favour of the Income-tax Commissioner. Costs of Rs. 250 were awarded to the Commissioner.

Implications:

  • The direct effect on the parties is that the Income-tax Commissioner's finding — that the remittance and the tax payment were not from the previously taxed fund — was upheld. The assessment treating the remittance as taxable (and the tax already paid by the assessee) stands as sustained by the court's answer to the reference.
  • The court emphasized that the ordinary presumption that a remittance is out of profits is rebuttable and that the assessee's own book entries may be relied on to rebut such a presumption. The opinion does not assert that any new binding legal principle beyond this application was established; it treats prior authorities (including the Quilon decision) as supportive and distinguishes the Sugden passage on the facts. No novel or sweeping irrebuttable presumption was created by this decision.

Judicial authorship: Opinion delivered by Sundaram Chetty, J.; concurred in by Burn, J. and another Judge (names as in the provided opinion).

    M.S.M.M Meyyappa Chettiar Petitioner (Assessee). v. The Commissioner Of Income-Tax, Madras (Referring Officer).

    1. The question referred to us is -

    Whether on the facts of this case any presumption as to the receipt of profits can be raised and, if it can, whether the presumption has not been rebutted.

    2. The facts of the case which can be stated quite shortly are as follows : The assessee carries on a business in Rangoon; and in Ipoh he is the sole proprietor of a business, which at the material times it is alleged by the assessee earned no profit at all, and he is also a partner in another money-lending business with other persons which did result in a profit at the material times. In 1926 sums of money amounting to Rs. 4,10,000 were sent from Ipoh to Rangoon to the petitioner there, the last sum being a sum received in December, 1926. In the Rangoon books there is a ledger account for Ipoh and in Ipoh there is a ledger account for Rangoon and money passing, from one place to the other is set out in the respective ledger accounts. The Income-tax authorities assessed that sum of Rs. 4,10,000 received from Ipoh by the petitioner in Rangoon to income-tax as being a remittance of foreign profits to British India and levied an income-tax of Rs. 91,262 odd upon it. The matter came before the High Court on a reference and the reference was answered against the petitioner (the same petitioner here) apparently not upon the merits but for some other reason; so that that assessment remains and a sum of Rs. 91,262 odd has been paid by the petitioner to the Income-tax authorities; and the question before us is, where did that sum of money come from?

    3. Now it appears and it is quite plainly proved from the assessee's own books that in February and March, 1927, a large sum of money very nearly equivalent to the sum sent by Ipoh to Rangoon the previous year was sent by Rangoon to Ipoh, the total amount being Rs. 4,08,662. In order to pay the income-tax levied by the'Income-tax authorities the assessee sent from Ipoh Rs. 91,262-14-0 by telegram from the Chartered Bank on the 27th April, 1928, and the receipt of that sum was duly entered in the Rangoon books as a credit on the 28th April, 1928, and as a debit to the suspense account on the 9th May, 1928. The petitioner's case here is that tax having been paid on the Rs. 4,10,000 sent from Ipoh to Rangoon in 1926 that was a tax-free fund and that tax-free fund or amount was sent back to Ipoh where there was that tax-free fund or, tax-paid fund in the hands of the assessee and in addition to that there was another fund which was a profit fund which of course would be liable to income-tax. We are not deciding here whether the money sent from Rangoon to Ipoh was in fact the money sent from Ipoh to Rangoon the previous year. We are dealing with this reference merely on the assumption that it was. The assessee's endeavour here and before the Income-tax Commissioner was to show that the Rs. 91,262 odd sent from Ipoh to Rangoon with which to pay the income-tax levied came out of the tax-paid or tax-free fund in his hands at Ipoh. Had he been able to prove any such thing as that, then, in our opinion, he would have been entitled to maintain that, as the fund had already been taxed, this sum of Rs. 91,262 odd could not be taxed again because that sum has been assessed to income-tax by the Income-tax Commissioner as a remittance received in British India out of profits of the foreign firm at Ipoh. We are asked to say that the presumption that a remittance is out of profits has been rebutted here, the ordinary presumption being that, when money is received in British India from another country, the remittance is out of profits. The assessee however contends that an overriding presumption in their favour has been raised and that is that where there are two funds at the disposal of a person, one a fund upon which income-tax has been levied and another fund which is still liable to income-tax the presumption is that the former will be drawn upon to make payments and not the latter and that this presumption has not been rebutted in this case. What do the entries in the assessee's account books at Ipoh show? The Income-tax Commissioner has found that the whole of the money sent from Rangoon to Ipoh, namely, Rs. 4,08,662, was, when it was received in Ipoh, re-invested with constituents and that, that being so, the assessee cannot be heard to say that the Rs. 91,262 odd remitted by him from Ipoh to Rangoon for the purpose of paying income-tax came out of that fund. The following are the entries to be found in the books of the assessee : On the 17th February, 1927, a sum of Rs. 77,250,, equivalent to $50,000, was remitted by the Rangoon business to the Ipoh business; on the 26th February, 1927, a sum of Rs. 1,00,912, equivalent to $65,000, was remitted; on the 4th March, 1927, a sum of Rs. 93,000, equivalent to $60,000, was remitted; on the 11th March, 1927, a sum of Rs. 77,500, equivalent to $50,000, was remitted; and finally on the 28th March, 1927, a sum of Rs. 60,000, equivalent to $38,799, was remitted, making a total of Rs. 4,08,662. Let us see how these sums of money were dealt with and the dates upon which they were. On the 17th February, 1927, the same date on which the sum of $50,000 was received, an identical sum was advanced to a constituent; on the 26th February, 1927, the date on which the sum of $65,000 was received, similarly an identical sum was lent out to somebody in Penang; on the 4th March, 1927, the same date on which the sum of $60,000 was received, a sum of $59,000 was advanced to a constituent and a sum of $1,000'was advanced to another, making a total of $60,000; on the 11th March, 1927, the same date on which the sum of $50,000 was received, an identical amount was lent out to a constituent in Penang; and on the 28th March, 1927, the same date upon which the sum of $38,799 was received, a sum of $38,803 was advanced to another constituent; so that, with the exception of a very small amount, the whole of the Rs. 4,08,662 was by the 28th March, 1927, re-invested with other constituents and was no longer in the hands of the assessee. We have got to consider again the date upon which the remittance in order to pay income-tax took place. That was on the 27th April, 1928. At that time according to the books the whole of the money received from Rangoon was still invested with the constituents of the assessee's firm. Therefore, upon the assessee's own showing and by reason of the entries made in his own books, presumably made upon instructions by the agent who was carrying on the business there, none of the Rs. 91,262 odd ever came out of the fund remitted from Rangoon to Ipoh. That being so, it is obvious that it did not come out of the fund upon which income-tax had already been paid. But in spite of these very clear entries which are admissions completely destructive of the assessee's case, we are asked to say that they cannot be taken as evidence of the fact that this sum of money received from Rangoon was not intact in the hands of the assessee and that the Rs. 91,262 odd did not come out of it. In support of this contention a passage in the judgment of the Lord Chancellor, Lord Haldane, in Sugden v. Leeds Corporation 6 T.C. 211, was relied upon. The passage referred to is at page 253 and it is as follows:

    If the annual payments would properly have been payable out of profits, but the person bound to make them has chosen to defray them out of some other source of income, this does not affect his right to retain the amount of tax he has deducted.

    4. We are told that in that case the Leeds Corporation in their books of account had shown that sums of money had been paid out of certain sources of income, that they had the right to make the payments out of another fund or another source of income and that in spite of their accounts showing that they had made these payments out of a certain source, they were entitled to say thereafter that the payments were made out of another fund. Whatever may be the facts of that case, I cannot for one moment think that that observation of the Lord Chancellor can have any application to the facts of this case. It is argued, of course, that here there is the certain presumption, that is to say, that where a person has a fund in his hands which has already been subjected to income-tax and another fund in his hands which is liable to income-tax, if he is called upon to make any payment in the course of his business or otherwise, he is much more likely to make the payment out of the fund which has already been taxed rather than out of the fund which remains to be taxed. That may be a reasonable presumption to draw but, in my view, this is not a case at all of drawing any presumption. No presumption of the kind suggested by the assessee arises here, in view of the fact that we have got the book entries of the assessee himself which clearly show that the remittance of of Rs. 91,262 odd was not made out of a fund which had already been subjected to income-tax. There were profits in the Ipoh business and the ordinary presumption arises therefore that there being profits more than sufficient or sufficient to cover the amount of the sum remitted, the remittance of Rs. 91,262 odd was a remittance from the profits of Ipoh business. To allow the contention of the assessee here would be to say that where a person has two funds in his possession, one of them being a fund which has been subjected to income-tax and the other being a fund which remains to be taxed, the presumption that any remittance he makes is out of the one already subjected to tax can never be rebutted, or it is an irrebuttable presumption. That of course cannot possibly be the law. In this case even if that presumption had arisen, it would be clearly rebutted by the book entries of the assessee himself. In what other way can the Income-tax authorities rebut such a presumption? If they are not to be allowed to pray in aid the book entries made by the assessee himself or by his agent, it is very difficult to see how they can possibly rebut the presumption which is sought to be raised in aid of the assessee here.

    5. Another case, namely, the Quilon case, Subbiah Aiyar v. The Commissioner of Income-tax, Madras (1930) 58 M.L.J. 602 (F.B.), was referred to. There the facts that book entries had been made by the assessee, that the payments made from Quilon to British India were out of current account, that the book entries made by the assessee in his British India books showed that the remittance was of capital and that the genuineness of those entries was not challenged were taken as circumstances rebutting the ordinary presumption which arose that the remittance from Quilon to British India was a remittance out of profits. It is an amazing contention that though an assessee can avail himself of book entries in order to rebut such a presumption, the income-tax authorities are not similarly entitled to rely upon book entries to rebut any other presumptions which may arise or which may be raised in favour of an assessee.

    6. Under these circumstances, our answer to the question referred to us must be in favour of the Income-tax Commissioner. Costs Rs. 250 to the Commissioner.

    Sundaram Chetty, J.

    7. I agree.

    Burn, J.

    8. I agree.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    M.S.M.M Meyyappa Che... v. The Commissioner Of ...
    (Aug 30, 1932)