Following the ruling in Karunakara v. Krishna, which takes a strict view of O. 21, R. 89 and holds that the terms of the rule should be “very strictly conformed to” I think this petition must be allowed. The 1st defendant did not deposit in Court the amount stated in the proclamation and the 5 per cent, himself. He is not entitled to take advantage of any deposit, made by his co-judgment debtor or the defendant, which was not made conjointly with him but quite independently of him. Such a deposit in Court cannot be treated as money received by the decree-holder within the meaning of the rule so as to enable the respondent to take advantage of it; see Trimbak v. Ramchandra(2), followed in Karunakara v. Krishna cited above.
In these circumstances I must hold that the provisions of R. 89 has not been complied with by the respondent and the order setting aside the sale of item No. 1 must be reversed. The order of the District Judge is set aside and that of the Subordinate Judge is restored with costs here and the Courts below.
C. K.Petition allowed.