Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The sale in question was proclaimed to be held by the Central Nazir of the Cuddalore District on 10 July 1919 and was held on that date. On the evening of the sale the judgment-debtor informed the Court that bidders had not come and later brought to the Nazir's attention that the process-server had proclaimed the sale as to be held by the District Munsif's Court of Villupuram instead of by the Central Nazir at Cuddalore. The Court, on 11 July 1919, cancelled the sale of three items (including items 2 and 3 purchased by the appellants), directed refund of purchasers' deposits and ordered a fresh sale to be held on 20 August on a fresh proclamation. It appears the appellant was not informed of the cancellation; he paid the remainder of the purchase-money into Court on 24 July 1919 and on 12 August 1919 applied for confirmation of sale and grant of a sale certificate. The decree-holder contested confirmation and contended the sale should be set aside and a resale ordered. The Lower Court passed an order (now under appeal) setting aside the sale under Order 21, Rule 90 of the Code on the ground of a material irregularity in publishing the sale proclamation. The appellate Court reviewed the matter, treating earlier irregular procedures separately, and examined the order on its merits.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the error in publication of the sale proclamation (process-server naming a different selling officer and place of sale) amounted to a mere irregularity under Order 21, Rule 90, or to an illegality that invalidated the sale entirely.
  2. Whether, having found the publication to be defective in the village, the Lower Court's order setting aside the sale should be confirmed and the appeal dismissed.

Arguments of the Parties

Judgment-Debtor's Representations

  • The judgment-debtor informed the Court on the evening of the sale that bidders had not come.
  • The judgment-debtor also brought to the Nazir's attention that the process-server had proclaimed that the sale would be held by a different selling officer (District Munsif's Court of Villupuram) rather than by the Central Nazir at Cuddalore.

Decree-Holder's Position (as to confirmation application)

  • On notice of the purchaser's application for confirmation (12 August 1919), the decree-holder contended that the sale should be set aside, that a resale should be ordered, and that the purchaser's petition for confirmation should be dismissed.

Appellant's (Purchaser's) Counsel — Mr. Krishnaswami Aiyar

  • Referred to a number of authorities addressing, in particular cases, whether specific facts constituted irregularities or illegalities; argued by analogy to those authorities in support of the appellant's position.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Krishnaji v. Bomanji Consideration of distinction between irregularity and illegality; cited for discussion of degree-based distinction. The Court expressed doubt about the correctness of the main conclusion in that case but relied on Mr. Justice Heaton's observation that the question is one of degree — supporting the view that some irregularities, depending on severity, can amount to illegality.
Basharutull(a) v. Uma Charan Dutt (Basharutulla v. Uma Churn Dutt) Where a sale advertised for a particular date was held at an earlier hour than that stated, the proclamation and holding of sale at the time and place advertised are conditions precedent to a sale under the Code; if violated, the property never had been sold under the Code. The Court regarded this authority as closely analogous and held that misleading publication which diverts bidders to a different place amounts to the sale never having been conducted under the Code — supporting a finding of illegality/nullity.
Trimbak Ravji v. Nana Omission to beat the drum (one mode of proclamation) regarded as only an irregularity in some cases. The Court noted that omission to beat the drum was held only an irregularity and distinguished that situation from the present case where village proclamation (the critical mode) failed.
T. R. Arunachalam Chetty v. V. R. R. M. A. R. Arunachalam Chetty Misdescription of property can be a mere irregularity; the Judicial Committee in that case relied on estoppel where the judgment-debtor was present and acquiesced. The Court observed that this case (and the estoppel principle applied) is distinguishable because there was no similar acquiescence in the present case; the authority does not support a broad rule that such defects are never illegality.
Nana Kumar Roy v. Golam Chunder Dey Proclamation in the Collector's Office (as opposed to village proclamation) — different impact on bidders; modes of proclamation are not equivalent in practical effect. The Court rejected the argument that proclamation in different official places should be treated the same, holding that failure to proclaim in the village is far more serious because that is where prospective bidders gather.
Rang Lal Singh v. Ravaneshwar Pershad Singh Sale held some days after the date mentioned in proclamation constituted merely an irregularity where the local circumstances meant bidders were aware of the adjournment; not every deviation vitiates sale absent proof of substantial loss. The Court treated this case as distinguishable because there local awareness made the deviation only an irregularity; it is not authority for cases where there was no proclamation relating to the place actually used.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The appellate Court proceeded by first acknowledging the procedural irregularities in the Lower Court's handling but chose to decide the present appeal on the merits of the order passed after notice and opportunity to produce evidence (the order arising from the purchaser's 12 August 1919 application).

The Lower Court had found that the sale proclamation, as framed, was not published in the village: the process-server, through carelessness or otherwise, substituted a different selling officer and place of sale in the village proclamation. The Lower Court treated this as a material irregularity under Order 21, Rule 90 and also found that the decree-holder sustained substantial injury.

The appellate Court accepted the factual finding that the village proclamation did not correctly identify the selling officer/place. However, the Court declined to treat the defect merely as an irregularity. It analyzed the distinction between "irregularity" and "illegality" and concluded that the process-server's substitution produced not just an irregularity but an illegality, because it undermined the publicity that secures fairness in public sales.

The Court relied on the reasoning in Basharutulla v. Uma Churn Dutt, where publication errors that defeated the conditions precedent for sale meant the property had never been sold under the Code. The Court reasoned that when a proclamation is misleading in a way that diverts potential bidders to a place where the sale is not to be held, publicity — a main safeguard for fair sales — is destroyed and the sale must be treated as never having been conducted under the Code.

Justice Seshagiri Aiyar (concurring) complemented this analysis by referring to O.21, R.90, which permits setting aside a sale for material irregularity or fraud; he inferred that where there was no effective publication at all (as in this case in the village), the sale should be regarded as illegal. He contrasted the present facts with authorities where omissions (e.g., not beating a drum) were only irregularities and with cases where misdescription plus acquiescence led to estoppel; those authorities were distinguished on their facts because they did not involve failure of village proclamation that would deter bidders from attending.

On balance, both judges found that a substantial provision of the statutory procedure (publication in the village such that bidders would attend) had been violated and that the violation had the effect of preventing attendance by persons who would otherwise bid. Therefore the sale was illegal/null and the Lower Court's order setting it aside was justified.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The order of the Lower Court is confirmed and the appeal is dismissed.

Direct consequences for the parties:

  • The sale is treated as having been illegally conducted and consequently as not having been a sale under the Code (i.e., it is void/null).
  • The Lower Court's earlier directions (including cancellation of the sale and refund of purchasers' deposits, as ordered on 11 July 1919) are consistent with that finding and are sustained by the confirmation of the order under appeal.
  • The Court made no order as to costs in this Court.

Broader implications: The Court reiterated that the distinction between an irregularity and an illegality is largely one of degree and depends on factual circumstances — particularly whether the defect in proclamation defeats the publicity necessary to attract bidders. The opinion applies existing authorities to the facts rather than purporting to lay down a new general rule.

    Jayarama Aiyar v. Vridhigiri Aiyar

    Oldfield, J, — These proceedings were marked in the Lower Court by grave irregularities; and it is the more necessary that in correcting these irregularities, we should be careful to do nothing which would inflict unfair prejudice on either party.

    The sale, which is the subject of these proceedings was according to the proclamation to be held by the Central Nazir of the Cuddalore District on 10th July 1919 and it was held accordingly. On the evening of that day, the judgment-debtor represented to the Court that bidders had not come and that the sale was open to objection on other grounds, with which we are not concerned. Afterwards, and this was material in connection with the representation that bidders had not come, he brought to the notice of the Nazir that the process-server charged with the duty of making the proclamation in the village had proclaimed that the sale would be held not by the Central Nazir at Cuddalore, but by the District Munsif's Court of Villupuram. This communication from the judgment-debtor to the Nazir was brought to the notice of the court on the next day, 11th July 1919, and I am constrained to express my disapproval of the Court's method of doing business, by accepting representation of this kind made by a subordinate officer. Such complaints should be considered by the Court, only when they are made to it in open Court in the usual way.

    The Court then, however, at once cancelled the sale of the three items of property which had been sold the previous day, of which the second and third items, those purchased by the appellants are the subject of the present appeal. It also directed the refund to the purchasers of their deposits and lastly it ordered that a fresh sale should be held on the 20th August, on a fresh proclamation. It does not appear that any communication of these orders was made, at all events at the time, to the present appellant; for, on the 24th July 1919, he paid into Court the remainder of the purchase-money due by him and on the 12th August 1919, applied for confirmation of sale and the grant of sale certificate; and again this cancellation of the sale was obviously an irregularity of considerable moment.

    On the 29th July 1919, the Court had obtained a draft proclamation apparently from the decree-holder and altered the date fixed for sale to 4th September 1919. Later, it may be said that as regards items other than 2 and 3, to which I shall return, the Court passed an order that the original sale should be continued, as it was the Court's own fault that it was not held properly; and as properly speaking there was no sale; and later on, the sale was stopped by an order of this Court dated 6th November 1919.

    To go back to items 2 and 3, on the purchaser's application or confirmation of sale and sale certificate, of 12th August 1919, notice was issued to the decree-holder, who contended that the sale should be set aside, that a resale should be ordered and that the purchaser's petition should be dismissed; and in these proceedings the order now under appeal was passed.

    It is material that there has, in this case, been an order (now appealed against), which was passed after notice to all concerned and it was passed after every opportunity had been given for the production of evidence. In these circumstances, greatly as we must regret the irregular manner in which the then District Judge Mr. Edgington, passed the order by which the sale was in the first instance set aside, we think we can disregard that order aqd deal with the matter simply with reference to what happened afterwards in connection with the application of 12th August 1919. As I have pointed out, there was no prejudice to the appellant, the purchaser, or to any one else, owing to any omission of the Court to hear them or to take evidence. These proceedings were perfectly regular and we therefore examine the order now under appeal simply on its merits and without regard to what had happened at the earlier stage.

    The order under appeal purports to be passed under O. 21, R. 90, on the ground of a material irregularity in publishing the sale proclamation. We have been shown no valid objection to the Lower Court's finding that the sale proclamation, as it was framed by the Court, was not published in the village. The process-server owing to carelessness or some other reason substituted for the selling officer and place of sale fixed by the Court a different selling office and a different place of sale. Besides finding that this occurred and that it was an irregularity, the Court has also, as R. 90 requires found that the plaintiff, decree-holder, sustained substantial injury, by reason of that irregularity. We do not think it necessary to follow the Lower Court in that part of its order, because we do not think that R. 90 is applicable at all. The mistake, so to describe it, made by the process-server resulted not in any irregularity, but in an illegality which invalidated the proceedings.

    Mr. Krishnaswami Aiyar on behalf of the appellant had referred to a number of authorities dealing with the facts in particular cases, which were, or were not, held to constitute irregularities or illegalities. It is unnecessary to go through those cases, because the decision in each rested on the facts in it and because it does not appear that any general rule for distinguishing between an irregularity and an illegality has even been laid down. It would appear, in fact, that the distinction is one of degree and that an irregularity of so serious a nature as to render impossible the publicity which affords one main security for the fairness of public sales, must be deemed to be an illegality. This view, that the question is one of degree, is implicit, it seems to me, in the judgment of Mr. Justice Heat on in Krishnaji v. Bomanji and although 1 am doubtful as to the correctness of the man conclusion reached by the learned Judges in that case, I avail myself of the support, which the view 1 take receives from Mr. Justice Heaton's observation that, although the facts before him did not constitute such an illegality as would render the sale in question void, yet he wished at the same time to be clearly understood not to ignore that in other cases there might be other circumstances, which, combined with similar ones, would amount to an illegality, such as the Court could act on.

    The nearest case perhaps to the facts before us is Basharutull v. Uma Charan Dutt. There the property that had been advertised for a particular date was sold on that date, but at an earlier hour than that stated in the proclamation and the Court said that in those circumstances it seemed to it that there was no sale within the meaning of the Code and that the proclamation of the time and place and the holding of the sale at such time and place advertised were conditions precedent to its being a sale under the Code at all. It appeared to the Court that the property never had been sold under the Code and consequently the plaintiff was entitled to a declaration that whatever took place when the property was put up for sale had no effect as against him. It seems to me that, if, when a proclamation was made, any of the usual and effective methods prescribed or permitted by the Code for its publication has been misleading as to details of the matter proclaimed and has been such as not merely not to give information to possible bidders, but to divert them to a place, where the sale is not to be held, the result must be in the words of Basharutulla v. Uma Churn Dutt, that the property had never been sold under the Code at all.

    In these circumstances the Order of the Lower Court must be confirmed and the appeal dismissed. As regards the question of costs we bear in mind that the decree-holder and the judgment-debtor were in fact present during the sale and apparently it was not until the sale was concluded that the latter made any objection to the manner in which it had been proclaimed or conducted. There is then the fact that throughout the proceedings, apparently without objection from the decree-holder, who ordinarily would have their direction, have been carried on in the highly irregular manner, to which we have referred. In these circumstances we think that we are jurtified in making no order as to costs in this Court.

    Seshagiri Aiyar, J.—I entirely agree. The facts have been fully stated by my learned brother. The question for consideration in whether the Court sale should be regarded as having been irregularly conducted, or whether it was illegal. As this point was argued with some insistence by Mr. Krishnaswami Aiyar, I propose to say a few words on it.

    The Code itself gives some indication as to when a sale can be regarded as irregular and when illegal. In O. 21, R. 90, which permits an aggrieved party to come to Court to set aside a sale, the language employed is that it may be set aside on the ground of material irregularity, or fraud in publishing or conducting it. Where there is no publication or conduct of the sale, it is, I think, a right inference to draw from R. 90 that the sale should be regarded as illegal. In the present case, on the facts which my learned brother has fully stated my conclusion is that there has been no publication at all. If a sale is held at a place to which the proclamation at the village makes no reference and per contra invites bidders to go to another place, I a prepared to hold that there was no proclamation leading up to sale. Mr. Krishnaswami Aiyar drew our attention to cases where there has been no beating of drum and it was held that such a mistake should be regarded, only as an irregularity. As Mr. Chandrasekhara Aiyar pointed out, under the rules it is not obligatory to beat the drum and the proclamation may be made in any other manner, which the people of the village are accustomed to hear. Therefore the decision in Trimbak Ravji v. Nana that the omission to beat the drum is only an irregularity does not affect the present case.

    The present case, I agree with my learned brother, is practically covered by the authority of Basharutulla v. Uma Churn Dutt(2). In that case, the question was, whether if a sale was held at an hour anterior to the one mentioned in the proclamation, the sale was irregularly conducted, or whether it was illegally held. The learned Judges came to the conclusion that there was a violation of the fundamental condition of the sale, namely, the time of sale, and that consequently the sale was a nullity. The same argument can be used with reference to a sale held at a place different from the one mentioned in the proclamation.

    I concede that it is not easy to draw the line between an irregularity, and an illegality, but I am clear that where a substantial provision of law has been violated and that has the effeet of not attracting persons who could be expected to be present, for the purpose of bidding at the sale, the sale should be regarded as having been illegally conducted. As regards the decision chiefly relied on by Mr. Krishnaswami Aiyar, namely Krishnaji v. Bomanji, I agree with my learned brother in dissenting from the conclusion reached in that case. Mr. Justice Chandavarkar bases his conclusion mainly on T. R. Arunachalam Chetty v. V. R R. M. A. R. Arunachalam Chetty. In the latter case, the Judicial Committee had before it a case of misdescription of property and their Lordships were of opinion that a mere misdescription would be only an irregularity. Their Lordships laid stress on the fact that the judgment-debtor was throughout present and acquiesced in the irregularity, and that when he found that there was no other means of vacating the order, he resorted to this expedient of setting aside the sale. The principle on which their Lordships rested their decision was estoppel. There is no such question in this case. I do not think that case is an authority for the broad proposition, which Chandavarkar, J., had deduced in Krishnaji v. Bomanji.

    In Nana Kumar Roy v. Golam Chunder Dey(3), the proclamation was in the Collector's Office. Mr. Krishnaswami Aiyar argued that as the proclamation in the Court or in the Collector's Office and the proclamation in the village are all mentioned together in the Code, no distinction should be drawn between one mode of proclamation and another. I am unable to agree with him. The failure to proclaim in the Collector's Office will not have as serious an affect on bidders as the failure to proclaim in the village. It is in the latter place that people, who are likely to purchase, will gather. That is the most important part of the procedure relating to proclamation; and if it is violated, such a violation does not stand upon the same footing, as the failure to affix a copy of the proclamation, in the Collector's Office. There is only one other decision to which reference may be made and that is Rang Lal Singh v. Ravaneshwar Pershad Singh(4). In that case the Judicial Committee had to consider a case of sale, which was held some days after the date mentioned in the proclamation. The facts of that case make it clear that that was a case of merely irregularity. That sale itself was being adjourned from day to day and ultimately it was fixed for the day on which the usual Court sales were held. That was the 13th July. On the 13th July the presiding Officer happened to be absent on leave and the sate was held on the day when he returned. The people in the locality were apparently aware that in consequence of the absence of the presiding officer, the monthly sales would not be held on the usual day but would be held immediately on the return of the presiding officer. On these facts, the Judicial Committee Came to the conclusion that there was only an irregularity and that it would not vitiate the sale, unless substantial loss was proved. That case is no authority for this case, where there was no proclamation relating to the place, where the sale was actually held.

    For these reasons, I agree that the order of Mr. Stodart is right and that this appeal must be dismissed.

    C. K.Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Jayarama Aiyar v. Vridhigiri Aiyar
    (Apr 14, 1920)