Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges

    Ramasami Pattar v. Mankurisi Variath Lakshmi Varassiar

    Ramesam, J. — The suit was brought to recover certain lands, known as Kunnathupadam lands on the ground that they belong in Jenm to the Kurichimalai Devaswom represented by the 1st plaintiff; that they were granted to the 1st defendant on condition of rendering Kazhagam service in the temple, that he has ceased to render Kazhagam service and hence the lands are liable to be resumed; that the 1st defendant's right in the lands was sold in execution of a decree (O. S. No. 25 of 1915) and purchased by the 2nd and 3rd defendants; and that the 1st defendant though called upon to surrender the lands failed to do so.

    The defendants plead that the lands were not held on condition of rendering Kazhagam service and were not resumable.

    I will now refer to the previous litigations bearing on the tenure under which the suit lands were held. In 1851 the predecessor-in-title of the 1st plaintiff sued the predecessor-in-title of the 1st defendant for possession of the same lands on practically the same allegations; but the suit was compromised. Ex. B was the petition of compromise in which it was stated that “the lands and paramba involved in the above suit had been given away long time back as offering (Vazhipadu) and as Uuruyilydakam for the Kuruchimala Thevar (deity) to the Kurichimala Variyam of the 1st and 3rd to 6th defendants who are the Karaima Kazhakam holders of the temple”. It then proceeds to state that 1st plaintiff executed a deed of consent “to the effect that the said properties may be held and enjoyed on Saswatham right after conducting the offerings, (Vazhipadu) in future”. The deed referred to in this petition is Ex. A. the operative words in which are “you are to hold the said properties for ever as Saswatham as in the past and to enjoy the same conducting Vazhipadu to the deity.” In my opinion the tenure on which the suit lands are held depend on the construction of Ex. A.

    In O. S. No. 501 of 1890 the present 1st defendant and other members of his tarwad obtained a decree against the then karnavan of the plaintiff's tarwad for wages for Kazhagam service and O. S. No. 152 of 1892 was filed by the junior members of the plaintiff's tarwad for declaring that as the defendants held the present suit lands as wages for Kazhagam service, the decree in O. S. No. 501 of 1890 was improperly obtained. It was found that the present suit lands were not held as wages for Kazhagam service but for utilizing the income for the nivadyam in the temple. The Courts below relying on the latter part of this finding and considering that Nivadayam is a kind of Kazhagam held that the suit land is held on condition of performing Kazhagam service and decreed the plaintiff's suit as the 1st defendant has ceased to perform the services.

    In the first place, it is clear that, as the real issue in O.S No. 152 of 1892 was whether the decree in O.S No. 501 of 1890 was properly obtained and the nature of the tenure of the suit lands arose only incidentally: therefore the decree in O.S No. 152 of 1892 is not res judicata against the plaintiffs on the question whether the suit lands were held for Kazhagam service or not. Still less is it res judicata against defendants on the question whether they were held for any other service. The proper view is thus not to regard the observations in the judgment of O. S. No. 152 of 1892 as finally deciding anything regarding the tenure of the suit lands.

    One point is obvious from the history of the suit lands as set forth above—Viz., that whatever the defendant had to do in connection with the suit lands was certainly not Kazhagam. From 1851 onwards, the defendants always denied that the lands had anything to do with Kazhagam service and they always succeeded in this plea. It is significant that neither Ex. A 1 nor B connects the lands with Kazhagam. Having regard to the terms of Ex. A 1:—“You are to enjoy the same conducting Vazhipadu to the deity” and to the meaning of the terms Vazhipadu in Gundart's Dictionary:—“offering of rice and of which the greater part returns to the donor”, it seems to me that the grant was not at all a service grant. The obligation to make the show of an offering being a nominal obligation seems to be a merely moral one. The burden of founding a resumable tenure is on the grantor: Lakhamgauda v. Keshav Annaji; and the words in Ex. A are too vague to connote a condition on breach of which the lands could be resumed. On a construction of Ex. A1, the 3rd issue ought to be found against the plaintiff. The Second Appeal must be allowed and plaintiff's suit dismissed with costs of appellants throughout.

    Sir William Ayling, J.—I agree.

    S.SAppeal allowed..

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ramasami Pattar v. Mankurisi Variath Lakshmi Varassiar
    (Jan 17, 1923)