AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • rule in 2004 Rules corresponding Rule 3(6) of the Service Tax Credit Rules, 2002. Under Rule 2(l) of the 2004 Rules,
  • Rule 3 read with Rule 2(1) of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004
  • provisions of Rule 16(1) of CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004
  • Rule 16 of CENVAT Credit Rules 2004, the Central
  • Rule 3(6) of the Service Tax Credit Rules, 2002,
  • Rule 9(5) of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004.2.
  • provisions of 2004 Rules, the Central
  • Rule 16 of the 2004 Rules,
  • Rule 3(6) of 2002 Rules,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • rule in 2004 Rules corresponding Rule 3(6) of the Service Tax Credit Rules, 2002. Under Rule 2(l) of the 2004 Rules,
  • Rule 3 read with Rule 2(1) of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004
  • provisions of Rule 16(1) of CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004
  • Rule 16 of CENVAT Credit Rules 2004, the Central
  • Rule 3(6) of the Service Tax Credit Rules, 2002,
  • Rule 9(5) of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004.2.
  • provisions of 2004 Rules, the Central
  • Rule 16 of the 2004 Rules,
  • Rule 3(6) of 2002 Rules,
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Oral Judgment per J.P. Devadhar, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

During the period 2006-2007 the respondent-assessee availed CENVAT credit of Service Tax paid on various input services, including mobile phone services. Show cause notices were issued seeking disallowance and recovery of the credit claimed for mobile phone services under the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 ("2004 Rules"). The Assistant Commissioner, Central Excise, Chandrapur, relying on a Central Board of Excise & Customs' circular dated 23-08-2007, dropped the proceedings by an order dated 26-10-2007. On appeal by the Revenue, the Commissioner (Appeals), Central Excise, Nagpur, by order dated 19-02-2008, dismissed the Revenue's appeal following various Tribunal decisions. The Customs, Excise & Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT) by its impugned order dated 02-06-2009 dismissed the Revenue's further appeal, inter alia following the Gujarat High Court decision in Commissioner of Central Excise v. Excel Crop Care Ltd., 2008 (12) STR 436. The present appeal challenges the Tribunal's order dated 02-06-2009.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Hon'ble CESTAT was correct in holding that the credit of Service Tax paid on Mobile Phone service is allowable especially when the Circular No. 59/8/2003 dated 20th June, 2003 issued by the Central Board of Excise and Customs under the Service Tax Credit Rules, 2002, restricted such credit, and statutory provisions of Rule 16(1) of CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 stipulates that Board's Circular shall remain in force and valid for deciding the eligibility for Credit under CENVAT Credit Rules 2004.
  2. Whether in the facts and circumstances of the present case the Hon'ble CESTAT was right in holding that the Respondents were entitled to avail Cenvat Credit on Service Tax paid on mobile phones services in terms of Rule 3 read with Rule 2(1) of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 despite the Respondents not having established that the same was in relation to the business activity as envisaged under Rule 9(5) of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004.

Arguments of the Parties

Revenue's Arguments

  • Reliance on Rule 3(6) of the Service Tax Credit Rules, 2002: Service Tax credit was available only in respect of telephone connections installed in the premises from where the output service is provided; thus credit on mobile phones should not be available.
  • Reliance on Central Board of Excise & Customs' Circular dated 20-06-2003 (Circular No. 59/8/2003): The Board had clarified under the 2002 Rules that credit of Service Tax is not available on mobile phones.
  • Reliance on Rule 16 of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004: The 2003 circular in force at the commencement of the 2004 Rules is deemed to be valid and issued under the corresponding provisions of the 2004 Rules; therefore the 2003 circular's restriction should continue to operate and prevent credit on mobile phones.
  • Overall submission: Service Tax credit on mobile phone services could not be allowed for the period in question (2006-2007).

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the Respondent/Assessee's separate, specific legal arguments in reply beyond the procedural history and the Tribunal's and Board's positions noted in the record.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Commissioner of Central Excise v. Excel Crop Care Ltd., 2008 (12) STR 436 The opinion does not specify the precise rule or principle from this decision; it records that the Tribunal followed this Gujarat High Court decision. The Tribunal relied on this decision in dismissing the Revenue's appeal; the present Court noted that the Tribunal had followed this decision when upholding the allowance of credit and found no fault in the Tribunal's order.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded in a chronological and textual manner, applying the statutory framework in force for the period 2006-2007:

  1. Temporal applicability: The dispute concerned the year 2006-2007, a period after the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 had come into force. Therefore, the 2002 Rules were not in force for the relevant period and had been replaced by the 2004 Rules.
  2. Comparison of the 2002 Rules and the 2004 Rules: Under Rule 3(6) of the Service Tax Credit Rules, 2002, service tax credit was confined to telephone connections installed in premises from which the output service was provided. The 2004 Rules did not contain a corresponding provision restricting credit in the same manner.
  3. On Circular No. 59/8/2003 (20-06-2003): That circular interpreted the 2002 Rules and restricted credit on mobile phones. Because the 2002 Rules themselves were no longer in force for the period in question, the Court held the 2003 circular — which interprets the 2002 Rules — was not relevant to the period governed by the 2004 Rules.
  4. On Rule 16 of the 2004 Rules: Rule 16 provides that circulars in force at the commencement of the 2004 Rules shall, to the extent relevant and consistent with the 2004 Rules, be deemed valid under the corresponding provisions of the 2004 Rules. The Court noted that there is no rule in the 2004 Rules corresponding to Rule 3(6) of the 2002 Rules; therefore the substantive restriction in the 2002 Rules (and the 2003 circular interpreting it) could not be imported into the 2004 Rules by application of Rule 16.
  5. On the substantive scope of the 2004 Rules: Rule 2(1) of the 2004 Rules makes CENVAT credit available on any input service used by a manufacturer directly or indirectly in or in relation to manufacture of final products and explicitly includes services used in activities relating to business. The Court emphasized that, unlike the 2002 Rules, the 2004 Rules do not carry the same restriction placed by Rule 3(6) of the 2002 Rules.
  6. Administrative clarification: The Central Board of Excise and Customs issued a circular on 23-08-2007, interpreting the 2004 Rules and stating that credit of service tax on mobile phones would be available under the 2004 Rules, thereby superseding earlier circulars.
  7. Conclusion of analysis: Because the 2004 Rules did not contain the restrictive provision of the 2002 Rules, the 2003 circular interpreting 2002 Rules was not applicable for the period governed by the 2004 Rules; additionally, the Board's 23-08-2007 circular supported availability of credit on mobile phones under the 2004 Rules. On this basis the Court found no error in the Tribunal's order allowing the credit.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is DISMISSED. The questions posed were answered in favour of the assessee and against the Revenue.

Direct Implications:

  • The Customs, Excise & Service Tax Appellate Tribunal's order dated 02-06-2009, which allowed CENVAT credit of Service Tax paid on mobile phone services for the period 2006-2007, is upheld.
  • The Revenue's contention that the 2003 circular (interpreting the 2002 Rules) and Rule 3(6) of the 2002 Rules barred credit on mobile phones was rejected for the period governed by the 2004 Rules.
  • The Central Board's circular dated 23-08-2007, interpreting the 2004 Rules to allow credit on mobile phones, is noted by the Court and was treated as superseding earlier circulars.
  • No order as to costs.

Broader implications or any creation of a new precedent by this Court are not discussed in the opinion beyond affirming the Tribunal's decision in the particular facts and legal framework before it.

Source: Oral judgment per J.P. Devadhar, J. (extract provided).

    The Commissioner Of Central Excise v. M/S Ultratech Cement

    ORAL JUDGMENT (Per J.P Devadhar, J)

    1. Heard. Admit on the following questions of law :

    “(1) Whether the Hon'ble CESTAT was correct in holding that the credit of Service Tax paid on Mobile Phone service is allowable especially when the Circular No. 59/8/2003 dated 20th June, 2003 issued by the Central Board of Excise and Customs under the Service Tax Credit Rules, 2002, restricted such credit, and statutory provisions of Rule 16(1) of CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 stipulates that Board's Circular shall remain in force and valid for deciding the eligibility for Credit under CENVAT Credit Rules 2004.

    (2) Whether in the facts and circumstances of the present case the Hon'ble CESTAT was right in holding that the Respondents were entitled to avail Cenvat Credit on Service Tax paid on mobile phones services in terms of Rule 3 read with Rule 2(1) of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 despite the Respondents not having established that the same was in relation to the business activity as envisaged under Rule 9(5) of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004.

    2. By consent of learned Counsel for the parties, the appeal is taken up for final hearing.

    3. The relevant facts are that - In 2006-2007 the respondent-assessee had availed CENVAT Credit of Service Tax paid on various input services including Mobile Phone service.

    4. Show cause notices were issued to the assessee to show cause as to why credit on mobile phone service availed by the assessee and therefore, CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 (“2004 Rules” for short) during the above period should not be disallowed and recovered.

    5. On being shown cause and considering the Central Board of Excise & Customs' Circular dated 23-8-2007, the Assistant Commissioner, Central Excise, Chandrapur by his order dated 26/10/2007 dropped the proceedings.

    6. On appeal filed by the Revenue, the Commissioner (Appeals), Central Excise, Nagpur by his order dated 19-2-2008, dismissed the appeal filed by the Revenue by following various decisions of the Tribunal.

    7. On further appeal filed by the Revenue, the Customs, Excise & Service Tax Appellate Tribunal by the impugned order dated 02-6-2009, dismissed the appeal filed by the Revenue inter alia following the decision of the Gujrat High Court in the case of Commissioner of Central Excise v. Excel Crop Care Ltd., 2008 (12) STR 436. The present appeal is filed to challenge the aforesaid decision of the Tribunal dated 02-6-2009.

    8. It is contended on behalf of the Revenue that as per Rule 3(6) of the Service Tax Credit Rules, 2002, the Service Tax Credit is available only in respect of such telephone connections which are installed in the premises from where output service is provided. It is contended that by Central Board of Excise & Customs' Circular dated 20 June, 2003, the Board has clarified that the credit of Service Tax is not available on mobile phone. It is further contended that as per Rule 16 of CENVAT Credit Rules 2004, the Central Board of Excise & Customs' Circular dated 20-6-2003 in force at the commencement of 2004 Rules, shall be deemed to be valid and issued under the corresponding provisions of 2004 Rules. Accordingly, it is contended on behalf of the Revenue that Service Tax Credit could not be allowed on mobile service.

    9. We see no merit in the above contentions. The dispute in the present case relates to availing Service Tax Credit on mobile phones supplied to the employees during the period 2006-2007, that is, after 2004 Rules came into force. Under Rule 3(6) of the Service Tax Credit Rules, 2002, service tax credit was available in respect of such telephone connections which are installed in the premises from where output service is provided. There is no such provision contained in the 2004 Rules. Therefore, reliance placed on Rule 3(6) of the Service Tax Credit Rules, 2002 for the period in question is totally misplaced because, during the period in question the 2002 Rules were not in force and the said rules were replaced by 2004 Rules. Similarly the circular dated 20 June, 2003 which interprets 2002 Rules would also be not relevant for the period governed by 2004 Rules.

    10. Strong reliance was placed by the counsel for the Revenue on Rule 16 of the 2004 Rules, which provides that the Circular in force at the commencement of 2004 Rules, shall to the extent relevant and consistent with the 2004 Rules, shall be deemed to be valid and issued under the corresponding provisions of 2004 Rules. As noted earlier, there is no rule in 2004 Rules corresponding Rule 3(6) of the Service Tax Credit Rules, 2002. Under Rule 2(l) of the 2004 Rules, Cenvat Credit is available on any input service used by a manufacturer directly or indirectly, in or in relation to the manufacture of the final products and includes services used in activities relating to business. Thus, unlike in the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2002, the service tax credit under 2004 Rules are not restricted. As there are no rules in 2004 Rules corresponding to Rule 3(6) of 2002 Rules, the question of applying circular dated 20-6-2003 by relying upon Rule 16 of the 2004 Rules does not arise at all.

    11. In fact, interpreting the provisions of 2004 Rules, the Central Board of Excise and customs has issued a circular on 23rd August, 2007 superseding all earlier circulars and has held that credit of service tax on mobile phones would be available under the 2004 Rules.

    12. In these circumstances, we are of the opinion that no fault can be found in the order of the Customs, Excise & Service Tax Appellate Tribunal in granting credit of service tax paid on mobile phones. Accordingly, the appeal is dismissed by answering the questions in favour of the assessee and against the revenue. No order as to costs.

    JUDGE JUDGE

    pma

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    The Commissioner Of Central Excise v. M/S Ultratech Cement
    (Sep 27, 2010)