Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges

    Nadvil Edom Kelu Achan (1St Petitioner) v. Parasu Pattar And Others S (Counter-Petitioners And 2Nd Petitioner).

    JUDGMENT

    The facts are not in dispute. A decree was obtained against an Anandravan of a Malabar Tarwad. Certain properties, alleged to belong to him were attached after his death and the Karnavan of the Tarwad was brought in as the legal representative of the deceased Anandravan; when he was thus brought before the Court the Karnavan pleaded that as the deceased Anandravan was indebted to the Tarwad, the attached properties had been appropriated towards the debt due from him. The Subordinate Judge held that the Karnavan was not the proper legal representative of the Anandravan under the above circumstances and rejected the Tarwad's claim. An appeal was preferred against the order. The District Judge held that no appeal lay to him as the matter arose in claim proceedings.

    We are unable to agree with the District Judge. The party brought in to represent the judgment-debtor is virtually the Tarwad which is represented by its Karnavan. It is in his capacity as the representative of the Tarwad that he claims the appropriation. Consequently it is clear that his capacity to represent the deceased Anandravan under the decree is the same as the capacity in which he puts forward the rights of the Tarwad. The claim therefore is cognisable under Sect. 47 of the Code of Civil Procedure. This was the view taken in Kuriyali v. Mayan. In that case the decree against which the claim of the Tarwad was made was on a mortgage. It is clear that if the Karnavan represented the deceased judgment-debtor, it was not open to him to impeach the decree for sale, was lost sight of by the parties and the Court proceeded to deal but apparently the fact that the decree was for sale with the case as if there was a money decree and attachment This mistake was pointed out in Zamindar of Karvetnagar v. Trustee of Tirumalai, etc., Devastanams, and to the extent that the Karnavan was allowed to claim against the decree for sale, the decision in Kuriyali v. Mayan, is wrong. But that case decided the larger question that when there is a claim by the legal representative in two capacities both of which are traceable to the same source, the executing Court should deal with the question. This decision was quoted with approval by the Judicial Committee for this latter proposition in Prosunno Kumar Sanyal v. Kali Das Sanyal. The decision in Ramanathan Chettiar v. Levvai Marakayar was relied on as being in conflict with Kurayali v. Mayan. We do not think so. In Ramanathan Chettiar v. Levvai Marakayar although the claimant was the same, in one capacity he put forward the right of a trust which under no circumstances can be said to have been parties to the suit. The right advanced was that of a third party and it was held that such a claim was not cognisable in execution proceedings. There is no ground for saving that Kureyali v. Mayan was dissented from in Ramanathan Chettiar v. Levvai Marakayar. The decision which was overruled was the one reported in Upenara Bhatta v. Ranganatha Bhatta. We are cleat that the decision in I. L. R., 23 Mad., 195, is not inconsistent with the decision in I. L. R., 7 Mad., 255. The decision in I. L. R., 7 Mad., 255 was followed in Vengapayyan v. Krimpanakal Parvati(6) and in Marivittil Mathu Amma v. Pathram Kunnot Cherukot(7). Thus there has been a course of decisions in this Presidency which has recognised the correctness of the principle that where a person's claim is traceable to the same capacity in which he is brought in as the legal representative, the executing Court should hear and determine the matter.

    Following these decisions we hold that an appeal lies to the District Judge. We reverse the orders of the Courts below and remand the application for disposal to the Court of First Instance. Costs will abide the result.

    S. S.Appeal allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Nadvil Edom Kelu Ach... v. Parasu Pattar And Ot...
    (Nov 9, 1916)