AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • rule 73 of the Representation of the People (Conduct of Elections and Election Petitions) Rules, 1951
  • rule 9 of the above-mentioned Punjab rules of 1961.
  • sub-rule (3) of rule 8,
  • rule 73(2)(d)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • rule 73 of the Representation of the People (Conduct of Elections and Election Petitions) Rules, 1951
  • rule 9 of the above-mentioned Punjab rules of 1961.
  • sub-rule (3) of rule 8,
  • rule 73(2)(d)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

A meeting of the Panchayat Samiti of Ghall Khurd was convened by the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Ferozepore (respondent No. 1), acting as Presiding Officer under the Punjab Panchayat Samitis and Zila Parishads Act, 1961, for 16th February, 1965 to elect the Chairman and Vice-Chairman of the Samiti. Two candidates contested the office of Chairman: Des Raj (petitioner) and Arjan Singh (respondent No. 3). Twenty-five members cast votes. On counting, 13 votes were recorded in favour of the petitioner and 12 in favour of Arjan Singh. The Presiding Officer declared one of the 13 votes for the petitioner invalid, producing a tie which was resolved by a toss in which Arjan Singh won and was declared elected.

The petitioner filed a writ petition (the text states it was filed on 19th February, 1985) seeking a declaration that he was in fact elected having obtained 13 valid votes, and alleging that the rejection of one of his votes was illegal. The petitioner also sought a stay of the notification declaring the result at the time of filing. A Motion Bench admitted the writ petition on 24th February, 1965 but declined to grant a stay.

The Presiding Officer (Shri Gurnam Singh) submitted a written statement dated 15th April, 1965 stating that one of the petitioner's votes was declared invalid under rule 9 of the Punjab Panchayat Samitis and Zila Parishads, Chairman and Vice-Chairman (Election) Rules, 1961 because the ballot paper bore another mark in red pencil by which the voter could be identified. Arjan Singh filed a written statement objecting to the maintainability of the writ petition on the ground that an election petition under section 121 of the Act was the appropriate remedy and asserting that an election petition by Hari Singh was already pending.

The petitioner contended that the disputed ballot showed only one clear cross (X) in red pencil against his name and that a thin/red straight line found in a column containing no candidate did not invalidate the ballot.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the writ petition is maintainable in the face of an alternative remedy by way of an election petition under section 121 of the Act, particularly where an election petition remedy exists or has been instituted by another person.
  2. Whether the Presiding Officer lawfully rejected the disputed ballot under rule 9 of the Punjab Panchayat Samitis and Zila Parishads, Chairman and Vice-Chairman (Election) Rules, 1961 on the ground that it bore a mark by which the voter could be identified.
  3. Whether the Court should interfere with the Presiding Officer's decision to reject a ballot paper when that decision is based on an error of law apparent on the face of the record.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The disputed ballot paper bore a single clear cross mark (X) in red pencil placed unambiguously against the petitioner's name.
  • The thin/red straight line found in a column where no candidate's name appeared did not render the ballot invalid and did not amount to a mark by which the voter could be identified.

Respondents' and Other Parties' Arguments

  • The Presiding Officer (Shri Gurnam Singh) asserted in his written statement that the ballot paper was invalid under rule 9 because it bore another mark in red pencil by which the voter could allegedly be identified.
  • Arjan Singh (respondent) objected to the maintainability of the writ petition on the ground that an election petition under section 121 was the appropriate remedy, and that such an election petition had already been filed by Hari Singh and remained pending.
  • Mr. Sanwalka, counsel for the respondent, relied on a Division Bench judgment (Bhagirath Singh v. The State of Punjab, A.I.R. 1965 Punj. 170) to argue that the writ petition should be dismissed because an alternative remedy by way of an election petition was available.
  • A further objection advanced by Mr. Sanwalka was that it was for the Presiding Officer alone to accept or reject a ballot paper and, so long as he had jurisdiction, the Court should not interfere with his decision. The Court treated this as subject to review where the Presiding Officer acted without jurisdiction or where an error of law was apparent on the face of the record.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Bhagirath Singh v. The State of Punjab, A.I.R. 1965 Punj. 170 (Division Bench) That the existence of an alternative remedy by way of an election petition is not an absolute constitutional bar to writ relief; the alternative remedy may be a self-imposed restriction and should not prevail if it is not equally adequate, efficacious and speedy. The Court considered and applied this authority in assessing the preliminary objection based on availability of an election petition remedy and held the alternative remedy was not equally adequate or speedy in the circumstances; the objection was overruled.
Charan Das v. State, 1965 67 P.L.R. 1238 (Division Bench) That mere existence of an alternative remedy cannot by itself (per se) require the Court to withhold writ relief; the Court must weigh facts and circumstances to determine whether interference furthers justice. The Court relied on this principle to justify judicial intervention despite the theoretical availability of an election petition, reasoning that dismissing the writ would thwart rather than further the ends of justice in this exceptional case.
Dr. Anup Singh v. Abdul Ghani, A.I.R. 1963 Punj. 429 (Full Bench) Interpretation of the phrase "any mark ... by which the voter can be identified": a mark (other than handwriting/signature) invalidates a ballot only if there is evidence of an arrangement to vote in that peculiar manner enabling identification; handwriting/initials may in themselves provide evidence of identity and must be assessed for sufficiency. The Court adopted the Full Bench's analytical distinction and used it to interpret rule 9 of the Punjab rules, concluding that a mere distinguishing mark is insufficient to invalidate a ballot absent evidence of arrangement or handwriting capable of identification.
Re. Dr. Anup Singh v. Shri Abdul Ghani, A.I.R. 1965 S.C. 815 (Constitution Bench, Supreme Court) The Supreme Court held that a ballot is invalid under the relevant rule only if there is a reasonable probability of identification of the elector by the mark or writing; mere possibility of identification is not sufficient. The Court treated this Supreme Court decision as authoritative under Article 141 and applied the standard of "reasonable probability of identification" to rule 9, concluding the Presiding Officer's ground for rejection did not meet that standard.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in a structured manner:

  1. Preliminary objection on alternative remedy: The Court examined whether the availability of an election petition under section 121 precluded writ relief. Relying on Division Bench and Full Bench authorities, the Court held that the mere existence of an alternative remedy is not an automatic bar; the Court must evaluate whether the alternative remedy is equally adequate, efficacious and speedy. Noting that the limitation period for filing an election petition had expired and that an election petition's trial and decision would not be as speedy as the writ process in the circumstances, the Court found the election-petition remedy inadequate and overruled the preliminary objection.
  2. Scope of Presiding Officer's power under rule 9: The Court examined rule 9 of the 1961 Punjab rules, which enumerates specific categories in which a ballot paper may be declared invalid (e.g., (X) against more than one name; ambiguous placement; absence of Presiding Officer's signature; signatures of the voter; any mark by which the voter can be identified). The Court emphasized that the Presiding Officer may reject a ballot only if it falls within one of these categories.
  3. Factual assessment of the disputed ballot: The sealed ballot (No. PZCH 4490) was produced. It contained only two candidate names: Arjan Singh at item No. 1 and Des Raj at item No. 2. There was no mark against Arjan Singh; a clear red cross (X) stood against Des Raj. In the place for item No. 3 (where no candidate's name appeared) a small straight red pencil line was present. The Presiding Officer's handwritten note on the ballot read: "Rejected as invalid since there is a distinguishing mark underneath the cross."
  4. Application of precedent on identifying marks: The Court analysed the precedents (Full Bench and Supreme Court in the Dr. Anup Singh line of authority) which hold that a mark invalidates a ballot only if there is evidence that the mark provides a reasonable probability of identifying the elector (mere possibility or mere distinguishing quality is insufficient). The Court treated the Supreme Court decision as binding under Article 141.
  5. Conclusion on jurisdictional error and effect: There was no evidence of any arrangement between the voter and any candidate; the stray straight line was too insubstantial to permit identification (the Court observed even expert handwriting analysis could not identify the maker of such a mark). Therefore, the Presiding Officer's stated ground for rejection did not fall within rule 9 and was an error of law apparent on the face of the record. Because that error had led to manifest injustice (the petitioner had otherwise secured more votes), the Court found itself duty-bound to set aside the rejection.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition is allowed. The order of respondent No. 1 rejecting the disputed ballot paper is set aside, and the Court directed that the appropriate authorities should declare the petitioner elected in place of Shri Arjan Singh, respondent, unless there is some legal impediment to such declaration. There will be no order as to costs.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The immediate consequence is that the rejection of the disputed ballot is quashed and the petitioner is to be declared elected in place of the declared winner, subject to any legal impediment.
  • Scope for future application: The Court applied established Supreme Court authority (Re. Dr. Anup Singh) and this decision follows that binding interpretation; the opinion itself does not purport to establish a new doctrinal rule beyond applying the Supreme Court's standard that invalidation requires a reasonable probability of identification.

Note: All content in this summary is drawn exclusively from the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts beyond those explicitly stated in the text.

    Shri Des Raj v. S. Gurnam Singh, S.D.M, Ferozepore And Others

    R.S Narula, J.:— The relevant facts of this case are not in dispute. A meeting of the Panchayat Samiti of Ghall Khurd was convened by the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Ferozepore (respondent No. 1) in his capacity as Presiding Officer under the Punjab Panchayat Samitis and Zila Parishads Act, 1961 for 16th February, 1965 to elect the Chairman and Vice-Chairman of the Panchayat Samiti of that village. There were two contestants to the office of Chairman, namely, Des Raj, petitioner and Arjan Singh, respondent No. 3. It is admitted that in all 25 members of the Samiti cast their votes at the said election. When the votes were counted it was admittedly found that 13 had been polled in favour of the petitioner while 12 had been cast in favour of Arjan Singh, respondent. The Presiding Officer declared one of the 13 votes cast in favour of the petitioner as invalid. The resultant equality of votes was resolved by resorting to toss. In the toss, Arjan Singh respondent won any he was declared elected as Chairman. It is this election of Arjan Singh as Chairman which is sought to be set aside in this writ petition filed on 19th February, 1985. The petitioner seeks a declaration to the effect that it was he who had been elected as he had obtained 13 votes on the ground that the rejection of one of his votes was illegal. At the time of filing the writ petition he also prayed for stay of the issue of notification declaring the result of the election. The Motion Bench (R.P Khosla and Jindra Lal, JJ.) while admitting the writ petition on 24th February, 1965 declined to grant any stay order. The case of the petitioner is that the voter in question had put only one cross mark with red pencil which was clearly and unambiguously placed against the name of the petitioner on the disputed ballot paper and that the thin red line stated to have been found down below on the same ballot paper against an empty column containing no name of any candidate did not invalidate the ballot paper.

    2. Shri Gurnam Singh, Sub-Divisional Magistrate (as Presiding Officer of Panchayat Samiti Election) has submitted his written statement dated 15th April, 1965 in reply to the writ petition. Therein he has stated that one of the votes polled in favour of the petitioner was declared invalid under rule 9 of the Punjab Panchayat Samitis and Zila Parishads, Chairman and Vice-Chairman (Election) Rules, 1961 since the said ballot paper had another mark in red pencil on it by which the vote could be identified. Arjan Singh, respondent has filed a separate written statement wherein he has, inter alia, taken up an objection to the maintainability of this writ petition on the ground that an election petition under section 121 of the Act lies and that an election petition challenging the election of Arjan Singh, respondent has already been filed before the appropriate authority by one Hari Singh, Member of the Block Samiti, Ghall Khurd and the same is pending. Mr. Sanwalka, the learned counsel for the respondent relies on a Division Bench judgment of this Court (Grover and Dua, JJ.) in Bhagirath Singh v. The State of Punjab . A.I.R 1965 Punj. 170, and argues that this writ petition should be dismissed on the short ground that an alternative remedy by way of an election petition was available to the petitioner. In the case cited by him Dua, J., who wrote the judgment of the Court held that an alternative remedy by way of an election petition was not a constitutional bar but was merely in the nature of a self-imposed restriction and that an objection to this effect should not be allowed to prevail if the alternative-remedy is not equally adequate, efficacious and speedy or when it is found by the Court that interference of this Court in exercise of its writ jurisdiction is necessary to facilitate the cause of substantial justice and to further the ends of justice.

    3. Again in Civil Writ No. 1552 of 1965 a Division Bench of this Court (Dua, J. and myself) held in Charan Das v. State . 1965 67 P.L.R 1238., on 30th July, 1965, as follows:—

    “The conclusion is irresistible that mere existence of an alternative remedy cannot by itself or per se enjoin this Court to decline interference on the writ side, but that the Court must consider and weigh in a disciplined and responsible manner according to the rules of reason and justice all the facts and circumstances before it and eliminating prejudice and sympathy, judicially determine whether or not interference would further the purposes of securing justice to the citizens for which this power is conferred”.

    4. In this writ petition the facts are not in dispute. The limitation for filing an election petition has already expired and the petitioner has admittedly not filed any election petition so far. Even it he had filed a petition under section 121 of the Act its trial and decision would certainly not have been as speedy as the decision in a writ case. In the circumstances of this case, I do not consider the alternative remedy by way of an election petition to be an adequate or equally efficacious and equally speedy remedy. In the view that I am taking of the matter on its merits. It appears that error of law is writ large on the face of the decision of the Presiding Officer and in fact his decision is contrary to the law of the land as settled by the Supreme Court. To dismiss a writ petition in an exceptional case of this type appears to thwart rather than further the ends of justice. I, therefore, overrule the preliminary objection raised by the contesting respondent in this behalf.

    5. Still another objection has been raised by Mr. Sanwalka. He argues that it was for the Presiding Officer to accept or reject a ballot paper and so long as he has the jurisdiction to do so it is not for this Court to interfere with his decision. This is indeed so. But if it is found that the Presiding Officer rejected a ballot paper or declared it to be invalid on a ground on which he has no jurisdiction to do so or if his decision is based on an error of law apparent on the face of the record, it is the duty of this Court to set aside such an order.

    6. Coming to the merits of the case, rule 9 of the Punjab Panchayat Samitis and Zila Parishads Chairman and Vice-Chairman (Election) Rules, 1961 reads as follows:—

    “9. Any ballot-paper which bears any mark or signature by which the voter can be identified or on which the mark “(X)” is placed against more than one name or in an ambiguous manner or which does not bear the signature of the Presiding Officer prescribed in sub-rule (3) of rule 8, shall be declared invalid.”

    7. A mere reading of the above-said rule would show and indeed it is not disputed that the Presiding Officer has the jurisdiction to reject any ballot paper only if it falls within one of the five categories mentioned in the above rule and analysed below and in no other case:—

    1. If the prescribed mark “(X)” is placed against more than one name on the relevant ballot paper.

    2. If the prescribed mark “(X)” is placed on the ballot paper in an ambiguous manner, i.e, the mark is placed in such a way is to make it difficult or doubtful for the Presiding Officer to judge the candidate in whose favour the vote has been cast.

    3. If the ballot paper in question does not bear the signature of the Presiding Officer.

    4. If the ballot paper bears the signatures of the voter.

    5. If the ballot paper bears any mark by which the voter can be identified.

    8. It is admitted case of both the parties before me that this case does not fall within any of the first four categories enumerated above. According to the respondent and according to the affidavit of the Presiding Officer filed in reply to the writ petition the case falls in the fifth category mentioned above. In the presence of the parties I have got the sealed cover containing the relevant ballot paper opened. In this ballot paper (No. PZCH 4490) names of only two candidates are mentioned, i.e, of Shri Arjan Singh, respondent at item No. 1 and of Shri Des Raj, petitioner at item No. 2. No mark whatever has been put in the relevant column against the name of Arjan Singh. A clean cross mark in red pencil exists in the column for voting against the name of Des Raj, petitioner. In the place for casting the vote against item No. 3 where no name of any candidate occurs a small straight line in red pencil admittedly occurs. On this ballot paper Shri Gurnam Singh, the Presiding Officer has passed an order 16th February, 1965 in his own handwriting which reads as follows:—

    “Rejected as invalid since there is a distinguishing mark underneath the cross.”

    9. What is required by law to invalidate a ballot paper is not the mere existence of a mark or even a distinguishing mark but only such a mark by which a voter can be identified. Similar words occur in rule 73(2)(d) of the rvles framed under the Representation of the People Act. There also the mark which can invalidate a ballot paper “must be one by which the elector can be identified.” The above phrase came up for interpretation before a Full Bench of this Court (Mehar Singh, Dua and Mahajan, JJ.) in Dr. Anup Singh v. Abdul Ghani . A.I.R 1963 Punj. 429 F.B.. The learned Judges of the Full Bench held as follows:—

    “The position in law that now emerges on consideration of all these cases seems to me to be this: In so far as any mark, other than writing on a ballot paper in addition to the mark required to signify intention to vote, is concerned, its peculiarity as a mark of identification can only invalidate a ballot paper if there is evidence of arrangement to vote in that peculiar manner to enable identification; but in the case of intitials or handwriting on a ballot paper the same is by itself evidence of the identity of the voter, the handwriting providing the evidence of such identity. In the latter case the only question that remains on the facts of a particular case is the sufficiency and adequacy of the writing to support an inference that the handwriting amounts to identification of the voter. It is upon this consideration that in some of the cases referred to a type of writing has been held not to invalidate a ballot paper. But that obviously must be a question for consideration in the facts and circumstances of each particular case.”

    10. The judgment of the Full Bench of this Court was the subject matter of a further appeal to the Supreme Court. That appeal was disposed of by a Constitution Bench of that Court and the judgment is reported in Re. Dr. Anup Singh v. Shri Abdul Ghani . A.I.R 1965 S.C 815.. The judgment of this Court was upheld by their Lordships of the Supreme Court and it was held that the vote will be invalidated under rule 73(2)(d) of the above-said rules if there should be a reasonable probability of identification of the elector by the mark or writing (other than that permitted by the relevant rule). Their Lordships held that the mere possibility of identification will not invalidate the vote under the above-said rule. It was held that a rule of this type requires that there should not only be a mark or writing on the ballot paper other than what is permitted by the relevant provisions but the mark or writing should be such that the elector can lie identified because of it. An illustration of this kind has been given in the Full Bench judgment of this Court, i.e, where signature or some other writing is made by the elector, which can lead to an identification of the voter. If mere possibility of identification had been enough to invalidate a ballot paper, held the Supreme Court, the rule would have read something like this:—

    “that there is any mark or writing other than that permitted * *”

    11. On a careful consideration of the matter I hold that what has been laid down by the Full Bench of this Court and by their Lordships of the Supreme Court in Dr. Anup Singh's case in relation to rule 73 of the Representation of the People (Conduct of Elections and Election Petitions) Rules, 1951 equally applies to the relevant clause in rule 9 of the above-mentioned Punjab rules of 1961. Though the Presiding officer has tried to quote the words of the relevant rule in his affidavit in reply to the writ petition, it is obvious that the ground on which he stated that he was rejecting the ballot paper on 16th February, 1965 in his order passed on the ballot paper itself, did not fall within rule 9, ibid. Under Article 141 of the Constitution the interpretation of such a rule as authoritatively pronounced by the Supreme Court is the law of the land. I, therefore, hold that the ground on which the disputed ballot paper was rejected is contrary to law. In the absence of evidence of any arrangement between the person who cast the disputed ballot and the candidate in whose favour it was polled, it is impossible to identify the voter who cast the disputed ballot in the instant case. Even the most capable of handwriting experts cannot identify the writer of this less than one inch straight line in red pencil. Suppose, this was somehow possible, even then it is not the mere possibility of identification of the voter from the mark that will invalidate a ballot paper under rule 9. The mark would be fatal only if the elector can be identified because of it without any further evidence of special arrangement. Admittedly, there was no such evidence before the Presiding Officer. He had no jurisdiction to reject the ballot paper merely because it could be distinguished from the other ballot papers on account of the straight line referred to above. Still it was on this account alone and for no other reason that the crucial ballot paper was invalidated by the Presiding Officer. This being an error of law apparent on the face of the record and having led to manifest injustice to the petitioner who has otherwise admittedly secured more votes than the contesting respondent, the impugned order cannot be sustained.

    12. In the above circumstances, this writ petition is allowed, the order of respondent No. 1 rejecting the disputed ballot paper is set aside and it is further directed that the appropriate authorities should declare the petitioner as elected in place of Shri Arjan Singh, respondent, unless there is soma legal impediment against such a declaration. In the circumstances of the case there will be no order as to costs.

    13. Petition allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Shri Des Raj v. S. Gurnam Singh, S.D.M, Ferozepore And Others
    (Oct 8, 1965)