Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • section 20 of the Agra Tenancy Act,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • section 20 of the Agra Tenancy Act,
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiffs are zamindars of the village of Karmanpur (Ballia district). A small cultivator's holding was held from the plaintiffs by one Ram Dhian as a tenant at fixed rates. In 1870 Ram Dhian executed a usufructuary mortgage of this holding in favour of the respondents; the mortgage contained a provision for redemption in any Jeth. Ram Dhian is said by the plaintiffs to have disappeared several years prior to the suit, allegedly not heard of for more than seven years and presumed dead, and the plaintiffs allege that he died without heirs.

The plaintiffs instituted a suit for redemption of the usufructuary mortgage. The defendants contested the plaintiffs' right to redeem and further alleged that Ram Dhian was still alive. The lower appellate court, relying on Ram Dihal Rai v. The Maharaja of Vizianagram, held that the plaintiffs had no interest in the equity of redemption and could not maintain the suit. A second appeal to this Court was dismissed by the learned Judge. A Letters Patent appeal was preferred to the Full Bench, which referred the question for decision by a larger Bench; the matter is decided by this Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the plaintiffs (the zamindars) have such an interest in the mortgaged property as to entitle them to maintain a suit for redemption of the usufructuary mortgage.
  2. If Ram Dhian died without heirs, whether his fixed-rate tenancy is extinguished and reverts to the zamindar (the plaintiffs), or whether it vests in the Crown (i.e., the legal effect of a tenant-at-fixed-rates dying without heirs).
  3. Whether the decision in Ram Dihal Rai v. The Maharaja of Vizianagram was correctly decided and applicable to the present facts.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' (Plaintiffs') Arguments

  • Ram Dhian died without heirs, causing his tenancy to be extinguished under the relevant provisions of the Agra Tenancy Act, so the tenancy lapsed to the zamindars.
  • Consequently, the plaintiffs are entitled either to possession of the holding or at least to possession upon redemption of the 1870 mortgage. They have offered and are willing to discharge the mortgage debt.

Respondents' (Defendants') Arguments

  • The defendants contested the plaintiffs' right to redeem the mortgage.
  • The defendants alleged that Ram Dhian was alive, which, if true, would defeat the plaintiffs' claim.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ram Dihal Rai v. The Maharaja of Vizianagram Held that (1) the tenancy (interest) of a fixed-rate tenant vested in the Crown upon death without heirs and (2) a person seeking redemption must have an interest "in the mortgaged property"; accordingly the zamindar had no such interest to redeem the mortgage. The Court concluded that Ram Dihal Rai was wrongly decided as applied to fixed-rate tenancies. The present Bench overruled the holding insofar as it treated fixed-rate tenancy as escheating to the Crown and as depriving the zamindar of an interest sufficient to redeem; the Court set aside the lower courts' reliance on that decision and remanded the matter for determination on the merits.
Ranee Sonet Kowar v. Mirza Himmut Bahadoor (Privy Council) Held that a mokurrari (an absolute, alienable, hereditary tenure carved from zamindari) was an absolute and alienable interest that did not revert to the grantor on the grantee's death without heirs and that the Crown was entitled by prerogative to such lease in that circumstance. The Court treated the Privy Council ruling as addressing an absolute, alienable mokurrari tenure, and distinguished it from the present case. The Court held that the Privy Council's reasoning does not apply to limited fixed-rate tenancies, which are extinguished under the Agra Tenancy Act when the tenant dies without heirs.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded in several steps, grounded in the character of the tenancy and the statutory provisions of the Agra Tenancy Act:

  1. Character of the tenancy: The Court explained that a fixed-rate tenant is a tenant who has a right of occupancy at a fixed rate (section 5, Agra Tenancy Act). Such a right of occupancy is a limited interest, liable to ejectment for non-payment of rent or breach of conditions (section 57), and is capable of heritable and transferable incidents under section 20, but is not an absolute and alienable interest comparable to a mokurrari.
  2. Distinguishing authority: The Court examined Ranee Sonet Kowar v. Mirza Himmut Bahadoor and observed that that case concerned an absolute, alienable, hereditary mokurrari tenure. Their Lordships of the Privy Council held that such an interest did not revert to the grantor and was an interest that could vest in the Crown. The Court found that the facts and legal character in Ranee Sonet Kowar were materially different from a fixed-rate tenancy.
  3. Statutory extinguishment: The Court relied on the Agra Tenancy Act's provisions (notably section 18, and the right of occupancy described in section 5) which prescribe that a right of occupancy is extinguished when a tenant dies leaving no heir entitled to inherit. On that basis, the Court reasoned that a fixed-rate tenancy is a limited interest which, upon the tenant's death without heirs (as defined in section 22), is extinguished and consequently reverts to the landlord (the zamindar).
  4. Critique of Ram Dihal Rai: With respect to Ram Dihal Rai v. The Maharaja of Vizianagram, which had held that a tenancy of this character vested in the Crown and that a zamindar lacked the requisite interest to redeem, the Court (Stanley, C.J., with Knox and Banerji, JJ. concurring) held that that decision was wrongly decided. The Chief Justice stated that the limited nature of a fixed-rate tenancy meant it could not be treated as an absolute interest or as subject to escheat to the Crown in the manner asserted in Ram Dihal Rai.
  5. Practical consequences for the present suit: The Chief Justice observed that if Ram Dhian is indeed dead without heirs as defined by the Act, the plaintiffs are entitled to redeem the mortgage (and possibly to possession). However, because the first court found that Ram Dhian was alive, the plaintiffs' suit would fail if that fact is true. The lower appellate court had decided the matter on the preliminary point that the plaintiffs lacked an interest; the High Court judge had accepted that view. Because the Court overruled that preliminary legal point, it remanded the appeal to the lower appellate court with directions to decide the appeal on the merits (fact and law).

Judges Knox and Banerji expressly concurred. Banerji, J. emphasized that a tenancy at fixed rates is carved out of the landholder's interest and that if it ends (for example by death without heirs), it lapses back to the landholder; he reiterated that the fixed-rate tenancy differs in material respects from an absolute hereditary mokurrari tenure considered by the Privy Council.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court allowed the appeal, set aside the decrees of the learned Judge of this Court and of the lower appellate court, and remanded the cause to the lower appellate court to be determined on the merits (order under Order XLI, rule 23).

Implications:

  • The Court rejected the reasoning in Ram Dihal Rai v. The Maharaja of Vizianagram insofar as it treated a tenancy at fixed rates as vesting in the Crown on the tenant's death without heirs and as depriving the zamindar of any interest to redeem; the Bench held that Ram Dihal Rai was wrongly decided on that point.
  • As a practical consequence for this case, the lower appellate court must now proceed to adjudicate the appeal on its merits (including the factual question whether Ram Dhian is alive or died without heirs) rather than dismissing the claim on the preliminary legal point that the plaintiffs lacked an interest to redeem.
  • The decision clarifies, consistent with the Agra Tenancy Act provisions cited by the Court, that a fixed-rate tenancy is a limited statutory interest which may be extinguished upon death without heirs and may revert to the landlord; the Court distinguished such tenancies from absolute, alienable mokurrari tenures considered in Privy Council authority.
Appeal decreed. Cause remanded.

    Tulshi Ram Sahu v. Gur Dayal Singh

    Stanley, C.J:— The plaintiffs are zamindars of the village of Karmanpur in the district of Ballia. There is a small cultivators holding which was held from the plaintiffs by one Ram Dhian as a tenant at fixed rates. In the year 1870 he executed a usufructuary mortgage of this holding in favour of the respondents, which contained a provision for redemption in any Jeth. Ram Dhian is said to have disappeared a number of years ago, and according to the plaintiffs he has not been heard of for more than seven years and must be presumed to have died. It is also alleged that he died without heirs. The plaintiffs instituted the suit for redemption of the usufructuary mortgage, out of which this appeal has arisen. The right of the plaintiffs to redeem is contested and the defendants further allege that Ram Dhian is alive. The lower appellate court held, relying upon the decision of a Bench of this Court in the case of Ram Dihal Rai v. The Maharaja of Vizianagram(4), that the plaintiffs had no interest in the equity of redemption of the property and could not maintain a suit for redemption. A second appeal was preferred to this Court and the learned Judge, before whom it came for disposal, dismissed it. An appeal under the Letters Patent was then preferred, and the correctness of the decision in Ram Dihal Rai v. The Maharaja of Vizianagram is challenged. My brother Banerji and myself, before whom the appeal came for hearing, were of opinion that the question raised was one of importance and should be decided by a larger Bench. Accordingly the appeal has come before us.

    The sole question for determination is whether or not the lower appellate court and the learned Judge of this Court were right in holding that the plaintiffs had no such interest in the mortgaged property as entitled them to maintain a suit for redemption of the defendants' mortgage. The contention on behalf of the appellants is that Ram Dhian died without heirs and that thereupon his tenancy became extinguished and that the plaintiffs are entitled to possession of the holding, or at least to possession of it on redemption of the mortgage of 1870.

    In Ram Dihal v. The Maharaja of Vizianigram the facts were these:—A zamindar brought a suit to redeem a mortgage made by a fixed rate tenant alleging that the fixed rate tenant had died without heirs and that his interest had thereby lapsed to him. The court of first instance held that, in the event of the tenant having died childless, his interest went to the Crown and not to the plaintiff, and dismissed the suit. His decision was reversed by the lower appellate court and a second appeal was preferred to the High Court. The learned Judges before whom it came for disposal held that the tenancy did not lapse upon the death of the tenant without heirs, but that the tenancy became vested in the Crown. They relied on the ruling of their Lordships of the Privy Council in Ranee Sonet Kowar v. Mirza Himmut Bahadoor. They further held that in order to redeem, the person seeking redemption must have an interest “in the mortgaged property,” that the mortgaged property in that case was the interest of a fixed rate tenant, and that the mere fact that the zamindar has a proprietary interest in the land out of which this interest is carved, does not give him an interest within the meaning of section 91 of the Transfer of Property Act.

    Let us see what was decided in Ranee Sonet Kowar v. Mirza Himmut Bahadoor. In that case the grantee from a Hindu zamindar of an ordinary mokurraree istimraree tenure died without heirs and it was held that the Crown by the general prerogative was entitled to the lease; that the mokurraree, though carved out of zamindari, being an absolute alienable interest therein, could not have reverted to the grantor and that there was no authority upon which the power of taking by escheat can be attributed to the grantor. In that case it will be observed that the mokurraree was an absolute and alienable interest. It could not have been forfeited for the non-payment of rent. The zamindar could only in the case of non-payment of rent have caused it to be seized, put up for sale and sold to the highest bidder. It was therefore property which might have passed to any purchaser, and having so passed the estate would not have determined upon the death of the grantee without heirs if it had been sold in her life-time. The language of their Lordships is as follows:—“The mokurraree was clearly an absolute interest. It was also an alienable interest. It might have been seized and sold, as Mr. Doyne has shown, under Act X of 1859, even in a suit for rent. It could not have been forfeited for the non-payment of rent; for in such a case the zamindar could only have caused it to be seized, put up for sale, and sold to the highest bidder. It is therefore property which, like that in the case above cited, might have passed to any purchaser, whatever his nationality, or by whatever law he was to be governed. It cannot, their Lordships think, be successfully argued that having so passed the estate would have determined upon the death of Sharfun-nissa (supposing it had been sold in her life-time) without heirs, for the grant contains no provision for the lease of the estate created in such event.”

    The grant in this case was, it will be observed, that of an absolute interest and altogether unlike the interest of a fixed rate tenant. Let us see what is the nature of the interest of a fixed rate tenant.

    Section 5 of the Agra Tenancy Act, I of 1901, prescribes that when any land in a district which is permanently settled, has been held by a tenant and his predecessor in title from the time of the permanent settlement at the same rate of rent, “such tenant shall have a right of occupancy at that rate.” A fixed rate tenant therefore is a tenant who has a right of occupancy at a fixed rate. Session 18 prescribes that a right of occupancy shall be extinguished when, amongst other cases, a tenant dies leaving no heir entitled under the Act to inherit the right of occupancy. A fixed rate tenant is liable to ejectment for non-payment of rent or breach of conditions (section 57). It appears to me, therefore, that a fixed rate tenancy is but a limited interest, which cannot be the subject of escheat to the Crown. In fact, the Act provides that on the death of the tenant without heirs the interest of such a tenant, described in the Act as a right of occupancy, shall be extinguished. With all deference to the learned Judges who decided the case of Ram Dihal Rai v. The Maharaja of Vizianagram, I am of opinion that case was wrongly decided. If then it be the case that Ram Dhian is dead without leaving an heir as defined in section 22 of the Act, the plaintiffs are clearly entitled to redeem the mortgage held by the respondents, if they are not entitled to possession of the holding without redemption. The question whether the plaintiffs are bound to discharge the mortgage debt does not arise, because they are willing and have offered to do so. The first court found that Ram Dhian was still alive. If this be so, the plaintiffs' suit must fail. The lower appellate court, however, dismissed the appeal to it on the sole ground that the plaintiffs could not be regarded as having any interest in the equity of redemption of the holding, and this is the view which seems to have commended itself to the learned Judge of this Court. I would allow the appeal and set aside the decree of the learned Judge of this Court: and as the lower appellate court, decided the appeal on a preliminary point, I would remand the appeal to that court with directions that court determine the appeal on the merits.

    Knox, J.:— I have nothing to add to the judgement of the learned Chief Justice. I fully agree with the view taken by him.

    Banerji, J.:— I also concur with the learned Chief Justice. The view taken in Ram Dihal Rai v. The Maharaja of Vizianagram was never adopted, as far as I am aware, in any other case and seems to me to be inconsistent with the nature of a tenancy at fixed rates. Such a tenancy is carved out of the landholder's interest in the land to which it relates and a fixed rate tenant has no absolute interest in it. If the tenancy comes to an end it necessarily goes back to the estate which it was carved out of and lapses to the landholder. It is true that a fixed rate tenant has a heritable and transferable interest in his holding under section 20 of the Agra Tenancy Act, but if he does not transfer the holding and dies leaving no heirs entitled to inherit it, the tenancy becomes extinct and reverts to the landlord who created it. The landlord has in certain cases a right to determine the tenancy, eject the tenant and re-enter into possession. For example, under section 57 of the Act, a tenant, not being a permanent tenure-holder, may be ejected for any of the reasons mentioned in the several clauses of the section, and as a fixed rate tenant is not a permanent tenure-holder, he may be ejected for any of those reasons. His interest in his holding is thus of a limited character and differs in material respects from an absolute hereditary mokurrari tenure which formed the subject of consideration by their Lordships of the Privy Council in Ranee Sonet Kowar v. Mirza Himmut Bahadoor. As pointed out by their Lordships, such mokurrari is an absolute interest and could not have been forfeited to the zamindar. Such is not the case with a fixed-rate tenancy. The ruling of their Lordships therefore does not support the decision in the case of Ram Dihal Rai v. The Maharaja of Vizianagram. Having regard to the incidents of a fixed rate tenancy I am unable, with great respect, to agree with that decision and to hold that a tenancy in these provinces escheats to the Crown.

    By the Court:—The order of the court is that the appeal be allowed and the decrees of the learned Judge of this court and of the lower appellate court be set aside and, as the case was decided by the lower appellate court on a preliminary point and we have overruled the court on that point, we remand the case under order XLI, rule 23, to the lower appellate court with directions to readmit the appeal under its original number in the register of civil appeals and proceed to determine the appeal.

    Appeal decreed. Cause remanded.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Tulshi Ram Sahu v. Gur Dayal Singh
    (Jul 28, 1910)