Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Acts
  • Subbarayadu 13 M. 293 : 4 Ind. Dec. (N.S.) 916, a rule
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Acts
  • Subbarayadu 13 M. 293 : 4 Ind. Dec. (N.S.) 916, a rule
Smart Summary

Concise Analytical Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This is an appeal by the first defendant against a decree in a suit for a declaration that the plaintiffs are entitled to participate in the cooked rice bhog offered to three idols and for consequential relief. The litigation concerns temples and consecrated images established by a common ancestor, Gopinath Chatterjee, over 200 years ago, and by his sons Nandadulal Chatterjee and Durga Charan Chatterjee. Temples were consecrated (existing temples consecrated in 1792 and 1801) and elaborate arrangements for daily worship were made. Although there was no direct written instrument evidencing dedication of property, the courts found evidence of lands (including a bund/tank of 1,100 bighas, gardens and other lands) whose income was regularly appropriated to meet puja expenses including bhog.

The plaintiffs alleged continuous participation by themselves and their ancestors (descendants of the founders through their daughters) in the cooked rice bhog until the first defendant obstructed them on 31 December 1914. The courts below found that (a) the shebaitship (management/officiation) had been enjoyed by descendants of the founders in the male line, (b) the descendants of the founders in the female line had, for generations, participated in the bhog after it was offered, and (c) that there is an endowment whose income has been applied to daily worship including bhog. The appeal challenges those conclusions.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether there was a valid endowment/dedication of property to the worship of the idols (sufficient to fund daily worship and bhog), notwithstanding lack of a written instrument.
  2. Whether the founder could lawfully prescribe that the shebaitship be vested in his descendants through his sons while directing that his descendants through his daughters should have the right to participate in the bhog offering.
  3. Whether the plaintiffs (descendants through the daughters) retained a right, by long usage, to participate in the bhog and whether the first defendant's obstruction was wrongful.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiffs' Arguments

  • The plaintiffs alleged continuous, generation-to-generation participation by themselves and their ancestors (female-line descendants of the founders) in the cooked rice bhog until obstruction on 31 December 1914.
  • The conduct and application of revenues to puja over a long period supported the existence of an endowment and a right to participate in bhog distribution.

First Defendant's Arguments

  • The first defendant contested the plaintiffs' claim to participate in the bhog offerings.
  • The opinion records that the first defendant "has not been able to invoke any general principle or to cite any authority" in support of his contention.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Muddun Lal v. Komul Bibee (8 W.R. 42) That execution of a written document is not essential for a valid dedication; dedication may be inferred from application of proceeds and family conduct. Used to support the proposition that the absence of a written deed does not preclude a valid dedication where conduct and application of income show endowment.
Moonohar Ganesh Tambekar v. Lakhmiram Govindram (12 B. 247 / 12 Ind. Jur. 387) Same principle as above regarding inference of dedication from conduct and application of proceeds. Cited alongside other authorities to uphold the finding of an endowment despite lack of written evidence.
Abhiram Goswami Mohant v. Shyama Charan Nandi (4 Ind. Cas. 449; 36 I.A. 148) Support for inference of dedication from family conduct and application of income. Relied on to confirm that the available evidence sufficed to establish an endowment and its application to worship.
Jagadindra Nath Roy v. Hemanta Kumari Debi (31 I.A. 203) Authority on the nature of dedication/endowment under Hindu law (also cited later for shebait principles). Referenced as part of the authorities showing validity of the endowment and as support for rules on shebaitship and devotional endowments.
Ashutosh Dutt v. Doorga Churn Chatterjee (6 I.A. 182) Consideration of whether property dedicated is secular but charged with religious trust; related principles of endowment. Cited to show alternative conceptualizations of dedicated property, while court held it sufficient to find an endowment applied to worship.
Venkatachalapati v. Subbarayadu (13 M. 293) That usage of an institution is an index to the intention of founders; courts look for rules of determination in usage. Applied to infer the founder's intention from long-standing usage in the family institution and worship.
Greedharee Doss v. Nundokishore Doss Marsh (573 : 2 Hay 633) Supports the proposition that usage evidences founders' intention. Used to support the inference of original direction by the founders from long usage.
Thackersey Dewraj v. Hurbhum Nursey (8 B. 432) Also cited for the role of usage as evidence of founders' intention in institutions. Relied upon to sustain the conclusion that immemorial usage points to the founders' direction.
Raghubhushana v. Vidiavaridhi (34 Ind. Cas. 875) That intention may be presumed from a number of instances over a limited period if invariable practice is shown by clear evidence. Applied to justify inferring founder's intention where long continuance of practice was established.
St. John's College v. Todington (1757) 1 Burr. 158 English principle that a charitable corporation, insofar as charitable, is the creature of the founder and the founder may prescribe governance/application of revenue. Invoked for the general proposition that a founder may govern and direct administration of a charitable institution consistent with its charitable character.
Green v. Rutherforth (1750) 1 Ves. Sen. 462 Founder may provide for government and application in perpetuity of revenue; founder's power over administration of charitable creature. Used to support the argument that the founder can prescribe governance and application subject to limits thereafter noted.
Philips v. Bury (1694) and related authorities (various early English reports) Review of founders' rights over charitable trusts and endowments. Referred to as part of the English authorities establishing the founder's power to prescribe governance/application.
R v. Vice-Chancellor of Cambridge (1765) 3 Burr. 1647 Reservation that a founder cannot, unless special power reserved, vary trusts or modify application of endowment after constitution of corporation. Quoted to indicate limits on a founder's power to alter established trusts after constitution.
Ex Parte Bolton School (1789) 2 Bro. C.C. 662 Reinforces limits on founders' ability to vary trusts after constitution. Cited with other authorities to show that founders cannot unilaterally alter established charitable trusts.
Attorney General v. Dulwich College (1841) 4 Beav. 255 Further authority on the limitation of founders' ability to vary trusts. Used to state the English legal background limiting founders' post-constitution powers.
Gossami Sri Gridhariji v. Romanlalji Gossami (16 I.A. 137) That under Hindu law, when worship of an idol is founded, shebaitship vests in the founder and his heirs unless disposed otherwise or usage points otherwise. Applied to show the accepted principle in Hindu law governing shebaitship succession.
Mohan Lalji v. Gordhan Lalji (10 Ind. Cas. 337; 40 I.A. 97) Illustration of principles about shebaitship and endowments under Hindu law. Placed among authorities demonstrating that founders may prescribe succession unless contrary usage appears.
Kunjamani Dasi v. Nikunja Behary Das (32 Ind. Cas. 823) Authority relating to religious endowments and their management under Hindu law. Referenced as part of the consistent body of Hindu law authorities on shebaitship and endowments.
Juggut Mohini Dossee v. Sokheemoney Dossee (14 M.I.A. 289) That once a grant is made it cannot be revoked (irrevocability of grant); limitations on altering the grant. Used to show that grants/dedications, once constituted, are not revocable by the founder in a manner defeating the trust.
Teertdruppa v. Soonderajien (1851 Mad. S.D.A. 57) That while the shebait is bound to carry out legitimate directions of the founder at establishment, the shebait is otherwise free to manage the trust without interference. Applied to explain the balance between founder's directions at establishment and subsequent management by shebaits.
Fatmabibi v. Advocate General of Bombay (6 B. 42) Example of cases where there may be controversy whether dedication is charitable or private aggrandisement. Referred to as an example of cases that raise doubts; court found no such doubt in the present case.
Limji Nowroji Banaji v. Bapuji Ruttonji (11 B. 441) Another authority illustrating potential controversy over charitable vs. private purposes. Cited among authorities to note possible areas of dispute; not found applicable here as the endowment was genuine.
Yeap Cheah Neo v. Ong Cheng Neo (1875) 6 P.C. 381 Illustrative of cases involving questions whether dedications are truly charitable. Referred to in a list of authorities on potential controversy; the court held the present facts left no room for doubt.
Commissioners of Income Tax v. Pemsel (1891) A.C. 531 Landmark authority on charitable purposes (English law) cited as part of comparative discussion on charitable endowments. Quoted among authorities to frame permissible scope of charitable trusts; used to parry possible objections to the nature of the endowment.
Bhupati Nath v. Smrittiirtho v. Ram Lal Mitra (3 Ind. Cas. 642) Explains the fundamental distinction between a gift to a sentient being and an offering/dedication to a deity. Applied to show that offerings (bhog/prasad) do not become property of the officiating priest but are for maintenance of the shrine and distribution as part of worship.
Girijanund Datta Jha v. Sailajanund Datta Jha (23 C. 645) Support for the proposition that offerings to a deity are not the property of the officiating priest but contribute to the shrine's maintenance. Used to justify that participation in distribution of bhog is consistent with the endowment and not a private appropriation by priests.
Maharanee Shibessouree Debia v. Mothooranath Acharjo (13 M.I.A. 270) Authority on how consecrated offerings are to be regarded and distributed in the context of temple worship. Relied upon to illustrate the established practice that prasad is for distribution and maintenance of the shrine rather than private property of officiants.
Chotalal Lakhmiram v. Manohar Ganesh (24 B. 50; 2 Bom. L.R. 516) Case supporting the treatment of offerings and the nature of continued worship of consecrated images. Invoked with others to explain the daily ritual treatment of the deity and the distribution of bhog/prasad.
Ram Parkash Das v. Anand Das (33 Ind. Cas. 583) Further authority on offerings and worship practices; reinforces that offerings are not private property of officiants. Referenced to support the court's view of the character of bhog and its distribution as part of religious practice.
Kalyana Venkataramana Aiyangar v. Kasturi Ranga Aiyangar (38 Ind. Cas. 73) Illustrative authority on temple worship practices and treatment of offerings/prasad. Used as part of the body of authorities explaining the religious context for distribution of bhog and its importance to devotees.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in a sequential factual and legal analysis based solely on the evidence and authorities set out below.

  1. Fact-finding: The court accepted the findings of the lower courts that (a) images were consecrated by the founders more than two centuries ago; (b) temples existed and arrangements for daily worship, including bhog, had long been in place; (c) there were lands and income routinely applied to meet puja expenses; and (d) various service-lauds (drummer, barber, gardener, woodman, fisherman) have been employed, showing ritual continuity.
  2. Dedication/inference: Relying on established authorities, the court held that a written instrument was not essential to prove a valid dedication where the application of proceeds and family conduct permitted an inference of endowment. On that basis the court concluded there was an endowment applied to daily worship and bhog.
  3. Usage and intention: The court accepted the proposition that immemorial or long-continued usage is an index of the founder's intention; where a practice has continued for generations invariable practice can render the founder's intention almost conclusive. The courts below had found an established practice of female-line descendants participating in bhog after offering, and male-line descendants occupying the shebaitship by turns (palas). The appellate court treated that finding as legitimately inferring an original direction by the founders.
  4. Founder's powers: The court examined English authorities showing that founders of charitable corporations may prescribe government and application of revenues (subject to limits), and applied analogous principles in Hindu law: when worship is founded the shebaitship vests in the founder and his heirs unless otherwise disposed or unless usage points elsewhere. The court held there is no reason why a founder could not direct management arrangements not inconsistent with the trust's religious/charitable character.
  5. Limits and tests: The court noted limits — a founder cannot, after constitution, arbitrarily vary trusts and directives inconsistent with the endowment's nature; the test is whether the founder's direction is inconsistent with the character of the religious and charitable trust or a colourable attempt to evade rules against perpetuity. The court observed that while some cases raise doubt whether a dedication is genuinely charitable, the present facts showed a genuine, valid endowment for over two centuries.
  6. Nature of offerings: The court emphasized the legal distinction between gifts to sentient beings and offerings to a deity: offerings (bhog/prasad) are not treated as the private property of officiating priests but contribute to maintenance of the shrine and distribution among family and guests. Given this, a direction enabling descendants through daughters to partake in distribution of consecrated food was not inconsistent with the endowment.
  7. Conclusion as to competence: Drawing together these principles and the uncontested long usage, the court concluded it was competent for the founder to prescribe that shebaitship vest in male-line descendants while directing that female-line descendants be entitled to participate in the bhog distribution.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is dismissed and the decree of the Subordinate Judge (in concurrence with the Trial Court) is confirmed. In the words of the opinion, the result is that the lower courts' decree is confirmed and the appeal is dismissed with costs.

Implications:

  • The direct effect on the parties is that the plaintiffs' right to participate in the bhog, as recognised by the lower courts, is upheld and the first defendant's challenge is rejected.
  • The court treated the facts and long-standing usage as determinative; it did not purport to create a new general rule beyond applying existing authorities on dedication, shebaitship, founders' directions, and the legal nature of offerings/prasad. No broader novel precedent was announced beyond the application of established principles to the facts of this case.

    Rambrama Chatterjee v. Kedar Nath Banerjee And Ors.

    1. This is an appeal by the first defendant in a suit for declaration that the plaintiffs are entitled to participate in the bhog offered to three idols and for consequential relief. One Gopinath Chatterjee, the common ancestor of the plaintiffs and defendants, more than 200 years ago, consecrated an image of Vishnu. His sons Nandadulal Chatterjee and Durga Charan Chatterjee followed in the footsteps of their father; each of them consecrated an image of Siva, and Durga Charan Chatterjee consecrated, in addition, an image of Kali. Temples were erected, those now in existence were consecrated in 1792 and 1801 and elaborate arrangements were made for the daily worship. Properties were also dedicated to secure the due performance of the worship, though this is not directly evidenced by a written document. But the execution of a document is not essential for the purpose of a valid dedication which may be inferred from application of proceeds and family conduct; Muddun Lal v. Komul Bibee 8 W.R. 42; Moonohar Ganesh Tambekar v. Lakhmiram Govindram 12 B. 247 : 12 Ind. Jur. 387 : 6 Ind. Dec. (N.S.) 650.; Abhiram Goswami Mohant v. Shyama Charan Nandi 4 Ind. Cas. 449 : 36 I.A. 148 at p. 164 : 36 C. 1003 : 10 C.L.J. 284 : 6 A.L.J. 857 : 11 Bom. L.R. 1234 : 19 M.L.J. 530 : 14 C.W.N. 1 (P.C.). It is established that from a long time past, service lauds have been held by persons who discharge various duties in connection with the temples and the worship, such as the dome who beats the drum during the daily puja of the thakurs, the barber who supplies flowers and bel leaves for the puja and provides light at dusk in, the temples, the gardner who supplies plantain leaves, the woodman who procures fuel, and the fisherman who supplies fish for the bhog. There is further evidence of the existence of a bund or tank which covers an area of 1100 bighas, of gardens and of other lands, the income whereof is regularly appropriated to meet the expenses of the puja including the bhog offering. It is not necessary to determine here whether the dedication was of the completest kind known to the law; Jagadindra Nath Roy v. Hemanta Kumari Debi 31 I.A. 203 : 32 C. 129 : 8 C.W.N. 809 : 6 Bom. L.R. 765 : 1 A.L.J. 585 : 8 Sar. P.C.J. 698 (P.C.); or whether the property was secular, charged with a religious trust; Ashutosh Dutt v. Doorga Churn Chatterjee 6 I.A. 182 : 5 C. 438 : 5 C.L.R. 296 : 4 Sar. P.C.J. 58 : 3 Suth P.C.J. 694 : 3 Ind. Jur. 571 : 3 Shome L.R. 32 : 2 Ind. Dec. (N.S.) 888 (P.C.). It is sufficient to hold, as the Courts below have done, that there is an endowment and that the income thereof has been and is applied for the performance of the daily worship pf the idols including the offering of the bhog.

    2. The plaintiffs allege that they and their ancestors, who are descendants of the founders through their daughters, participated in the cooked rice bhog from generation to generation till the first defendant obstructed them on the 31st December 1914. The Courts below have concurrently found that the descendants of the founders in the male line have been the shebaits, and as their number increased they arranged amongst themselves to carry on the worship, as is common, by turns or palas. The Courts have further found that the descendants of the founders in the female line have 'al-ways participated in the bhog after it has been duly offered to the idols. From the long continuance of this arrangement, which has been in operation now for several generations, the Courts have come to the conclusion that this system must have had its origion in a direction given by the founders. This was a legitimate inference, for as stated by Muthusami Iyer, J., in Venkatachalapati v. Subbarayadu 13 M. 293 : 4 Ind. Dec. (N.S.) 916, a rule of determination is looked for in the case of such institutions in their usage, because it is an index to the intention of those who founded and endowed them and who have since kept them up; Greedharee Doss v. Nundokishore Doss Marsh 573 : 2 Hay 633; Thackersey Dewraj v. Hurbhum Nursey 8 B. 432 : 4 Ind. Dec. (N.S.) 664. The proof of the intention of the founder becomes almost conclusive where, as here, the usage is immamorial, though intention may be presumed from a number of instances extending over a limited period, provided only that the existence of an invariable practice is made out by clear and unambiguous evidence; Raghubhushana v. Vidiavaridhi 34 Ind. Cas. 875.

    3. The question thus arises, whether it was competent to the founder to direct that the shebaitship shall be vested in his descendants through his sons, and that his descendants through his daughters should have the right to participate in the bhog offering. The first defendant, who alone amongst the shebaits contests the claim of the plaintiffs to participate in the bhog offering, has 10: been able to invoke any general principle or to cite any authority in support of his contention. In the words of Lord Mansfield in St. John's College v. Todington (1757) 1 Burr. 158 at p. 200 : 97 E.R. 845, a charitable corporation, in so far as it is charitable, is the creature of the founder. On this view, Lord Hardwicke had ruled in Green v. Rutherforth (1750) 1 Ves. Sen 462 at pp. 468, 472 : 27 E.R. 1144, that the founder may provide for the Government and administration of his creature and the application in perpetuity of the revenue; see also Philips v. Bury (1694) 1 Ld. Raym 5 : Comb. 268 : Holt 715 : 4 Mod. 106 : Skin 447 : Carth 180 : 1 Shower 360 : 2 T.R. 346 : 91 E.R. 900, which was ultimately decided by the House of Lords Philips v. Bury (1694) Shower P.C. 35 : 15 Ld. Jo. 441 : 1 Burn. E.L. 442 : 2 T.R. 346 : 4 Mod. 106 : Skin 447 : 1 E.R. 24 and contains an elaborate review of the rights of founders of charitable and religious trusts. This is subject to the reservation that a founder may not, unless special power has been reserved in this behalf, after the constitution of the corporation, vary the trusts or modify the application of the endowment or its. revenues; R v. Vice-Chancellor of Cambridge (1765) 3 Burr. 1647 at p. 1656 : 97 E.R. 1027; Ex Parte Bolton School (1789) 2 Bro. C.C. 662 : 29 E.R. 367 Attorney General v. Dulwich College (1841) 4 Beav. 255 : 5 Jur. 814 : 49 E.R. 337. These principles have been applied in the case of religious endowments created in accordance with Hindu Law. According to that law, when the worship of an idol has been founded, the shebaitihip is vested in the founder and his heirs unless he has disposed of it otherwise, or there has been some usage or course of dealing which points to a different mode of devolution; Gossami Sri Gridhariji v. Romanlalji Gossami 16 I.A. 137 : 17 C. 3 : 13 Ind. Jur. 211 : 5 Sar. P.C.J. 350 : 8 Ind. Dec. (N.S.) 541 (P.C.); Jagadindra Nath Roy v. Hemanta Kumari Debi 31 I.A. 203 : 32 C. 129 : 8 C.W.N. 809 : 6 Bom. L.R. 765 : 1 A.L.J. 585 : 8 Sar. P.C.J. 698 (P.C.); Mohan Lalji v. Gordhan Lalji 10 Ind. Cas. 337 : 40 I.A. 97 : 35 A. 283 : 17 C.W.N. 741 : 11 A.L.J. 548 : 17 C.L.J. 612 : 15 Bom. L.R. 606 : (1913) M.W.N. 536 : 14 M.L.T. 27 (P.C.); Kunjamani Dasi v. Nikunja Behary Das 32 Ind. Cas. 823 : 22 C.L.J. 404 : 20 C.W.N. 314. There is no reason why the founder, who is competent to provide for the government and administration of the trust, should not be able to give a direction for its management, which is not inconsistent with its character as a religious and charitable trust. No doubt, as held in Juggut Mohini Dossee v. Sokheemoney Dossee 14 M.I.A 289 : 17 W.R. 41 : 10 B.L.R. 19 : 2 Suth. P.C.J. 512 : 2 Sar. P.C.J. 23 20 E.R. 795, the grant once made cannot be re-samad and is irrevocable; but so long as the foundation continues, the shebait is, on the one hand, bound to carry out all legitimate directions given by the founder at the time of the establishment, and is, on the other hand, free to manage the trust without interference by him or his representatives: Teertdruppa v. Soonderajien (1851) Mad. S.D.A. 57. The test in each case is, whether the direction given by the founder is inconsistent with the nature of the endowment as a religious and charitable trust and is a colourable device for the evasion of the law of perpetuities. There may be room for controversy in a concrete case, whether the dedication is in reality for a charitable purpose or is designed for private aggrandisement; Fatmabibi v. Advocate General of Bombay 6 B. 42 : 6 Ind. Jur. 253 : 3 Ind. Dec. (N.S.) 485; Limji Nowroji Banaji v. Bapuji Ruttonji 11 B. 441 : 6 Ind. Dec. (N.S.) 289; Yeap Cheah Neo v. Ong Cheng Neo (1875) 6 P.C. 381; Commissioners of Income Tax v. Pemsel (1891) A.C. 531 : 61 L.J.Q.B. 265 : 65 L.T. 627 : 55 J.P. 805. But there is manifestly no room for such doubt in the present case. There is unquestionably a genuine and valid debuiter which has been in existence for more than two centuries; the shebaitship has been enjoyed by the descendants of the sons of the founder, at the same time, after the bhog offerings have been made to the idols, the descendants of the daughters of the founder have participated in them. The Court will be slow to draw an inference which would defeat a right that has been exercised without question during so long a period as the present and unless such inference is irresistible the Court will presume everything that is reasonably possible to presume, in favour of such a right. It is now well-settled that, as explained in Bhupati Nath v. Smrittiirtho v. Ram Lal Mitra 3 Ind. Cas. 642 : 37 C. 128 : 14 C.W.N. 18 : 10 C.L.J. 355. There is a fundamental distinction between a gift to a sentient being and an offering or dedication to a deity. Subject to special usages to the contrary, the offerings do not become the property of the officiating priest, but contribute to the maintenance of the shrine with all its rights, ceremonies and charities: Girijanund Datta Jha v. Sailajanund Datta Jha 23 C. 645 : 12 Ind. Dec. (N.S.) 429; Maharanee Shibessouree Debia v. Mothooranath Acharjo 13 M.I.A. 270 : 13 W.R.P.C. 18 : 2 Suth P.C.J. 300 : 2 Sar. P.C.J. 528 : 20 E.R. 552; Chotalal Lakhmiram v. Manohar Ganesh 24 B. 50, 2 Bom. L.R. 516 : 4 C.W.N. 23, 261. A. 199, 199 : 7 Sar. P.C.J. 559 : 2 Ind. Dec. (N.S.) 570 (P.C.); Ram Parkash Das v. Anand Das 33 Ind. Cas. 583 : 43 I.A. 73 : 43 C. 707 : 20 C.W.N. 802 : 14 A.L.J. 621 : (1916) 1 M.W.N. 406 : 31 M.L.J. 1 : 18 Bom. L.R. 490 : 3 L.W. 556 : 24 C.L.J. 116 : 20 M.L.J. 267 (P.C.); Kalyana Venkataramana Aiyangar v. Kasturi Ranga Aiyangar 38 Ind. Cas. 73 : 20 M.L.T. 490 : 31 M.L.J. 777 : 5 L.W. 625 : (1917) M.W.N. 400 : 40 M. 212. We need not describe here in detail the normal type of continued worship of a consecrated image, the sweeping of the temple, the process of smearing, the removal of the previous day's offerings of flowers, the presentation of fresh flowers, the respectful oblation of rice with flowers and water, and other like practices. It is sufficient to state that the deity is, in short, conceived as a living being and is treated in the same way as the master of the house would be treated by his humble servant. The daily routine of life is gone through with minute accuracy; the vivified image is regaled with the necessaries and luxuries of life in due succession, even to the changing of clothes, the offering of cooked and uncooked food, and the retirement to rest. The dedicated food, known as bhog, is, after completion of the worship, distributed in charity amongst members of the family as also among guests invited and uninvited; for in the oldest Brahminical writings hospitality is regarded as the discharge of a common debt to humanity and the guest is honoured as a divinity. In our opinion, a direction that the descendants of the daughters of the founder should participate in such a distribution of consecrated food, is in no way inconsistent with the purpose of the endowment. The pecuniary value of the bhog may be and in the present case is insignificant from a secular point of view. But to the pious Hindu, the worth of prasad or consecrated food, which has been dedicated to the deity, cannot be measured in money; and the right to participate in its distribution would obviously possess special importance in the eyes of the descendants of the founder. Our conclusion is, that it was competent to the founder, not only to prescribe the line of succession to the shebaitship in the descendants of his sons, but also to direct that the decendants of his daughters would be entitled to participate in the bhog offerings dedicated to the idols established by him.

    4. The result is, that the decree made by the Subordinate Judge, in concurrence with the Trial Court, is confirmed and this appeal dismissed with costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Rambrama Chatterjee v. Kedar Nath Banerjee And Ors.
    (Aug 14, 1922)