Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • section 105 read with section 52(1)(a) of the Bengal Tenancy Act
  • section 52(a) of the Bengal Tenancy Act
  • section 105 of the Bengal Tenancy Act
  • sub-section (2) of section 52
  • Bengal Tenancy Act, 1885,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • section 105 read with section 52(1)(a) of the Bengal Tenancy Act
  • section 52(a) of the Bengal Tenancy Act
  • section 105 of the Bengal Tenancy Act
  • sub-section (2) of section 52
  • Bengal Tenancy Act, 1885,
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This is an appeal under the Letters Patent from the decision of a single Judge of the Court which had overruled the decision of the Special Judge. The Special Judge had affirmed the decision of the Assistant Settlement Officer (ASO).

The appellant (a landlord) brought proceedings under section 105 of the Bengal Tenancy Act against numerous tenants. Some claims sought enhancement under section 30, while the claims relevant to this appeal sought additional rent under section 52(1)(a) in respect of land held by tenants in excess of the area for which rent had been previously paid.

Relevant factual circumstances: certain tenants had been in occupation since before the Survey and Settlement operations of 1898 and had been paying rent. A subsequent settlement and record-of-rights (finally published in 1917) showed the rent unchanged but recorded a larger area in the later survey than in the earlier settlement. The ASO, after comparing the surveys, allowed the landlord additional rent for the excess areas after making a 5% allowance for probable differences in area extraction. The Special Judge dismissed the tenants' appeal and upheld the ASO. On second appeal, Mr Justice Ross held that the landlord could not recover additional rent unless he proved the area at the inception of the tenancy was less than the later measured area, relying on earlier precedent. The present opinion disagreed with that view and allowed the appeal, restoring the ASO's decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, under section 52(1)(a) of the Bengal Tenancy Act, a landlord claiming additional rent for land "proved by measurement to be in excess of the area for which rent has been previously paid" must always prove the area of the holding at the inception of the tenancy (i.e., the original settlement), or whether an intermediate scientifically made settlement/measurement (such as the 1898 settlement) that established the area for which rent was paid can suffice to support a claim based on a later measurement showing excess.
  2. What is the burden of proof and its allocation where there are intermediate scientifically made surveys/settlements showing areas for which rent was paid and later surveys showing greater areas?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant relied on measurements recorded in an earlier scientifically conducted settlement (the record-of-rights published in 1898) showing the area for which the tenants had been paying rent, and on a later survey (publication in 1917) using the same measurement standard that showed the tenants in possession of excess lands. The appellant therefore claimed additional rent under section 52(1)(a).
  • In the lower courts (per Adami, J.), the appellant asserted that at the inception of the tenancies the area had been determined by an older measurement method (the use of a pole of ten cubits was specifically alleged in the application as a fact, though the ASO found issues about proving the standard used).

Respondents' (Tenants') Arguments

  • The tenants contended that the landlord had not proved that the lands in respect of which additional rent was claimed were in excess of the area comprised in the tenancy at its inception — i.e., they argued that the landlord must go back to the origin of the tenancy and prove the original area.
  • On appeal to the Special Judge and in this Court, the tenants urged that the survey measurements (particularly the later one) might have been inaccurate; the argument that the survey measurements were inaccurate was the principal point they urged to challenge the ASO's findings.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Gouri Pattra v. H.R. Reilly Principle that where there has been no prior scientific measurement and areas in zamindari papers were arrived at by guesswork, those entries cannot be treated as accurate proof of the area for which rent was paid; landlord must show original terms and any process of measurement. The Court distinguished that case on its facts: Gouri Pattra applied where there was no previous scientific measurement. The present case involved an intermediate scientifically made settlement (1898), so Gouri Pattra did not dictate the same result here.
Rajendra Lal Goswami v. Chunder Bhusan Goswami Held (as interpreted by Ross, J.) that the landlord must show the alleged excess is really an excess over the area of the tenure as originally created; sub-section (2) was read as mandatory to require proof of origin in some circumstances. The Court observed that this decision was founded on Gouri Pattra and noted that in Rajendra Lal Goswami there was no intermediate settlement by which area could be definitely ascertained; thus it did not govern the present facts where there was a scientific intermediate settlement.
Raj Kumar Pratab Sahay v. Ram Lal Singh Followed Gouri Pattra: where no scientific previous measurement was shown, landlord must prove original settlement/area at inception before claiming additional rent. The Court treated this case as another authority limited to situations lacking a prior scientific measurement; it did not apply to the present circumstances where an intermediate scientific settlement existed.
Durga Priya Chowdhuri v. Nazra Gain Held that it is not in all cases necessary for the landlord to prove the area of the holding at the inception of the tenancy; it is sufficient for the landlord to establish that rent had been assessed on a certain area and that the tenant is in possession of land not included in that area and on which no rent was assessed. The present Court cited this authority as supporting the view that an intermediate assessment/settlement can be sufficient to determine the area for which rent was previously paid, and therefore supports landlord's claim where later scientific measurement shows excess.
Ratan Lal Biswas v. Ladu Halsuna Followed the line that where there is no scientific measurement at origin, landlord must prove origin area or other particulars (e.g., boundary encroachment, rent per bigha). The Court treated it as an authority limited to cases without prior scientific survey and thus not controlling here.
Akbur Ali Mian v. Mussammat Hira Bibi Interpreted “the area for which rent has been previously paid” in section 52 to mean the area with reference to which the rent previously paid had been assessed or adjusted. The court cited this interpretation in support of the position that an intermediate recorded assessment (such as the 1898 record-of-rights) may constitute the relevant area for section 52 purposes.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's reasoning proceeds from a textual and contextual reading of section 52(1)(a) of the Bengal Tenancy Act. The section states, in plain terms, that "Every tenant shall be liable to pay additional rent for all land proved by measurement to be in excess of the area for which rent has been previously paid by him..." The Court emphasized that the statutory phrase focuses on the area for which rent has been previously paid, not, in all cases, strictly the area at the inception of the tenancy.

The Court distinguished two factual categories:

  • Cases where there has been no prior scientific measurement or assessment (for example, where zamindari papers or rent receipts are the only entries and those were originally fixed by guesswork). In such cases Gouri Pattra and related authorities require the landlord to prove the original settlement or the process by which the earlier amounts were fixed, because the earlier entries cannot be accepted as accurate without proof.
  • Cases where there is evidence of an intermediate scientifically made settlement/measurement (as with the record-of-rights published in 1898) that fixed the area for which the tenants were paying rent. In that category the settlement is treated as defining the relationship between landlord and tenant and is presumed correct until the contrary is proved; the burden does not require the landlord to go back to the inception of the tenancy.

Applying these distinctions to the facts before the Court:

  1. The ASO produced the previous survey and settlement khatian (record-of-rights) from 1898 which showed both the area and the rent then recorded; that settlement had been made by scientific measurement and was conducted publicly with opportunity to object.
  2. The subsequent settlement (published in 1917) also used the same scientific method and showed the tenants in occupation of excess land, while the rent remained unchanged. The ASO allowed additional rent after making a 5% allowance for probable difference in area extraction between surveys.
  3. The tenant's main challenge on appeal was to impugn the accuracy of the survey measurements; the Special Judge did not accept that contention and found both surveys to have been made by a scientific process and that the comparison provided sufficient evidence of excess.
  4. The Court concluded that where an intermediate scientific settlement exists and was accepted by the parties (as the 1898 settlement was presumed accepted), the landlord has discharged the burden required by section 52 by producing the earlier measured record showing the area for which rent was paid and the later measurement showing excess. The onus shifts to the tenant to show that the intermediate settlement did not accurately represent the position.

Both Dawson Miller, C.J. and Adami, J. followed this analytical path: they treated earlier decisions (Gouri Pattra and those following it) as limited to situations lacking intermediate scientific measurement, and they relied on the wording of section 52 and on the public and scientific nature of the 1898 settlement to justify allowing the landlord's claim for additional rent on the later-measured excess area.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court allowed the appeal. The Court set aside the decree of Ross, J., restored the decision of the Assistant Settlement Officer granting additional rent for the excess areas (after allowance), and awarded costs to the appellant for the proceedings here and before Ross, J. The core ruling may be stated as: Appeal allowed; ASO's decision restored; appellant entitled to additional rent for excess areas and to costs.

Immediate consequences for the parties:

  • The appellant-landlord is entitled to recover additional rent judged "just and equitable" upon the excess areas as found by the Assistant Settlement Officer (subject to the allowance applied by the ASO and subject to any further court direction consistent with this judgment).
  • The decree of the single Judge (Ross, J.) denying recovery was set aside; the ASO's award is reinstated.

Broader legal implication (as reflected in the opinion):

The decision clarifies that section 52(1)(a) does not universally require proof of the area at the inception of the tenancy; where there is a duly made and accepted intermediate scientific settlement or assessment that records the area for which rent was paid (and that settlement was public and susceptible of challenge at the time), that intermediate record can constitute "the area for which rent has been previously paid" for the purposes of section 52(1)(a). Earlier authorities requiring proof of the original inception-area are confined to situations where no such scientific intermediate measurement exists. The Court therefore treated intermediate scientifically made settled areas as presumptively accurate and sufficient to support a later claim for additional rent when a later scientific measurement shows excess.

    Bishun Pragash Narayan Singh v. Achaib Dusadh

    Dawson Miller, C.J:— This is an appeal under the Letters Patent from the decision of a single Judge of the Court overruling the decision of the Special Judge who had affirmed that of the Assistant Settlement Officer.

    The appellant took proceedings under section 105 of the Bengal Tenancy Act as landlord against a large number of tenants claiming in some cases enhancement of rent under section 30 of the Act and in other cases additional rent under section 52(a).

    The present appeal is concerned only with the claims under the latter section in respect of land held by the tenants in excess of the area for which rent had been previously paid by them. In certain cases it was found that the tenants had been in occupation of their holdings since before the Survey and Settlement operations of 1898 and paying rent therefor to the landlord, and that the settlement and record-of-rights finally published in March 1917 showed that although the rent remained the same, the area of their holdings was in excess of that for which they had been paying rent according to the previous settlement. The Assistant Settlement Officer before whom the case came held that in the cases mentioned the landlord was entitled to an additional fair rent for the excess areas after making an allowance of 5 per cent, for probable difference in area extraction. An appeal by the tenants to the Special Judge was dismissed. On second appeal to this Court the case came before Mr. Justice Ross who took the view that in all such cases, in order to prove that the lands in respect of which an additional rent is claimed are in excess of the area for which rent was previously paid, the landlord must show that the area included in the tenancy at its inception was less than that subsequently shown by measurement to be in occupation of the tenant. It followed from this, in his view, that although the tenants' holdings were proved by scientific measurement at the previous survey and settlement operations, made some twenty years earlier, to have been less than that for which they were still paying the same rent as shown by the subsequent survey, the landlord could not recover any additional rent in respect of the excess area. For this finding he relied upon the decisions in the following cases: Gouri Pattra v. H.R Reilly, Rajendra Lal Goswami v. Chunder Bhusan Goswami, and Rajkumar Pratab Sahay v. Ram Lal Singh.

    With great respect to the learned Judge, I am unable to concur in the view taken by him. On referring to section 52(a) of the Bengal Tenancy Act it does not appear that the tenant's liability to pay additional rent is limited to cases where the area is in excess of that comprised in the settlement at its inception, but merely to cases where the land is proved by measurement to be in excess of the area for which rent has been previously paid by him. The section provides as follows:

    “52.(1) Every tenant shall—

    (a) be liable to pay additional rent for all land proved by measurement to be in excess of the area for which rent has been previously paid by him, unless it is proved that the excess is due to the addition to the tenure or holding of land which having previously belonged to the tenure or holding was lost by diluvion or otherwise, without any reduction of the rent being made”.

    The exception in the latter part of this section does not apply to the present case. By clause (b) of the section the tenant is entitled to a reduction of rent in similar circumstances where the measurement shows a deficiency in the area of his tenure or holding as compared with the area for which rent has been previously paid by him. And in the case of some of the tenants the Assistant Settlement Officer allowed such reductions but we are not concerned with them in the present appeal.

    Where no previous measurement has been made upon a scientific basis from which the actual area of the land held by the tenant can be accurately determined and compared with the area proved to be held at the date of the claim, no doubt the landlord is confronted with a more serious problem in proving an excess of area, and generally speaking he could only discharge the burden of proof in the case supposed by showing that the area of the tenure or holding at its inception was less than that subsequently shown by proper measurement to be in occupation of the tenant. Consequently it was held in Gouri Pattra v. Reilly in 1893 , that the mere fact that a measurement made under Chapter X of the Bengal Tenancy Act, 1885, showed the tenants to be in occupation of lands in excess of the areas shown in the zamindari papers and rent receipts did not necessarily prove that the landlord was entitled to an additional rent. It is important to bear in mind that in that case it was found that at no previous time had there been a measurement of the lands in suit, and that the actual areas let out were originally ascertained by guess work without any accurate survey, and it was the areas so arrived at that were entered in the landlord's papers. The Court thought it would be impossible in these circumstances to find that the areas were accurately stated in the landlord's papers. They added that it was for the zemindar to show that the lands were in excess of those for which rents were being paid and that to do this it was for him to show what those lands are and what were the terms of the original settlement and what was the process of measurement, if any, adopted. This has been relied on for the proposition that in all cases, even if there has been an intermediate settlement, the landlord mutt go back to the inception of the tenancy and prove what area was then settled. I do not think the decision can be held to support this view. Tn dealing with the object of Chapter X of the Bengal Tenancy Act, the judgment states that it is to enable the landlords and tenants to know their relative positions towards one another and not to disturb previously existing relations unless it can be shown that they have terminated, and added, “The zamindar in this case is bound to show how the areas in the last settlement with the raiyats were ascertained and that the raiyats are now in possession of excess lards and consequently liable to pay additional rent therefore.” The settlement and record-of-rights defines the relationship between landlord and tenant in various respects including the area of the holdings for which rent is paid and is presumed to represent what is the relationship between them until the contrary is proved. The Settlement in 1898 was made in the presence of both parties and accepted without objection as representing the area for which rent is paid. The effect of such a settlement would be to throw the onus upon the party questioning it, in this case the tenant, to show that it did not accurately represent the true state of affairs. In the present case therefore, it must be presumed that the Settlement of 1898 was correct and the initial onus cast upon the landlord is discharged. The subsequent Settlement shows an area arrived at by the same process of measurement to be in excess of that for which rent has been previously paid.

    The later decisions which have been referred to are based upon the decision in Gouri Pattra's case and do not carry the matter any further in so far as the general principle is concerned. In none of them was there an intermediate Settlement by which the area could be definitely ascertained. Rajendra Lal Goswami v. Chandra Bhusan Goswami was complicated by the fact that the excess claimed by the landlord was alleged by the tenant to be due to the addition of land previously belonging to the tenure but lost by diluvion, which is not the case here. In Raj Kumar Pratab Sohay v. Ram Lal Singh there was no intermediate Settlement and therefore the original settlement had to be proved before it could be shown that the lands were in excess of those for which rent was previously paid. In the later case of Durga Priya Chowdhnri v. Nazra Gain it was definitely held that it is not in all cases necessary for the landlord to prove the area of the holding at the time of the inception of the tenancy. It is sufficient for the landlord to establish that since the inception of the tenancy rent has been assessed on the basis of a certain area and that the tenant is in possession of lands not included in that area and on which no rent was assessed.

    In the present case the previous survey and settlement khatian were produced and proved, and from these it appears on comparison with the recent survey, in which the method of measurement was the same, that the tenants are holding lands in excess of those for which, they were paying the same rent since 1898. The only point which appears to have been urged by the tenants on appeal to the Special Judge was that the survey measurements must have been inaccurate, an argument which did not commend itself to the Special Judge. In this respect, I concur with his view. On the facts proved, I think, the appellant has satisfied the burden of proof required by section 52 of the Act, and is entitled to the additional rents such as may be just and equitable upon the excess areas found by the Assistant Settlement Officer. The appeal is allowed. The decree of Ross, J., is set aside and that of the Assistant Settlement Officer restored. The appellant is entitled to his costs here and before Ross, J.

    Adami, J.:— The appellant in applications under section 105 read with section 52(1)(a) of the Bengal Tenancy Act claimed additional rent in respect of lands in the holdings of the respondents, his tenants in village Hiramni, which, according to his allegation, were shown by the measurement entered in the record-of-rights to be in excess of the area for which rent had been previously paid by them. He asserted in the application that at the inception of the tenancies the area of the holdings had been determined by measurement with a pole of ten cubits.

    The Assistant Settlement Officer decided that the appellant had failed to prove either actual encroachment or that there was a practice of settlement of land by measurement in the estate, and, if there was such a practice, how the measure adopted for the purpose compared with the present survey measure. He found, however, that the respondents had held the tenancies from the time of the previous settlement, the record-of-rights of which was finally published in 1898, and that there had been no alteration of rent since that year, and held that the appellant landlord was entitled to additional rent for any excess area found on comparison of the survey area of 1898 with the area shown in the record-of-rights published in 1917. Therefore, after making an allowance of 5 per cent, for probable difference in the area extraction of the same field by different persons at different times, he assessed a fair rent in respect of the excess area so found; and granted the applications to that extent.

    The Special Judge, on appeal by the present respondents, upheld the decision of the Assistant Settlement Officer, finding that at each survey the area was determined by a scientific process and that the comparison gave sufficient evidence of an excess.

    On second appeal the learned Judge of this Court has disagreed with the Lower Courts and has held, basing his decision on Gouri Pattra v. H.R Reilly, Rajendra Lal Goswami v. Chunder Bhusan Goswami and Raj Kumar Pratab Sahay v. Ram Lal Singh, that, in order to show that the lands in respect of which an additional rent is claimed are lands held in excess of those for which rent was paid, the landlord must prove an excess over the quantity of land included in the tenancy at its inception, and that the criterion is the area of the holding at the inception of the tenancy and not any intermediate measurement. The learned Judge refused to accept the argument that the present case should be differentiated from the cases on which he relied because in the present case there were two survey measurements in both of which the same scientific standard was employed, as he found that there is no authority to support the view, and no justification in principle to support the argument.

    Now section 52(1)(a) is perfectly clear in its terms; it provides that.

    “Every tenant shall be liable to pay additional rent for all land proved by measurement to be in excess of the area for which rent has been previously paid by him”,

    and sub-section (2) runs,

    “In determining the area for which rent has been previously paid, the Court shall, if so required by any party to the suit, have regard to—

    (a) the origin and conditions of the tenancy, for instance whether the rent was a consolidated rent for the entire tenure or holding.

    (d) the length of the measure used or in local use at the time of the origin of the tenancy as compared with that used or in local use at the time of the institution of the suit”.

    In the case of Gouri Patira v. H.R Reilly, the landlord sought to prove the area for which rent had been previously paid by the tenants by entries of area in his zamindari papers and in rent receipts. There was no evidence in that case that there had been any measurement of the lands according to any actual standard and it was found that the areas shown in the zamindari papers were arrived at by guess work. The Court rightly held that the areas shown in the papers could not be accepted. The judgment shows that it was assumed that the tenants had required the Assistant Settlement Officer to have regard to the points mentioned in sub-section (2). In the absence of other evidence of measurement the Court decided that it was for the landlord to show what were the terms of the original settlement and whether it was by any, and if so by what process of measurement.

    In the case of Rajendra Lal Goswami v. Chunder Bhusan Goswami, the landlord sought to base the comparison on the area shown in the Revenue Survey papers of 1854. The learned Judges appear to have considered that sub-section (2) of section 52 was mandatory, whether the ton nuts required the Court to have regard to the origin of the tenancy or not, and held that the landlord must show that the alleged excess is really an excess over the area of the tenure as originally created. They state. “We think the language of sub-section (2) clause (a), by referring to the origin and conditions of the tenancy as some of the circumstances which the Court is required to have regard to, shows that the expression ‘the area for which rent has been previously paid’ must be under-stood to mean the area with reference to which the rent previously paid had been assessed or adjusted”.

    The decision in Raj Kumar Pratab Sahay v. Ram Lal Singh followed that in Gouri Pattra v. H.R Reilly, as did the decision in Ratan Lal Biswas v. Ladu Halsuna, but in both of these cases the landlord sought to base the comparison on entries in zamindari papers and receipts; no scientific previous measurement was shown.

    The above cases are authorities for the principle that where there is no good evidence of scientific measurement, assessment or adjustment since the inception of the tenancy, the landlord will have to prove what was the area at the origin of the tenancy, or that the lands originally settled were defined by boundaries which have been encroached upon, or that rent was settled at a certain rent per bigha.

    In Rajendra Lal Goswami v. Chunder Bhusan Goswami and in Akbur Ali Mian v. Mussammat Hira Bibi it has been held that the words “the area for which rent has been previously paid” in section 52 mean “the area with reference to which the rent previously paid has been assessed or adjusted”, and in the case of Durga Priya Choudhuri v. Nazra Gain, where the District Judge had held that it was necessary for the plaintiff to prove the area, of the holding at the time of the inception of the tenancy, Sir Asutosh Mukherjee, Acting Chief Justice, held that the view taken by the District Judge was erroneous and that it was sufficient for the landlord to prove that, since the creation of the tenancy, rent had been assessed, that when rent was last assessed the assessment was on the basis of a certain area and that the defendants were in possession of land on which no rent was assessed it the time.

    Now in the present case there is nothing to show when the tenancies were created, or how rent was assessed, whether the rent was a consolidated rent, or was assessed at a certain rate per bigha, or whether there was any measurement of the holdings at the inception. We have the evidence, however, of the record-of-rights published in 1898 that a certain rent was then being paid for a holding of a certain area. During the preparation of the record-of-rights the holding was measured scientifically and the area shown in the record was the result of the measurement; the settlement proceedings were carried on publicly and the parties may be presumed to have been present and to have had every opportunity of objecting. The rent payable by the tenants was ascertained and recorded, and it must be presumed that the tenants accepted that rent as the rent payable for the area as recorded. They did not come forward and prove that the area recorded was less than the area of the holding at its inception. The entry shows that the rent entered there was either the rent for the area which the tenants had been paying previous to 1898, or was the rent assessed or adjusted after dispute during the settlement proceedings between the parties as to the amount payable. In my opinion the area shown in the record-of-rights was the area with reference to which the rent previously paid by the respondents was assessed or adjusted. The respondents continued to pay the same rent for nearly twenty years and at the end of that time, in the settlement of 1917, it was found after scientific measurement by the same standard that the area of the holding for which that rent was being paid had increased. I am of opinion that according to the clear wording of section 52(1)(a), the landlord was entitled to additional rent for the land in the holdings which was not covered by the area entered in the record-of-rights of 1898.

    I would therefore allow the appeal with costs and set aside the decree now appealed against.

    Appeal allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bishun Pragash Narayan Singh v. Achaib Dusadh
    (Mar 27, 1922)