Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Smart Summary

Summary of Opinion by Mookerjee, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from a suit by the plaintiff for ejectment, assessment of rent and premium, recovery of arrears, and incidental reliefs. On 22 June 1899 the plaintiff granted a kayami maurasi mokarari pattah (lease) in respect of Chakdari jungle lands in the Sunderbuns to Syamacharan Das. On 12 January 1902 the lessee's representatives conveyed their interest to the defendant.

The plaintiff's case was that, although under the lease the defendant was entitled to 2,500 bighas, the defendant occupied 2,729 bighas 5 cottahs and 11 chattaks; the plaintiff sought possession of 229 bighas 5 cottahs and 11 chattaks, and alternatively sought assessment of rent and premium on all land in excess of 2,000 bighas (the original quantity mentioned in the lease) and recovery of arrears.

The Subordinate Judge dismissed the ejectment claim but held the plaintiff entitled to rent and premium at the lease rates on 500 bighas in excess of 2,000 bighas (i.e., up to 2,500) and to rent at Re. 1-8 per bigha and premium at Rs. 5 per bigha on lands in excess of 2,500 bighas; arrears were decreed for specified years. Dissatisfied, the defendant appealed on three grounds and the plaintiff filed cross-objections on two grounds. This Court delivered judgment allowing the appeal in part and disallowing the cross-objections, with modification of the Subordinate Judge's decree as to the rates applied to a specified area.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a decree for ejectment in respect of all lands in excess of 2,500 bighas.
  2. At what rate should rent and premium be assessed and in respect of what excess lands.
  3. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a decree for arrears antecedent to the institution of the suit.

Arguments of the Parties

Defendant's Arguments (as stated in the opinion)

  • The determination of the excess area assessable should allow an allowance for a towpath.
  • Rent and premium should be assessed throughout at the rates mentioned in the lease (i.e., the original lease rates).
  • Arrears should not have been decreed for any period antecedent to the institution of the suit.

Plaintiff's Arguments / Cross-objections (as stated in the opinion)

  • The plaintiff was entitled to a decree for ejectment with regard to all lands in excess of 2,500 bighas.
  • Rent and premium should have been assessed at higher rates than those fixed by the Subordinate Judge.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Brojo v. Kedar Support for the proposition that the landlord in the earlier litigation was "in no sense what is called a formal party." The Court relied on this to show the landlord (plaintiff) had participated and therefore could not take a position inconsistent with the earlier judgment; it helped justify treating the earlier adjudication as binding in substance.
Soorjomonee v. Suddanund Enunciation that the conclusive nature of a previous adjudication must be determined by reference to the substance and not to the form of the proceedings. Used to support the view that the prior litigation's substantive determination precluded the plaintiff from now asserting ejectment over the same tract.
Pahalwan v. Muheshur Listed together with Soorjomonee as authority for the same principle regarding the conclusive nature of previous adjudication. Applied as part of the line of authority holding that the substance of the prior decision binds the parties and prevents the plaintiff from recovering land the defendant had obtained under the earlier judgment.
Krishna v. Bunwari Lal Referenced as part of the same principle that a previous adjudication's conclusiveness depends on substance not form. Invoked to reinforce that the plaintiff, having been a party in the earlier litigation, cannot now claim ejectment inconsistent with that judgment.
Assanullah v. Mohini Cited in support of the proposition that a plaintiff may be entitled to recover arrears of rent. Relied upon to support the Court's conclusion that the plaintiff is entitled to recover arrears despite portions of the period being affected by the prior possession dispute.
Jagannath v. Jumman Cited alongside Assanullah as supporting recovery of arrears. Used to bolster the Court's conclusion that arrears could be recovered by the plaintiff under the circumstances described in the opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded sequentially through the three framed issues.

1. Ejectment (Issue 1): The Court analyzed the terms of the 22 June 1899 lease. The lease purported to grant approximately 2,000 bighas with defined boundaries on three sides and an indefinite eastern boundary described as "jungle lands held by me (the grantor) in khas." The lease allowed the tenant to include approximately that quantity or an additional quantity of 500 bighas at most; the landlord reserved a power to take khas possession of any lands in excess of such inclusion after measurement. The measurement contemplated was that to be done after the rent-free period (year 1308 B.S. / 1901–1902) or thereafter.

The Court noted two bar(s) to the plaintiff's present exercise of the landlord's option to eject: first, the option could not reasonably have been intended to be exercisable after an indefinite lapse of time; second, and decisively, the plaintiff was a party to a previous litigation concluded on 19 April 1917 in which the disputed tract was adjudicated as being covered by the 22 June 1899 lease (the defendant's lease) and not by the rival lease. That earlier litigation resulted in the defendant obtaining possession of the disputed tract (by depositing money and getting delivery in February 1918). Because the plaintiff had been a party to that litigation and the prior decree determined the dispute in substance, the plaintiff could not now take a position inconsistent with that decree. The Court invoked authorities (Soorjomonee v. Suddanund, Pahalwan v. Muheshur, Krishna v. Bunwari Lal and Brojo v. Kedar) to justify determining the conclusive effect of the prior adjudication by substance rather than form. The Court therefore held the Subordinate Judge correctly dismissed the ejectment claim.

2. Rate and Area for Assessment of Rent and Premium (Issue 2): The Court rejected the defendant's contention that a deduction should be made for a towpath since the towpath was not in existence. Regarding rates, the Subordinate Judge had allowed the lease rates for the 500 bighas in excess of 2,000 bighas (i.e., up to 2,500 bighas) and had assessed higher rates on the area exceeding 2,500 bighas. The appellate Court held this distinction unjustified. Because the defendant's success in the prior litigation had established that the additional tract (665 bighas 15 cottahs) was covered by the 22 June 1899 lease, it could not be treated as outside the original grant for purposes of imposing higher rates. Thus rent and premium must be assessed at the same rates throughout the entire excess area; the Court concluded no valid distinction could be made between the initial 500 bighas excess and the further excess arising from the prior litigation.

3. Arrears (Issue 3): The Court held the plaintiff was entitled to recover arrears. It relied on Assanullah v. Mohini and Jagannath v. Jumman for support. The Court acknowledged the apparent anomaly that arrears were decreed for years 1322–1324 B.S. (1915–1918) although the defendant obtained possession from Peary Mohan Roy only on 2 February 1918. The Court explained that the defendant had earlier sued Peary Mohan Roy alleging wrongful dispossession (dating from 12 November 1902) and in substance recovered mesne profits; the prior proceedings showed Peary Mohan Roy had been allowed to retain profits from the land in lieu of interest on reclamation expenditure. The plaintiff had not realised rent from Peary Mohan Roy for the excess lands; on that basis, the Court saw no reason why the defendant should escape liability for rent due to the plaintiff. The Court directed that the amount decreed be readjusted according to the rates now allowed.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The appeal is allowed in part and the cross-objections are disallowed.

Consequences and specific directions given in the opinion:

  • The Subordinate Judge's dismissal of the claim for ejectment was affirmed; the plaintiff cannot obtain ejectment for the lands in question because the same tract had earlier been adjudicated as covered by the defendant's lease and the plaintiff was a party to that earlier litigation.
  • Rent and premium must be assessed at the same rates (the rates mentioned in the original lease) in respect of the entire excess lands; the Court ordered a modification so that, with regard to 229 bighas 5 cottahs 11 chataks, rent and premium be calculated at Re. 1 per bigha (instead of at Re. 1-8 and Rs. 5 per bigha respectively as assessed by the Subordinate Judge).
  • The plaintiff is entitled to recover arrears; the decreed amount is to be readjusted according to the rates fixed by this Court.
  • There will be no order for costs in this Court (the victory being divided), but the costs allowed in the Court below will be recalculated. A self-contained decree is to be drawn up in this Court.

The opinion applies previously cited authorities to bar a relitigation inconsistent with an earlier substantive adjudication and to support recovery of arrears; it does not state that it establishes a new general precedent beyond the application of those authorities to the facts of this case.

Final Disposition

Appeal allowed partly; cross-objections disallowed. The decree of the Subordinate Judge is modified as directed and a fresh self-contained decree will be drawn up in this Court.

    Bhupendra Kumar Chakraburty v. Suraj Kanta Rai Chowdhury

    Mookerjee, J.:— This is an appeal by the defendant in a suit for ejectment for assessment of rent and premium, for recovery of arrears, and for incidental reliefs.

    2. On the 22nd June 1899, the plaintiff granted a kayami maurasi mokarari pattah in respect of Chakdari jungle lands in the Sunderbuns to one Syamacharan Das.

    3. On the 12th January 1902, the representatives of the lessee conveyed their interest to the defendant. The case for the plaintiff is that, whereas under the lease, the defendant is entitled to 2500 bighas of land, he has managed to obtain possession of 2729 bighas 5 cottahs and 11 chattaks. The plaintiff, consequently, seeks to recover possession of 229 bighas 5 cottahs and 11 chataks. The plaintiff, claims, in the alternative, that rent and premium may be settled on all land in excess of 2000 bighas, which was the original quantity mentioned in the lease and formed the basis of calculation of the sum payable by the lessee. The plaintiff further prays for recovery of arrears. The Subordinate Judge has dismissed the claim for ejectment. He has held that the plaintiff is entitled to rent and premium on 500 bighas in excess of 2000 bighas at the rates mentioned in the lease, namely, at Re. 1 per bigha. He has further held that the plaintiff is entitled to have rent assessed at Re. 1-8 a bigha and premium at Rs. 5 a bigha on all lands in excess of 2500 bighas. He has finally decreed arrears at the rates mentioned from 1322 B.S to 1324 B.S The decree has satisfied neither party. The defendant has appealed on three grounds, namely, first, that in the determination of the excess area assessable, allowance should have been made for a towpath: secondly, that rent and premium should have been assessed throughout at the rates mentioned in the lease; and thirdly, that arrears should not have been decreed for any period antcedent to the institution of the suit. The plaintiff has preferred cross-objections and attacked the decree on two grounds, namely, first, that the plaintiff was entitled to a decree for ejectment with regard to all lands in excess of 2500 bighas; and, secondly, that rent and premium should have been assessed at higher rates than those fixed by the Subordinate Judge.

    4. The three questions which thus emerge for consideration, are, first, is the plaintiff entitled to a decree for ejectment in respect of all lands in excess of 2500 bighas; secondly, at what rate should rent and premium be assessed and in respect of what excess lands; thirdly, is the plaintiff entitled to a decree for arrears antecedent to the suit.

    5. As regards the first question, the decision must rest primarily on the terms of the lease of the 22nd June 1899. The lease purported to be a grant of approximately 2000 bighas of jungle lands within boundaries defined in the schedule. There of these boundaries, namely, the northern, the western and the southern were definite. The fourth boundary, that is, the boundary towards the east, was indefinite, inasmuch as it was stated to be “jungle lands held by me (the grantor) in khas.” The rent was, as usual, made progressive. Seven per cent, of the land was made perpetually rent free on account of reclamation and collection charges. The rent on the remainder was assessed at a maximum of Re. 1 per bigha. During the first three years, however, no rent was to be levied in the fourth year, only one-third of the maximum was to be paid, while, in the fifth year, two-thirds was to be paid; the full rent was to come into operation from the sixth year. The lease further provided that on the expiry of the rent-free period, the landlord would cause a measurement to be made with a chain of 80 cubits of 18 inches a cubit, and that, after deduction of seven percent, from the additional lands, the remainder would be assessed at the rate fixed in the document, namely, premium at one rupee per bigha and rent at one rupee per bigha. The lease next provided that if the measurement should disclose a deficiency in the area, the tenant would be entitled to a proportional abatement. Then followed the following provision:

    “Be it further stated that out of extensive jungle lands, this pattah is granted to you in respect of 2000 bighas of land as per boundaries given below. You shall be competent to include in your share approximately that quantity of land or an additional quantity of 500 bighas at most; and you shall pay rent and premium on account of the additional quantity of lands at the rate fixed. But if you get more lands enclosed over and above the same, then I shall be competent to take khas possession thereof, after measurement, and you shall not be competent to claim any compensation for taking the same into my khas possession.”

    6. The measurement here contemplated is that previously mentioned, namely, the measurement to take place at the end of the rent-free period, that is, in the year 1308 (1901-1902) or thereafter. The present suit was not instituted till the 19th November 1918, and there is considerable force in the contention of the defendant that the option vested in the plaintiff under the lease of the 22nd June, 1899, to eject the tenant from land in excess of 2500 bighas, could not have been intended to be capable of exercise after the lapse of an indefinite period of time. Apart from this, we are of opinion that the plaintiff is not competent to exercise the option by reason of the decision in a previous litigation which was terminated by a judgment of this Court delivered on the 19th April 1917.

    7. It appears that, after the grant of the lease to the defendant on the 22nd June 1899, the plaintiff granted a lease of adjoining lands to one Peary Mohan Roy on the 12th August and 1st December, 1899. The document of the 12th August 1899 describes the western boundary as the ganthi land of Syama Charan Das the lessee under the grant of the 22nd June, 1899. On the 9th April 1906, the present defendant instituted a suit against Peary Mohan Roy for recovery of possession of a large tract of land on the allegation that it was comprised within the lease of the 22nd June, 1899, and not within the lease of the 12th August 1899. The present plaintiff, as the common landlord of the two rival claimants, was joined as a defendant, inasmuch as, in the words of the Subordinate Judge who tried that litigation, unless he was made a party to the suit, he would not be bound by any decree that might be passed therein. A commissioner was appointed to demarcate the boundary between the chucks of the claimants. The trial Court came to the conclusion that the lands then in dispute were comprised within the chuck covered by the lease of the 22nd June, 1899, which was subsequently purchased by the plaintiff. The Subordinate Judge, however, came to the conclusion that as Peary Mohan Roy had reclaimed the tract, the plaintiff should reimburse him and a decree was made accordingly on the 19th June, 1907. Upon appeal and cross-appeal, the District Judge affirmed the decree on the 18th January, 1913, subject to the modification that he increased the amount of compensation payable by the then plaintiff to Pearv Mohon Roy from Rs. 3868/12 to Rs. 637/8. On appeal to this Court, Flecher and New bould, JJ. affirmed this decree on the 19th April 1917, subject to a variation in form which did not affect the substance. Sub sequently, the present defendant, then plaintiff, deposited Rs. 6637/8 in Court to the credit of Peary Mohan Roy and obtained delivery of possession on the 2nd February, 1918. The tract thus obatined by the defendant was 665 bighas 15 cottahs, and taken with the area already in his occupation brought up the total to 2729 bighas 5 cottahs 11 chataks. It is plainly not open to the landlord, who was a party to that suit, to take up a position inconsistent with the decision in the previous litigation which was pronounced in his presence. The effect of the decree in that suit was to determine that the tract then in dispute was covered by the lease of one of his two tenants and not that of the other. The Subordinate Judge has emphasised the important fact that there was no khas land of the landlord between the eastern boundary of the lease of the 22nd June, 1899 and the western boundary of the lease of the 12th August 1899. The lots covered by the two leases had a common dividing line and the land then in dispute belonged to either the one or the other of the two rival claimants under their common landlord; there was no third alternative admissible. The landlord was in no sense what is called a formal party: Brojo v. Kedar(1). Consequently, the principle enunciated by the Judicial Committee in Soorjomonee v. Suddanund(2); Pahalwan v. Muheshur(3); and Krishna v. Bunwari Lal(4), applies namely that the conclusive nature of a previous adjudication, must be determined by reference to the substance and not to the form of the proceedings. If the plaintiff were now allowed a decree for ejectment, the net result would be that the defendant would be deprived of the fruit of the previous litigation, which he had secured, at considerable expense, in the presence of the plaintiff himself. The plaintiff cannot be permitted to snatch away from the defendant the spoils of his victory in this manner. We are of opinion that the Subordinate Judge has correctly dismissed the claim for ejectment.

    8. As regards the second question, it is plain that no deduction can be allowed on account of a towpath which is not in existence. As regards the rate of rent and premium, the Subordinate Judge has allowed the rates mentioned in the lease in respect of 500 bighas in excess of 2000 bighas, which was taken as the basis of calculation of liability when the document was executed. The propriety of this course has not been challenged by either party, and the dispute thus narrows down to the area in excess of 2500 bighas. Here the Subordinate Judge has assessed the rent and premium at higher rates than those mentioned in the lease. We are of opinion that this view cannot be justified. The decision in the previous litigation was that the area of 665 bighas 5 cottahs then in dispute must be regarded as covered by the lease of the 22nd June 1899. It was the success of the defendant in that litigation, which made the area in his occupation exceed 2500 bighas. He could not have succeeded then except off the footing that the tract was included in his lease and not in that of his rival. It is not open to the plaintiff now to have the rent and premium assessed on any portion of those lands on the basis that they are not covered by and subject to the operation of the grant in his favour. We hold accordingly that the rent and premium should be assessed at the same rates in respect of the entire excess lands; no valid distinction can be made between the area of 500 bighas and the area in excess of 500 bighas.

    9. As regards the third question, we are of opinion that the plaintiff is entitled to recover arrears. This view is supported by the decisions in Assanullah v. Mohini(5); Jagannath v. Jumman(6). We are not unmindful that arrears have been decreed in respect of the years 1322 B.S 1324 B.S (1915-1918), while the defendant obtained possession from Peary Mohan Roy only on the 2nd February 1918. It must be remembered, at the same time, that he instituted the suit against Peary Mohan Roy nn the allegation that he had been wrongfully dispossessed on the 12th November 1902. His remedy was clearly to realise mesne profits from Peary Mohan Roy and he did in substance so recover. The proceedings in the previous litigation leave no doubt that Peary Mohan Roy was allowed to keep the profits from the land in lieu of interest on the expenditure incurred by him in reclamation. The plaintiff, it may be added, did not realise rent from Peary Mohan Roy in respect of the excess lands. There is consequently no reason why the defendant should escape liability for rent justly due to the plaintiff. The amount decreed will however be readjusted according to the rates now allowed.

    10. The result is that the appeal preferred by the defandant is allowed in part, and the cross-objections preferred by the plaintiff disallowed. The decree of the Subordinate Judge will be modified in one respect only, namely, with regard to 229 bighas 5 cottahs 11 chataks, the rent and premium will be calculated at Re. 1 per bigha instead of at Re. 1-8 per bigha and Rs. 5 per bigha respectively. As the victory has been a divided one, there will be no order for costs in this Court, but the costs allowed in the Court below will be calculated afresh. A self-contained decree will be drawn up in this Court.

    11. Appeal allowed partly Cross-objections disallowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bhupendra Kumar Chakraburty v. Suraj Kanta Rai Chowdhury
    (Apr 11, 1923)