AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • section 140.Then sub-section (3) of section 169 provides:A
  • Section 169 of the City of Bombay Municipal Act, 1888,
  • section 169, sub-section (1) and sub-section (3),
  • section 169.Sub-section (2) of section 169
  • sub-section (3) of section 169
  • section 139, and section 140
  • section 169(3). Section 212
  • Bombay Municipal Act, 1888,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • section 140.Then sub-section (3) of section 169 provides:A
  • Section 169 of the City of Bombay Municipal Act, 1888,
  • section 169, sub-section (1) and sub-section (3),
  • section 169.Sub-section (2) of section 169
  • sub-section (3) of section 169
  • section 139, and section 140
  • section 169(3). Section 212
  • Bombay Municipal Act, 1888,
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This is an appeal by the Municipality of Bombay against a decision of Mr. Justice Tyabji. The central dispute concerned whether a charge for water supplied by meter in respect of certain premises can be recovered by enforcing a charge on the premises under section 212 of the City of Bombay Municipal Act, 1888. The Court below (Mr. Justice Tyabji) had held that the charge for water supplied by meter is not a property-tax and is not a charge within section 212. The respondent (defendant No. 3) purchased the property and contended he was a bona fide purchaser without notice of arrears; the respondent paid an amount into Court sufficient to cover the charge for which he was personally liable. Attorneys for appellants: Messrs Crawford, Bayley & Co. Attorneys for respondent: Messrs Dastur & Co.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, under the City of Bombay Municipal Act, 1888, a charge for water supplied by measurement (meter) can be recovered as a first charge on the premises under section 212 (i.e., whether such meter-charges qualify as "property-taxes" for the purposes of section 212).
  2. Whether defendant No. 3 (the purchaser) is personally liable for water charges levied for water supplied and charged by meter prior to the date he purchased/took possession of the premises.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (Coltman) — Municipality's submissions

  • The charge for water supplied by meter should be treated as a property-tax or, at least, the charge should be enforceable under section 212; the whole intendment of the Act should be considered.
  • The charge is a method of recovery in the same way that distress is a mode of recovery; the only material difference between meter-charges and water-tax is timing (meter-charges are billed after consumption; water-tax is levied in advance).
  • The lower Court's reliance on certain Madras cases was misplaced because, in those cases, there was no nexus between the moneys recovered and the premises sold.
  • Defendant No. 3 claims to be a bona fide purchaser without notice of arrears; he ought to have made inquiries and cannot avoid liability — a charge under section 212 is paramount and attaches to the entire property.

Respondent (Daphtary) — Municipality charges should not be constituted under section 169(3) as property-tax

  • Section 169 and section 212 operate differently: section 212 deals expressly with property-taxes, while section 169 allows the Commissioner to charge for water by measurement instead of levying water-tax under section 141.
  • The legislature could have declared that water-dues under section 169 are to be deemed water-tax for Act purposes, but did not; section 140 omits reference to water-dues by measurement.
  • The giving of a charge under section 169 is not itself a process of recovery; it merely entitles the chargee to come to court and ask for sale. Section 212 confers a substantive right (a charge) and is not merely a method of recovery.
  • The framers of the Act did not intend that water-dues by measurement be a charge under section 212; there is no nexus between such water-dues and the property as required for a property-tax.
  • In R.M.V.V.M. Chettyar Firm v. M. Subramaniam, what was charged was in fact a property-tax recoverable as an arrear of land revenue — that situation is distinguishable from meter-charges under section 169.
  • Authority and commentary cited: Craies on Statute Law (3rd Edn.) were referenced regarding statutory construction.

Reply by Coltman

  • Referred to the sub-heading before section 169 and the definition of "tax" in section 3(p) to support the position that the charge is ancillary and should be treated as a method of recovery.
  • Submitted that the charge is ancillary to the power of recovery by sale and that section 212 is a compendious way of providing for sale of property to enforce unpaid sums.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ramachandra v. Pitchaikanni Relied upon by the lower Court (as authority concerning recovery and charges related to municipal dues). The appellate court observed that in this and certain related Madras cases there was no nexus between the moneys recovered and the premises sold, and therefore those decisions provided no assistance in construing the City of Bombay Act provisions at issue.
Chinnasami Mudali v. Tirumalai Pillai Relied upon by the lower Court (Madras authority on municipal charges/taxes). The appellate court treated the Madras cases collectively as dealing with taxes not imposed with reference to particular land and held they were not helpful in construing the Bombay Act sections in question.
Right Honourable the Secretary of State for India, Kadir Mohideen Marakkayar v. Muthukrishna Ayyar Relied upon by the lower Court (grouped with other Madras cases). As above: the appellate court concluded these Madras decisions do not assist because they concern Acts of a different character and lack the requisite nexus between the debt and the specific land.
Ibrahim Khan Sahib v. Rangasami Naicken Referenced in argument (Madras authority). No specific principle from this case was applied by the appellate court; it treated the Madras line of cases as inapplicable to the construction of the Bombay Act provisions.
Sankaran Nambudripad v. Ramaswami Ayyar Referenced in argument (Madras authority). No specific principle from this case was applied by the appellate court; it held the Madras decisions dealt with different statutory schemes and were not helpful here.
R.M.V.V.M. Chettyar Firm v. M. Subramaniam Discussed by respondent: held that what was charged in that case was a property-tax recoverable as an arrear of land revenue (and hence recoverable by sale). The court accepted that this case involved a true property-tax (recoverable by sale) and distinguished it from meter-charges under section 169 of the Bombay Act, which in the court's view are not property-taxes for the purposes of section 212.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded by textual construction of the relevant provisions of the City of Bombay Municipal Act, 1888, notably sections 139, 140, 141, 169 (subsections (1) and (3)) and 212.

  1. Definition and scheme under the Act:
    • Section 139 imposes property-taxes. Section 140 defines "property-taxes" to include a water-tax (a percentage of rateable value) and section 141 identifies premises subject to such water-tax (premises connected to municipal water-works or in a district where sufficient municipal water is available).
    • Section 169(1) authorises the Commissioner, in specified cases, instead of levying the water-tax under section 141, to charge for water supplied by measurement (meter) at prescribed rates — thus substituting the meter-charge for the statutory water-tax in those cases.
  2. Interpretation of section 169(3):
    • Section 169(3) provides that a person charged by measurement "shall not be liable for payment of the water-tax, but any sum payable by him on account of water and not paid when it becomes due shall be recoverable by the Commissioner as if it were an arrear of water-tax."
    • The Court reasoned that if meter-charges remained a water-tax, subsection (3) would be redundant. The subsection's language indicates that meter-charges are not themselves water-tax but are made recoverable by the same authorised methods as arrears of water-tax.
  3. Scope and effect of section 212:
    • Section 212 explicitly makes "property-taxes due under this Act" a first charge upon the building or land and on goods and chattels found thereon.
    • The Court held that section 212 imposes a charge only in respect of property-taxes; since, in the Court's view, meter-charges under section 169 are not property-taxes, there is no charge created by section 212 in respect of those sums.
  4. Whether subsection (3) of section 169 imports the operation of section 212:
    • The Court considered whether the phrase "recoverable ... as if it were an arrear of water-tax" in section 169(3) should be read to mean that section 212 also applies to meter-charges.
    • The Court concluded that to make section 212 applicable to meter-charges would require reading additional words into subsection (3) (for example, to state expressly that the charge under section 212 applied to such sums). Because this is a charging Act, the Court refused to insert words that are not present and adopted a strict construction.
  5. On the nature of the relationship and relevance of other authorities:
    • The Court rejected the lower Judge's view that section 169 created a contractual relationship distinguishing meter-charges from water-tax; the Court found no contractual relationship introduced by section 169.
    • The Court declined to rely on the Madras cases cited by the lower Court because those cases arose under statutes of a different character and concerned taxes not imposed with reference to the particular land sought to be charged; consequently, they were not helpful in construing the Bombay Act.
  6. Personal liability and apportionment:
    • The Court held meter-charges are necessarily apportionable de die in diem by reading the meter, and therefore defendant No. 3 could not be held liable for water supplied and charged by meter before he took possession of the property.
    • Because defendant No. 3 had paid into Court an amount sufficient to cover the charge for which he was personally liable (taking the date of liability as the date he took possession), the Municipality's claim against him also failed.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISMISSED WITH COSTS

Direct effect on the parties:

  • The Court dismissed the Municipality's appeal: the Municipality cannot, under section 212 of the City of Bombay Municipal Act, 1888, enforce a first charge on premises in respect of water supplied by meter because such meter-charges are not property-taxes within the meaning of section 212.
  • Defendant No. 3 (the purchaser) is not personally liable for water supplied and charged by meter before he became owner/took possession; the sums properly apportionable to his period of ownership were covered by the amount he paid into Court.

Broader legal implications highlighted by the Court:

  • The Court emphasised strict construction of charging Acts: the Court refused to read into section 169(3) additional words to import the effect of section 212 where the statute did not plainly provide for it.
  • The Court warned against construing one Act by reference to decisions on other Acts of different character; it found the Madras decisions inapplicable to the statutory scheme of the City of Bombay Municipal Act, 1888.

The opinion does not purport to lay down a novel general rule beyond the construction applied to these provisions; its holding is limited to the interpretation and application of sections 140, 141, 169 and 212 of the City of Bombay Municipal Act, 1888, as between these parties.

    Municipal Corporation Of The City Of Bombay v. Haji Eisa Haji Oosman

    Coltman. The important section is section 212. The learned Judge in the Court below held that the charge for water supplied by meter is not a property-tax and is not a charge within section 212. My submission is that we should look to the whole intendment of the Act. I submit that the charge is a method of recovery, just as distress is a mode of recovery. The only difference in respect of water supplied by meter is that you send a bill after the water is consumed whereas water-tax is levied in advance. The lower Court relied on Ramachandra v. Pitchaikanni, Chinnasami Mudali v. Tirumalai Pillai and the Right Honourable the Secretary of State for India, Kadir Mohideen Marakkayar v. Muthukrishna Ayyar, but in those cases there was no nexus between the moneys recovered and the premises sold. Reference was also made to Ibrahim Khan Sahib v. Rangasami Naicken, Sankaran Nambudripad v. Ramaswami Ayyar, and R.M.V.V.M Chettyar Firm v. M. Subramaniam. No distinction can be drawn from the fact that section 169(3) refers to “person”. Defendant No. 3 contends that he is a bona fide purchaser without notice of the arrears of water-dues. He ought to have made inquiries. A charge under section 212 is paramount and attaches to the entire property.

    Daphtary. The Court is asked to constitute the Municipality charges in respect of water-dues under section 169(3). Section 212 deals with property-taxes. The legislature should have provided that the water-dues under section 169 are to be deemed a water-tax for the purposes of the Act. Section 140 omits reference to water-dues. If the water-dues under section 169 are to be deemed a property-tax, then they would not have been omitted from section 140. Similarly in section 212 water-dues could have been easily included. Section 169 gives an option to the Municipal Commissioner to charge for water by measurement. The giving of a charge is not a process for recovery. The chargee merely becomes entitled to come to Court and ask for a sale of the property. Section 212 confers a right and does not constitute a mode of recovery. The framers of the Act did not intend to create a charge in respect of water-dues. In the Madras cases cited, the right to sell was not denied. The power of sale was there. It was further provided that on the sale there should be priority in respect of certain dues. The water dues are not a levy on the property under section 140. There is no nexus between the water-dues and the property. In R.M.V.V.M Chettyar Firm v. M. Subramaniam what was charged was in fact a property-tax which could be recovered as an arrear of land revenue, namely, by sale. Reference was made to Craies on Statute Law, 3rd Edn. p. 105.

    Coltman, in reply, refers to the sub-heading before section 169 and to the definition of “tax” in section 3(p). I say that charge is a method of recovery. The charge is given as ancillary to the power of recovery by sale. Section 212 is a compendious way of saying that you may sell the property.

    Beaumont, C.J:—This is an appeal by the Municipality of Bombay against a decision of Mr. Justice Tyabji; and the principal question is, whether upon the true construction of the City of Bombay Municipal Act, 1888, a charge for water supplied by meter in respect of certain premises can be recovered by means of a charge on the premises under section 212 of the Act. The question turns upon the construction of a few of the sections of the Act in question.

    Property-taxes are imposed by section 139, and section 140 defines “property-taxes” as including, amongst other things, “a water-tax of so many per centum of their rateable value as the corporation shall deem reasonable with reference to the expenses of providing a water-supply for the City”; and then section 141 enacts what premises are to be subject to the water-tax. Putting it shortly, they are premises connected with the municipal water-works, or premises situate in a district in respect of which the Commissioner has given public notice that sufficient water is available from municipal water-works for furnishing a reasonable supply to all the premises in that district. So that, under those two sections, any premises falling within the ambit of section 141 are liable to water-tax, which is to be levied by a percentage on the rateable value of the premises.

    Then we come to section 169, which provides in sub-section (1) that—

    “(1) The Commissioner may—

    “(a) in such cases as the standing committee shall either generally or specially direct, instead of levying the water-tax in respect of any premises liable thereto under section 141, charge for the water supplied to such premises by measurement at such rate as shall from time to time be prescribed by the said committee in this behalf.”

    It is to be noted that under that sub-section a charge on the premises for water supplied by meter is substituted for the levy of water-tax. It has been argued by Mr. Coltman on behalf of the Municipality that the charge for water supplied by meter remains a water-tax. But it seems to me that view is inconsistent with the plain words of section 169, sub-section (1) and sub-section (3), to which I will refer in a moment. No doubt, the Act might have been framed so as to provide that water-tax should be levied either on the percentage value of the premises, or on the amount of water consumed, in which case the tax, however levied, would still have been a water-tax. But that is not what is done by section 169.

    Sub-section (2) of section 169 deals with compounding and is not relevant, and sub-section (3) provides:—

    “A parson who is charged for water by measurement or who has compounded for a fixed periodical sum shall not be liable for payment of the water-tax, but any sum payable by him on account of water and not paid when it becomes due shall be recoverable by the Commissioner as if it were an arrear of water-tax.”

    The whole of that sub-section would be unnecessary if the charge for water supplied by meter remained a water-tax. The sub-section recognizes that it is not a water-tax, but directs that an arrear in respect thereof shall be recoverable as if it were an arrear of water-tax.

    It is necessary, therefore, to look at the sections which provide how arrears of water-tax are recoverable. The arrears can be recovered by distress under section 203 and the following sections, or under section 209 from the occupier if the person primarily liable fails to pay, or by a suit under section 211.

    Then comes section 212, which is the material section, and which is in these terms:—

    “Property-taxes due under this Act in respect of any building or land shall, subject to the prior payment of the land-revenue, if any, due to Government thereupon, be a first charge upon the said building or land and upon the goods and chattels, if any, found within or upon such building or land and belonging to the person liable for such taxes.”

    That section in terms imposes a charge in respect of property-taxes due, which taxes include water-tax, but do not, in my opinion, include the charge by meter under section 169.

    The only question, therefore, to my mind is whether the recovery of arrears of payments by meter can be made by enforcing a charge under section 212, having regard to the words of section 169(3), namely, that such arrear shall be recoverable “as if it were an arrear of water-tax”. If it were an arrear of water-tax, the money could be recovered by distress, or by a suit, or by enforcing a charge under section 212; but the difficulty I feel in regard to the latter method is that in respect of the money due by meter there is no charge under section 212, that charge being confined to property-taxes; and if we are to hold that money due by meter can be recovered by the enforcement of a charge under section 212, we shall have to read into sub-section (3) of section 169 at the end after the words “as if it were an arrear of water-tax” some such words as “and as if the charge under section 212 applied to sums so due”. This being a charging Act, we are not, in my opinion, at liberty to read into it words which are not there, and to say that moneys due by meter can be recovered by enforcing a charge which does not extend to such moneys. The mere giving of a charge is not by itself a method of recovery. The charge exists under section 212 in every case where property-taxes are in arrear; the charge may or may not be enforced; the Municipality may recover the arrears by other methods. It is only the enforcement of the charge which is really a method of recovery; and in respect of an arrear of a charge by meter this method of recovery is not available, because there is no charge to enforce. That being the case, I think the decision of the learned Judge on this question is right.

    I am not prepared, however, to accept the view which the learned Judge took that section 169 is based upon some contractual relationship, which distinguishes a charge by meter from a water-tax. In my opinion, there is no contractual relationship introduced by section 169.

    With regard to the Madras cases on which the learned Judge relied, I think it is dangerous to attempt to construe one Act by reference to decisions on other Acts quite different in character, even though the actual phrase in the several Acts may be the same. The Madras cases dealt with taxes not imposed with reference to the particular land sought to be charged. Personally, therefore, I think that no assistance can be derived from those cases. We have to decide the question entirely on the construction of sections 140, 141 and 169 and 212 of the present Act, and on the true construction of those sections I am of opinion that the charge claimed by the Municipality is not established.

    With regard to the second point as to the personal liability of defendant No. 3 (the respondent) for charges due before the date at which he purchased the property, it seems tome clear that charges by meter are necessarily apportionable de die in diem by reading the meter, and defendant No. 3 cannot be held liable for any water supplied and charged by meter before he took possession of the property, and as defendant No. 3 has paid into Court an amount sufficient to cover the charge for which he is personally liable, that claim of the Municipality also fails.

    The appeal, therefore, will be dismissed with costs.

    Blackwell, J.:—I agree. Section 169 of the City of Bombay Municipal Act, 1888, makes a distinction between a water-tax and the charge for water supplied to premises by measurement which the Commissioner is empowered to charge in the cases therein referred to.

    Section 140 makes a water-tax as therein defined a property-tax. There is nothing in section 140 to suggest that a charge for water supplied by measurement is a property-tax. Section 212 of the Act provides that the property-taxes due under the Act shall be a first charge upon the building or land and upon the goods and chattels found thereon. So far, therefore, it seems to be plain that the charge conferred by section 212 as far as water is concerned is only applicable to the water-tax mentioned in section 140.

    Then sub-section (3) of section 169 provides:—

    “A person who is charged for water by measurement or who has compounded for a fixed periodical sum shall not be liable for payment of the water-tax, but any sum payable by him on account of water and not paid when it becomes due shall be recoverable by the Commissioner as if it were an arrear of water-tax.”

    The authorised methods of recovery provided for in the Act, such as distress and a suit, are clearly made applicable to a sum payable on account of water treated as an arrear of water-tax; but the question is, whether the first charge provided for by section 212 in respect of a property-tax is applicable to water supplied by measurement merely by virtue of the words “recoverable as if it were an arrear of water-tax” in section 169(3).

    Mr. Coltman has contended that section 212 provides a method of recovery. I do not agree with him. Section 212 imposes a charge; and unless you have got a charge, you cannot take steps to enforce that charge. This being a charging Act, I think it must be construed strictly. It would have been quite easy to provide in the Act that the charge for water supplied by measurement should be deemed to be a property-tax, or should be upon the same-footing as a water-tax, with which section 140 deals. There is no such provision in the Act. I do not think we are justified, therefore, in treating the charge for water supplied by measurement as a water-tax, when the Act merely states that sums payable on account of such water shall be recoverable “as if it were an arrear of water-tax”.

    Accordingly, I think that the appellants fail in their contention that there is a charge on the premises in respect of the water supplied by measurement, and that this appeal fails upon that point.

    As regards the question of personal liability, I agree that the water supplied by meter must be treated as apportionable de die in diem. That being so, it seems to me to be plain that defendant No. 3 incurred no liability until he became the owner of the premises. He has been content to take August 18, 1930, as the date from which his liability commenced, and it has been conceded that the sum of Rs. 75 paid by him into Court is sufficient to discharge his personal liability upon the footing that the amount is apportionable.

    I agree, therefore, that on both the points this appeal fails and must be dismissed with costs.

    Attorneys for appellants: Messrs Crawford, Bayley & Co.

    Attorneys for respondent: Messrs Dastur & Co.

    Appeal dismissed.
    B.K.D
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Municipal Corporation Of The City Of Bombay v. Haji Eisa Haji Oosman
    (Sep 20, 1935)