Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of sec. 49 of the Registration Act and sec. 91 of the Evidence Act.
  • clause (h) of sec. 17 of the Registration Act
  • sec. 17, clause (b) of the Registration Act.
  • cl. (b) of sec. 17, of the Registration Act,
  • sec. 17, cl. (b) of the Registration Act;
  • sec. 91 of the Indian Evidence Act,
  • sec. 17 of the Registration Act.
  • sec. 49 of the Registration Act,
  • sec. 91 of the Evidence Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of sec. 49 of the Registration Act and sec. 91 of the Evidence Act.
  • clause (h) of sec. 17 of the Registration Act
  • sec. 17, clause (b) of the Registration Act.
  • cl. (b) of sec. 17, of the Registration Act,
  • sec. 17, cl. (b) of the Registration Act;
  • sec. 91 of the Indian Evidence Act,
  • sec. 17 of the Registration Act.
  • sec. 49 of the Registration Act,
  • sec. 91 of the Evidence Act
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion — Partition Suit Appeal

Factual and Procedural Background

This is an appeal by the Plaintiffs from a preliminary decree in a suit for partition of joint family properties. The parties are equal co-owners (in equal moieties) because the Plaintiffs' father was the uterine brother of the Defendant. The Defendant principally resisted the suit on two grounds: (a) that the homestead had previously been partitioned, and (b) that the pleadings were defective because some items of joint property were excluded from the suit. The parties agreed that all proved joint properties must be included in the litigation, so the dispute focused mainly on the allegation of a prior partition.

The Defendant relied on a deed dated 25 October 1893 to prove a prior partition. The Court of first instance (Subordinate Judge) held the deed inadmissible for want of registration under sec. 17 of the Registration Act, but found there had been some informal/amicable partition and directed a partition awarding occupied blocks and cook-rooms to the respective occupying parties and dividing other properties equally. Both parties appealed to the District Judge.

The District Judge held that there had been an amicable partition as evidenced by the deed and the attached map and excluded properties shown in that plan from the partition; he also authorised a Commissioner to determine by summary inquiry whether disputed properties were joint. The Plaintiffs appealed to the present Court (the opinion summarized here).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the properties covered by the deed of 25 October 1893 were rightly excluded from partition — specifically, whether the deed (being unregistered) was admissible and whether sec. 49 of the Registration Act coupled with sec. 91 of the Indian Evidence Act bars proof of that partition by other evidence.
  2. Whether the District Judge erred in delegating to the Commissioner the judicial question of whether certain disputed properties are joint properties (i.e., whether that question must be determined by the Court before a preliminary decree for partition is made).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The deed of 25 October 1893 is essentially a deed of partition and therefore compulsorily registrable under sec. 17, clause (b) of the Registration Act.
  • Because the deed was not registered, it is inadmissible under sec. 49 of the Registration Act and, consequently, sec. 91 of the Indian Evidence Act excludes other evidence in proof of the terms of that disposition.
  • The delegation to the Commissioner to decide whether disputed properties are joint was improper; the Court should have determined that question before making a preliminary decree.

Respondent's Arguments

  • In answer to the first ground, the Respondent argued that the partition relied upon was effected earlier (in 1887), so the deed need not be treated as a compulsorily registrable instrument, or alternatively that the deed (though unregistered) is admissible as proof of an antecedent agreement for partition. Reliance was placed on decisions including Kedar Nath v. Sham Lal and Magni Ram v. Gurmuk Roy.
  • The Respondent alternatively argued that the equitable doctrine of part performance (and related equitable/fraud considerations) permits proof of the arrangement despite non-registration, because the arrangement had been acted upon for many years and the Defendant had expended money in repairs and bought portions from the Plaintiffs, such that negating the arrangement would enable the Plaintiffs to commit a fraud.
  • The Respondent did not challenge the Appellants' objection to delegation to the Commissioner (i.e., the second ground was not contested by Respondent).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For (as stated in the opinion) Application by the Court in This Case
Kedar Nath v. Sham Lal Cited by Respondent in support of admissibility of unregistered deed as evidence of antecedent agreement for partition; referenced by Court in discussing this point. The Court held that the principle in this case did not assist the Respondent; the deed before the Court was part of the partition transaction and thus compulsorily registrable and inadmissible when unregistered.
Magni Ram v. Gurmuk Roy Cited by Respondent as supporting admissibility of the unregistered deed to prove a prior agreement. The Court rejected reliance on this authority for the facts here, finding the deed to be an integral partition document requiring registration.
Lakshmamma v. Kamleshwar Held that a deed of partition declaring rights or reciting allotments and containing an agreement to act accordingly is compulsorily registrable. Adopted as supporting the proposition that the 1893 document was compulsorily registrable and therefore inadmissible unregistered.
Ram Chandra v. Dinkar Similar proposition that a deed of partition is compulsorily registrable. Used to support the Court's conclusion that the 1893 deed required registration and was inadmissible when unregistered.
Knchu Bhai v. Krishna Bhai Held that a deed is not necessarily required to be registered merely because it recites a prior division; distinguishes between a deed that records a prior completed transaction and one that is part of the partition transaction. The Court cited this case to explain the distinction but concluded the 1893 document was part of the partition transaction (not a mere recital) and so required registration.
Bengal Banking Corporation v. Mackertich Recognised that an unregistered deed of sale may be admissible in a suit for specific performance (collateral purpose) though not as a conveyance. The Court acknowledged the principle but held it inapplicable because the Defendant sought to exclude property from the partition (a primary, not a collateral, purpose), rather than to enforce specific performance.
Adakkalam v. Theethan Authority on admissibility of unregistered deed in suit for specific performance. Distinguished and held not applicable to the present case where the deed was relied upon to alter title rather than to enforce an agreement.
Nagappa v. Devu Authority on admissibility of unregistered instrument for specific performance purposes. Distinguished; Court held the doctrine did not permit the Defendant to prove a partition that would alter title without registration.
Rex v. Castle Morton Support for the proposition that where a written instrument is the essence of the transaction, it cannot be proved by other evidence. Relied upon to hold that sec. 49 of the Registration Act excludes the unregistered document and sec. 91 of the Evidence Act excludes other evidence, because the document was essential.
Burjorji v. Muncherji Discussed reconciliation of clauses (b) and (h) of sec. 17 of the Registration Act and exceptions for collateral purposes. Used to explain that clause (h) does not help when the document is relied on for the primary purpose of altering title; collateral-purpose exceptions (e.g., for specific performance) were not applicable here.
Bibi Jawahir Coomari v. Chatrapat Singh Applied on part-performance and collateral-use principles; relied upon by Respondent to support equitable relief in spite of non-registration. The Court considered it but held the reasoning inapplicable because specific performance of a partial partition cannot be enforced and the doctrine of part performance does not apply to permit proof of the alleged partial partition.
Singhiram Podder v. Bhagabat Chunder Nandi Followed Bibi Jawahir on related principles. Considered but held not to assist the Respondent for the reasons stated by the Court.
Nimai Charan v. Kokil Baug Cited among authorities concerning part performance / specific performance. Not applied to overturn the Court's conclusion that part performance doctrine did not permit proof of the alleged partial partition.
Kedar Nath v. Poora Sundari Cited in the context of part performance and admissibility. Not treated as altering the Court's conclusion that part performance and specific performance doctrines were inapplicable to partial partition of joint property.
Parker v. Taswell Cited among authorities acknowledging doctrines about leases/unregistered instruments and part performance. Referenced as part of the body of authority the Court considered but not held to support the Respondent's case.
Lincoln v. Wright Cited among authorities on equitable relief / part performance. Considered but did not change the Court's conclusion regarding inapplicability of part performance here.
Satya Kumar v. Satya Kripal Holds that although there may be private partial partition, there cannot be a partial partition enforced by suit; the question of title must be determined before preliminary decree. Applied to conclude that specific performance of a partial partition would not be enforceable and later to support the view that the Commissioner could not be authorised to decide jointness — that question must be judicially determined before interlocutory decree.
Walsh v. Lonsdale Authority on the principle relied upon by respondent-advocates for applying equitable doctrines to unregistered instruments (mentioned in relation to Bibi Jawahir). Found inapplicable because it would imply enforcing an agreement to effect a partial partition, which the Court held could not be maintained.
Maddison v. Alderson Explains the basis of part performance: the requirement of irrevocable acts changing the parties' relative positions and the need for acts that speak for themselves (evidentia rei). Used to analyse the part-performance argument and conclude that the doctrine does not apply where specific performance would not have been available and where alleged acts could be undone.
Lavery v. Pursell Described as stating that part performance is only an exception to the Statute of Frauds in actions for specific performance. Referred to in explanation that part performance doctrine is confined to specific performance contexts and so does not help the Respondent.
Williams v. Williams Authority suggesting family arrangements for division of land may be upheld when carried out by acts of part performance. The Court accepted the general proposition but held it inapplicable to the present circumstances (partial partition of joint property by suit cannot be enforced).
Cood v. Cood Similar to Williams v. Williams regarding family arrangements and part performance. Not applied to permit proof of the 1893 arrangement by the Respondent.
Bakshu v. Gobindo Cited by Respondent invoking doctrine of fraud to prevent inequitable outcome. The Court held the fraud argument did not assist because Plaintiffs were not seeking to retain improvements or proceeds; equitable adjustments (credit for purchases, attribution of occupied portions) could avoid injustice.
Swan v. Swan Authority for equitably considering improvements by a joint owner when making a partition. Applied in support of the Court's direction that improvements and purchases by Defendant be considered in partition (e.g., allotting the occupied block to Defendant and valuing it unimproved; crediting sums paid for cook-rooms).
Pascoe v. Swan Authority on allowance to co-owner who has made valuable improvements to common property. Used to justify equitable treatment of Defendant's improvements in the partition scheme ordered.
Watson v. Gass Authority on equitable consideration of improvements at partition. Referred to as part of the authorities supporting equitable adjustments at partition.
In re Jones Earlier authority collected with others on allowances for improvements. Referenced to support the Court's approach to allot improvements or give credit at partition.
Kenrick v. Mount Steven Authority among earlier cases concerning equitable consideration of improvements at partition. Referred to in support of equitable allotment/allowance principles the Court applied.
Dijindra Narain v. Purnendu Narain Explains that a co-tenant who spent money improving joint property typically has a defensive equity enforceable on partition; allocation is on the basis of unimproved value. Applied to order that Defendant's occupied and improved portion be allotted to him and valued in its unimproved condition, with credits for amounts paid for cook-rooms.
Story v. Johnson Authority referenced as part of background on equitable allotment methods. Mentioned as supporting precedent for mode of equitable adjustment at partition.
Ward v. Ward Authority referenced alongside Story v. Johnson on equitable allotment. Referenced to support the proposition that such equitable allotments are appropriate when practicable.
??? v. Cooke Listed in the opinion among authorities that payment of money is not necessarily part performance; the exact case name is not legible in the text ("??? v. Cooke"). Quoted only to indicate the general proposition that payment alone is not necessarily part performance; no further application beyond that citation.
Watt v. Evans Cited as authority that payment of money is not necessarily an act of part performance. Used to support the Court's view that alleged payments/repairs by Defendant did not amount to part performance compelling admission of the unregistered instrument.
Britain v. Rossitter Cited in the same context as Watt v. Evans regarding part performance. Referred to as part of authorities limiting part performance doctrine.
Hughes v. Morris Cited among authorities about part performance and payments. Used to reinforce that payment alone is insufficient to invoke part performance here.
Tincowri v. Satya Dyal Held that a Commissioner cannot deal with a case as if he were the Judge or an arbitrator appointed by the parties. Applied to conclude that delegation to a Commissioner to decide whether properties are joint was improper; the Court must decide such title questions before making a preliminary decree.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in two main strands of analysis corresponding to the Appellants' principal complaints.

1. Admissibility of the 25 October 1893 Deed (first ground)

  1. The Court examined whether the 1893 document was merely a recital of a prior completed partition or whether it formed part of the partition transaction (i.e., the document was the repository and primary evidence of the settlement).
  2. Applying sec. 17, cl. (b) of the Registration Act, the Court held that a non-testamentary instrument which purports or operates to create or declare rights in immoveable property of statutory value must be registered; precedent (Lakshmamma v. Kamleshwar; Ram Chandra v. Dinkar) supports that a deed of partition is compulsorily registrable.
  3. The Court examined the face of the 1893 document and the Defendant's written statement: the deed described itself as an amicable partition deed, recited the settlement was made on the day of execution, and stated the parties undertook to abide by it; parts of the joint estate were first divided by that document. That showed the document was intended as the primary evidence of partition rather than a mere recital.
  4. Because the document was part of the partition transaction and was unregistered, sec. 49 of the Registration Act rendered it inadmissible; consequently sec. 91 of the Evidence Act excluded other evidence too because the instrument was not collateral but essential to the transaction (citing Rex v. Castle Morton).
  5. The Court distinguished authorities allowing admission of unregistered instruments in suits for specific performance (e.g., Bengal Banking Corporation v. Mackertich; Adakkalam v. Theethan; Nagappa v. Devu) on the ground that those were collateral uses to enforce an agreement; here the Defendant sought to use the instrument to alter title and exclude property from the suit, which is a primary purpose and cannot be sustained without registration.
  6. The Court observed clause (h) of sec. 17 (documents which create only a right to obtain another document) but held that reconciliation of clauses (b) and (h) does not help when the document is relied upon for the primary purpose of establishing title. Consequently the first branch of the Respondent's contention failed.

2. Part Performance / Equitable Defences (second branch of first ground)

  1. The Respondent argued that the arrangement had been acted upon (repairs, purchases, long acquiescence) and invoked equitable doctrines (part performance, preventing fraud) to permit proof despite statutory bars.
  2. The Court analysed the doctrines relied upon: part performance is an exception to the Statute of Frauds in actions for specific performance and rests upon irrevocable acts that change parties' positions and are explicable only as performance of the contract (Maddison v. Alderson; Lavery v. Pursell).
  3. The Court held specific performance could not have been enforced for a partial partition of joint property — a party cannot obtain partial partition by suit (Satya Kumar v. Satya Kripal). Consequently, the doctrinal basis that permits part performance evidence in aid of specific performance does not exist here, so the doctrine does not apply.
  4. The Court further explained that acts relied upon (repairs, payments, purchases) did not amount to part performance because such acts could be undone and did not necessarily show the irrevocable change required; payment of money is not per se part performance.
  5. On the equity/fraud argument, the Court held the Plaintiffs were not seeking to retain improvements or proceeds so as to profit unfairly; equitable adjustments at partition (allotment of occupied/improved parts to the Defendant and giving credit for purchases) could prevent injustice without admitting the unregistered deed.
  6. Therefore the equitable doctrines did not permit admission of the unregistered deed nor bar partition of all joint properties; the Court directed that equitable considerations (allotting occupied block to Defendant, valuing unimproved, crediting purchase sums) be taken into account at partition.

3. Delegation of the Judicial Question to Commissioner (Appellants' second ground)

  1. The Court considered whether the District Judge properly authorised the Commissioner to determine, by summary inquiry, whether disputed properties were part of the joint estate.
  2. Relying on authority (Tincowri v. Satya Dyal) and the principle stated in Satya Kumar v. Satya Kripal, the Court held that questions involving title and the right of parties (i.e., whether particular properties are joint) are judicial in character and must be determined by the Court itself before a preliminary/interlocutory decree is made.
  3. Because the District Judge's delegation to the Commissioner amounted to authorising determination of a judicial question by a non-judicial officer in a manner akin to substituting the judge, that course could not be justified; this objection was therefore sustained.

Holding and Implications

Holding (core ruling): THE APPEAL IS ALLOWED.

Consequences and direct effects on the parties:

  • The decrees of both the Courts below (the Subordinate Judge and the District Judge) are discharged.
  • The case is remitted to the Court of first instance for a fresh investigation of the question of the extent of the joint properties; after that inquiry a preliminary decree for partition is to be made in the manner already directed by the Court (i.e., partition of all joint properties, with equitable adjustments: allotment of the north-facing block in Defendant's occupation to his share and valuation in unimproved condition; allotment of the two cook-rooms purchased by the Defendant and credit for the sums paid).
  • The costs of the appeal are to abide the result of the remitted proceedings.

Broader legal implications: The opinion applies and reaffirms existing principles concerning (a) the compulsory registration requirement for deeds that create or declare interests in immoveable property (sec. 17), (b) the exclusionary effect of sec. 49 (and sec. 91 of the Evidence Act) where an unregistered instrument is part of the primary transaction, and (c) the limited scope of the part-performance doctrine (confined to cases where specific performance would lie). The Court did not purport to lay down any novel precedent beyond applying established authorities to the facts before it.

    Upendra Nath Banerjee v. Umesh Chandra Banerjee

    This is an appeal on behalf of the Plaintiffs against a preliminary decree in a suit for partition of joint family properties. The father of the Plaintiffs was the uterine brother of the Defendant, and it is not disputed that the joint properties are owned by the parties in equal moieties. The Defendant resisted the claim substantially on the grounds that the homestead had been previously partitioned, and that the frame of the suit was defective, inasmuch as various items of joint properties had been excluded from its scope. It is unnecessary to discuss in detail the second objection because the parties are agreed that all properties which are proved to be joint, must be included within the scope of the litigation. The controversy between the parties has been directed principally to the first ground. The Defendant, in support of his allegation of a previous partition of the homestead, relied upon a deed executed by the parties on the 25th October 1893. The Court of first instance held that this document was inadmissible, because it had not been registered as required by sec. 17 of the Registration Act. The Court further held that there had been some sort of amicable partition of the homestead between the parties, though the transaction did not amount to a complete and regular partition. But in view of the fact that this arrangement had continued for good many years, but the Defendant on the faith of the permanency of the distribution had spent considerable sums in repair of a portion of the homestead in his occupation and had, on the 14th June 1896 and 3rd July 1897, purchased from the Plaintiffs portions of the homestead in their occupation, the Court directed that the partition should be so effected as to award to the parties the blocks and cook-rooms respectively in their possession. The Subordinate Judge further directed a division in equal halves of all the other properties. The Plaintiffs as well as the Defendants were dissatisfied with this decision and appealed to the District Judge. The District Judge held that there had been an amicable partition of the properties mentioned in the deed of the 25th October 1893 and the map attached thereto, and on the ground that the arrangement had been acted upon for some years, he concluded that the properties marked in the plan must be excluded from the partition. The District Judge further directed that the Commissioner appointed to effect the partition by metes and bounds should determine by summary inquiry whether the properties as to which the parties were not agreed were really included in the joint estate. In this view he modified the decree of the Court of first instance. The Plaintiffs have now appealed to this Court, and on their behalf the decision of the District Judge has been assailed substantially on two grounds, namely, first, that the properties, covered by the deed of the 25th October 1893, have been erroneously excluded from the partition; and, secondly, that the Commissioners ought not to have been authorised to decide whether the disputed properties were joint or not, a question to be determined upon evidence by the Court itself before the preliminary decree was made. On behalf of the Respondent, the second of these grounds has not been challenged but in answer to the first contention, it has been argued, first, that as the partition of the homestead relied upon by the Defendant was effected in 1887, the deed was admissible although it was not registered; and, secondly, that as the partition had been acted upon, it ought to be upheld on the equitable ground of part performance, because if it was negatived, the Plaintiffs would be entitled to commit an act of fraud.

    In support of the first point taken on behalf of the Appellants, it has been argued that the deed of the 25th October 1893 was in essence a deed of partition; that it was compulsorily registrable under sec. 17, cl. (b) of the Registration Act; that inasmuch as it was not so registered, it was inadmissible under sec. 49 of the Registration Act, so as to affect any immoveable property comprised therein, or as evidence of any transaction affecting such property; and consequently, under sec. 91 of the Indian Evidence Act, no other evidence was admissible in proof of the terms of such disposition of property. It has not been disputed on behalf of the Respondent that the property affected by the deed of the 25th October 1893 was of the statutory value and that if the document is regarded as a deed of partition, it was compulsorily registrable under sec. 17, clause (b) of the Registration Act. It has been argued, however, on behalf of the Respondent, that though compulsorily registrable and yet unregistered, it is still admissible in evidence in proof of the agreement for partition of the homestead which must have preceded the actual partition itself. In support of this view, reliance has been placed upon the cases of Kedar Nath v. Sham Lal(1) and Magni Ram v. Gurmuk Roy(2). In our opinion, the principle deducible from the cases to which reference has been made is of no assistance to the Respondent in the case before us. It is clear that the deed of the 25th October 1893, whether it is treated as a deed by which the partition was effected, or as a deed which declared a partition previously effected by the parties, was compulsorily registrable under cl. (b) of sec. 17, of the Registration Act, which provides that a non-testamentary instrument, other than an instrument of gift of immoveable property, which purports or operates to create or declare any right, title or interest in immoveable property of the statutory value, must be registered. If any authority is needed in support of this proposition, reference may be made to the cases of Lakshmamma v. Kamleshwar(3) and Ram Chandra v. Dinkar(4), where it was ruled that a deed of partition, either declaring certain rights over immoveable property, or reciting the allotment of lands and containing an agreement to act accordingly, is compulsorily registrable. This view is really not inconsistent with that indicated by Westropp, C.J, in Knchu Bhai v. Krishna Bhai(5), where he held that a deed is not required to be registered, merely because it recites that the bulk of the family property had been divided previously to its date. The essence of the matter is whether the deed is a part of the partition transaction or contains merely an incidental recital of a previously completed transaction. In the case before us, the document is described on the face of it as an amicable partition deed of the homestead (which the Defendant now alleges had been previously partitioned in 1887), and of the lands adjoining thereto. The document further recites that the settlement was made on the day of its execution, and that the parties undertook to abide by it in future. In the written statement of the Defendant in the present case although it is stated that the inner apartment of the homestead had been amicably partitioned, and possession had been held accordingly, the partition was kept informal till the 25th October 1893, and to preserve evidence of the transaction the document in question was executed. It is further admitted in the written statement that portions of the joint family properties other than the inner apartment were, for the first time, divided on the date of the execution of the document. It is clear, therefore, that the intention of the parties was that the document should be the only repository and the appropriate evidence of the partition. Considered from this point of view the document is clearly inadmissible by reason of want of registration. This view is supported by the observations of Sir Richard Couch, C.J, in the case of Kedar Nath v. Sham Lal. The Defendant seeks to use the document in evidence, not for any collateral purpose, but to prove that certain portion of what was at one time admittedly joint property has ceased to be such, in other words, that the title to such property has been altered by the partition transaction, without proof of which the property would still retain all the incidents of joint property. It may be conceded as ruled in the cases of Bengal Banking Corporation v. Mackertich(6), Adakkalam v. Theethan(7) and Nagappa v. Devu(8) that although an unregistered deed of sale is not admissible in evidence as a conveyance it is admissible in a suit for specific performance of the contract of sale. That doctrine, however, is clearly inadmissible in the case before us. The Defendant does not seek to enforce the agreement for partition which may be imagined to have preceded the alleged actual partition of the homestead but he wishes to exclude from the scope of the present litigation, the property which on the face of the deed in question was partitioned thereby. It is manifest that the deed is not admissible to establish the fact that the property was so partitioned. We must hold, therefore, that sec. 49 of the Registration Act excludes the document with the result that sec. 91 of the Evidence Act excludes other evidence also in support of the transaction, because the written instrument is not collateral, but is of the very essence of the transaction. See Rex v. Castle Morton(9). In fact, it is obvious that if the contrary view were maintained, the principle on which a document is deemed part of the essence of the transaction any consequently the sole as well as the primary proof of it would be completely negatived. That principle is, as Domat puts it (Civil Law, 3, 6, 2), that when men agree to preserve by writing the remembrance of past events of which they wish to create a memorial either with a view to lay down a rule for their own guidance, or in order to have in the instrument a lasting proof of the truth of what is written, the truth of the written acts must be established by the acts themselves, that is, by the inspection of the originals. We are not unmindful that clause (h) of sec. 17 of the Registration Act excepts from registration documents which do not themselves create or declare any right, title or interest in immoveable property, but merely create a right to obtain another document which, when executed will create or declare such right, title or interest but as observed in Burjorji v. Muncherji(10) and Bengal Banking Corporation v. Mackertich, cls. (b) and (h) of sec. 17 may be reconciled if we hold that a document though not admissible as creating an interest in land, is receivable in evidence for a collateral purpose, namely, for the purpose of obtaining specific performance of the agreement. As we have already explained, however, the Defendant here seeks to use the deed of 1893, not for a collateral purpose but to prove that the property covered thereby, has ceased to be joint property. For such a purpose the document, in our opinion, is inadmissible. The first branch of the contention of the learned Counsel for the Respondent must consequently fail.

    The second branch of the contention of the Respondent is to the effect that as the arrangement has been acted upon by the parties, it may be proved irrespective of the provisions of sec. 49 of the Registration Act and sec. 91 of the Evidence Act. His argument in substance is (that the equitable doctrine of part performance is applicable to the present class of cases, and that as the Plaintiffs, if their contention prevail, will be practically enabled to commit an act of fraud no Court of Equity should assist them to effectuate such a purpose. In support of this proposition, reliance has been placed upon the case of Bibi Jawahir Coomari v. Chatrapat Singh(11) which was followed by Fletcher, J., in the case of Singhiram Podder v. Bhagabat Chunder Nandi(12). Reference has also been made to the decision in Nimai Charan v. Kokil Baug(13), Kedar Nath v. Poora Sundari(14), Parker v. Taswell(15) and Lincoln v. Wright(16). The cases to which reference has been made, seem to recognise two principles, namely, first, that although an instrument may he inoperative as a lease, because not registered in accordance with law, it may be admissible in evidence in proof of an oral agreement to lease, which may be made the foundation of a decree for specific performance; and, secondly, that if possession has been taken under a verbal agreement to lease, though formal documents have not been executed, the tenant in possession holds under the terms and subject to the conditions of the agreement, if the agreement is one of which specific performance might be enforced in the Court in which the suit has been brought against him and at the same time as the subsequent legal question falls to be determined. In our opinion neither of these principles is of any assistance to the Respondent, even if it is assumed that they have any application to a case of the character now before us. If it is imagined that the partition mentioned in the deed of 1893, was preceded by an agreement to effect partition to the extent and in the manner indicated in the deed, it is clear that specific performance could not have been enforced in respect of such contract. It is well settled, as stated in the case of Satya Kumar v. Satya Kripal(17), that although there may be partial partition by private arrangement, there cannot be a partial partition by suit. On the same principle, a suit ought not to be entertained for specific performance of an agreement to effect a partial partition of joint property. To allow such a suit to be maintained, would be to enable the parties to do indirectly what the Court would not assist them to achieve directly. If, therefore, specific performance could not have been claimed of the agreement which may be imagined to have preceded the partial partition, the principle of the decision in Walsh v. Lonsdale(18) and Bibi Jawahir v. Chatrapat Sing has obviously no application. It is equally clear that the doctrine of part performance has no application. The principle upon which the doctrine of part performance rests, was explained by Lord Selborne in the case of Maddison v. Alder son(19) substantially in the following manner. The real ground of equitable intervention is that there is an irrevocable act which has lifted the contract out of the sphere of pure contract so that the Court has to choose between undoing what has been done (which is not always possible, or, if possible, just), and completing what has been left undone; accordingly the res gesta must be such as could be done with no other view or design than to perform the agreement; there must be some evidentia rei, which means that the act must speak for itself, so as to connect itself with the agreement; and further the act must change the relative positions of the parties towards the subject-matter of the agreement. To put the matter in another way, if there is part performance by the party seeking relief, and to the knowledge of the other party, proof will be admitted of the verbal contract in cases where an action for specific performance would lie; but it has been said that part performance is only an exception to the plea of the Statute of Frauds in an action for specific performance, Lavery v. Pursell(20). When the reason for the rule is thus investigated, it becomes clear that the rule has no application to the case before us. As we have already explained, no suit for specific performance of the alleged agreement to effect a partial partition of the joint property could possibly have succeeded. Nor is it suggested that the parties cannot be restored to their former position and full justice done to them it is well settled that the mere fact of payment of money is not necessarily an act of part performance. ??? v. Cooke(21), Watt v. Evans(22), Britain v. Rossitter(23) and Hughes v. Morris(24). In other words, an act done by a party in pursuance of the parol agreement in order to be a part performance of it, must not only be one which could not be done with any other view or design than to perform it, but must also be such as could not be undone without causing the praty unliquidated damage. Hence, if it is possible to restore the parties to precisely the same position as they occupied before they entered into the parol agreement, the doctrine of part performance will not ordinarily be allowed to be invoked. Even if it be conceded therefore that, as indicated in the cases of Williams v. Williams(25) and Cood v. Cood(26), a family arrangement for the division of land, although only verbal, will be upheld when it has been carried out by acts of part performance by the parties interested holding and dealing with the land in accordance with the terms of the arrangement, it is clear that the doctrine is not applicable to the case before os. Nor does the doctine of fraud in support of which reliance was placed upon the case of Bakshu v. Gobindo(27), really assist the Respondent. The Plaintiffs do not and cannot claim to take advantage of the improvements alleged to have been effected by the Defendant, or to retain the fruits of the sales of the 14th June 1896 and 13th July 1897. All that they contend is that, as the deed of partition is inoperative, a partition should be effected by decree of the Court subject to such equitable considerations as may properly be applied to adjust the rights of the parties. It is manifest that complete justice may be done, if we direct, that although all the joint properties are to be partitioned, the portion of the homestead of which the Defendant has been in possession as also the cook-rooms which he has purchased should be allotted to his share. In fact, it is well-settled that if one joint owner has in good faith effected valuable improvements upon the common property at his own expense, equity will take this fact into consideration upon a parttion, and in some way will make an allowance to him therefor, in addition to his rateable share of the property. Swan v. Swan(28), Pascoe v. Swan(29), Watson v. Gass(30), In re Jones(31), Williams v. Williams(32) and Kenrick v. Mount Steven(33), where many of the earlier authorities will be found collected). In other words, as stated by this Court in Dijindra Narain v. Purnendu Narnin(34), although a co-tenant who has spent money in the improvement of the joint property may not be entitled to call upon his co-sharers to compensate him for the expenditure, yet he has a defensive equity which is enforcible in the event of a partition; it is in recognition of such equitable right that to the co-owner who has made the improvements is assigned that portion of the property on which the improvements have been made, the division being made on the basis of the unimproved value. This method is adopted whenever the nature of the property and the improvements and situation of the latter are such as to render such distribution practicable, and it can be done without injury to the other co-tenants [Story v. Johnson(35), Ward v. Ward(36)]. The equity of a co-tenant to have the part of the common property which he has improved allotted to him on a partition, is not founded upon the theory that he made the improvements with the consent, expressed or implied, of his co-tenants; the principle rather is, that if the right of one joint owner, to effect an improvement for which he will ultimately be entitled to claim allowance, were denied, beneficial user of the joint property might in many instances become impracticable. It is not necessary for us to consider what the position would be, if a joint owner purposely covered the whole of the estate with valuable improvements in such a manner as to render it impossible to assign the shares of others without including part of such improvements: It is sufficient to state that no such considerations arise in the present case because there is no cotroversy here, that the improvements, if any, have been effected in good faith upon the portion of the joint property in the occupation of the Defendant. When the partition, therefore, conies to be effected, the north facing block which has been in the occupation of the Defendant will be allotted to his share, and the value thereof will be taken in its unimproved condition. The two cook rooms also purchased by the Defendant from the Plaintiffs will be allotted to his share, and as the Plaintiffs obtained from the Defendant Rs. 75 and Rs. 200 respectively for the rooms on the assumption that they were exclusively entitled thereto in proprietary right, the Defendant will have credit for these sums if the partition is effected in this manner, it is clear that no injustice will be done, and there will be no foundation for the suggestion that the Plaintiffs will be enabled to commit a fraud and to enrich themselves unjustly at the expense of the Defendent. The second branch of the contention of the Defendant must, therefore, fail. The first ground urged on behalf of the Appellants will consequently prevail, and all the joint properties will be partitioned in the manner indicated.

    In support of the second ground urged on behalf of the Appellants, it has been contended that the District Judge ought not to have delegated to the Commissioner the determination of the question as to whether certain disputed properties are joint properties, and in support of this proposition reference has been made to the case of Tincowri v. Satya Dyal(37), where it was ruled that the Commissioner cannot deal with the case as if he is the Judge or an arbitrator appointed by the parties. It has not been disputed, on behalf of the Respondent, that the course adopted by the District Judge cannot be justified. As pointed out by this Court in the case of Satya Kumar v. Satya Kripal, the question whether a particular property, alleged to be joint, really possesses that character, must be determined before the preliminary decree is made; all questions involving the title of the parties and their right to any relief within the issues, are judicial in character, and must be determined by the Court, such determination to be made ordinarily by the Court and incorporated in the interlocutory decree before any partition is made or directed. The second objection therefore, must prevail.

    The result is that this appeal is allowed, and the decrees of both the Courts below discharged. The case will be remitted to the Court of first instance, in order that the question of the extent of the joint properties may first be investigated, and a preliminary decree made thereafter for partition of the properties in the mode already directed. The costs of this appeal will abide the result.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Upendra Nath Banerjee v. Umesh Chandra Banerjee
    (Apr 20, 1910)