Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts

    Radhe Lal v. East Indian Railway Company, Limited

    Mullick, A.C.J:— (After stating the facts set out above, proceeded as follows): The present Letters Patent appeal is against an order of Das, J.

    The learned Judge, relying on the decision in East Indian Railway Company v. Ram Lakhan Ram* held that this was a case brought against the Agent of the Railway and not the Railway Company and that the plaintiffs were not entitled to any relief against the Company, and the learned Judge laid down his view of the law in the following words: “In my opinion when there were two known persons in existence and the plaintiff brings the suit against one of them and afterwards applies to have the other brought on the record as a defendant on the ground that he all along intended to sue the other and that in substance he sued the other and no question of representation arises in the case, it is impossible to maintain to view that the case is one of misdescription.” There is no reason for dissenting from this statement of the law. It has been accepted in other cases and also recently in Agent, Bengal Nagpur Railway v. Behari Lal Dutt. The question now before us depends not upon the correctness of the proposition as stated above but upon its application to the facts of this case. Was the suit against the Railway in substance or not? If it was a suit against the Agent then obviously no relief can be given against the Railway Company but the point is whether upon a consideration of the plaint and the circumstances of the case it is possible to hold that in truth and substance be plaintiff sued not the Agent as a designated person but the Railway Company as a corporate body. That is a question of fact and must be decided upon the evidence in the case. The decision in other cases cannot therefore be any guide. Now the view that the learned Subordinate Judge took in appeal was that the suit was in substance one against the Railway and that it was competent to proceed. This is a finding of fact which is conclusive in second appeal but it is urged on behalf of the respondent before us that there is no evidence to support it. It is necessary therefore for us to see whether there was any evidence upon which the learned Judge was competent to come to the conclusion that this was really a case of misdescription.

    In order to come to a finding upon this point it is necessary to see what the plaintiffs did. In their plaint they describe the first party defendants as the

    “Agent of the East Indian Railway.”

    In paragraph 5 they state that the two bales were lost when in the custody of the defendant first party. In paragraph 6 they state that they made the demand to the Agent. In the relief portion they pray for judgment against the defendant first party,

    “as Agent of the East Indian Railway Company.”

    In their application of the 24th October, 1922, asking for issue of process they describe the defendant not as Agent but as the East Indian Railway Company. In filing the deficit court-fee with their plaint on the 28th October they again repeat this description.

    Let us now see what the defendant did. The defendant who appeared on the 21st November, 1922, was not the Agent but the Company. The defendant who filed the written statement on the 3rd January was again not the Agent but the Company and no objection was taken to the competency of the suit until the 12th December, 1923. It is pointed out by the appellant that if that ground had been taken at the earliest moment the error could easily have been remedied within the period of limitation which appears to have not expired till about February 1923. In reply it is urged on behalf of the respondent that paragraph 1 of the written statement does take the objection. That paragraph runs as follows:

    That the suit as framed is not maintainable.”

    It is clear, however, from the fact that the Railway Company appeared on the 21st November and also filed a written statement that this objection had reference not to the designation of the defendant but to other grounds upon which the suit of the plaintiffs was liable to fail.

    Let us next see what the Court did. In the order sheet it describes the suit as one between Radhe Lal, plaintiffs, and the East Indian Railway Company and others defendants. On the 21st November, 1922, the Court accepts a petition from the Railway Company for time and on the 3rd January, 13, it accepts the written statement not from the Agent but from the Company. It is true that process was issued upon the Agent but that was clearly in consequence of the provisions of section 140 of the Indian Railway, Act.

    It is clear therefore that the plaintiffs, the Company, and the Court, till the 13th December, 1923, all thought that the suit was not against the Agent but against the Railway Company.

    Is this therefore a case in which the plaintiffs have deliberately chosen to proceed not against the principal but his servant? Clearly the plaint differs from that in East Indian Railway Company v. Ram Lakhan Ram for here in the prayer portion the plaintiffs claim against the defendant first party as Agent and they make it clear that they desire to proceed against the corporation and not against the Agent in his personal capacity.

    In my opinion the facts of this case are such that the decision in East Indian Railway Company v. Ram Lakhan Ram has no application.

    There was evidence on which the Subordinate Judge could find that this was a case of misdescription and his finding is conclusive.

    The appellant also urges that the Munsif's orders of the 21st November, 1922, and of the 3rd January, 1923, are really orders substituting the Railway Company as a defendant in the suit. Order 1, rule 10, of the Civil Procedure Code would therefore apply and no question of limitation would arise. It is true that no formal amendment of the plaint was made. This should have been done but the omission was an irregularity and, I do not think it vitiates the order of the Subordinate Judge.

    With regard to the general question as to what is the correct way of designating the defendant in, a claim against a Railway Company the point has been argued but it is unnecessary to deal with it in detail.

    The Civil Procedure Code of 1882 and the present Code both contemplate that a registered corporation should be described by its official name and title. In the case of an unincorporated or unregistered Company the names of the individuals must be given or the ordinary name by which the company is known and under which it carries on its business. There are companies constituted by Statute which are permitted to sue or be sued in the name of an officer or trustee. As to this class provision was made in section 435 of the Code of 1882 but Order XXIX of the present Code of 1908 is silent. The omission, however, is remedied in the appendix to the Code which makes it clear that this class of Company may be sued through the designated officer. Therefore in the case of the East Indian Railway the proper name under which the Company should be sued is the name and style under which it carries on its business. A suit against the Agent would be incompetent and would fix no liability upon the Company. The Company has no registered office in India but the Indian Railways Act provides that an officer named the Agent may be appointed in India upon whom service may be made of all notices and processes adressed to the Company. The appointment of such an office, however, does not in any way relieve the plaintiff of the duty of suing the proper person and of correctly describing him.

    If a plaintiff deliberately choses to sue not the Company but the Agent he cannot by any decree which he obtains in the suit bind the Company. If, however, upon a fair reading of the plaint it is made out that the description of the defendant is a mere error and that the Company is the real defendant then the suit may proceed against the Company.

    Here the Railway did in fact appear and conducted the case till the 12th December, 1923, on the footing that they were the real defendants in the suit.

    In these circumstances the judgment of the learned Judge of this Court must be set aside and the appeal must be decreed with costs. The order of the Subordinate Judge will be restored and the case will proceed to trial as directed by him.

    Kulwant Sahay, J.:— I agree.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Radhe Lal v. East Indian Railway Company, Limited
    (Jul 15, 1925)