Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • sec. 106 of the Bengal Tenancy Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • sec. 106 of the Bengal Tenancy Act

    Bhupendra Chandra Singha v. Harihar Chackravarti

    The Judgment of the Court was as follows:—

    Mookerjre, C.J:— This is an appeal, under cl. 15 of the Letters Patent from the judgment of Mr. Justice Panton in a proceeding under sec. 106 of the Bengal Tenancy Act for determination of the nature of a tenure.

    The landlords, who are the Appellants in this Court, alleged that the rent of the tenure was enhanceable; the tenants, contended, on the other hand, that the rent had been fixed in perpetuity. The Court of first instance decided in favour of the landlords and that view was accepted by the lower Appellate Court. On second appeal to this Court, Mr. Justice Panton has reversed the concurrent decisions of the Courts below, and has come to the conclusion that the rent of the tenure has been fixed in perpetuity.

    In the interpretation of the contract of tenancy, which has been placed before us and is dated the 31st August 1823, we must bear in mind the principle enunciated by the Judicial Committee in the case of Bama Sundari Dassya v. Radhika Chowdhrain where Sir James W. Col vile observed as follows: “A suit to enhance rents proceeds oil the presumption that a zemindar holding under the Perpetual Settlement has the right, from time to time, to raise the rents of all the rent-paying lands within his zemindary, according to the Perguuuah or current rates, unless either he is precluded from the exercise of that right by a contract binding on him, or the lands in question can be brought within one of the exemptions recognised by Bengal Reg, VIII of 1793 and it also assumes, that the Defendant has some valid tenure or right of occupancy in the lands which are the subject of the suit.”

    In the case before us, it is not contended that the lands in question can be brought within one of the exemptions recognised by Bengal Reg. Vin of 1793. Consequently the only point for consideration is, whether the zemindar is precluded from the exercise of the right to enhance the rent of the tenure by a contract binding on him.

    Reliance has been placed by the tenants on the use of the expression ‘putni taluk’ in the contract of tenancy, which it has been argued on the authority of the decision in Tarinee v. Watson prima facie imports a hereditary tenure. But that is not sufficient to support the case of the Respondents who urge that the tenure is not merely hereditary but is held on a rent fixed in perpetuity. We cannot overlook in this connection that it was conceded in the Court of first instance that the document does not create a putni taluk in the technical sense of that expression as used in Reg. VIII of 1819. On behalf of the Respondents, an endeavour has been made to resile from that position in this Court. But it is perfectly plain that this document does not create a putni taluk, in other words, a taluk subject to the summary procedure for realisation of rent provided by Reg. VIII of 1819. We have the two other clauses in the document which bear upon the question now under consideration. In one clause, it is stated that “On account of this” (i.e, the land described) “I” (the tenant) “shall pay the annual rent of Rs. 173-8 as. 12 gds., year by year and month by month as per dowl in the khas taluk.” The other clause is that “I shall continue to be in enjoyment down to my sons, grandsons, etc., on receipt of the talukdari rents according to custom, on account of tanks, bheries, etc., lying in the village.” There can be no doubt in our opinion that as shown by these clauses, the tenure was intended to be hereditary. But the mere fact that a tenure is hereditary does not show that the rent of the tenure has been fixed in perpetuity: In this document although we find expressions which show that the tenure was maurasi, there is nothing to show that the tenure was intended to be mokarari.

    Reliance has been placed on behalf of the tenants on the decision of the Judicial Committee in the case of The Port Canning and Land Improvement Co., Ltd. v. S.M Katyayani Debi which, however, has no application to the circumstances of the present litigation. There the land was let out for purposes of reclamation: no rent as payable for some years from the commencement of the tenancy: then there was a progressive scale of rent. The Judicial Committee held, confirming the view of this Court, [Katyayani v. Port Canning and Land Improvement Co. (4) that the rent mentioned in the lease as the last in the series of the progressive rents was intended to be fixed in perpetuity. In the case before us, the tenants covenanted to pay an annual rent of Rs. 173-8-12 gds. There is no indication that this rent was fixed in perpetuity and would not be varied from time to time. Consequently this document does not show that the landlord had precluded himself from the exercise of the right of enhancement, by a contract binding on him.

    Reference has been made to a subsequent document, dated the 9th December 1852, which in our opinion, is of no assistance to the Respondents. It merely shows that the lands of the taluk had become patit; and the landlord consequently granted a temporary remission; there is an express statement that after the expiry of the period of temporary remission, the original rent would be revived: consequently we are thrown back on the initial contract between the parties dated the 31st August 1823, and, on the interpretation of that contract, we have already held that it does not preclude the landlord from enhancing the rent.

    Reference has also been made to the conduct of the parties. In our opinion, in a case of this description, the evidence of conduct is not relevant. If the terms of the contract are ambiguous, the rights of the parties may be determined with reference to the conduct of the parties [Hebbert v. Purchas ]; but in any case where the terms of the contract are unambiguous no evidence can be given of the conduct of the parties in contradiction to the terms of the contract [N.E Railway v. Hastings ].

    We feel no doubt that the Court of first instance took a correct view of the relative position of the parties in this case and its judgment was rightly affirmed by the Court of Appeal below. The result is that the appeal is allowed, the decree made by Mr. Justice Panton set aside and that of the Court of Appeal below restored with costs both here and before Mr. Justice Panton.

    Fletcher, J.:— I agree.

    S.C.S
    Appeal allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bhupendra Chandra Singha v. Harihar Chackravarti
    (Apr 28, 1920)