Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges

    Thakurji v. Narsingh Narain Singh

    Das, J.:— (after dealing with facts, proceeded).

    2. The substantial question, however, is whether the plaintiff's suit is at all maintainable in view of the fact that it has admittedly not been brought on behalf of all creditors. I have no doubt whatever that if the plaintiffs' suit be regarded as one under section 53 of the Transfer of Property Act to obtain a declaration that the conveyance in question is voidable at the instance of the creditors of the transferor, the suit has not been properly framed and is not maintainable. It is not difficult to understand the principle on which this equitable rule is based. As was said by Mr. Justice Mukherjee in the case of Hakim Lal v. Mooshahar Sahu(1).

    “To allow one creditor to impeach the validity of a conveyance would expose the transferee to separate attacks by different creditors each of which might litigate the same question in a different suit and it is not inconceivable that the court might arrive at different conclusions in dice rent suits brought at the instance of different creditors.”

    3. The question for our determination therefore is was this suit instituted under section 53 of the Transfer of Property Act to obtain a declaration that the conveyance was voidable at the instance of the creditors of the transferor? In my view the suit cannot be regarded as a suit under section 53 at all. It must be remembered that the suit was a suit to obtain possession of the property. It is true that the plaintiffs asked for a declaration that the conveyance in favour of the idols was a fraudulent conveyance but it was necessary to ask for that declaration inasmuch as the conveyance threw a cloud on the plaintiffs' title. But the primary object of the action was nevertheless to obtain possession of the property itself. It seems to me that the primary object of an action under section 53 of the Transfer of Property Act is to make the assets of the transferor available to the general body of creditors; but that is clearly not the object here. A proper test to apply when a question of this nature is raised is to see whether, if the plaintiffs succeed in the action, the property claimed in the action would be available to the general body of creditors

    4. If it would, then the action would in substance be an action under section 53 of the Transfer of Property Act and would have to be instituted by or on behalf of all the creditors. If it would not, then I do not see how the action can by any possibility be regarded as an action under section 53 of the Transfer of Property Act.

    5. Let us apply the test here. It is obvious that the property claimed in the action could not by any possibility be available to the general body of creditors. The plaintiffs have purchased the property at a sale held in execution of their decree; they have perfected their title to the property in suit. The only obstacle to their title is not the debt due by the defendant No. 2 to the other creditors but the conveyance executed by defendant No. 2 in favour of the idols in question. Therefore the plaintiffs would be entitled to recover possession of the properties in suit. That property cannot by any possibility go to the general body of creditors. In my view, therefore, the suit could not be instituted by or on behalf of the general body of creditors. In my opinion the question has been decided correctly by the Lower Appellate Court and I would dismiss this appeal with costs.

    6. Adami, J.:— —I agree.

    7. Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Thakurji v. Narsingh Narain Singh
    (Dec 8, 1920)