Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges

    Kali Charan Naskar v. Ram Kumar Sardar

    Coxe, J.:— This was a suit to establish the right of the villagers to use a certain path obstructed by the Defendants. It appears that the land in suit lies between the Plaintiff's ditch on the South and the Defendant's tank on the North. The Plaintiff alleges that it is a public road while the Defendants assert that it is a part of the bank of their tank.

    The lower Appellate Court has found that the land is part of the public road and has been obstructed by the Defendants. It has also found that the Plaintiff has suffered no special damage.

    On these findings the suit must be dismissed. As pointed out by Woodroffe, J., in Monmotha Nath Das v. Harish Chandra Das(2), “under the substantive law no action can be maintained by a private individual in respect of a infringement of the right of the general public unless he has sufiered special damage …… In a case therefore of infringement of a right of the general public no suit can be brought under sec. 30 or at all, unless on proof of special damage”. See also Buroda Prosad Moostafi v. Gora Chand Moostafi(3), Raj Luckhee Dibia v. Chunder Kanto Chowdhury(4) Adamson v. Atumugam(5).

    It seems to me an extremely hard case practically the Plaintiff had no other remedy. According to the decision in Buroda Prosad Moostafi v. Gora Chand Moostafi cited above, the complainant should have gone to the Magistrate for redress. But if he had done so, and the Defendant had in good faith claimed the land as his own (and there is plenty of room in the circumstances of this case for an honest difference of opinion) the Magistrate's jurisdiction would at once have been ousted. See Dulalram Deb…2Nd Party, v. Baishnab Charan Deb…1St Party, Opposite.(6) and the cases cited therein. However, I have no alternative but to follow the cases cited above with which indeed, so far as they lay down that a civil suit does not lie, I fully agree. The appeal will accordingly be allowed and the suit dismissed but in the circumstances I will not allow costs.

    [The Plaintiff preferred this Appeal under the Letters Patent.]

    Babus Mohendta Nath Roy, Biswa Nath Base and Manmatha Nath Roy for the Appellant.

    Babu Sarat Chandra Mukerjee for the Respondents.

    The Judgment of the Court was as follows:—

    Jenkins, C.J:— This is a suit brought by the Plaintiff under sec. 30 of the Code of Civil Procedure of 1882, on behalf of himself and his co-villagers to vindicate their right to a village pathway, and to obtain appropriate relief. That is bow the case was specifically framed by the pleadings. Before the Munsif, evidence was adduced with the result that the Munsif passed a decree in these terms:—“The suit is decreed with costs; it is declared that the land described in the map filed along with the plaint is a village road”. The learned Munsif then proceeded to give the appropriate relief. In the grounds of appeal preferred from this decree, nowhere is it suggested that the appropriate description was not a village road but a public highway. All that was contended was that there was no pathway at all. The case came before the lower Appellate Court, with the result that the decision of the Court of first instance was confirmed and the appeal dismissed with costs. Then the case came on second appeal before Mr. Justice Coxe, and it was contended before him that the suit must fail because the subject matter of the litigation was a public highway and therefore a suit could not be brought under the terms of sec. 30. The learned Judge, though very reluctantly, yielded to the argument. Had the judgment of Mr. Justice Wilson in Chuni Lal v. Ram Kishen Shahu been brought to his notice, he would have been able to give effect to what evidently was his view as to the justice of the case. But that case apparently was not cited to him, nor did the argument bring to his notice the distinction between a public highway and a road over which a section of the public, as for instance, the inhabitants of a particular locality, might have a right of way. To my mind it is clear, notwithstanding stray expressions to be found here and there in the judgment of the lower Appellate Court, that the ultimate decision was, as the decree itself declared, that the particular pathway was a village road. That conclusion completely meets the difficulties raised by the Defendants and the result is that, in my opinion, the judgment and decree of Mr. Justice Coxe must be set aside, and the decree of the lower Appellate Court confirmed. The Respondents must pay the costs in the High Court and in the lower Courts.

    N.R Chatterjea, J.:— I agree.

    Appeal allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Kali Charan Naskar v. Ram Kumar Sardar
    (Mar 25, 1912)