AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Article 183 of the Limitation Act, 1908,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Article 183 of the Limitation Act, 1908,

    Chatterput Singh Judgment-Debtor v. Daya Chand Marwari Decree-Holder .

    1. This appeal arises out of an application for the execution of a decree of this Court dated the 3rd September 1896. On the 3rd April 1897, application was made for the execution of the decree by the arrest of the judgment-debtor. Notice was ordered to be issued under S. 245-B of the then Code but no evidence is given to show that any other action was taken. On 2nd March 1909, an application was made for the transfer of the decree to Bhagalpur and this was ordered by the Registrar. On 6th April application was made to the Bhagalpur Court to execute the decree. Notice was issued under O. 21, R. 22, and on the 6th May the following order was passed.— “Service of notice proved, no objection raised. Let attachment be issued.” On the attachment being effected the judgment-debtor came in and objected that the execution was barred by limitation, and this is the sole question that arises in this appeal.

    2. The learned Subordinate Judge held that the decree-holder had, under Article 183 of the Limitation Act, 1908, twelve years from the time when he had an existing right to execute the decree, that he had such an existing right in April 1897 and that therefore, the suit was in time.

    3. He also held that as this Court had transferred the decree it was necessarily of opinion that execution was not barred.

    4. The view that under Article 183 the plaintiff had twelve years from any time when be still had an existing right is clearly untenable. Limitation runs from the time when the right accrues, that is to say, from the date of the decree. Nor does the fact that this Court transmitted the decree show that it was of opinion that the execution was not barred. That question was not considered much less decided, by this Court.

    5. The grounds, therefore, on which the decision of the Court below is based appear to us to fail. The decision, however, has been supported by the learned Vakil for the respondent on three other grounds, namely, (1) that the question of limitation should have been decided by this Court, (2) that question is concluded by the order of the 6th May and (3) that limitation is saved by the proceedings of 1897, which amounted to a revivor of the decree.

    6. As to the first point the learned Pleader relies on the cases of Soomut Dass v. Court of Wards . 1874 21 WR 292., and Lutfullah v. Kirat Chand . 1874 21 WR 330., which are, no doubt, in his favour. Those cases, however, were rulings under Act VIII of 1859 which contained no provision analogous to S. 228 of the Code of 1882. And, moreover, it is difficult to reconcile them with the case of Leake…Decree-Holder; v. Daniel…Judgment-Debtor.* . 1868 10 WR 10 FB.. The case of Jassoda Koer v. Land Mortgage Bank of India . 1882 8 Cal 916. does not really lend much support to the respondent while that of Chhotay Lal v. Puran Mull . 1896 23 Cal 39. is against him. On the other hand it was held in the case of Sripatti Charan Chowdhry v. Belchambers . 1910 8 IC 22. that it is for the executing Court to deal with the question of limitation and in Suja Hossein v. Monohur Das . 1895 22 Cal 921. the right of the executing Court to deal with this matter seems not to have been questioned. We think that the executing Court was fully competent to deal with the question and must so decide the first point taken on the respondent's behalf.

    7. The second point is based on the case of Mungal Prashad Dichit v. Grija Kant Lahiri . 1882 8 Cal 51. But that case is no authority for holding that if a judgment debtor does not appear to contest a notice under O. 21, R. 22 he cannot avail himself of the provisions of the Code which authorise him to put in objections when his property is attached. In the case cited the judgment-debtor acquiesced in the order of attachment and the decision of their Lordships was in great measure based on that acquiescence.

    8. The third point taken is wholly opposed to the decision in Jogendra Chandra Roy v. Syam Das . 1909 36 Cal 543 in which it was held that a writ of revivor is identical with a proceeding under S. 248 of the Code (see also Ashootosh Dutt v. Doorga Churn Chatterjee . 1881 6 Cal 504.. Reliance has been placed on Beni Madhub v. Shiva Narain . 1907 4 ALJ 405.. We understand that the learned Vakil does not invite us to go to the whole length of that decision and hold that an application for transfer amounts to a revivor, but it was argued that what was essential to constitute revivor was this, that where execution could not proceed without leave of the Court, the granting of that leave was a revivor of the decree. But no leave was necessary for the arrest of the judgment-debtor. Under S. 254, every money, decree could be enforced by the imprisonment of the judgment-debtor. Under S. 245-B the Court had powers to issue a notice first when an application for execution in this manner was filed. But it was not bound to exercise this special power, and if it did not see fit to pass any special orders in the matter, the execution would proceed in ordinary way. Moreover, even if an order for execution after a notice under S. 245-B did amount to revivor, there is nothing to show that any such order was passed. The notice alone would not be sufficient: Sripotti Churn Chatterjee v. Belchambers; Monohar Das v. Fatteh Chand . 1903 30 Cal 979.; Kamini Debi v. Aghor Nath Mukerjee . 1909 4 IC 402..

    9. We think, therefore, that the application for execution is clearly barred by time. The appeal is allowed and the application refused with costs of both Courts which we assess at 5 gold mohurs.

    V.B/R.K

    10. Appeal allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Chatterput Singh Judgment-Debtor v. Daya Chand Marwari Decree-Holder .
    (Jun 30, 1911)