Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges

    Mussammat Nand Rani Kuer v. Durga Dass Narain

    Mullick, J.:— (after stating the facts, as set out above, proceeded as follows):—

    The only question is whether the Court had power to extend the time allowed by an agreement which has resulted in a decree of Court.

    It is contended by the petitioner that no extension of time can be given without the consent of the parties and reliance is placed upon Australian Automatic Weighing Machine Company v. Walter; but the matte has been exhaustively considered in Kandarpa Nag v. Banwari Lal Nag and it seems now settled that no general rule can be laid down and that although a contract may have ripened into a decree the Court will not be preclude from giving relief which it would have been competent to give if it had been called upon to adjudicate upon the contract in the first instance and without its having been embodied in a decree. There are cases which have held that when a compromise takes place between an auction-purchaser, a judgment-debtor and a decree-holder stipulating that the sale would be set aside on the payment of the judgment debt on a certain date time was of the essence of the contract. On the other hand it seems to be now settled that where the agreement is for the payment of money on a prescribed date and that upon default of payment on that date money or land is to be forfeited, time is not of the essence of the contract. Indeed the rule is clear that in every case the Court must determine upon the facts of that case whether relief against forfeiture is to be given or not. I have no doubt that in the present case the Subordinate Judge had jurisdiction to determine whether time was of the essence of the contract. He has decided that it was not and, therefore, it does not seem to me that section 115 can be invoked for the purpose of setting aside the learned Subordinate Judge's order. The learned Subordinate Judge in one part of his judgment expresses the view that section 148 is applicable to the case, but I would prefer to base his jurisdiction on the general rules of equity.

    The only question that remains is whether we should further extend the time. Having regard to the fact that the application to this Court was made without much delay and that the defendants were uncertain whether the learned Judge's order would be affirmed by the High Court I think this is a fit case for granting further extension; and we give seven days' further time from this date for complying with the order of the Subordinate Judge.

    We direct that if the defendants deposit in the Court of the Subordinate Judge the sum of Rs. 6,600 on Account of the decretal sum together with the sum of Rs. 200 on account of intermediate interest, that is to say a total sum of Rs. 6,800 on or before the 10th July, full satisfaction will be entered in respect of the claim as provided by the compromise decree and that on default the terms of the said decree will the duly enforced according to law.

    There will be no order as to costs.

    Bucknill, J.:— I agree.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mussammat Nand Rani Kuer v. Durga Dass Narain
    (Jul 3, 1923)