Mookerjee and Walmsley, JJ.:— We are invited in this Hale to set aside an order whereby the Sub-ordinate Judge has refused an application for the issue of a commission for the examination of the petitioner, who is a purdanashin lady. The petitioner moved the Court below to institute proceedings under the Legal Practitioners Act against the opposite party, who is alleged to have acted as her pleader. On the 6th June last, she applied to be examined on commission in support of her allegations. The application was opposed, on the ground that as the applicant had appeared before the Criminal Court on the 2nd Jane to institute a complaint against one Bhakta Das, she should appear before the Sub-ordinate Judge and be examined in Court. The Sub-ordinate Judge thereupon refused the application. In our opinion, the order cannot possibly be supported.
Section 132, sub-section (1) of the Civil Procedure Code of 1908, provides that women, who according to the customs and manners of the country, ought not to be compelled to appear in public, shall be exempt from personal appearance in Court. It is not disputed that the petitioner is a purdanashin Hindu lady and, according to the customs and manners of the country, ought not to be compelled to appear in public. The question consequently arises, whether she has forfeited the exemption she enjoys under sub-section (1) of section 132, by reason of the fact that she has appeared in a Criminal Court to institute a complaint; on that occasion, the Court room was cleared and she was examined in camera. In our opinion, the question should be answered in the negative, in accordance with the principles explained by this Court in the cases of Chamatkar Mohiney Dabee v. Mohesh Chunder Bose and Mohesh Chunder Addy v. Manick Lall Addy. In the earlier of the two cases, Mr. Justice Trevelyan observed that he should be exceedingly careful before he forced into the public gaze a woman, even though she might have gone outside the purda once, either by way of experiment or otherwise. In the second case, Mr. Justice Stanley ordered a commission to issue although it was established that the lady had on a previous occasion appeared in Court and was examined seated inside a palanquin. The Sub-ordinate Judge has overlooked the obvious distinction between the voluntary and the compulsory appearance of a purdanashin, lady in Court to be examined as a witness. No doubt, a purdanashin lady may completely alter her mode of life, and cease to be included in the statutory description of “women, who, according to the customs and manners of the country, ought not to he compelled to appear in public”. When this transformation has taken place, she can no longer claim, as of, right, the statutory exemption formulated in section 132. But, if she is, in fact, & purdanashin lady, she is not deprived of the statutory protection, merely because she may have previously appeared in public. It is not necessary for our present purpose to investigate exhaustively the law applicable in this respect to criminal cases; but, as the Sub-ordinate Judge has relied upon the fact of the voluntary appearance of the petitioner in a Criminal Court, to her detriment, we may point out that, as regards criminal cases, there has perhaps been a slight divergence of Judicial opinion on the question of the examination of purdanashin ladies on commission. In this Court, it has been sometimes maintained [In re Hurro Soondery Chowdhrain, In re Din Tarini Debi, Abhayeswari Debi v. Kishori Mohan Banerjee, Hem Coomaree Dasee v. Queen Empress], that she is entitled to be examined on commission. In Allahabad, on the other band, In re Faridunnissa, In re Basant Bibi, it has been said that a purdanashin lady is not entitled as of right to be exempt from personal attendance in Court, although, as a matter of prudence, she should not be compelled to appear. But, whatever may be the exact rule of procedure applicable to criminal cases, the true scope of section 132 of the Civil Procedure Code is not open to serious discussion. We are, consequently, of opinion that in the present case the application by the lady to be examined on commission should not have been opposed in the Court below, or in this Court, and we cannot but express our surprise that a person in the position of the opposite party should have thought it proper to take up and maintain such an attitude.
The result is that this Rale is made absolute. We direct that a commission do issue for the examination of the petitioner in accordance with law. As the Rule has been opposed, the petitioner will have her costs in this Court.
L.R
Rule absolute.