Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • thereby.V.S/R.K6. Rule
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • thereby.V.S/R.K6. Rule

    Bhairo Gope And Others v. Emperor Opposite Party.

    1. The rule must be made absolute. In the notice issued upon the petitioner, dated 27th March, 1920, it is clearly stated that the dispute relates to 60 bighas of land detailed and described with the boundaries thereof in the notice. From the order dated 18th April, 1920 it appears that the parties were heard and papers were filed. The Magistrate thereafter on 27th April merely went through the papers and confirmed his order under S. 144 against the petitioners. It is clear from the order that the Magistrate was fully alive to the fact that he had to decide which of the parties was in possession of the disputed land, and he addressed himself at great length on that point. The petitioners claimed possession of the land on the strength of the entries in the finally published Record of Rights, dated 27th January, 1912, in which they were recorded, as being in possession of the land in dispute and having the status of tenants. From the deposition of Mr. Ambler, representing the opposite party, dated 1st April 1920, during the pendency of the S. 145 proceedings, it is evident that the possession of the petitioners, along with other lessees, was admitted to have been up to May 1918. Mr. Ambler says that be gave them notice to quit the land after having divided the crops in May of that year and that he had given four or five bighas to Bhairo, one of the petitioners, rather the leading member on behalf of the petitioners, and that he gave notice to him also to quit as he was found to be dishonest. Mr. Ambler further says that the petitioners interfered with and tried to sow the land even in September 1919, but that through the intervention of the police most of the tenants gave istifa or relinquishment of the land. It is however admitted that Bhairo refused to surrender the land. The present dispute relates to the crop that was grown on the land in September 1919. It is patent that Mr. Ambler could not claim on the basis of the aforesaid istifa, at least against Bhairo, who was no party to that transaction, and that he (Mr. Ambler) was not in undisputed and undisturbed possession of the land in question and unless the possession of a party is undisputed, S. 144 can have no application, and the Magistrate had therefore no jurisdiction to pass orders against the petitioner under that section.

    2. This has been made clear by a series of decisions in the Court, and it would have been unnecessary to refer to them but for the persistence with which some Magistrates still adopt a short route of determining disputes relating to possession of land under S. 144, instead of determining it effectively and conclusively under S. 145 of the Code.

    3. Reference may however be made to the case of Tarapada Bhattacharji… v. Emperor…Opposite Party.(1) and to the concluding words in the case of Kaniz Amira v. Emperor(2) which have been quoted in extenso in the former case. If S. 144 of the Code is inapplicable to any case, it is to the pie sent case. Mr. Ambler and Har Sahai Singh, his lessee, have admitted in proceedings, prior to the present one, that the lands in dispute, along with other lands amounting to 250 bighas, were settled with Bhairo and other petitioners. Mr. Ambler relies upon the reliqnishment made in the first instance by Har Sahai Singh, his servant and lessee, and thereafter by the under-tenants. But Bhairo, the petitioner, did not give any istifa and there is no document to show that he parted with possession, nor is there any document showing that Mr. Ambler was in undisputed possession of the property. This fact distinguishes the present case from the case of Sukam Singh v. Prayag Singh(3), where there was undisputed possession given under the civil Court's decree, and it was held that the possession of the auction-purchaser should be maintained by an order under S. 144 or 107, and no proceeding under S. 145 was necessary.

    4. The question of possession in this case could hardly be determined merely by a perusal of documents on record. It must be established by evidence as to the actual possession. This can only be done by a proceeding under S. 145 and not by an order under S. 144. I therefore set aside the order of the Magistrate, leaving him to take action under S. 145 of the Code, there being a danger of the breach of the peace.

    5. The District Magistrate in his report says that the order expired in this case on 26th May last. It may be so, but the order being without jurisdiction must be set aside, so that the rights of the parties may not be affected thereby.

    V.S/R.K

    6. Rule made absolute.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bhairo Gope And Others v. Emperor Opposite Party.
    (Jun 10, 1920)