Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 20, Agency Rules
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 20, Agency Rules

    Pedda Vikrama Deo Garu v. Maharaja Of Jeypore

    We have before us an application under Rule 20, Agency Rules asking us to call on the Agent to review his judgment, and a petition for the same relief forwarded to us by Government under R. 31 Mr. Sarma for the 1st respondent-plaintiff, however, contends that the Agent's order, one passed in an appeal, remanding the suit for disposal is not liable to interference by this Court on either the application or petition. The argument is in effect that there are some orders of the Agent, this being one of them, which are not subject to the powers of control, which this Court can (with or without invitation of Government) exercise. We feel bound to hold in accordance with the view expressed in Maharaja of Jeypore v. Neladevi, that R. 31 must have been intended to provide for cases for which no previous provision had been made, including orders against which no appeal was allowed —Vide also Chakrapani v. Varahalamma(2) Maharajah of Jeypore v. Jammanadhora(3) and Vikramadeo v. Pattamadhadevi(4). It is argued then that in the present case the remedy by appeal is open to 2nd defendant, because he will be able if the Court of First Instance decides against him at the remand hearing to appeal to the Agent and then, if necessary, to this Court. But we cannot treat that as a remedy for the prejudice, which the order of remand, if erroneous, must cause. We have then considered whether we should deal with the application under R. 20, or the petition under R. 81. The former rule relates to the decrees passed by the Agent in Appeal. But we do not think that we can treat this order of remand as a decree. For though the Code of Civil Procedure is not applicable the definition in it affords guidance, which in the absence of any other authoritative interpretation of the word we are not prepared to disregard; and that definition would not cover the order before us. We therefore dismiss the C. M. P. No. 2561 of 1915 and deal with C. M. P. No. 3762 of 1915.

    The suit is in ejectment, plaintiff alleging that the property was originally granted to one Viswambaradeo and that the grant was continued to his widow and is resumable. The Special Assistant Agent held that nothing was proved as to the original grant or the origin of the defendants' possession. The Agent however, observing that “it would appear that the property or the revenue from it was given to Visvambara” referred to the points in issue as being only whether plaintiff was entitled to resume and on what terms the grant was made. He then remanded the case observing that the burden of proving the absolute gift alleged by the defendants was on them. His order of remand was clearly unjustifiable in the absence of any discussion of the evidence as to the plaintiff's original ownership and the grant to the defendants or their predecessors and any statement of his reasons for dissenting from the Special Assistant Agent's decision that neither plaintiff's possession nor any grant was proved. Until a conclusion in favour of both had been reached, the question whether the grant was, as defendants alleged, an absolute gift, did not arise, and they ought not to have been called on to discharge the burden of proof in connections with it. The Agent's order of remand is, therefore, set aside and he is directed to readmit the appeal, and deal with it in the light of the foregoing, disposing of it only after recording a definite finding on all the points involved in the first issue, including plaintiff's title and the circumstances in which his possession terminated. We make no order as to costs in C. M. P. No. 2561 of 1915. In C. M. P. No. 3762 of 1915 the costs in this Court will abide the result and be provided for in the Agent's decree.

    C. K.Rehearing ordered.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Pedda Vikrama Deo Garu v. Maharaja Of Jeypore
    (Aug 24, 1916)