Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges

    Khaji Sayyid Yusuf Sahib v. Ediga Narasimhappa

    The Matter has been fully argued before us and we have come to the conclusion that the District Judge's judgment cannot be supported. In the previous litigation. The present ist plaintiff's father claimed a right of way over the path in question. The case was taken up to the High Court and it was held in Hussain Sahib v. Narasimhappa accepting the finding of the Lower Appellate Court in that behalf, that the path was a public one and that the plaintiff was not entitled to maintain the suit without alleging special damage. Accepting this decision, the present 1st plaintiff who is the son of the plaintiff in the provious litigation sued along with three others, the same defendants for a declaration that the path is a public one. The necessary sanction under Sect. 91 of the Civil Procedure Code was obtained to institute the suit. The defendants now plead that it is a private right of away. The District Munsif overruled this plea and gave plaintiffs a decree. On appeal the District Judge has reversed this judgment and has dismissed the suit.

    Apart from the view we take in regard to the binding nature of the previous judgment, it seems to us that it woud not conduce to the proper administration of justice, if a defendant who has been successful on a particular view of the facts put forward by him is allowed to resile from that position and to raise a defence inconsistent with his original contention. Even if there is no question of res judicata, we would have held that the defendants are estopped from questioning the judgment to which they were parties. See Ramamurthi Dkora v. The Secretary of for India in Council(2).

    But we think that the present contention is res judicata and that Explanation VI to Sect. 11 governs this case. The essence of a litigation which is carried on by a private party for injuries sustained by him in the exercise of a right common to him and others is that there is a public right and that they party suing has Suffered special damage in enforcing that right. The fact that in obtaining this individual remedy, it is not open to him in get a declaration embodied in the decree that the right is a public one will not affect the principle of res judicata. Mr. Balakrishana Rao's citations from English decisions only establish that a private individual is not competent to obtain a declaration that a right is a public one. The vindiration of such a right is either by indictment or by a suit by the Attorney-General. But no authority has been quoted for the proposition that an individual is not entitled in his own right to seek redress in respect of the injuries sustained by him in the exercise of his privileges connected with a public right. That is a common law right; and when that right is put in Court, there must necessarily be 3 finding whether the special injury was sustained by the plaintiff in exercising his rights a? a member of the public. When that adjudication is given, the finding regarding the right becomes res judicata in a subsequent litigation by virtue of Explanation VI to Sect. 11 which gives a comprehensive definition of the terms “under whom they or any of them claim.” Mr. Balakrishna Rao's argument that the enactment of Sect. 91 prohibits a member of the public from obtaining a finding regarding the public right would render nugatory Explanation VI to Sect. 11 and would strike at the root of the common law right which every individual possesses in these matters. There is authority also for the view we have taken. Rangamma v. Narasimhacharyulu decides the converse of the present case, but the principle is there recognised as argued by Mr. K. V. Krishnaswami Aiyar that the right litigated in the first litigation need not be on behalf of the general public, provided the foundation of the claim is that the injury was suffered in exercising a right common to the plaintiff and others. Muhammad Amir v. Sumitra Kuar is also to the same effect. The decision in Ramados v. Hanumantha Rao(3) under Sect. 92 of the Code enunciates the same principle.

    For these reasons we are of opinion that the finding in the previous litigation that the suit path is a public one operates as res judicata in the present suit and that it is not open to the defendants to go behind that finding.

    We must reverse the decree of the District Judge and restore that of the District Munsif with costs here and in the Lower Appellate Court.

    K. V. S.Appeal allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Khaji Sayyid Yusuf Sahib v. Ediga Narasimhappa
    (Nov 8, 1917)