Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • section 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order XLI, rule 11, Civil. Procedure Code,
  • section 11 of the Code,
  • Order XLI, rule 11,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • section 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order XLI, rule 11, Civil. Procedure Code,
  • section 11 of the Code,
  • Order XLI, rule 11,
Smart Summary

Court Opinion Summary — Kulwant Sahay, J. (with Macpherson, J. concurring)

Factual and Procedural Background

These two appeals were filed by the defendant(s) and arise from two separate suits for rent (Suit No. 355 of 1922 and Suit No. 354 of 1922).

The plaintiff (Syed Hussain / Mir Syed Hussain) claimed to be the lessee of "6 annas and odd" of mauza Hussainabad: four annas under four registered thika pattas (one patta being a 1 anna 18 dams 10 kauris odd share executed by Bibi Imaman and Bibi Batul) and the remaining ~2 annas under an amaldastak from the defendants-second-party.

Suit No. 355 related to a holding of 2,131 acres held by Muhammad Kabir (the defendant in that suit; now deceased and represented by his widow Bibi Wasilan) with rent claimed for years 1327–1329 F.S. Suit No. 354 was against Bibi Wasilan in respect of five holdings consolidated with a consolidated rental claimed at Rs. 152-14-3. The names on the thikas were in Aulad Ali, whom the plaintiff alleged to be his benamidar; defendants contended Aulad Ali was the real thikadar (and not the plaintiff's farzidar) and challenged the plaintiff's entitlement to rent for 1327–1329, with a plea of payment.

The Munsif dismissed both suits. On appeal the learned Subordinate Judge held that Aulad Ali was a farzidar (i.e., the plaintiff was the real thikadar) for the four annas and that the plaintiff was entitled to rent for 1328–1329 under the amaldastak; a modified decree was entered for the plaintiff. The present appeals were filed by Bibi Wasilan (in one appeal in her own right and in the other as representative of her late husband).

A subsequent suit instituted by Bibi Wasilan (as proprietor) against Aulad Ali (as thikadar) for thika rent was ultimately decreed in her favour at trial and on appeal, and a second appeal to this Court was dismissed under Order XLI, rule 11, on 24 June 1927. Although that suit was instituted after the present suits were filed, it was finally decided before the final decision in the present appeals, giving rise to the contention that the present suits were barred by res judicata.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the judgment in Bibi Wasilan's subsequently instituted (but ultimately finally decided prior) suit operates as res judicata to bar the present suits (i.e., whether the question of who was the real thikadar — the plaintiff or Aulad Ali — is res judicata between the parties).
  2. In Appeal No. 1148 (from Suit No. 354): whether the amount of rent was correctly determined by the courts below (dispute between claimed rent Rs. 152-14-3 and alleged rent Rs. 145-1-6) and whether that issue was decided below.
  3. Whether the finding of fact by the Subordinate Judge that Aulad Ali was a farzidar (i.e., that the plaintiff was the real thikadar for the relevant shares) could properly be disturbed in Second Appeal.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (Bibi Wasilan) — Principal Contentions

  • The judgment in her later-filed suit for thika rent (instituted against Aulad Ali and Mir Syed Hussain) had been finally decided before the final decision in the present appeals and held that Aulad Ali was the real thikadar; therefore the question whether the plaintiff or Aulad Ali was the real thikadar is res judicata and the present suits for rent cannot be maintained by the plaintiff.
  • In Appeal No. 1148 (Suit No. 354) the court below had not decided the correct amount of rent; the defendant alleged the rent should be Rs. 145-1-6 rather than the Rs. 152-14-3 claimed by the plaintiff.

Respondent / Plaintiff (Syed Hussain) — Principal Positions as Presented in the Opinion

  • The plaintiff claimed title as lessee: 4 annas under four registered pattas (one patta being the 1 anna 18 dams 10 kauris share) and ~2 annas under an amaldastak; he alleged Aulad Ali was his benamidar and that he was entitled to recover rents from cultivating raiyats.
  • Evidence included Aulad Ali's admission (as a witness) that the plaintiff was entitled to recover rents (i.e., an acknowledgment relevant to the dispute over who the real thikadar was vis-à-vis the cultivating raiyats).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Balkishan v. Kishan Lal Cited for the proposition that the question of res judicata can be raised in appeal. Used to support the conclusion that it is open to the appellant to raise res judicata in the present appeals.
Dhani Singh v. Chandra Choor Deo (decision of this Court) Noted as a decision of this Court in which previous decisions on the point of raising res judicata in appeal were considered. Relied upon to show existing authority in this Court addressing the point that res judicata may be raised in appeal.
Abdul Majid v. Jew Narain Mahto Referenced as taking a different view on whether the plea (res judicata) can be taken in appeal (specific holding not fully detailed in the opinion). Noted as representing divergent authority; the Court contrasted this view with other authorities and subsequent Full Bench decisions.
Mariamnissa Bibi v. Joynab Bibi Also cited as taking a different view (by Ghose, C.J., and Harington, J.) on the same point; Rampini, J. dissented. Used to show there was conflicting authority on whether res judicata may be raised in appeal; the opinion records the divergence of views.
Zaharia v. Debia (Full Bench, Allahabad High Court) Full Bench accepted the view expressed by Rampini, J. (i.e., in relation to whether res judicata can be raised in appeal). Relied upon to demonstrate that a Full Bench had accepted the view that the plea can be raised in appeal, supporting the Court's conclusion that the question could be raised here.
Isup Ali v. Gour Chandra Deb (Calcutta High Court) Later Calcutta High Court decision cited as having taken the view that the plea (res judicata) can be taken in appeal. Referenced to show that later decisions in another High Court aligned with the proposition that res judicata may be raised in appeal.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court first addressed whether the plea of res judicata could be raised in these appeals. It surveyed the authorities and concluded that it is open to an appellant to raise res judicata in appeal (citing Balkishan v. Kishan Lal, Dhani Singh v. Chandra Choor Deo, and noting a Full Bench decision in Zaharia v. Debia as supportive, with later Calcutta High Court decisions also approving the view).

The Court then applied the statutory rule: although Bibi Wasilan's suit was instituted after the present suits, it was finally decided before this Court's final decision; under Explanation 1 to section 11 of the Civil Procedure Code her suit must be taken as the "former suit" for the purposes of section 11, so the threshold temporal requirement for res judicata could be satisfied.

The Court proceeded to examine whether the other elements of res judicata — identity of parties, identity of title or cause of action, and identity of issues — were established between the earlier (Wasilan's) suit and the present suits:

  • Title/Capacity: In the former suit Wasilan sued as proprietor to recover her proprietary share of thika rent (in respect of the 6 dams she had purchased). In the present suits Wasilan was contesting under the character of a raiyat in respect of certain land comprised within the thika lease. Thus the parties were litigating under different titles.
  • Identity of Parties: Although some parties (Wasilan and Mir Syed Hussain) appeared in both suits, Aulad Ali — a defendant in the former suit who was there held to be the lessee — is not a party to the present suits. The Court also observed that Aulad Ali had testified in the present suits as a witness and admitted that the plaintiff was entitled to recover rents.
  • Identity of Issues: The issue decided in the former suit was who was liable to the lessor for thika rent (i.e., whether Aulad Ali was the lessee). The issues in the present suits included who was entitled to recover rent from the cultivating raiyats; these are not precisely the same issues. The Munsif in the former suit had expressly "kept open" the rights between the two defendants (Aulad Ali and Syed Hussain) for future trial, indicating the former judgment did not decide the inter se rights relevant to the present suits.
  • Scope of the plaintiff's claim: The present plaintiff claimed under four thika pattas and an amaldastak; Wasilan acquired only a fractional interest in one patta (6 dams). The Court held that res judicata could not be raised in respect of the other three pattas and the amaldastak on which the plaintiff based his claim.

On these bases the Court concluded the elements required to render the earlier judgment res judicata of the present suits were not established: the titles, issues, and parties were not the same in the two proceedings, and the Munsif's judgment in the earlier suit expressly left certain rights open.

Regarding the factual finding by the Subordinate Judge that Aulad Ali was a farzidar (i.e., that the plaintiff was the real thikadar for the four annas), the Court treated this as a finding of fact and held that it could not be disturbed in Second Appeal.

On the separate point concerning the amount of rent (Appeal No. 1148), the Court observed the objection to the correctness of certain jamas was not pressed before the Subordinate Judge; the Munsif had made specific findings (noting he had not been persuaded that the jamas were incorrect). Because the rent-amount question was not raised on the appeal below, the Court held it was not open to the appellant to raise it anew in this Second Appeal.

Wort, J. (sitting singly) had found the Subordinate Judge correct in awarding the full amount claimed and referred the res judicata question to a Division Bench. The present Division Bench agreed with Wort, J.'s conclusion on the merits and overruled the appellant's contention regarding the amount of rent.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The appeals are DISMISSED with costs.

Direct consequences for the parties:

  • The Subordinate Judge's modified decree in favour of the plaintiff (holding that the plaintiff was the real thikadar for the relevant shares and entitled to rent for the years found due) stands.
  • The contention that the earlier suit (instituted by Bibi Wasilan and finally decided before these appeals) operates as res judicata to bar the present suits was rejected by the Court on the factual and legal grounds summarized above.
  • The appellant's challenge to the amount of rent in Appeal No. 1148 was denied on the procedural ground that the issue was not raised on the earlier appeal to the Subordinate Judge and therefore could not properly be re-agitated in this Second Appeal.

Broader legal implications: The opinion applies existing authorities about whether the plea of res judicata may be raised in appeal and analyses the factual prerequisites for res judicata; the Court did not purport to lay down a novel principle of law beyond applying those authorities to the facts before it. No new precedent of sweeping scope is announced beyond these applications.

Result: Appeals dismissed. (Macpherson, J. concurred.)

    Bibi Wasilan v. Mir Syed Hussain

    Kulwant Sahay, J.:— These two appeals are by the defendant and arise out of two suits for rent. Appeal no. 1147 arises out of suit no. 355 of 1922 in which Sheikh Muhammad Kabir was the defendant. He is now dead and is represented by his widow Bibi Wasilan who was the defendant in suit no. 354 of 1922 out of which Second Appeal no. 148 arises.

    The plaintiff's case is that he is the lessee in respect of 6 annas and odd share out of the 16 annas of mauza Hussainabad. He held 4 annas share under four registered pattas granted by different sets of proprietors, one of the pattas being of the share of Bibi Imaman and Bibi Batul in respect of 1 anna 18 dams 10 kauris odd share. The remaining 2 annas and odd was held by the plaintiff under an amaldastak from the defendants second-party in the present suits. Suit no. 355 was in respect of a holding of 2131 acres of land held by the defendant Muhammad Kabir at a rental of Rs. 116-11-17 dams and the rent was claimed for the years 1327-1329. Suit no. 354 against Bibi Wasilan was in respect of five holdings which had been consolidated into one, bearing a consolidated rental of Rs. 152-14-3. The thikas under which the plaintiff claimed stood in the name of one Aulad Ali and the plaintiff alleged that Aulad Ali was his benamidar. The defence of the defendants was that Aulad Ali was the thikadar in respect of the 4 annas covered by the four registered pattas and that he was not the farzidar for the plaintiff and that, as regards the remaining 2 annas and odd, the defence was that the plaintiff did not acquire any right to recover the rent for the years 1327-1329 F.S, and there was a plea of payment.

    The trial Court dismissed both the suits on the ground that Aulad Ali was the real thikadar and that the plaintiff was not entitled to the rent of the 4 annas and as regards the remaining 2 annas odd, it was held that under the amaldastack the plaintiff was not entitled to the rent for the years 1327-1329. There were appeals by the plaintiff in each suit and the learned Subordinate Judge held that Aulad Ali was a farzidar for the plaintiff and the plaintiff was the real thikadar in respect of the 4 annas share, and as regards the amaldastak from the defendants-second-party the learned Subordinate Judge held that the plaintiff was entitled to the rent in respect of the years 1328-1329. He accordingly made a modified decree in favour of the plaintiff.

    The present appeals were preferred by Bibi Wasilan in her own right in one case and as the representative of her late husband, Sheikh Muhammad Kabir, in the other case. The point argued is that the present suits are barred by res judicata on account of the decision in another suit instituted by Bibi Wasilan in which it has been held that Aulad Ali was the real thikadar. The circumstances under which the other suit was instituted are that Bibi Wasilan is also a part proprietor of the village. Subsequently she acquired the interest of Bibi Imaman and Bibi Batul who were the executant of one out of the four pattas under which the plaintiff claimed, to the extent of 6 dams by purchase from Gulam Raza Khan the heir of the two ladies under a deed of sale dated the 24th of February, 1922. The present suits, out of which the appeals now before us arise, were instituted by the present plaintiff Syed Hussain on the 11th of September, 1922. The suits were dismissed by the Munsif on the 24th of September, 1923, and they were decreed by the Subordinate Judge on appeal on the 30th March, 1925, and the present appeals were filed in this Court on the 18th June, 1925. Bibi Wasilan, the defendant in one of the present suits, instituted a suit for rent as proprietor against Aulad Ali as the thikadar in respect of her share in the proprietary interest. This suit was instituted on the 19th of August, 1925, that is after the filing of the present appeals in this Court. The suit was, however, decreed by the Munsif on the 10th of March, 1926, who held that Aulad Ali was the real thikadar, and this decision of the Munsif was upheld in appeal by the District Judge on the 8th January, 1927, and a Second Appeal to this Court was dismissed under Order XLI, rule 11, Civil. Procedure Code, on the 24th of June, 1927. Therefore, although Bibi Wasilan's suit for the thika rent was instituted in point of time after the institution of the suits out of which the present appeals arise, yet it was finally decided before the final decision in the present appeals, and, it is therefore contended on behalf of the defendant-appellant that the judgment in that suit operates as res judicata and the question whether the plaintiff or Aulad Ali was the real thikadar is no longer open between the parties, and it must be held that Aulad Ali was the real thikadar and the plaintiff could not maintain the present suit for rent.

    Another point is taken in Appeal no. 1148, which arises out of suit no. 354, viz., the question of the amount of the rent. Plaintiff claimed rent at Rs. 152-14-3, but the defendant alleged that the rent was Rs. 145-1-6, and the question raised was that the Court below had not decided the amount of rent.

    As regards the first point, viz., the question of res judicata, an affidavit has been filed on behalf of the appellant setting out the fact of the institution of the suit for thika rent by Bibi Wasilan and the decision thereof, and copies of the decisions of the Munsif as well as of the District Judge and the order of this Court dismissing the appeal under Order XLI, rule 11, have been produced. There can be no doubt that the question of res judicata can be raised in appeal [See Balkishan v. Kishan Lal and a decision of this Court in Dhani Singh v. Chandra Choor Deo in which the previous decisions on the point are noticed]. A different view was taken in Abdul Majid v. Jew Narain Mahto and in Mariamnissa Bibi v. Joynab Bibi by Ghose, C.J and Harington, J., but Rampini, J. dissented from that view and his view was accepted by a Full Bench of the Allahabad High Court in Zaharia v. Debia. Later decisions in the Calcutta High Court have also taken the view that the plea can be taken in appeal [Isup Ali v. Gour Chandra Deb]. It is thus clear that it is open to the appellant to raise the question of res judicata in the present appeals. Although the suit of Bibi Wasilan for the thika rent was in point of time subsequent to the present suits, yet it was finally decided prior to the final decision of the present suits by this Court, and under Explanation 1 to section 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure Bibi Wasilan's suit must be taken to be the former suit within the meaning of section 11 of the Code, and if the other elements necessary to constitute res judicata be established the decision in that suit will operate as res judicata in the present suits. The question is whether such elements have been established.

    In the suit of Bibi Wasilan, Aulad Ali was the defendant-first-party and Mir Syed Hussain, the present plaintiff, was the defendant-second-party. The suit was for arrears of rent in respect of one of the four thikas under which the present plaintiff bases his title in the present suits, viz., the thika patta executed by Bibi Imaman and Bibi Batul. The thika of these two ladies was in respect of 1 anna 18 dams 10 kauris odd share. Bibi Wasilan had purchased 6 dams out of this share under the deed of sale dated the 24th of February, 1922, and she had instituted the suit against Aulad Ali as the defendant-first-party and Mir Syed Hussain as the defendant-second-party for realization of her share of the thika rent to the extent of 6 dams purchased by her. The title, therefore, under which she was litigating in the former suit was that of a proprietor, and the question raised was whether the relationship of landlord and tenant subsisted between her as proprietor and Aulad Ali as lessee. It was held in that case that Aulad Ali was the lessee. In the present suits the title under which Bibi Wasilan is contesting the suit is that of a raiyat in respect of certain land comprised within the thika lease. It is thus clear that in the former suit, although some of the parties, viz., Wasilan and Mir Syed Hussain, were the same, yet they were not litigating under the same title. Moreover, Aulad Ali, who was a party in the former suit, is not a party in the present suits. He has given his evidence as a witness admitting that he was the farzidar for the present plaintiff. Thus all the parties in the two litigations are not the same. It appears that the Munsif expressly left Open the question as regards the rights between the two sets of defendants in the former suit, viz., between Aulad Ali and Syed Hussain and dismissed the suit against Syed Hussain. The last sentence in the judgment of the Munsif in the former suit is:

    “Be it noted that the rights amongst the two defendants are kept open for a future trial.”

    From this it is clear that the decision in the former suit does not debar the plaintiff in the present suits from raising the question that he is the real thikadar and is entitled to recover rents from the cultivating raiyats of the share leased to him. All that was decided in the former suit was that the lessor was not bound to recognize any other person as her lessee except the one in whose name the lease stood, but that decision did not debar the present plaintiff from recovering the rent from the cultivating raiyats if he succeeded in establishing as against Aulad Ali that he was entitled to do so. Although Aulad Ali is not a party to the present litigation, he admits in his evidence that the plaintiff is entitled to recover rents. The lessor may not be bound to recognize the present plaintiff, but the cultivating raiyats cannot raise the question if the ostensible thikadar admits that the plaintiff, is the real thikadar. Wasilan's suit had been dismissed as against the present plaintiff, and the decree being in his favour it is open to doubt whether he could appeal against the finding of the Munsif that Aulad Ali was the real thikadar, and if he could not appeal against that decree, the decision in that suit cannot operate as res judicata in the present suits. Furthermore, the plaintiff in the present suits claims under four thika pattas. Bibi Wasilan has acquired a fractional share of the interest of the lessor in one of those pattas, and the question of res judicata cannot be raised as regards the title of the plaintiff under the other three pattas and the amaldastak. The issue which was decided in the former suit was: who was liable for the thika rent to the lessor? The issue involved in the present suits is who is entitled to recover rent from the cultivating raiyats? The issues, therefore, in the two suits are not exactly the same. For all these reasons I am of opinion that the decision in the former suit does not operate as res judicata in the present suits. The finding of the learned Subordinate Judge that Aulad Ali is a farzidar for the plaintiff is a finding of fact and it cannot be interfered with in Second Appeal.

    The other point as regards the amount of rent arises only in one of the suits, viz., in the suit giving rise to Appeal no. 1148. The question of amount of rent was raised in issue no. 4 in the trial Court and the learned Munsif had reduced the amount in the suit giving rise to Appeal no. 1147. As regards the suit out of which Appeal no. 1148 arises, the learned Munsif said:

    “The objection regarding the correctness of the jamas of other khatas has not been pressed, and I find no reason to hold them to be incorrect.”

    The question was not raised in the appeal before the Subordinate Judge, and I am of opinion that it is not open to the appellant to raise this question again in this Second Appeal. These appeals in the first instance came for decision before Wort, J., sitting singly and he found that the learned Subordinate Judge was right in giving a decree for the full amount claimed. He, however, referred these appeals to a Division Bench for a decision of the question of res judicata. I agree with Wort, J., and the contention of the appellant as regards the amount of rent must be overruled.

    The result is that these appeals are dismissed with costs.

    Macpherson, J.:— I agree.

    Appeals dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bibi Wasilan v. Mir Syed Hussain
    (Jun 18, 1928)