Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiffs are certain reversioners of the family of the deceased Ram Lochan Singh, who was the last male owner. The plaintiffs' case was that they were his next heirs and that Ram Lochan Singh died without issue. There had been a prior dispute in the revenue Court in which the plaintiffs were unsuccessful; this led them to bring the present civil suit.

The contesting defendant, Shankar Dayal Singh, denied that the plaintiffs were the nearest collaterals and pleaded that he was the daughter's son of Ram Lochan Singh and therefore entitled to succeed in preference to the plaintiffs. At trial the Subordinate Judge framed an issue concerning whether the plaintiffs were the reversionary heirs and whether the defendant was the daughter's son. The trial Court found that the defendant was the daughter's son of Ram Lochan Singh and, accordingly, the suit was dismissed. One of the plaintiffs appealed; the appeal challenges burden allocation, the rejection of prior testimony (deposition of Mt. Pato) taken in a mutation proceeding, and the findings based on evidence.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the plaintiffs were the next/reversionary heirs of Ram Lochan Singh (i.e., entitled to the estate as nearest collaterals).
  2. Whether the defendant, Shankar Dayal Singh, was the daughter's son of Ram Lochan Singh and therefore had a preferential right to succeed.
  3. Whether the Subordinate Judge improperly shifted or imposed an unfair burden of proof onto the plaintiffs.
  4. Whether a prior statement (deposition) of Mt. Pato given in a mutation (revenue) proceeding was admissible in the civil suit, i.e., whether that revenue proceeding was a "judicial proceeding" or involved a person authorised by law to take evidence for the purposes of Sections 32 and 33 of the Indian Evidence Act.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff-Appellants' Arguments

  • The Subordinate Judge wrongly placed the burden of proof on the plaintiffs by starting from the proposition that plaintiffs had to show the defendant was not the daughter's son of Ram Lochan Singh in order to oust him.
  • The Subordinate Judge wrongly rejected the deposition of Mt. Pato given in the earlier mutation proceeding, even though she was dead at the time of the civil suit.
  • The trial judge's factual findings based on the evidence were challenged as incorrect.

Contesting Defendant's Position (as presented in the opinion)

  • The defendant denied that the plaintiffs were the nearest collaterals entitled to succeed.
  • The defendant pleaded that he was the son of a daughter (Mt. Murti) of Ram Lochan Singh and therefore had a superior right to the estate over the plaintiffs.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Burden of proof:

The appellate court examined the complaint that the Subordinate Judge had imposed a heavier burden on the plaintiffs. The court held that the Subordinate Judge did not impose an unfairly heavy burden: plaintiffs, who sought to oust the defendant, were required to prove that they were the next heirs of the deceased and to show that there were no nearer heirs—such as a daughter or a daughter's son—who would exclude them even if they were the nearest male collaterals. The Subordinate Judge, however, did not decide the case by finding that the plaintiffs merely failed to meet that burden; instead he recorded a categorical finding that the defendant was the daughter's son and had a better title than the plaintiffs.

Admissibility of Mt. Pato's statement from the revenue (mutation) proceeding:

The Subordinate Judge treated the statement as inadmissible because the mutation case had been regarded by him as an administrative proceeding rather than a judicial proceeding. The appellate court analysed the issue under Sections 32 and 33 of the Evidence Act:

  • Section 32: The court agreed that Mt. Pato's statement was not admissible under Section 32 because it was made after the dispute had been raised (Section 32 concerns statements made by persons who cannot be called as witnesses, but only those made before the existence of a dispute are covered in certain respects).
  • Section 33: The court noted the additional words in Section 33 making relevant evidence given by a person "in a judicial proceeding or before any person authorised by law to take it." Thus the question was whether the revenue proceeding was a judicial proceeding or whether the Collector was a person authorised by law to take evidence.

The court concluded that where a dispute is referred to the Collector under the relevant revenue provisions (the opinion refers to S. 39(3) and S. 40), the Collector's functions include making a decision based on possession and, if necessary, conducting a summary enquiry to determine who is best entitled and passing an order as to possession. This process requires the Collector to follow a procedure resembling judicial enquiry and to base his decision on evidence taken before him. The appellate court therefore held that even if the proceeding were not strictly a "judicial proceeding," the Collector was nonetheless a person authorised by law to take evidence within the meaning of Section 33 of the Evidence Act.

The court further observed that Section 193 of the Land Revenue Act would apply to such proceedings, meaning persons summoned must state the truth when examined; the Collector could not rely on undisclosed private information. Consequently, Section 33 applied and Mt. Pato's statement made in the revenue proceeding was, in principle, admissible.

Evaluation of Mt. Pato's credibility and other evidence:

  • Despite holding the statement admissible under Section 33, the appellate court upheld the trial judge's view that Mt. Pato's evidence was unreliable. The revenue courts had rejected her evidence, and the Subordinate Judge described several inconsistent and conflicting statements made by her (e.g., contradictions about whether Ram Lochan Singh had issue, uncertainty about proximity of houses, and a puzzling remark translated as "At this place Ram Lochan Singh used to allege himself as my brother. He was not my kinsman").
  • The appellate court agreed that these discrepancies were damaging and that Mt. Pato's previous statement was not worthy of belief.
  • Plaintiffs' reliance on a school register entry showing a Shankar Dayal Singh admitted in a village school in March 1906 was examined. The court concluded this fact did not permit an inference adverse to the defendant because local geography and school choices explained why the boy might have been admitted at the recorded school; no probative inference could be drawn.
  • The plaintiffs produced five documents (two mortgage deeds of 1884 and 1897, a copy of a report of vasilbaqi navis, and two documents relating to revenue court orders). The court observed that some copies were ambiguous (the name might read as "Ram Bakhsh Singh") and that even if some documents were obtained from Ram Lochan Singh, they would only show some connection and not bear directly on whether the defendant was the daughter's son.
  • The plaintiffs' case relied principally on oral evidence, which the Subordinate Judge saw and heard and found unconvincing. The defendant's evidence, by contrast, was described as specific and direct, including witness testimony that they had seen the daughter and the daughter's son living with Ram Lochan Singh.
  • The appellate court stated the established principle that, in a simple question of fact involving witness credibility, an appellate court will not overturn the view of the trial judge who heard and saw the witnesses unless there is reason to believe the judge did not weigh the evidence fairly and properly.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

APPEAL DISMISSED.

The appellate court accepted the Subordinate Judge's factual finding that Shankar Dayal is the son of Mt. Murti, who was the daughter of the deceased Ram Lochan Singh, and that he therefore has a preferential right to succeed to the estate over the plaintiffs. The appeal was dismissed with costs.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The defendant, Shankar Dayal Singh, is held to have a better title as the daughter's son and will succeed in preference to the plaintiffs. The plaintiffs' challenge to burden allocation and to the exclusion of prior testimony did not succeed in overturning the trial court's factual conclusions.
  • On admissibility: The court clarified that statements made in a revenue "mutation" proceeding may be admissible under Section 33 of the Evidence Act when taken before a Collector acting under statutory provisions (such as S. 39(3) and S. 40) who is authorised by law to take evidence; however, admissibility does not guarantee weight if the finder of fact rejects the evidence due to inconsistencies.
  • Broader precedent: The opinion does not announce or discuss any new legal principle beyond its application of existing statutory provisions to the facts; the decision operates as the resolution of the parties' dispute and does not purport to create a novel precedent.

Note: This summary strictly reflects only the information contained in the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts beyond the text.

    Mahendra Singh v. Shankar Dayal Singh

    1. This is a plaintiff's appeal arising out of a suit brought by certain reversioners of the family of Ram Lochan Singh deceased who was the last male owner. The plaintiffs' case was that they were his next heirs and that he had died without any issue. There was previously a dispute in the revenue Court in which the plaintiffs were not successful. Hence the present suit. On behalf of the contesting defendant, Shankar Dayal Singh, it was first denied that the plaintiffs were the nearest collaterals and it was also pleaded that the defendant was the son of a daughter of the deceased Ram Lochan Singh, and was therefore entitled to succeed to the estate in preference to the plaintiffs. The trial Court framed issue 1 as to whether the plaintiffs were the reversionary heirs of the ??? of Ram Lochan Singh, and if so, ??? the defendant the daughter's son of ??? Lochan Singh? The lower Court has ??? that the plaintiffs are the ???, but has also found that the ??? is Ram Lochan Singh's daughter's ??? Accordingly the suit has been ???. Only one of the plaintiffs, namely, ??? Singh has appealed.

    2. It is urged on behalf of the appellant that the learned Subordinate Judge has thrown the burden of proof on the plaintiffs wrongly inasmuch as he started with the proposition that as the plaintiffs want to oust the defendant, unless they show that the defendant is not the daughter's son of Ram Lochan Singh, they cannot succeed. It is further urged that the learned Subordinate Judge has wrongly rejected the deposition of Mt. Pato given in the previous mutation proceeding, although she was dead at the time of the civil suit. The finding based on the evidence is also challenged. It seems to us that the learned Judge has not thrown a heavier burden on the plaintiffs than that of requiring them to prove that they were the next heirs of the deceased Ram Lochan Singh. The mere fact that the plaintiffs were the nearest male collaterals would not in itself be sufficient to show that they were the next heirs. It was certainly incumbent on them to show that he had not left any nearer heirs like daughter or daughter's son, who would exclude the plaintiffs, even if they were the nearest male collaterals. The learned Judge however has not decided the case on a finding that the plaintiffs have failed to discharge the burden of proving this. He has recorded a categorical finding that the defendant is the daughter's son of Ram Lochan Singh and has a better title than the plaintiffs who were separate from him. The question of the burden of proof therefore is not of any great importance now. As regards the statement of Mt. Pato, the sister of Ram Lochan Singh, made by her in the mutation Court in the proceeding in which the plaintiffs and the defendant were parties, the learned Judge has considered it inadmissible inasmuch as the evidence was not given in a judicial proceeding because the mutation case is only an administrative proceeding and not a judicial proceeding.

    3. The learned Judge regarded the statement as evidence, but thought that inasmuch as the proceeding in the revenue Court was not a judicial proceeding, the statement was not admissible. He is quite right in holding that the statement is not admissible under Section 32 of the Evidence Act, because the statement was made after the dispute had been raised. But the learned Judge has overlooked the additional words which occur in Section 33 of the Evidence Act, which make the evidence given by a person in a judicial proceeding “or before any person authorised by law to take it” relevant. The question therefore was not only whether the proceeding before the revenue Court was a judicial proceeding but also whether the Collector was not a person authorised by law to take such evidence. No doubt it is the duty of the Collector to maintain annual registers, and in cases where there is no dispute, the entry of transfers in the Registers is an administrative Act. But where a dispute has arisen and the case has been referred to the Collector under S. 39(3), the proceeding is governed by the provisions of S. 40, which lays down that all disputes shall be “decided” on the basis of possession, and also provides that if in the course of his “enquiry” the Collector is unable to satisfy himself as to which party is in possession, then he is to ascertain by “summary enquiry” who is the person best entitled to the property and is to put such person in possession sub-S. (3) speaks of putting such person in possession as an “order as to possession passed under the section.” It seems to us that when the section speaks of a decision and directs that the Collector should make a summary enquiry and then pass an order as to who is the person entitled to possession, the proceeding before him is certainly before an officer who is authorised by law to take evidence.

    4. It cannot be suggested that the Collector can act on private information received from undisclosed sources behind the back of the parties and decide the case on such information. He must adopt the procedure laid down for a judicial enquiry and he must base his decision on evidence taken before him. To such a proceeding Section 193 of the Land Revenue Act, would be applicable and persons who are summoned to attend the Court have to state truth upon the subject respecting which they are examined and are called upon to make statements. We must therefore hold that even if the proceeding were not strictly speaking a judicial proceeding, the Collector is certainly a person authorised by law to take evidence, and that therefore Section 33 of the Evidence Act, is applicable to the statement of Mt. Pato made in the previous proceeding. But the evidence of Mt. Pato was rejected by the Revenue Courts themselves and has also been considered worthless by the learned Subordinate Judge. In her deposition she certainly made several conflicting statements which cannot be easily reconciled. She stated first that Ram Lochan Singh was her own brother and that she had no issue nor was any child born to him, although it was the plaintiffs' case that Mahendra Singh used to live in the same house with Ram Lochan Singh. She stated in cross-examination that she did not count the houses which were between the; houses of Ram Lochan Singh and Mahendra Singh. She also made a curious statement which, as translated, runs as follows:

    At this place Ram Lochan Singh used to allege himself as my brother. He was not my kinsman.

    5. She was either confused or has made a statement about matters which she did not know. The learned Subordinate Judge has regarded these discrepancies as very damaging.

    6. We think that her previous statement is not worthy of belief. The plaintiffs relied, on entries in a school register showing that one Shankar Dayal Singh, son of Bahadur Singh, was admitted in the village school of Karan Chhapra in March 1906, and that in October of that year his name was struck off on account of non-payment of fee and continued absence from the school. On the evidence of two school teachers it is argued that there was already a school in village Lachhman Chapra where an uncle of Shankar Dayal Singh was admittedly married and where Shankar Dayal Singh might presumable have been residing temporarily as hit father was a resident of Adar, a village 20 miles distant from this place. It is then argued that the boy would have been admitted in the school of village Lachhman Chhapra and not in the village of Karan Chhapra. This circumstance is however not of any importance because according to the evidence of these teachers village Lachhman Chhapra is about a mile long and village ??? Chhapra is only four furlongs fronts ??? village. It might well be that the ??? of in which the boy was admitted ??? nearest school, or it might be late ??? guardian knew the head master ??? to send the boy to that sons. We are unable to draw any infer miss this circumstance. The next ??? on which great stress was laid was that the plaintiff Mahendra Singh was ??? to produce five documents: (1) a mortgage-deed of 1884; (2) a mortgage-deed of 1897; (3) a copy of a report of vasilbaqi navis; (4) a copy of an order of ??? Revenue Court and (5) another copy of an order sheet of a Revenue Court, which according to the plaintiffs were in come way connected with the deceased Ram Lochan Singh.

    7. The third and fourth documents might possibly not relate to any affair of Ram Lochan Singh as the name in the copies is ambiguously written and has been ready the translator as Ram Bakhsh Singh. But even assuming that these documents were obtained by Mahendra Singh from Ram Lochan Singh that fact would only show some connection between the two and would not necessarily have any bearing on the question whether the defendant is the daughter's son or not. Mahendra Singh has stated in his evidence that he obtained these documents during the life-time of Ram Lochan Singh. The plaintiffs' lase rests exclusively on the oral evidence which was produced by them and which has been disbelieved by the learned Sub-ordinate Judge who heard that evidence. (The judgment then discussed the plaintiff's evidence and proceeded). Now all these witnesses were seen and heard by the learned Subordinate Judge and they did not at all impress him. (The judgment then discussed the defendant's evidence and proceeded). The evidence of these witnesses was specific and direct. The plaintiffs' evidence merely at best would come to this; that their witnesses did not know the existence of the daughter of Ram Lochan Singh who must have been married some time towards the close of the last century and might have been living mostly with her husband, whereas the defendant's witnesses depose that they actually saw the daughter and the daughter's son living with Ram Lochan Singh. In a case of this kind when there is a simple question of fact involved we cannot differ from the view taken by the learned Subordinate Judge who heard and saw the witnesses unless there is something to show that he has not weighed the evidence fairly and properly. We must accept the finding of the learned Subordinate Judge that it is established that the defendant Shankar Dayal is the son of Mt. Murti who was the daughter of the deceased Ram Lochan Singh and that accordingly he has a preferential right to succeed. The appeal is dismissed with costs.

    S.R/R.K

    8. Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mahendra Singh v. Shankar Dayal Singh
    (Oct 1, 1935)