AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges

    Sowcar Lodd Govindoss And Another v. Arumuga Mudali (Died) And Others S

    JUDGMENT

    This Second Appeal arises from a suit for damages for malicious prosecution. The case for the plaintiff is that the 1st defendant owned certain lands attached to Nove-lock Bhagayet near Thengal village, that the 1st defendant authorised the 2nd defendant to institute a criminal complaint and the 2nd defendant filed the complaint, C.C No. 548 of 1926, on the file of the Wallajah Sub-Magistrate's Court against the plaintiff and others charging them with offences under Ss. 147 and 430 of the Indian Penal Code alleging that on or about 11th November 1926 forty people, including the plaintiff (who was at that time supposed to be acting on behalf of Kalyani Ammal) ryots of Thengal village, gathered together and prevented the men of the 1st defendant from taking water in the Thengal Kasam which they are entitled to do, by removing or attempting to remove a dam which was put up by the men of the 1st defendant, that complaint was thrown out as false, that the 1st defendant was the real prosecutor in the case, and the 2nd defendant filed the complaint only on behalf of the 1st defendant, that the complaint was a malicious one and that therefore the plaintiff is entitled to damages for malicious prosecution. The main defence on behalf of the 1st defendant is that he was entitled to take water from the Thengal Kasam, that he acted on the information given by the 2nd defendant as his agent which he had no reason to disbelieve, that there was in fact an unlawful obstruction by the plaintiff and other ryots, and therefore he had reasonable and probable cause in instituting the complaint, that he was therefore not actuated by malice, and that there is no cause of action against him. The case for the 2nd defendant is that the plaintiff's men did really cause obstruction which was unlawful. The learned District Munsif of Ranipet dismissed the plaintiff's suit on the ground that there was reasonable and probable cause in instituting the complaint, that there was an unlawful obstruction by the plaintiff and other ryots, and that, in any event, the 1st defendant acted on the information of the 2nd defendant whom he believed. The learned Subordinate Judge reversed this decision on the ground that the 1st defendant was not entitled to take Thengal Kasam water for his lands in Novelock Bhagayet. He further found that many of the statements made by the 2nd defendant in his deposition regarding the plaintiff were false, and that his object in instigating the 1st defendant to file the criminal complaint was to satisfy his spite towards the plaintiff, that in any event the 1st defendant cannot take shelter under the action of the 2nd defendant, that he should have made proper enquiries before instituting the complaint, and therefore he must be held to have had no reasonable or probable cause in launching the prosecution. Having heard the learned counsel on both sides, I am not inclined to disturb the finding against the 2nd defendant but it seems to me that the decision so far as the 1st defendant is concerned cannot be sustained. The facts in this case which have been found to be undisputed are these; that forty people of Thengal village including the plaintiff assembled on 11th November 1926, and that obstruction was caused to the taking of water by those people, and the water was being taken to Novelock Bhagayet for a long time before the attempted obstruction. I may also observe that after the criminal complaint the 1st defendant did institute a civil suit to have his right established in consequence of the objection raised by the villagers of Thengal village, and that in that civil suit there has been a final adjudication that the 1st defendant is entitled to take water from the Thengal Kasam for his lands in Novelock village. Mr. Thiagaraja Iyer has asked me to admit the judgment in the civil suit in evidence because the question of title has been raised by the plaintiff and the learned Subordinate Judge found that the 1st defendant had no right to take water and therefore he could not have had any reasonable belief in his own right and therefore there can be no reasonable or probable cause in authorising the 2nd defendant to launch the prosecution. Mr. A.K Muthuswami Iyer contends that I ought not to admit the judgment in Second Appeal. The plaintiff had disputed the title of the 1st defendant and stated that the title was in the villagers of Thengal village and Kalyani Ammal whom he represented at the time of the criminal complaint. Therefore, the plaintiff, as a part of his case, has to prove that the 1st defendant at no time had any right to take the water. There having been now a final adjudication in regard to title, the said judgments are admissible in evidence in proof of the title of the villagers of Thengal which the plaintiff has made as part of his case. It is not necessary to cite any authority for the position that such evidence can be admitted in a Second Appeal or in a Civil Revision Petition. The main question therefore is; has the 1st defendant no reasonable and probable cause in instituting this complaint? It lies upon the plaintiff to allege and prove affirmatively that the 1st defendant had no reasonable and probable cause in having the complaint instituted. He must establish facts which are inconsistent with the existence of such reasonable and probable cause. And where a person acts on the information of another, the question is; did he believe in the information? Was the information credible and would a prudent man have acted on such information? And were there reasonable grounds for believing in such information? In Lister v. Perryman Lord Chancellor Hatherly observed thus:

    “What is now to be decided is this: how far this gentleman, having this information conveyed to him, may be said to have reasonably and discreetly trusted his informant. Because, I apprehend that you are to have regard to every shade of difference between the amount of credit to be given to one person and to another according to the character of the informant. Information given by one person of whom the party knows nothing, would be regarded very differently from information given by one whom he knows to be a sensible and trustworthy person. And the question whether or not a reasonable man would or would not act upon the information must depend in a great degree upon the opinion to be formed of the position and circumstances of the informant, and of the amount of credit which may be due under those circumstances to the person who thus conveyed the information.”

    Applying this principle to this case, the person who gave the information was the 2nd defendant, the admitted agent of the 1st defendant who was managing his affairs at Novelock. It has not been proved that there were no materials on which it could be said that the 1st defendant was not justified in acting on that information or that the 2nd defendant was not a credible informant. What was the information given by him? It was that 40 people gathered together and attempted to remove a dam and thus caused obstruction. These facts have been found to be true by both the lower Courts. Under such circumstances could it be said that no credible information was given to the 1st defendant on which the 1st defendant could not have acted. It must therefore be taken that the plaintiff had failed to prove want of reasonable and probable cause. I therefore set aside the findings against the 1st defendant and dismiss the suit as against him, but in the circumstances, I direct that so far as the 1st defendant is concerned each party will bear his own costs throughout. So far as the 2nd defendant is concerned the Second Appeal is dismissed with costs.

    Decree accordingly.

    N.R.R

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sowcar Lodd Govindoss And Another v. Arumuga Mudali (Died) And Others S
    (Feb 11, 1937)