Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions contained in Order 41 Rule 31 of CPC. These provisions
  • provisions contained in Order 41 Rule 31 of CPC,
  • provisions of Order 41 Rule 31 of CPC.9.
  • Order 41 Rule 31 of the Code.
  • Indian Contract Act, 1972.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions contained in Order 41 Rule 31 of CPC. These provisions
  • provisions contained in Order 41 Rule 31 of CPC,
  • provisions of Order 41 Rule 31 of CPC.9.
  • Order 41 Rule 31 of the Code.
  • Indian Contract Act, 1972.
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion Delivered by Dilip B. Bhosale, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This second appeal under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) is directed against the concurrent judgments of the courts below whereby a suit bearing O.S. No. 236/94 filed by the respondents-plaintiffs was allowed. The plaintiffs' suit sought a declaration that they are owners in possession of the suit properties and an injunction restraining the appellant-defendant from interfering with their possession.

Relevant factual assertions contained in the record are:

  • The plaintiffs are husband and wife who alleged that they were unable to look after and cultivate their agricultural land (the suit property) and requested the defendant to manage it.
  • The plaintiffs allege that the defendant took the first plaintiff to the Tahsildar's Office under the pretext of executing a power of attorney, and under that pretext obtained the first plaintiff's signatures on a sale deed dated 18.01.1993, thereby practicing fraud on him. On the basis of that sale deed the defendant began claiming rights and obstructing the plaintiffs' possession.
  • The defendant claimed that he had purchased the suit property under a registered sale deed dated 18.01.1993 and had been in possession since then as owner.

Procedurally, at the stage of admission of this second appeal, two substantial questions of law were formulated and the appeal challenges the concurrent findings in favour of the plaintiffs. The High Court examined the judgment of the First Appellate Court and directed that the first appeal be decided afresh after remand.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Courts below are justified in not framing proper issues when the suit filed by the plaintiff sought cancellation of sale deed dated 18.1.93 executed by him on the ground that the same is obtained by playing fraud on him?
  2. Whether appreciation of evidence by the Courts below is just and proper?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (as presented by Sri Nagabhushana, Learned Counsel for the appellant)

  • Contended that a mere statement such as “Whether the judgment of the Trial Court requires consideration?” as a point for determination by the Appellate Court is inadequate. He relied on the High Court of Bombay judgment in Anitha v. Abdul Wahid to support this submission.
  • Argued that as a result of framing such a general point for determination, the Appellate Court misdirected itself and/or failed to consider the real points/issues involved in the appeal, and that the first appellate court's judgment therefore erred in law.
  • Pointed out that the First Appellate Court failed to frame and decide appropriate points for consideration arising from the pleadings and evidence, resulting in misapplication of law and fact.

Plaintiffs' Contentions (as pleaded in the suit)

  • The plaintiffs claimed ownership and possession of the suit property and sought declaration and injunction.
  • The plaintiffs alleged that the sale deed dated 18.01.1993 was obtained by the defendant by practicing fraud and misrepresentation, and therefore sought cancellation of that sale deed.

Defendant's Contentions (as stated in the record)

  • The defendant claimed that he had purchased the suit property under a registered sale deed dated 18.01.1993 and since then he was in possession thereof as owner.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Anitha v. Abdul Wahid, AIR 1985 Bombay 98 Cited for the proposition that points for determination in the First Appellate Court must cover all important questions involved in the case and must not be general or vague; that stating a single general question like whether the trial court's decision is liable to be set aside is inadequate; and for interpretation of Order 41 Rule 31 CPC in this context. The Court relied on this authority to criticize the First Appellate Court's formulation of a single, general point (“Whether the judgment of the Trial Court requires interference?”) and to support the conclusion that appellate courts must frame and decide specific points arising from pleadings and evidence.
H. Siddiqui (Dead) By Lrs. v. A. Ramalingam, 2011 2 KCCR 1389 SC Cited for the guidance that Order 41 Rule 31 CPC requires the Appellate Court to independently assess evidence, state points for determination, and show that it has applied its mind to the facts and evidence; that the First Appellate Court must give reasons for its decision on each point independently to that of the Trial Court. The Court applied the statements in this Supreme Court decision to emphasize the mandatory nature of independent assessment by the Appellate Court and to require that the First Appellate Court's judgment should demonstrate proper appreciation of evidence and application of mind to each relevant point.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the judgment of the First Appellate Court in the light of the statutory requirement in Order 41 Rule 31 of the Code of Civil Procedure (as explained in the cited precedents). The analytical steps taken by the Court were as follows:

  1. The Court reviewed authoritative guidance (Anitha v. Abdul Wahid and H. Siddiqui) on the scope and purpose of Order 41 Rule 31 CPC, stressing that the First Appellate Court must frame specific points for determination and must independently assess the evidence on those points.
  2. The Court compared the issues framed by the Trial Court (12 issues, including title, acquisition under the 18.01.1993 sale deed, possession, obstruction, reliefs, and specific additional issues about fraud and cancellation) with the single point framed by the First Appellate Court: “Whether the judgment of the Trial Court requires interference?”.
  3. The Court observed that the First Appellate Court did not consider all relevant points in the manner required. Specifically, the First Appellate Court held that the defendants obtained the sale deed by undue influence whereas the plaintiffs' case was founded on fraud and misrepresentation — different legal concepts with distinct meanings under the Indian Contract Act, 1972 (as cited in the judgment).
  4. The Court found that the Appellate Court (a) misconstrued the pleaded case by addressing undue influence instead of fraud/misrepresentation, (b) considered issues that were not raised by the parties (e.g., whether the sale deed was supported by consideration and whether the defendant was financially capable to pay the consideration), and (c) failed to address essential reliefs actually claimed (possession and injunction).
  5. On these findings, the Court concluded that the First Appellate Court's failure to frame and decide the relevant points properly led to an erroneous approach to the appeal and demonstrated inadequate compliance with the requirements of Order 41 Rule 31 CPC.
  6. Accordingly, the Court set aside the judgment and order of the First Appellate Court dated 8.6.2005 and remitted the appeal (No.108/2004) to the First Appellate Court for fresh consideration in accordance with law, giving directions about expeditious disposal and sending of records.

The Court also observed that if an Appellate Court's judgment demonstrates that it considered and discussed in detail the facts and evidence and dealt with all points for consideration, then mere defects in formulation of points may not by themselves justify setting aside the judgment. However, in the present case the requisite independent assessment and point‑wise reasoning were not evident.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The judgment and order dated 8.6.2005 passed by the lower Appellate Court is set aside and the appeal bearing No. 108/2004 is restored to file and remitted to the First Appellate Court for its fresh consideration in accordance with law.

Direct consequences and directions ordered by the Court:

  • The First Appellate Court is directed to decide the appeal afresh in the light of the observations made in this judgment and preferably within six months from the date of receipt of the record and proceedings along with a copy of this judgment.
  • The Registry is directed to send the records to the First Appellate Court and a copy of this judgment forthwith.
  • An interim order passed by this Court on 21.9.2007 shall remain operative till disposal of the appeal.
  • Refund of court fee, if any, as per rules.

The opinion does not state that it establishes a new precedent beyond applying and re-affirming the settled principles regarding the duties of an Appellate Court under Order 41 Rule 31 CPC. The immediate legal effect is the remand and requirement of a fresh, reasoned appellate decision addressing the properly framed points arising from pleadings and evidence.

    Bangarappa v. Rudrappa And Another

    2.2011 (2) KCCR 1389 (H. Siddiqui (Dead) By Lrs. v. A. Ramalingam., Advocate for Appellant R2(a) Served

    The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

    Dilip B. Bhosale, J.:— This second appeal under Section 100 of the CPC is directed against the concurrent judgments of the Courts below whereby a suit bearing O.S No. 236/94 filed by the respondents-plaintiffs, hereinafter referred to as the plaintiffs, stands allowed. The suit was instituted for declaration that the plaintiffs are owners in possession of the suit properties and for injunction restraining the appellant-defendant, hereinafter referred to as the defendant, from interfering with their possession over the suit property.

    2. The facts that are relevant for deciding this appeal are as under:

    The plaintiffs are husband and wife. The defendant claims that he had purchased the suit property, under registered sale deed dated. 18.01.1993 and since then he is in possession thereof as owner.

    It is the case of the plaintiffs that they were not in a position to look after and cultivate their agricultural land i.e, the suit property and hence they had requested the defendant to help them out for managing the same. After the defendant started looking after the suit property, he allegedly took the first plaintiff to the Tahsildar's Office under the pretext that he needs to execute a power of attorney in his (defendant's) favour and under that pretext obtained his (plaintiff No. 1's) signatures on the sale deed dated 18.1.93, and thereby practiced fraud on him. The defendant on the basis of the sale deed, started claiming right in the suit property and obstructing the plaintiffs' possession.

    3. At the stage of admission of the appeal, the following substantial questions of law were formulated for consideration:

    1. Whether Courts below are justified in not framing proper issues when the suit filed by the plaintiff for cancellation of sale deed dated 18.1.93 executed by him on the ground that the same is obtained by playing fraud on him?

    2. Whether appreciation of evidence by the Courts below is just and proper?

    4. Sri Nagabhushana, Learned Counsel for the appellant, at the outset, invited my attention to the judgment of the High Court of Bombay in Anitha v. Abdul Wahid . AIR 1985 BOMBAY 98, to contend that mere statement as to “Whether the judgment of the Trial Court requires consideration?” as a point for determination by the Appellate Court is inadequate. He further submitted, as a result of framing of such a point for determination, the Court of appeal mis-directed itself and/or failed to consider the real points/issues involved in the appeal for determination. In support of his contentions, he took me through the judgments of the Courts below, more particularly, the judgment of the Court of first appeal and submitted that the Appellate Court mis-directed itself while deciding the first appeal, merely because no proper points for determination were framed.

    5. In Anitha's Case, the situation was somewhat similar. The Court of first appeal in that case had formulated the following point for consideration “Whether the judgment and decree of the Trial Court is liable to be set-aside?”

    The Learned Judge in that (Anitha's) case, after considering the provisions contained in Order 41 Rule 31 of CPC, held thus:

    17. The points which must arise for determination by a Court of first appeal must cover all important questions involved in the case and they should not be general and vague. It is a matter of almost text book knowledge that the exact questions which arise in the appeal and require determination must be stated in the judgment, “It is not sufficient to state the point to be determined in appeal whether or not the decision is consistent with the merits of the case.” “The point so stated is hardly a point for determination as contemplated in Order 41 Rule 31 of the Code.” The Learned Judges of the Courts of first appeal should not approach the appeals merely from the point of speedily disposing of the same. The appeals must be also intelligently disposed of after taking note of the arguments advanced, the points arising from the arguments and other material and then deciding those points properly. A failure to understand the object of the provision such as O. 41, R. 31(a) of the Code has demonstrably resulted in the instant case in the failure of justice at the hands of the lower Appellate Court.

    (emphasis supplied)

    6. Similarly, the Supreme Court in H. Siddiqui (Dead) By Lrs. v. A. Ramalingam. . 2011 2 KCCR 1389 SC, had occasion to consider the provisions contained in Order 41 Rule 31 of CPC. In that case, the Supreme Court observed that the said provisions provide guidelines for the Appellate Court as to how Court has to proceed and decide the appeal. It is further observed that the provision should be read in such a way as to require that the various particulars mentioned therein should be taken into consideration. It must be evident from the judgment of the Appellate Court that the Court has properly appreciated the facts/evidence, applied its mind and decided the case considering the material on record. In paragraph 18 of the Judgment, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, after considering its several judgments, observed thus:

    “It is mandatory for the Appellate Court to independently assess the evidence of the parties and consider the relevant points which arise for adjudication and the bearing of the evidence on those points. Being the Final Court of fact, the First Appellate Court must not record mere general expression of concurrence with the Trial Court judgment rather it must give reasons for its decision on each point independently to that of the Trial Court. Thus, the entire evidence must be considered and discussed in detail. Such exercise should be done after formulating the points for consideration in terms of the said provisions and the Court must proceed in adherence to the requirements of the said statutory provisions”.

    (emphasis supplied)

    7. Appeal Court, while considering and deciding a first appeal should realise that it has to be decided strictly in adherence with the provisions contained in Order 41 Rule 31 of CPC. These provisions deal with judgment of the Appeal Court and it says amongst other things that the judgment shall state the points for determination. When a requirement such as this is insisted upon by the procedural law, one must try to understand the object and scope of this provision. The Appeal Court, at the first instance is expected to re-appreciate/re-assess the evidence and apply its mind to the facts of the case in the light of the arguments advanced by Learned Counsel for the parties. It must be evident from the Judgment of the First Appellate Court that it has properly appreciated the facts/evidence, applied its mind and decided the case considering the material on record. Unless the Appellate Court's judgment is based on independent assessment of the relevant evidence on all points, it would not amount to substantial compliance of these provisions (O. 41 R-31 of CPC). It is, therefore, necessary for the Appellate Court to frame the points for determination and examine the same independently in the light of the facts/evidence led by the parties. Merely asking the question as to whether the judgment of the Court below is correct or legal or valid is hopelessly an inadequate method of meeting the requirement of this legal provision.

    8. The first appeal is a valuable right of the parties. The whole case in the first appeal is open for re-hearing, both on questions of fact and law. The Appellate Court has jurisdiction to reverse or re-affirm the findings of the Trial Court. It is, therefore, mandatory for the Appellate Court to independently assess the evidence of the parties and consider the relevant points which arise for adjudication andbearing of the evidence on those points. Being the Final Court of fact, the First Appellate Court must not record mere general expression of concurrence with the Trial Court judgment, and it must give reasons for its decision on each point independently to that of the Trial Court. Thus, the entire evidence must be considered and discussed in detail and such exercise should be done after formulating the points for consideration in terms of the provisions of Order 41 Rule 31 of CPC.

    9. It would be necessary, at this stage, to observe that from perusal of the judgement if it is clear/apparent or it could be demonstrated that the Appellate Court considered and discussed in detail, the facts and evidence, after application of mind and dealt with all the points for consideration, in such case, merely because points were not formulated properly, cannot be a ground for setting-aside the judgment, though it is necessary/desirable for the Courts of first appeal to formulate properly the points for consideration in the suit.

    10. During past one week, I have come across few judgments where the Appellate Courts framed similar points for determination, such as the one in the present case. This trend of formulating the point for decision is becoming routine. The question before the Courts of appeal is not only whether the judgment of the Court of below was liable to be set-aside or requires consideration or is valid. The First Appellate Court requires to frame all the points that arise on the basis of the arguments advanced by the parties in the appeal. As observed earlier, Courts of first appeal must cover all important questions involved in the case and they should not be general and vague. The exact question, which arises in the appeal and requires determination must be stated in the judgment.

    11. Keeping in view, the well settled position of law, I have examined the judgment of the First Appellate Court. The Trial Court had framed as many as 12 issues, out of which, I deem it proper to reproduce the relevant issues to understand whether the Appellate Court in fact misdirected itself while deciding the appeal.

    i) Whether the plaintiff prove their title to the suit lands?

    ii) Whether the defendant proves that he has acquired the suit properties under registered sale deed dated 18.01.1993 executed by first plaintiff?

    iii) Whether the plaintiffs prove their lawful possession over suit lands on the date of suit?

    iv) Whether the plaintiffs prove the interference and obstruction by defendant to their possession and enjoyment of suit lands?

    v) Whether plaintiffs are entitled for the relief of declaration and injunction as prayed?

    Additional Issues:

    vi) Whether the plaintiff proves that the sale deed dated: 18.01.1993 is obtained by playing fraud on him by defendant and by mis-representation and coercion?

    vii) Whether the plaintiff is entitled for the relief of cancellation of the sale deed dated 18.01.1993?

    12. The Lower Appellate Court, however, framed the following point for determination:

    “Whether the judgment of the Trial Court requires interference?”

    13. In my opinion, the Appellate Court did not consider all the points involved in the case in the manner in which it ought to have. For instance, the Appellate Court holds that the defendants got the sale deed executed by undue influence. As a matter of fact that was not the case set-up by the plaintiffs. The case set up by the plaintiffs was that the sale deed was obtained by the defendants by practicing fraud and mis-representation. The Learned Judge overlooked the definitions of the expressions “undue influence”, “fraud” and “mis-representation” as defined in the Indian Contract Act, 1972. From perusal of the definitions, of these expressions, it is clear that they have different connotations/meaning. The Appellate Court, in my opinion, committed such error of fact and law only because it did not frame proper points for determination on the basis of the pleadings/evidence and the arguments advanced by Learned Counsel for the parties. Further, the Appellate Court, considered the issues/points, which were not even raised and/or framed by the Trial Court. For instance, whether the sale deed was supported by consideration and that it was obtained by undue influence. There were not the issues raised in the suit. The Appellate Court, proceeded to consider whether the defendant was financially capable to pay the consideration to the plaintiff, which was not the point/issue involved in the suit. It was not a suit for specific performance of an agreement. Further, the First Appellate Court even did not address on the point of possession and injunction in the judgment and that all happened only because it failed to frame proper points for determination. In the circumstances, this appeal deserves to be allowed. Hence, I pass the following order:

    The judgment and order dated 8.6.2005 passed by the lower Appellate Court is set-aside and the appeal bearing No. 108/2004 is restored to file and remitted to the First Appellate Court for its consideration afresh in accordance with law.

    The Appellate Court, in the light of observations made in this judgment, shall decide the appeal as expeditiously as possible and preferably within a period of six months from the date of receipt of the record and proceedings along with copy of this judgment.

    Registry is directed to send the records to the First Appellate Court and copy of this judgment forthwith.

    Interim order passed by this Court on 21.9.2007 shall remain operative till disposal of the appeal.

    Refund of Court Fee, if any, as per the rules.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bangarappa v. Rudrappa And Another
    (Jan 13, 2012)