Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 14(18) of the CCS(CCA) Rules 1965.21. Provisions analogous to Rule 14(18) of CCS(CCA) Rule exist in Rule 9(21) of Railway Servant (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1958.
  • provisions of Article 320 (3)(c) of the Constitution of India
  • Rule 9(21) of Railway Servant (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1958
  • provisions of Rule 320 (3)(c) of the Constitution of India
  • Sub-rule (18) of Rule 14 of the CCS (CCA) Rules.
  • ARTICLE 226 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Rule 14 sub Rule 18 of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965
  • ARTICLE 141 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Rule 14(18) of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965
  • Rule 32 in Part-IX of CCS Rules,
  • Rule 11 of CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965
  • Rule 14(18) of CCS(CCA) Rules
  • Rule 14(18) OF THE Rules
  • Rule 14(18)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 14(18) of the CCS(CCA) Rules 1965.21. Provisions analogous to Rule 14(18) of CCS(CCA) Rule exist in Rule 9(21) of Railway Servant (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1958.
  • provisions of Article 320 (3)(c) of the Constitution of India
  • Rule 9(21) of Railway Servant (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1958
  • provisions of Rule 320 (3)(c) of the Constitution of India
  • Sub-rule (18) of Rule 14 of the CCS (CCA) Rules.
  • ARTICLE 226 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Rule 14 sub Rule 18 of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965
  • ARTICLE 141 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Rule 14(18) of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965
  • Rule 32 in Part-IX of CCS Rules,
  • Rule 11 of CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965
  • Rule 14(18) of CCS(CCA) Rules
  • Rule 14(18) OF THE Rules
  • Rule 14(18)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent was appointed as a Junior Engineer on 9 June 1989 and later promoted to Assistant Engineer (Electrical). On 9 July 1996, a memorandum of charges was served alleging (inter alia) that the respondent accepted an alternator of lesser frame size, falsely recommended passing of a running account bill of M/s. Escorts Ltd., and failed to initiate testing of the alternator. The respondent denied the charges.

An inquiry was conducted by an enquiry officer (Sh. Onkarmal Kedia, Commissioner for Departmental Inquiries, CVC). The respondent did not examine himself as a witness. The record shows that — according to the respondent — the evidence adduced against him was not put to him in compliance with Rule 14(18) of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965. The enquiry officer submitted a report dated 26 May 1998. The disciplinary authority imposed a penalty of withholding two increments for two years with cumulative effect. The respondent sought copies of CVC/UPSC advice that were consulted; he alleged those copies were not supplied.

The respondent appealed, and ultimately filed O.A. No. 2759/2005 before the Central Administrative Tribunal (Principal Bench). The Tribunal allowed the original application, set aside the major punishment dated 28 August 2002, and held that the respondent was entitled to consequential benefits. The Union of India (petitioners) challenged the Tribunal's order by filing the present writ petition under Article 226.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the enquiry was vitiated by non-compliance with Rule 14(18) of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 (i.e., whether the enquiry officer was required to put to the charged officer the circumstances appearing against him in the evidence when the charged officer did not examine himself).
  2. Whether non-supply of CVC second-stage advice (and/or UPSC recommendations) to the charged officer prejudiced the officer and vitiated the disciplinary proceedings, and if so, whether such non-supply must be shown to have caused de facto prejudice.
  3. Whether the penalty of withholding two increments for two years with cumulative effect was valid, in light of rules regarding increments and relevant tribunal decisions.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' (Union of India) Arguments

  • The petitioners argued that Rule 14(18) of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 had been complied with because three questions were put to the respondent during his general examination on 6 April 1998.
  • As regards non-supply of CVC/UPSC advice, the petitioners relied on Union of India v. Alok Kumar (2010) and Union of India v. T.V. Patel (2007), contending that consultation with CVC/UPSC is not necessarily a mandatory procedural requirement that vitiates proceedings unless it is shown that the advice influenced the disciplinary authority or caused prejudice to the delinquent officer.
  • The petitioners asserted that the UPSC advice, if furnished, was not shown to have been taken into consideration by the disciplinary authority; therefore, absence of the copy did not cause prejudice.
  • Regarding appointment of the presenting officer (Sh. A.J.S. Uppal), the petitioners contended it was made according to rules and did not cause bias; the duty of the presenting officer was only to present the department's case.
  • On preliminary inquiry material (e.g., report by V.B. Gupta), the petitioners asserted the enquiry officer's report did not rely on that preliminary enquiry, and therefore no prejudice arose from non-supply of that report.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The respondent contended the enquiry officer failed to comply with mandatory Rule 14(18) by not putting the evidence adduced at the enquiry to the charged officer (since he did not examine himself), but only repeating the articles of charge.
  • He argued the non-supply of CVC second-stage advice (and lack of supply of UPSC recommendations) deprived him of an opportunity to show cause and therefore vitiated the inquiry, relying on State Bank of India v. D.C. Aggarwal and Ministry of Finance v. S.B. Ramesh.
  • The respondent objected to reliance upon material (such as V.B. Gupta's report) not supplied to him, and to the appointment of the presenting officer who he alleged was involved in the underlying events, thereby causing prejudice.
  • On penalty, the respondent maintained that rules permit withholding only one increment in a year and that withholding two increments in the manner ordered was improper.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State Bank of India v. D.C. Aggarwal, (1993) 1 SCC 13 It obliges the department to serve a copy of CVC report along with the enquiry officer's report to the charged officer; non-supply can deprive the charged officer of reasonable opportunity (principles of natural justice). The Tribunal relied on this case to hold non-supply of CVC advice prejudiced the charged officer. The High Court noted the Tribunal's reliance and considered whether the Tribunal had shown that the CVC recommendations were actually taken into account by the disciplinary authority.
Ministry of Finance v. S.B. Ramesh, (1998) 3 SCC 227 (also cited as SLJ 1998 Vol. II) Held Rule 14(18) of CCS (CCA) Rules to be mandatory; failure by enquiry officer to put evidence to charged officer vitiates enquiry in absence of defence statement. The Court treated S.B. Ramesh as authority that Rule 14(18) is mandatory and used it to support the Tribunal's conclusion that non-compliance of Rule 14(18) vitiated the enquiry.
Charanjit Singh Khurana v. Union of India (OA-1826/98 decided 14.9.2002) Consideration of Rule 14(18) as mandatory and its role in ensuring reasonable opportunity in disciplinary proceedings. The Tribunal and the Court referenced this decision (as considered by the Apex Court in related contexts) to support the mandatory nature of Rule 14(18) and the requirement to put incriminating evidence to the charged officer.
Union of India v. Alok Kumar, (2010) 5 SCC 349 Non-supply of CVC advice (first/second stage) vitiates proceedings only if it is established that the advice was considered and caused prejudice; consultation with CVC is not necessarily mandatory; prejudice must be shown. The petitioners relied on Alok Kumar to argue that the Tribunal erred in quashing the enquiry without demonstrating de facto prejudice. The Court examined Alok Kumar and concluded the Tribunal should have considered whether CVC notes influenced the disciplinary authority and whether de facto prejudice was shown.
Union of India v. T.V. Patel, (2007) 4 SCC 785 Consultation with UPSC under Article 320(3)(c) is not mandatory and does not confer rights on a public servant; absence or irregularity in consultation does not necessarily give cause of action. The petitioners relied on T.V. Patel to argue that UPSC consultation and furnishing of commission advice are not mandatory preconditions that vitiate proceedings. The Court noted the case while assessing petitioners' contention regarding UPSC advice.
Harish Kumar v. Union of India (OA-256/2002, Jodhpur Bench, decided 5.2.2004) Addressed validity of withholding two increments; held that withholding two increments in a year is not sustainable because increments accrue one at a time. The Tribunal invoked this decision when considering the propriety of the specific penalty of withholding two increments cumulatively; the Court noted this usage in the Tribunal's reasoning on penalty.
Moni Shankar v. Union of India, 2008 (1) AJW 479 Analogy to rule 9(21) of Railway Servant (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1958: questions asking only generic matters (e.g., guilty plea, satisfaction with enquiry) do not comply with duty to put evidence to charged officer. The Court referenced Moni Shankar by analogy to illustrate that asking only generic questions does not satisfy statutory obligations to put incriminating evidence to the charged officer.
State Of U.P. v. Manbodhan Lal Srivastava, AIR 1957 SC 192 Constitution Bench authority relied upon in T.V. Patel concerning non-mandatoriness of Article 320(3)(c) rights. The Court noted that T.V. Patel relied on Srivastava to hold that Article 320(3)(c) does not confer rights on public servants; the present Court considered this in assessing petitioners' argument on UPSC consultation.
State of A.P. v. Dr. Rahimuddin Kamal, 1997 (3) SCC 505 and Deokinandan Prasad v. State of Bihar, 1971 (2) SCC 330 Referenced in Alok Kumar as authorities on whether absence of consultation or advice will vitiate proceedings. The Court observed that Alok Kumar relied on these cases in holding that absence of consultation or nondisclosure does not automatically vitiate departmental proceedings unless prejudice is shown.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the record, the Tribunal's findings, and the authorities relied upon by both parties. The Court's analysis proceeded in two principal strands: (A) the effect of non-supply of CVC/UPSC advice and (B) compliance with Rule 14(18) of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965.

(A) Non-supply of CVC/UPSC advice

  • The Tribunal had relied on State Bank of India v. D.C. Aggarwal to hold that non-supply of the CVC second-stage advice along with the enquiry report deprived the charged officer of a reasonable opportunity and thus prejudiced him.
  • The petitioners relied on Alok Kumar and T.V. Patel to argue that consultation with CVC/UPSC is not mandatorily binding on the disciplinary authority, and that non-supply vitiates proceedings only if prejudice (de facto effect on the disciplinary decision) is demonstrated.
  • The Court held that the Tribunal should have examined whether any CVC notes/recommendations had a direct bearing on the enquiry and whether they were actually taken into consideration by the disciplinary authority. The Court observed that the respondent could not show how CVC recommendations influenced the disciplinary authority or caused prejudice.
  • Consequently, on the narrow point of non-supply of CVC recommendation, the Court concluded that the Tribunal erred in not addressing whether the notes actually affected the disciplinary authority's mind and whether de facto prejudice resulted.

(B) Compliance with Rule 14(18) of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965

  • The record admitted that the respondent did not examine himself as a witness. In such circumstances Rule 14(18) obliges the enquiry authority to question the delinquent officer on circumstances appearing against him in the evidence so as to enable him to explain such circumstances.
  • The Court reviewed the questions actually put by the enquiry officer and found them to be generic and to the effect of repeating articles of charge rather than putting the specific incriminating evidence or circumstances to the respondent.
  • The Court noted binding authority (Ministry of Finance v. S.B. Ramesh and related decisions) establishing that Rule 14(18) is mandatory and that non-compliance, in the absence of the charged officer's own defence statement, vitiates the enquiry.
  • Applying that principle to the present facts, the Court concluded that there was no valid compliance with Rule 14(18) because the evidence adduced was not put to the respondent and this failure deprived him of an effective opportunity of defence.

Balancing both strands, the Court concluded that although the Tribunal should have examined whether CVC notes influenced the disciplinary authority (and whether de facto prejudice was demonstrated), the admitted non-compliance of Rule 14(18) independently warranted quashing of the enquiry. The Court therefore declined to interfere with the Tribunal's order on that ground.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition filed by the Union of India was dismissed. The Court held that the Tribunal's order quashing the enquiry and setting aside the punishment was not illegal or unsustainable because of the mandatory non-compliance with Rule 14(18) of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965.

Core Ruling: The writ petition is dismissed; the Tribunal's order setting aside the punishment is upheld on the ground of non-compliance with Rule 14(18) of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The disciplinary penalty of withholding two increments for two years with cumulative effect, which had been imposed on the respondent, remains set aside pursuant to the Tribunal's order upheld by this Court.
  • On CVC/UPSC advice: The Court stressed that a Tribunal should examine whether any non-supplied CVC/UPSC advice was actually taken into consideration by the disciplinary authority and whether such non-supply caused de facto prejudice before quashing proceedings on that ground. In this case, the Court found insufficient demonstration of such prejudice by the petitioners, but still upheld the Tribunal's order on the mandatory Rule 14(18) ground.
  • No new general legal precedent was created by this decision; the Court applied and followed existing authorities (notably S.B. Ramesh and D.C. Aggarwal) to the facts before it.
  • Costs: The parties were directed to bear their own costs.

    Union Of India Through Secretary, Ministry Of Information And Broadcasting & Anr. Petitioners v. Tarlok Singh

    ANIL KUMAR, J.

    1. The petitioners Union of India through the Secretary, Ministry of Information and Broadcasting and Anr. have challenged the order dated 12th March, 2007 passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal, Principal Bench in O.A No. 2759/2005 titled as ‘Sh. Tarlok Singh v. Union of India’ allowing the original application of the respondent and setting aside the order dated 28 August, 2002 of major punishment imposed upon the respondent and holding that consequent to setting aside of major punishment the respondent shall be entitled for all consequential benefits.

    2. The brief facts to comprehend the disputes between the parties are that the respondent was appointed as JE on 9 June, 1989 and was subsequently promoted as AE (Electrical). On 9 July, 1996 a memorandum of chargesheet was served on the respondent alleging that he had accepted an alternator of lesser frame size and had falsely recommended passing of the first running account bill of M/s. Escorts Ltd. Allegations were also made that he did not initiate action for testing the alternator. The articles of charges made against the respondent were denied by him. An enquiry officer, Sh. Onkarmal Kedia, Commissioner for Departmental Inquiries, CVC was appointed to enquire into the charges framed against the respondent. Though an enquiry was conducted in which the respondent did not examine himself as witness, however, in compliance with Rule 14(18) of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 the evidence against the respondent was not put to him. The allegation was also made by the respondent that the enquiry officers conducted the enquiry proceedings in violation of the principles of natural justice.

    3. The enquiry officer gave a report dated 26 May, 1998 and a copy of the enquiry report was also given to the respondent. The respondent submitted a representation dated 6 May, 1999 categorically contending that the enquiry was not conducted in compliance with the principles of natural justice; that the enquiry officer has not put the evidence which was against the respondent in compliance with Rule 14(18) of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 and also that the disciplinary authority, without properly considering the representation and without dealing with the pleas and contentions raised by the respondent imposed a penalty of withholding of two increments for a period of two years with cumulative effect.

    4. The respondent also came to know that the UPSC was consulted regarding the punishment to be imposed, however, copy of the opinion of UPSC was not given to the respondent, which was mandatory. The respondent, therefore, filed an appeal on 17 March, 2003 which was converted into a revision petition, however, the reviewing authority rejected the same by order dated 30 November, 2005. Aggrieved by the order, the respondent filed an original application being O.A No. 2759/2005 before the Central Administrative Tribunal, Principal Bench on the grounds inter-alia that the enquiry officer did not put the evidence adduced against him during the enquiry in compliance of Rule 14 sub Rule 18 of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 which contemplates that the enquiry authority, after Government servant closes his case, and if the employee has not examined himself, shall generally question him on the circumstances appearing against him in the evidence, for the purpose of enabling the employee to explain any circumstances appearing in the evidence against him. The respondent also challenged the appointment of Sh. O. Kedia, Commissioner for departmental enquiry, CVC, who conducted the enquiry against the respondent, on the ground that he was also directed to hold the enquiry in case of Sh. D.S Manchanda and Sh. Lalit Kumar against whom similar chargesheet had already been issued.

    5. The respondent contended that after examining the prosecution witness since there was no defence witness, the enquiry officer ought to have put the evidence adduced during the enquiry against the respondent in compliance of Rule 14(18) of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965. The respondent also contended that though there were three charges against the respondent, the enquiry officer did not put any question in regard to any evidence which was adduced against him during the enquiry. The respondent categorically contended that the enquiry officer had only put two generic questions in regard to charge No. 2 and charge No. 3 stipulating rebuttal of charges, but did not put any question regarding the evidence which had been recorded against the respondent and which was required to be explained by him. The respondent in the circumstances contended that the infirmity in the enquiry proceedings vitiates the entire enquiry and relied on ‘Ministry of Finance v. S.B Ramesh’, SLJ 1998 Vol. II SC page 67 holding that the failure of enquiry officer to put mandatory question on the charged officer regarding circumstances appearing against him would vitiate the entire enquiry proceedings.

    6. The respondent also objected to the enquiry officer directing the presenting officer to give his brief to refer to some extraneous material which was not produced during the enquiry. In the brief the presenting officer referred to the charge leveled against the respondent being investigated through Sh. V.B Gupta, Director, CEA regarding the frame size on the basis of which the Director General, AIR was directed to replace the Jyoti make alternator of the same size THJD-66-4-B3 with the alternator of the frame size as specified in the agreement. The presenting officer also referred to the advice of the CVC. Relying on the presenting officer's brief, it was contended that the chargesheet issued against the respondent was based merely on the enquiry report submitted by Sh. V.B Gupta, Director, CEA but surprisingly the basis on which the chargesheet was issued to the respondent was not given to the respondent. In the circumstances it was contended that even the enquiry officer could not have relied on preliminary enquiry without supplying a copy of the same to the respondent. It was further asserted that reliance of the enquiry officer on the report of Sh. V.B Gupta, a copy of which was not supplied to the respondent vitiates the entire enquiry proceedings. The respondent also objected to the appointment of Sh. Uppal as presenting officer and contended that his appointment had seriously prejudiced the case of the respondent as Sh. Uppal was one of the officers, who was concerned with the whole episode in respect of which the charges had been made against the respondent. Reliance was placed by the respondent on rule 57 of cpwd code. The respondent also relied on a letter by the presenting officer Sh. Uppal, who had not raised any objection in regard to any item accepted by the respondent. Relying on the testimonies of Sh. Manchanda who was the Chief Engineer in connection with the case of Sh. Lalit Kumar and Sh. D.C Banerjee who was the department witness in the case of Lalit Kumar, it was contended that they were categorical in stating that the frame size would not materially effect the capacity of the alternator as long as it satisfies other technical parameters without causing excessive heat in the winding. It was thus contended that the charges have not been made out even on the basis of the department witnesses. The respondent before the Tribunal also challenged the punishment imposed upon him on the ground that the UPSC recommendation which was relied upon by the Disciplinary Authority, a copy of which, as also a copy of the CVC report was not supplied to him, which was mandatory and thus the entire disciplinary proceedings were vitiated. In the circumstances the respondent had prayed that his application be allowed and the order of major penalty of withholding of two increments for a period of two years with cumulative effect be quashed.

    7. The petition was contested by the petitioners contending inter-alia that the respondent had not presented himself as defence witness and he was generally examined on 6 April, 1998 in accordance with Rule 14 sub Rule 18 of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965. Without categorically denying that the evidence adduced during the enquiry was not put to him, the petitioners contended that there has been no violation of Rule 14(18) of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965. The petitioners, however, did not deny that the questions put to the respondents were generic in nature e.g do you have anything else to say?; the prosecution has charged you with proposing over payment of Rs. 1.03 lakhs to the agency while recommending release of payment of part rate after accepting supply of LT panel. Your comment? Regarding the copies of recommendation of the UPSC and the advice of CVC, the petitioners contended that in his written statement of defence dated 27 July, 1996, the respondent had not sought for the copies of the documents. Regarding the appointment of Sh. A.J.S Uppal as presenting officer it was asserted on behalf of the petitioners that appointment was as per rules and there was no question of any prejudice caused to the respondent. Regarding the preliminary enquiry it was clarified that it was conducted by Sh. V.B Gupta, Director, CEA and not by Sh. Uppal. It was further contended that the duty of presenting officer is only to present the case for and on behalf of the disciplinary authority and, therefore, the question of bias cannot be attributed to him.

    8. The Tribunal after noting the pleas and contentions of the parties relied on State Bank of India v. D.C Aggarwal, (1993) 1 SCC 13 holding that it is obligated upon the department to serve a copy of the report of CVC along with the enquiry officer's report to the charged officer as the charged officer would be deprived of a reasonable opportunity in contravention of the principles of natural justice, if the copy of the report is not supplied to him. Taking into consideration the three questions put to the respondent the Tribunal noted that it is the Articles of Charge that had been put to the respondent and not the evidence adduced during the enquiry against him and, therefore, there was no valid compliance of Rule 14(18) of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965. In paragraph 6 of the order, the Tribunal held that there has been non compliance of Rule 14(18) of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 and the enquiry is also vitiated on account of non supply of CVC recommendations. The reasons and observations of the Tribunal are as under:-

    “6. It is trite that till the decision of the Tribunal is not overturned or modified, the same has precedent value and has to be followed under the doctrine of precedent. It is also trite that in a disciplinary proceeding, Courts/Tribunal cannot go into the correctness of the charge and re-appreciate the evidences by assumption of the role of appellant authority. It is open for the Courts/Tribunal to interfere in the matter only when the disciplinary proceedings are based on ‘no evidence’ ‘surmises’ and ‘conjectures’. Supply of CVC second stage advice has been made obligatory on the basis of D.C Aggarwal's case (Supra). It is also trite that administrative instructions, if not specific, would not be applied retrospectively. The decision in D.C Aggarwal's case (Supra) relied upon in the T.K Nath's case, has held that non-supply of CVC recommendations, which are administrative in nature along with the enquiry report, not only prejudice the concerned but deprived him of a reasonable opportunity to show cause against the enquiry report which ultimately affected the substantiate right of the applicant to effectively defend. The decision of the Apex Court is binding on us under Article 141 of the Constitution of India and we are in agreement with the decision of the Coordinate Bench decision in T.K Nath's case (Supra). We rule that non-supply of CVC second advice to the applicant has certainly prejudiced him in the enquiry, which vitiates the subsequent orders. In so far as Lalit Kumar's case is concerned, despite stay, we find that issue of CVC advice has been left open. Accordingly, stay of operation of our order would not be an impediment for us to rely upon in T.K Nath's case as well as D.C Aggarwal's case (Supra). The issue pertaining to punishment of withholding of two increments has been a matter of decision in an identical situated case of Harish Kumar v. Union of India OA-256/2002 decided on 5.2.2004 by the Jodhpur Bench of the Tribunal, wherein it is ruled that whereas increment can be withheld when one gets it and by no stretch of imagination two increments can be withheld in a year since one does not get them at all. From the perusal of penalty order, it is certain that penalty order is not in consonance with Rule 11 of CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965 as the same has been issued with a closed mind, which cannot be sustained in law. As regards violation of Rule 14(18) of CCS(CCA) Rules is concerned, CCS Rules are formulated for according a reasonable opportunity to a Government servant. One of the rules is that a delinquent is generally examined. The enquiry officer is obligated to put questions to the delinquent pertaining to the incriminating evidences, brought forth in the course of disciplinary proceedings, with an object sought to be achieved. Accordingly, Rule 14(18) considered by the Apex Court in OA-1826/98 decided on 14.9.2002 Charanjit Singh Khurana v. Union of India as well as by the Ministry of Finance v. S.B Ramesh 1998 (3) SCC 227. The same has been upheld as a mandatory valid compliance, which has been held to have caused prejudice and vitiated the enquiry in Lalit Kumar's case (Supra). In the facts and circumstances of the present case, what we find is that enquiry officer, on general examination of the applicant on 6.4.98, has only put him the article of charge alleged against him but incriminating evidence has not been put. This has deprived the applicant an opportunity of defence by virtue of Rule 14(18) OF THE Rules ibid, which is mandatory provision to be complied with and dispensation of which has not ruled either by the Apex Court or any pronouncement. Accordingly, Rule 14(18) has not been validly complied with, which has certainly caused prejudice to the applicant and deprived him to effectively rebut the circumstances appearing against him in the form of evidence. This has also vitiated the orders passed by the respondents subsequently. It is trite that it is incumbent upon the enquiry officer to serve a copy of document relied upon so that one gets an opportunity to defend. A reference of V.B Gupta's report, preliminary enquiry conducted before the disciplinary proceedings has been made. When the enquiry officer was brought to the notice the above objection, no finding has been recorded thereupon. Accordingly, once the evidence of witness where V.B Gupta's report has been mentioned has been relied upon having not been furnished to the applicant. He has been denied a reasonable opportunity to effectively defend the charges levelled against him.”

    9. The order of the Tribunal is challenged by the counsel for the petitioners primarily on the ground that the respondent was liable to show as to what prejudice had been caused to him on account of non supply of the copy of CVC report. The learned counsel for the petitioners has relied on (2010) 5 SCC 349, Union of India v. Alok Kumar holding that in terms of CVC circular dated 28 September, 2000 regarding non-furnishing of CVC's, first stage advice to the employee along with the chargesheet, disciplinary proceedings would be vitiated only if it is established that prejudice was caused to the employee in defending himself. It was also held that consultation with CVC is not a mandatory requirement. On the facts of the case the Supreme Court had held that there was nothing on record to show that CVC's advice was taken into consideration and it influenced the mind of the appointing authority and in the circumstances it was held that no prejudice was caused to the employee and failure to supply copies of CVC recommendation/advice would not vitiate the enquiry proceedings. Regarding non compliance of Rule 14(18) of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 it was contended that perusal of the record will reveal that the said provision has been complied with as three questions were put by the enquiry officer to the charged officer. The petitioner also contended that the supply of CVC's second stage advice was introduced by the instruction issued by CVC on 28 September, 2000 and they were prospective in nature whereas in the case of the respondent the enquiry report was submitted on 26 May, 1998 and the respondent had submitted his explanation to the same on 2nd February, 1999. The petitioners also contended that the enquiry officer in his enquiry report has not relied upon the preliminary enquiry conducted by Sh. V.B Gupta, therefore, no prejudice had been caused to the respondent on account of non supply of copy of the preliminary report.

    10. The learned counsel for the petitioner, Mr. Sudan also relied on (2007) 4 SCC 785, Union of India v. T.V Patel holding that consultation with Public Service Commission on all disciplinary matters under Article 320 (3)(c) is not mandatory and consequently absence of consultation or any irregularity in consultation process or in furnishing copy of advice tendered by Public Service Commission will not vitiate the enquiry.

    11. The petition is contested by the respondent, contending inter-alia that no material should have been relied upon by the enquiry officer, the copy of which had not been relied upon in the charge sheet and which had not been supplied to the charged officer. The reliance has been placed by the respondent on (1993) 1 SCC 13, ‘State Bank of India v. D.C Aggarwal’ holding that the material not supplied for showing to the charged officer cannot be taken into account by the Disciplinary authority in passing the order of punishment. In this matter, the enquiry officer had exonerated the charged officer however, the report was directed by the Bank, employer to be submitted through Central Vigilance Commission (CVC). The CVC however, disagreed with the report and recorded its finding of guilt and recommended imposition of major penalty of removal. The copy of recommendation of CVC was denied to the employee on the ground that the recommendation of CVC was a privileged document. The Disciplinary authority, however, relying on the recommendation of CVC disagreed with the report of the enquiry officer and imposed major punishment. The order of punishment passed by the Disciplinary authority was held to be vitiated for violation of principles of natural justice in denying the copy of the recommendation of CVC. The respondent also contended that the Central Vigilance Commission has also amended its rule vide Notification dated 28 September, 2000 which contemplated providing the second stage advice of CVC to the charged officer prior to imposition of penalty. The Commission held that it is consulted at two stages in Disciplinary proceeding i.e first stage advice is obtained on the investigation report before issue of the charge sheet and second stage advice is obtained either on receipt of reply to the charge sheet or on receipt of enquiry report. The Commission however, categorically noted that when the CVC second stage advice is obtained, a copy there of may be made available to the concerned employee along with the IOs report, to give him an opportunity to make representation against the IOs finding and CVC advice if he desires to do so. The relevant extract of CVC advice based on the judgment of the Supreme Court in D.C Aggrawal (Supra) is as under:-

    “3. The Commission, at present, is being consulted at two stages in disciplinary proceedings, i.e first stage advice is obtained on the investigation report before issue of the charge sheet, and second stage advice is obtained either on receipt of reply to the charge sheet or on receipt of enquiry report. It, however, does not seem necessary to call for the representation of the concerned employee on the first stage advice as the concerned employee, in any case, gets an opportunity to represent against the proposal for initiation of departmental proceedings against him. Therefore, a copy of the Commission's first stage advice may be made available to the concerned employee along with a copy of the charge sheet served upon him, for his information. However, when the CVC's second stage advice is obtained, a copy thereof may be made available to the concerned employee along with the IO's report, to give him an opportunity to make representation against IO's findings and the CVC's advice, if he desires to do so.”

    12. The respondent also contended that the rules provide for grant of only one increment in a year which can be withheld for a number of years, but if two increments are granted in a year, they cannot be withheld at the same time.

    13. Regarding non-compliance of the Rule 14(18) of CCS(CCA) Rules, the respondent asserted that he had not appeared as a witness during the enquiry, therefore, the enquiry officer was mandated to put the evidence adduced against him during the enquiry. Instead of putting the evidence adduced against him during the enquiry, the enquiry officer only repeated the charges which were against the respondent. It was contended that the rule is mandatory and non-compliance of the same would vitiate the enquiry proceedings. The respondent placed reliance on Ministry of Finance v. S.B Ramesh, SLJ 1998 (2) 67.

    14. This Court has heard the learned counsel for the parties in detail and has also perused the record. The learned counsel for the petitioner has relied on (2007) 4 SCC 785, ‘Union of India v. T.V Patel’ holding that where the Disciplinary authority sought advice of the UPSC before imposition of penalty on the delinquent officer, it was not necessary for the Disciplinary authority to make available the copy of the advice tendered by the UPSC to the delinquent officer so as to enable him to make effective representation to the punishment proposed, on the ground that the provisions of Article 320 (3)(c) of the Constitution of India are not mandatory and it does not confer any right on the public servant, so that the absence of consultation or any irregularity in consultation process or in furnishing a copy of the advice tendered by the UPSC, if any, does not afford the delinquent Government servant a cause of action in a Court of law. In this case the Disciplinary authority has sought advice of the UPSC which was tendered. After the Disciplinary authority passed the order, a copy of the advice tendered by the UPSC was also sent along with the copy of the final order imposing the penalty on the delinquent officer. In the circumstances, the question to be determined by the Supreme Court was whether a copy of advice tendered by the UPSC is to be furnished along with the order of penalty or before passing an order imposing final penalty. Referring to Rule 32 in Part-IX of CCS Rules, it was held that the rule contemplating “along with a copy of the order passed in the case by the authority making the order” would mean the final order passed by the authority imposing the penalty on the delinquent government servant. Consequently, relying on the judgment of the Constitution Bench in AIR 1957 SC 192, State Of U.P v. Manbodhan Lal Srivastava, it was held that the provisions of Rule 320 (3)(c) of the Constitution of India are not mandatory and they do not confer any rights on the public servant so that the absence of consultation or any irregularity in consultation process or in furnishing a copy of the advice tendered by the UPSC, if any, does not afford the delinquent Government servant a cause of action in a Court of law. Para 25 at page 793 of T.V Patel (Supra) is as under:-

    “25. In view of the law settled by the Constitution Bench of this Court in the case of Srivastava (supra) we hold that the provisions of Article 320(3)(c) of the Constitution of India are not mandatory and they do not confer any rights on the public servant so that the absence of consultation or any irregularity in consultation process or furnishing a copy of the advice tendered by the UPSC, if any, does not afford the delinquent government servant a cause of action in a court of law.”

    15. The learned counsel for the petitioner has also impugned the order of the Tribunal holding that non-supply of the CVC recommendation along with enquiry report not only prejudiced the concerned charged officer, but also deprived him of his reasonable opportunity to show cause against the enquiry report which ultimately affected the substantial right of the applicant to defend himself effectively.

    16. The learned counsel for the petitioner has however, relied on (2010) 5 SCC 349, ‘Union of India v. Alok Kumar’ to contend that non-supply of the CVC second stage advice will not vitiate the enquiry proceeding and the punishment imposed upon the respondent, as the respondent had not disclosed as to what prejudice had been caused to him. According to him, the prejudice being a matter of fact should have been categorically pleaded and demonstrated by cogent documents. It was further contended that de facto prejudice is one of the essential ingredients to be shown by the delinquent officer before an order of punishment could be set aside.

    17. In Alok Kumar (Supra), the Supreme Court had considered whether it is the duty of the Disciplinary authority to furnish the report of CVC and whether supply of CVC report arises out of a statutory rule or in consonance with the principles of natural justice and whether non-supply of such a report would cause any prejudice to the officer concerned. In the facts and circumstances of the case, it was held that there was nothing on record to show that CVC recommendations had actually been taken into consideration and the same had affected the mind of the Disciplinary authority while considering the defence of the delinquent officer and imposing punishment upon him. The Supreme Court had held that unless such notices were actually considered and had some prejudicial effect to the interest of the delinquent officer, it would not be necessary for the Court to interfere with the departmental enquiry. In Alok Kumar (Supra), the Supreme Court therefore, did not vitiate the enquiry proceeding on the ground that a copy of the CVC first stage recommendations/reports were not provided to the charged officer. Paras 78 & 79 at page 376 are as under:-

    “78. No rule has been brought to our notice where it is a mandatory requirement for the disciplinary authority to consult the vigilance officer and take the said report into consideration before passing any order. If that was the position, the matter would have been different.

    79. In the present case, firstly, no such rule has been brought to our notice and secondly, there is nothing on record to show that the alleged notes of the CVC were actually taken into consideration and the same effected or tainted the findings or mind of the authority while passing the orders of punishment. Thus, in our view, the findings of the Tribunal cannot be sustained in law. Unless the Rules so require, advice of the CVC is not binding. The advice tendered by the CVC, is to enable the disciplinary authority to proceed in accordance with law. In absence of any specific rule, that seeking advice and implementing thereof is mandatory, it will not be just and proper to presume that there is prejudice to the concerned officer. Even in the cases where the action is taken without consulting the Vigilance Commission, it necessarily will not vitiate the order of removal passed after inquiry by the departmental authority. Reference in this regard can also be made to the judgment of this Court in the cases of State of A.P v. Dr. Rahimuddin Kamal: 1997 (3) SCC 505 and Deokinandan Prasad v. State of Bihar: 1971 (2) SCC 330.”

    18. Though the Tribunal has held relying on D.C Aggarwal's case (supra) that non-supply of CVC recommendations has deprived the respondent of a reasonable opportunity to show cause against the enquiry report which ultimately affected the substantial rights of the respondent to effectively defend himself, however, the learned counsel for the respondent is unable to show as to how the CVC recommendations were taken into consideration by the Disciplinary authority, and how the case of the respondent has been prejudiced. It was incumbent upon the Tribunal to have considered whether there were any such CVC Notes or recommendations which had a direct bearing on the enquiry in question and whether such recommendations or Notes were actually taken into considerations by the Disciplinary authority while passing the impugned order and whether the respondent had suffered de facto prejudice as a result of non-furnishing of advice. In absence of these factors, the order of the Disciplinary authority imposing penalty on the respondent cannot be faulted, nor can the order of the Tribunal to this effect be sustained.

    19. The next contention on behalf of the petitioner is about the non-compliance of the Rule 14(18) of CCS(CCA) Rules. According to the petitioners, Rule 14(18) was substantially complied with. Perusal of the record, however, reveals that it is an admitted case that the respondent did not examine himself as a witness. In case the respondent had not examined himself as witness, it was incumbent upon the enquiry officer to put evidence adduced against the respondent during the enquiry to him in compliance of Rule 14(18) of CCS(CCA) Rules. The said rule had been enacted with a view that whatever evidence comes in the enquiry, explanation may be sought to rebut the circumstances, which would be in the consonance with the principle of reasonable opportunity and audi alterm partum as inbuilt in the principles of natural justice. On perusal of the questions put by the enquiry officer to the respondent, it is apparent that out of the three articles of charges, only two articles of charge were put to the respondent, while none of the evidence in support of those articles of charges which were against the respondent were put to him.

    20. Perusal of Rule 14(18) clearly reveals that it is obligatory upon the enquiry authority to question the delinquent officer on the circumstances appearing against him in the evidence, for the purpose of enabling him to explain any circumstance. As there is no reference to the evidence brought on record or circumstances appearing against the applicant, putting the charges against the respondent was not valid compliance of Rule 14(18) of the CCS(CCA) Rules 1965.

    21. Provisions analogous to Rule 14(18) of CCS(CCA) Rule exist in rule 9(21) of railway servant (discipline & appeal) rules, 1958. In the matter of Moni Shankar v. Union of India, 2008 (1) AJW 479, an enquiry proceeding was conducted in which the following questions that were put to the Charged Officer: “please state if you plead guilty?” ; “Do you wish to submit your oral or written arguments?”; “Are you satisfied with the enquiry proceeding” and “Can I conclude the enquiry?”, were held to be not in compliance of rule 9(21) of railway servant (discipline & appeal) rules, 1958 as such type of questions did not reveal the evidence adduced in support of charges against the charged officer.

    22. In Ministry of Finance v. S.B Ramesh, (1998) 3 SCC 227 the Supreme Court had held the Rule 14 (18) of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 to be mandatory. The Apex Court had upheld the decision of the Tribunal holding that the order of the Disciplinary Authority was based on no evidence and that the findings were perverse, on the reasoning that even if the Enquiry Officer had set the applicant ex parte and recorded the evidence, he should have adjourned the hearing to another date to enable the applicant to participate in the enquiry thereafter. Or even if the Enquiry Authority did not choose to give the applicant an opportunity to cross-examine the witness examined in support of the charge, he should have given an opportunity to the applicant to appear and then proceeded to question him under Sub-rule (18) of Rule 14 of the CCS (CCA) Rules. The omission to do this was construed to be a serious error committed by the Enquiry Authority. This also cannot be disputed that if the charged officer has examined himself as a witness then it will not be obligatory to examine the charged officer under Rule 14(18) of CCS(CCA) Rules. However, in the absence of any defense statement by the charged official, it was mandatory on the part of the enquiry officer to examine him under Rule 14(18), and the non-compliance of which will vitiate the enquiry proceedings.

    23. Consequently, the order of the Tribunal quashing the enquiry proceeding on account of non-compliance of Rule 14(18) of CCS(CCA) Rules 1965 by not putting the evidence adduced before the enquiry officer in support of the three articles of charge to the charged officer vitiates the enquiry proceeding, cannot be termed to be illegal or unsustainable so as to require any interference by this Court in exercise of its jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.

    24. In the circumstances, the order of the Tribunal setting aside the punishment awarded to the respondent does not require any interference in the facts and circumstances of the case and the writ petition is therefore, dismissed. The parties are however, left to bear their own costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Union Of India Throu... v. Tarlok Singh
    (Mar 10, 2011)