AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner challenged respondents' decision not to grant him benefits under the Persons with Disabilities (Equal Opportunities, Protection of Rights and Full Participation) Act, 1995 ("the Act"). He joined the erstwhile Haryana State Electricity Board on a work‑charged basis on 27.7.1970, was appointed ALM (T) on 21.8.1981 and appointed ALM on regular basis on 22.5.1982. After an accident on 7.8.1999 his left forearm was amputated four inches below the elbow and he was declared 70% disabled. The Medical Board declared him unfit to continue as ALM. By a memo dated 1.8.2000 he was provided alternative employment as a Meter Reader but was placed at the tail‑end of Meter Readers' seniority and was made to lose his seniority in the cadre of ALMs. The petitioner accepted the terms under protest and contended that this action contravened Section 47 of the Act and effectively deprived him of his past service benefits and promotion prospects. He also asserted that juniors in the ALM cadre received Assured Career Progression and other benefits which were denied to him.

The petitioner filed a writ petition in this court impugning respondents' action. The court heard counsel for both sides, considered Section 47 of the Act and relevant precedents cited by the petitioner, and on the merits quashed the condition placing the petitioner at the tail‑end of Meter Readers' seniority. The respondents were directed to calculate and grant benefits to which the petitioner may be entitled treating him in the seniority of ALMs as he was before the accident; however, payment of arrears, if any, was restricted to 38 months from the date of filing of the writ petition. The writ petition was disposed of.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the respondents' action of placing the petitioner at the tail‑end of the seniority list of Meter Readers and depriving him of his ALM seniority and related service benefits after he acquired a disability during service violated Section 47 of the Persons with Disabilities Act, 1995.
  2. Whether the petitioner is entitled to be treated, for purposes of seniority, promotion and other service benefits, as having continued in the ALM seniority stream for the period prior to his adjustment to Meter Reader and thereby to receive arrears and benefits lost as a result of the respondents' action.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner acquired 70% disability in service due to an accident and was declared unfit for his ALM post by the Medical Board.
  • He was provided alternative employment as a Meter Reader but the memo of 1.8.2000 arbitrarily stated that he would lose his ALM seniority and be placed at the tail‑end of Meter Readers' seniority, effectively depriving him of his prior service benefits and seniority.
  • That action contravenes Section 47 of the Act which prohibits dispensing with or reducing in rank an employee who acquires disability and provides that such an employee, if unsuitable for the post held, should be shifted to another post with the same pay scale and service benefits or kept on a supernumerary post until a suitable post is available or superannuation.
  • He cited Kunal Singh v. Union of India (2003) 4 SCC 524, Bhagwan Dass v. Punjab State Electricity Board (2008) 1 SCC 579 and Dhanmanti Devi v. State of Haryana, 2008 (6) SLR 250 to show that the respondents' action was illegal and arbitrary and that he should be granted the benefits due to him.

Respondents' Arguments

  • Once the petitioner was unable to perform the duties of ALM, he was assigned the duty of Meter Reader and was placed in the seniority of Meter Readers from the date he assumed charge in that post.
  • Respondents admitted that persons junior to the petitioner in the ALM cadre had been granted certain benefits to which they were entitled based on their length of service while performing those duties.
  • The respondents' position, as stated in court, was that the petitioner was adjusted as a Meter Reader from the date he took charge and thus placed in that seniority stream from that date.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kunal Singh v. Union of India, (2003) 4 SCC 524 Interpretation and mandatory effect of Section 47 of the Persons with Disabilities Act, 1995: employer shall not dispense with or reduce in rank an employee who acquires disability during service; such an employee must be shifted to another post with same pay/benefits or kept on supernumerary post; no promotion shall be denied merely on ground of disability. The court relied upon Kunal Singh to underscore the mandatory protection under Section 47, to reject respondents' contention that medical invalidation and pension rules (e.g., Rule 38 CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972) could override Section 47, and to support the conclusion that the petitioner could not be deprived of past service benefits or placed at the tail‑end of a new cadre merely because of disability.
Bhagwan Dass v. Punjab State Electricity Board, (2008) 1 SCC 579 Application of Section 47 principles in service‑related contexts involving employees who acquire disability while in service. The court noted that Bhagwan Dass is in line with Kunal Singh and treated it as supporting authority for the mandatory protections of Section 47.
Dhanmanti Devi v. State of Haryana, 2008 (6) SLR 250 Application of Section 47 principles (as reflected in earlier precedents) to cases of employees acquiring disability during service. The court referenced Dhanmanti Devi as another decision consistent with the principle that Section 47 protects employees who acquire disability during service and that they should not be deprived of service benefits or promotions merely due to disability.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by identifying Section 47 of the Persons with Disabilities Act, 1995, and reproducing its material provisions which forbid dispensing with or reducing in rank an employee who acquires a disability during service, require shifting the employee to another post with the same pay and service benefits if he is not suitable for the original post, and provide that no promotion shall be denied merely on grounds of disability.

The court analyzed the principles set out by the Supreme Court in Kunal Singh, emphasizing the mandatory and protective character of Section 47. Kunal Singh was used to illustrate that a social beneficial enactment intended to secure equal opportunities for disabled persons must be construed so as to advance its object; Section 47 casts a statutory obligation on the employer to protect an employee who acquires disability during service. The court also noted Kunal Singh's rejection of any argument that other service or pension rules (e.g., invalidity pension rules) could be used to deny the protections of Section 47.

Applying these principles to the facts, the court found the memo of 1.8.2000 placing the petitioner at the tail‑end of Meter Readers and depriving him of ALM seniority and past service benefits to be contrary to the spirit and mandate of Section 47. The court characterized that action as effectively punishing the petitioner without fault and as an arbitrary deprivation of the benefits of his prior service. The court observed that while the petitioner could legitimately be assigned to a Meter Reader post or another post he could perform, that assignment could not justify stripping him of his accrued seniority and service benefits arising from his prior ALM service.

Consequently, the court quashed the condition in the memo that placed the petitioner at the tail‑end of Meter Readers' seniority. It directed respondents to calculate and grant all benefits to which the petitioner may be entitled treating him in the seniority of ALMs as he stood before the accident; however, the court limited payment of arrears, if any, to 38 months from the date of filing of the writ petition.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The writ petition is disposed of and the condition placing the petitioner at the tail‑end of the seniority of Meter Readers (thereby depriving him of his ALM seniority and related past service benefits) is quashed.

Direct consequences for the parties:

  • The respondents are directed to treat the petitioner for the purpose of seniority and related service benefits as if he remained in the ALM seniority stream where he was placed prior to the accident, and to calculate and grant all benefits accordingly.
  • Payment of arrears, if any, is restricted to 38 months from the date of filing of the writ petition.

Broader implications: The court relied on established precedents emphasizing the mandatory nature of Section 47; the opinion applies those principles to the present facts but does not purport to lay down a new principle of law beyond affirming that employees who acquire disability during service cannot be deprived of accrued seniority and benefits consistent with Section 47.

    Sahib Singh Petitioner v. Uttar Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Limited And Others S

    Rajesh Bindal J.

    1. The petitioner has approached this court impugning the action of the respondents in not granting him the benefits, to which he is entitled to in terms of the provisions of the Persons with Disabilities (Equal Opportunities, Protection of Rights and Full Participation) Act, 1995 (for short, ‘the Act’).

    2. Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the petitioner joined service of the erstwhile Haryana State Electricity Board on work-charged basis on 27.7.1970 On 21.8.1981, he was appointed as ALM (T) on temporary basis, however, vide order dated 22.5.1982, he was appointed ALM on regular basis. On account of an unfortunate accident on 7.8.1999, left forearm of the petitioner had to be amputated four inches below elbow, which resulted in disability to the extent of 70%. The Medical Board declared the petitioner unfit for rendering service as ALM. Keeping in view the provisions of the Act, the petitioner was provided with alternative job of Meter Reader, however, it was arbitrarily mentioned in the order dated 1.8.2000 that the petitioner will lose his seniority in the cadre of ALMs and will be placed at the tail-end of the seniority of Meter Readers. The petitioner having no choice accepted the terms, which run contrary to the mandate of Section 47 of the Act, which inter-alia provides that no promotion shall be denied to a person merely on the ground of disability. As the petitioner was placed at the tail-end of the seniority of Meter Readers, in fact, the entire service rendered by him prior thereto was taken away. It is nothing else but a kind of punishment without any fault. He further submitted that persons, who were juniors to the petitioner in the seniority list of ALMs, have been granted Assured Career Progression Scheme and other benefits, but the petitioner has been denied the same. While referring to the judgments in Kunal Singh v. Union of India, (2003) 4 SCC 524; Bhagwan Dass v. Punjab State Electricity Board, (2008) 1 SCC 579 and Dhanmanti Devi v. State of Haryana, 2008 (6) SLR 250, it was submitted that action of the respondents, being illegal and arbitrary, deserves to be set aside and the petitioner be granted the benefits due to him.

    3. On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondents submitted that once the petitioner was unable to perform the duty of ALM, he was assigned the duty as a Meter Reader and was placed in the seniority of Meter Readers from the date he assumed his charge as such. He did not dispute the fact that persons junior to the petitioner as ALM have been granted certain benefits, to which they were entitled to, on account of their length of service, as they had been performing those duties.

    4. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the paper book.

    5. Before this court proceeds to consider the case of the petitioner on merits, it would be appropriate to deal with the legal issue involved therein. Section 47 of the Act, which is relevant, is extracted below:

    47. Non-discrimination in Government Employment - (1) No establishment shall dispense with, or reduce in rank, an employee who acquires a disability during his service:

    Provided that, if an employee, after acquiring disability is not suitable for the post he was holding, could be shifted to some other post with the same pay scale and service benefits:

    Provided further that if it is not possible to adjust the employee against any post, he may be kept on a supernumerary post until a suitable post is available or he attains the age of superannuation, whichever is earlier.

    (2) No promotion shall be denied to a person merely on the ground of his disability:

    Provided that the appropriate Government may, having regard to the type of work carried on in any establishment, by notification and subject to such conditions, if any, as may be specified in such notification, exempt any establishment from the provisions of this section.”

    6. The issue was considered by Hon'ble the Supreme Court in Kunal Singh's case (supra). It pertains to a Constable, who was working in Special Service Bureau. While on duty, he suffered an injury in his leg, which had to be amputated on account of gangrene, which developed from the injury. He was invalidated from service on the basis of a report of the Medical Board, which declared him permanently incapacitated for further service. Setting aside order of his discharge from service, Hon'ble the Supreme Court directed for grant of benefits to the appellant therein as available in view of Section 47 of the Act. The issue pertaining to Service Rules, which entitled an employer to discharge or retire such a person, was also considered in the light of Section 47 of the Act. The relevant paragraphs of the judgement are extracted below:

    “9. Chapter VI of the Act deals with employment relating to persons with disabilities, who are yet to secure employment. Section 47, which falls in Chapter VIII, deals with an employee, who is already in service and acquires a disability during his service. It must be borne in mind that Section 2 of the Act has given distinct and different definitions of “disability” and “person with disability”. It is well settled that in the same enactment if two distinct definitions are given defining a word/expression, they must be understood accordingly in terms of the definition. It must be remembered that a person does not acquire or suffer disability by choice. An employee, who acquires disability during his service, is sought to be protected under Section 47 of the Act specifically. Such employee, acquiring disabilty, if not protected, would not only suffer himself, but possibly all those who depend on him would also suffer. The very frame and contents of Section 47 clearly indicate its mandatory nature. The very opening part of the Section reads “no establishment shall dispense with, or reduce in rank, an employee who acquires a disability during his service”. The section further provides that if an employee after acquiring disability is not suitable for the post he was holding, could be shifted to some other post with the same pay scale and service benefits; if it is not possible to adjust the employee against any post he will be kept on a supernumerary post until a suitable post is available or he attains the age of superannuation, whichever is earlier. Added to this no promotion shall be denied to a person merely on the ground of his disability as is evident from sub-section (2) of Section 47. Section 47 contains a clear directive that the employer shall not dispense with or reduce in rank an employee who acquires a disability during the service. In construing a provision of a social beneficial enactment that too dealing with disabled persons intended to give them equal opportunities, protection of rights and full participation, the view that advances the object of the Act and serves its purpose must be preferred to the one which onstructs the object and paralyses the purpose of the Act. Language of Section 47 is plain and certain casting statutory obligation on the employer to protect an employee acquiring disability during service.

    xx xx xx

    12. Merely because under Rule 38 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972, the appellant got invalidity pension is no ground to deny the protection mandatorily made available to the appellant under Section 47 of the Act. Once it is held that the appellant has acquired disability during his service and if found not suitable for the post he was holding, he could be shifted to some other post with same pay scale and service benefits; if it was not possible to adjust him against any post, he could be kept on a supernumerary post until a suitable post was available or he attains the age of superannuation, whichever is earlier. It appears no such efforts were made by the respondents. They have proceeded to hold that he was permanently incapacitated to continue in service without considering the effect of other provisions of Section 47 of the Act.”

    7. In similar line are the judgments in Bhagwan Dass's case (supra) and Dhanmanti Devi's case (supra).

    8. Now coming to the facts of the present case. Undisputedly, the petitioner was working as ALM on regular basis with the respondents when he met with an accident on 7.8.1999 On account of amputation of his left forearm four inches below the elbow, he was declared 70% disabled. As the petitiner was no more able to perform his duty as ALM, he was given light job of Meter Reader vide memo dated 1.8.2000 In the aforesaid memo, a condition was put in that the petitioner will lose his seniority in the cadre of ALMs and will be placed at the tail-end of seniority of Meter Readers. This condition certainly goes against the spirit of Section 47 of the Act, which provides that no establishment shall dispense with or reduce in rank an employee who acquires disability during service. However, in case an employee if he acquires disability is not suitable for the post he was holding, he could be shifted to some post with same pay scale and service benefits. In the case in hand, the action of the respondents in taking away the benefits of the past service of the petitioner till such time he was adjusted on the post of Meter Reader is totally contrary to the spirit of Section 47 of the Act. It is nothing else but a punishment without any fault of the petitioner. He may have been assigned the duty of a Meter Reader as he was capable of performing the same or he may have been assigned any other duty as well carrying some pay scales or service benefits, but by no means he could be deprived of his past service or the benefits accruing to him subsequent to his adjustment on the new post taking into consideration his past service. In the present case, the petitioner has been denied that benefit. As the persons junior to the petitioner in the cadre of ALMs, have been granted certain benefits to which they became entitled to considering their length of service as ALM, however, the petitioner was denied those benefits as he was considered as freshly appointed Meter Reader on 1.8.2000 Such an action has to be declared illegal and arbitrary. Ordered accordingly. The condition that the petitioner will be placed at the tail-end of the seniority of Meter Readers is quashed. The respondents are directed to calculate all the benefits to which the petitioner may be entitled to considering him in the seniority of ALMs where he was placed before the accident took place and grant him the same. However, it is directed that payment of arrears, if any, shall be restricted to 38 months from the date of filing of the writ petition.

    9. The writ petition stands disposed of.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sahib Singh Petitioner v. Uttar Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Limited And Others S
    (Jan 9, 2013)