Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

M/s. Mundra Port and Special Economic Zone Limited (the appellant) is engaged in providing port services and is registered for service tax under "Port Services", "Storage and Warehousing Services" and "Cargo Handling Services". The appellant availed Cenvat Credit on service tax paid for input services used in providing output services. Show cause notices were issued questioning the entitlement to credit on excise duty paid on cement and steel used in constructing new jetties and other commercial buildings, as well as on air conditioners and various services. The appellant denied these allegations, asserting that the cement, steel, and services qualified as inputs and input services under the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004. The Commissioner of Central Excise confirmed the demand with interest and penalty. The appellant appealed to the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (Tribunal), which upheld the demand to the extent of cement and steel used in jetty and port building construction. The appellant challenged this Tribunal order by filing the present Tax Appeal under section 35G of the Central Excise Act, 1944.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, on the facts and circumstances of the case, the Tribunal was justified in law in rejecting the appellant's claim for Cenvat credit on cement and steel used in constructing the jetty and port buildings, in light of the provisions of Rule 2(k) of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant is a service provider, not a manufacturer or factory, and therefore the provisions of Explanation 2 of Rule 2(k) (which restrict input credit to manufacturers) do not apply to them.
  • Cement and steel used in jetty construction qualify as "inputs" under Rule 2(k) of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004, entitling the appellant to claim input credit.
  • The jetty was constructed by a contractor using materials provided by the appellant, and since the appellant is a taxable service provider, input credit should be allowed.
  • The appellant relied on the Division Bench judgment of the Andhra Pradesh High Court in Commissioner of Central Excise, Visakhapatnam-II Vs. Sai Sahmita Storages (P) Limited, which held that goods used by a provider of taxable service for providing an output service are eligible for Cenvat credit.

Respondent's Arguments

  • Reliance on the Larger Bench decision of the Tribunal in Vandana Global Limited Vs. Commissioner of Central Excise, which suggested that the amendment to Explanation 2 of Rule 2(k) was clarificatory and restricted input credit.
  • Argument that since the jetty construction is an exempted service, input credit on materials used in its construction should not be allowed.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Commissioner of Central Excise, Visakhapatnam-II Vs. Sai Sahmita Storages (P) Limited, 2011 (270) E.L.T. 33 (A.P.) Interpretation of Rule 2(k) of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 regarding eligibility of goods used by a service provider for input credit The Court found this precedent squarely applicable, supporting the appellant's entitlement to input credit on cement and steel used for jetty construction.
Vandana Global Limited Vs. Commissioner of Central Excise, 2010 (253) E.L.T. 440 (Larger Bench of Tribunal) Interpretation of amendments to Explanation 2 of Rule 2(k) of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 The Court rejected the Larger Bench's view that the amendment was clarificatory and prospective, finding no legislative intent for clarification and thus not applicable to the appellant's case.
Sangam Spinners Limited Vs. Union of India and others, (2011) 11 SCC 408 Interpretation of legislative amendments and their retrospective or prospective application The Court held this precedent inapplicable to the instant case due to lack of evidence that the amendment was clarificatory.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the definition of "input" under Rule 2(k) of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004, including Explanation 2, which restricts inputs to goods used in the manufacture of capital goods within a factory. It noted that the appellant is a service provider, not a manufacturer or factory, and that the disputed credit relates to cement and steel used in constructing a jetty within the port premises. The Court observed that the amendment to Explanation 2 was made effective from 7.7.2009 and was not clarificatory but a substantive amendment, thus not applicable retrospectively. The Court accepted the appellant's argument and the Andhra Pradesh High Court precedent that goods used by a service provider in providing output service qualify as inputs eligible for credit. The Court rejected the respondent's contention that input credit should be denied because jetty construction is an exempted service, holding that the appellant's provision of materials for construction entitles it to the credit. Consequently, the Court set aside the Tribunal's order denying credit on cement and steel.

Holding and Implications

The Tax Appeal is allowed.

The Court reversed the Tribunal's denial of input credit to the appellant on excise duty paid on cement and steel used in jetty construction. The appellant is entitled to claim this input credit. The decision clarifies that service providers constructing capital assets like jetties using their own materials are eligible for input credit under Rule 2(k) of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004, before the 2009 amendment. No new precedent beyond this case's direct effect was established.

    Mundra Ports & Special Economic Zone Limited (S) v. Commissioner Of Central Excise & Customs Opponent(S)

    JUDGMENT

    V.M. Sahai, Actg. C.J.

    1. This Tax Appeal filed under section 35G of the Central Excise Act, 1944 is directed against the order No. A/2122/WZB/AHD/08 dated 8.5.2008/30.9.2008 in Appeal No. ST/160/07 passed by the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal, Ahmedabad.

    2. The short facts of the present case are that M/s. Mundra Port and Special Economic Zone Limited, Mundra Port, Mundra - appellant herein is inter alia engaged in providing Port Services. The appellant is registered for service tax under the taxing entries of "Port Services", "Storage and Warehousing Services" and "Cargo Handling Services". The appellant uses/consumes various input services during the course of providing output services. The appellant avails Cenvat Credit of the Service Tax paid on such input services. A show cause notice No. V.ST/AR-G.dham/COMMR/035/2006 dated 17.4.2006 was issued wherein the appellant was asked to show cause as to why credit of the excise duty paid on the cement and steel used in the construction of new jetties and other commercial buildings should not be denied to them. The appellant filed a reply dated 5.7.2006 to the show cause notice. In the said reply, the appellant denied the allegations made in the show cause notice in their entirety and submitted that the cenvat credit of the excise duty paid on cement and steel was available to them as they qualified as inputs as defined under the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004. A second show cause notice No. V.ST/AR-G.dham/COMMR/032/2007 dated 13.4.2007 was issued wherein the appellant was asked to show cause as to why credit of (a) excise duty paid on the cement and steel used in the construction of new jetties and other commercial buildings should not be denied to them; (b) excise duty paid on air conditioners installed in the premises of the appellant and used by the electrical department should not be denied to them; and (c) service tax paid on various services such as CHA Fees, Surveyors fees, Rent-a-cab operator, bank charges, labour charges, installation charges etc. should not be denied to them. The appellant filed a reply dated 1.6.2007 to the second show cause notice. In the said reply, the appellant denied the allegations made in the show cause notice in their entirety and submitted that the cenvat credit of the excise duty paid on cement and steel was available to them as they qualified as "inputs" and the services on used by the appellant were "input services" as defined under the Credit Rules. A personal hearing in respect of both the show cause notices took place on 26.6.2007 wherein the factual background of the appellant was discussed in detail and in view of the nature of the business of the appellant, the submissions in the show cause notice replies on input and input services were reiterated.

    3. The Commissioner of Central Excise, Rajkot vide common order dated 26.7.2007 in respect of both the show cause notices confirmed the demand along with interest and penalty upholding the allegations made in the show cause notices. Against which, the appellant preferred the appeal before the Tribunal. By the impugned order, to the extent cement and steel are used in the construction of jetty and port building are concerned, the Tribunal held that the same are not eligible inputs used in providing output service and accordingly confirmed the demand on this account. The said order of the Tribunal has been challenged in the present Tax Appeal.

    4. This Tax Appeal has been admitted on 22.1.2009 on the following substantial question of law.

    "Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal was justified in law in rejecting the claim of the assessee in light of the provisions of Rule 2(k) of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004?"

    5. We have heard Mr. Hardik Modh, learned counsel for the appellant and Mr. Y.N. Ravani, learned counsel for the respondent.

    6. Before deciding the question, we deem it appropriate to extract Rule 2(k) and 2(l) of the Cenvat Credit Rules 2004.

    "Rule 2(k) "input" means-

    (i) all goods, except light diesel oil, high speed diesel oil and motor spirit, commonly known as petrol, used in or in relation to the manufacture of final products whether directly or indirectly and whether contained in the final product or not and includes lubricating oils, greases, cutting oils, coolants, accessories of the final products cleared along with the final product, goods used as paint, or as packing material, or as fuel, or for generation of electricity or steam used in or in relation to manufacture of final products or for any other purpose, within the factory of production;

    (ii) all goods, except light diesel oil, high speed diesel oil, motor spirit, commonly known as petrol and motor vehicles, used for providing any output service;

    Explanation 1. - The light diesel oil, high speed diesel oil or motor spirit, commonly known as petrol, shall not be treated as an input for any purpose whatsoever.

    Explanation 2. - Input include goods used in the manufacture of capital goods which are further used in the factory of the manufacturer;

    (l) "input service" means any service,-

    (i) used by the manufacturer, whether directly or indirectly, in or in relation to the manufacture of final products and clearance of final products upto the place of removal, and includes service used in relation to setting up, modernization, renovation or repairs of a factory, premises of provider of output service or an office relating to such factory or premises, advertisement or sales promotion, market research, storage upto the place of removal, procurement of inputs, activities relating to business, such as accounting, auditing, financing, recruitment and quality control, coaching and training, computer networking, credit rating, share registry, and security, inward transportation of inputs or capital goods and outward transportation upto the place of removal."

    7. It is not disputed that jetty was constructed and input credit was claimed on cement and steel. The aforesaid definition of Rule 2(k) was applicable and Explanation 2 did not provide that cement and steel would not be eligible for input credit. According to learned counsel for the appellant, the appellant is not manufacturer and, therefore, the provisions Explanation 2 of Rule 2(k) would be applicable only to the factory and manufacturer. The appellant is neither having any factory nor he is manufacturer. The appellant is a service provider of port. We need not go into this question as to whether the appellant is a factory or manufacturer or service provider in view of the fact that it is not disputed by Mr. Y.N. Ravani, learned counsel appearing for the revenue in this Tax Appeal that the appellant provides service on port for which he is getting jetty constructed through the contractor and the appellant has claimed input credit on cement and steel. The cement and steel were not included in Explanation 2 from 2004 upto March 2006. The Cenvet Credit Rules 2004 were amended in exercise of the powers conferred by section 37 of the Central Excise Act 1944 with effect from 7.7.2009, the date on which it was notified by the Central Government from the date of the notification. According to learned counsel for the appellant, this amended definition would apply only to the factory or manufacturer and would not apply to the service provider. According to him, either before the amendment made in the year 2009 or thereafter, the appellant was neither factory nor manufacturer and he has only constructed jetty by use of cement and steel for which he was entitled for input credit as jetty was constructed by the contractor, but the jetty is situated within the port area and the appellant is a service provider. According to the appellant, his case is squarely covered by the judgment of the Division Bench of the Andhra Pradesh High Court in Commissioner of Central Excise, Visakhapatnam-II Vs. Sai Sahmita Storages (P) Limited, 2011 (270) E.L.T. 33 (A.P.) wherein in paragraph 7, it has been clearly held that a plain reading of the definition of Rule 2(k) would demonstrate that all the goods used in relation to manufacturer of final product or for any other purpose used by a provider of taxable service for providing an output service are eligible for CENVAT credit. It is not in dispute that the appellant is a taxable service provider on port under the category of port services. Therefore, the appellant was entitled for input credit and the decision of the Division Bench of the Andhra Pradesh High Court squarely applies to the facts of the case and answered the question on which the appeal has been admitted.

    8. Mr. Y.N. Ravani, learned counsel for the revenue has placed reliance on the decision of the Larger Bench of the Tribunal in Vandana Global Limited Vs. Commissioner of Central Excise, Raipur, 2010 (253) E.L.T. 440. We have carefully gone through the decision of the Larger Bench of the Tribunal. We do not find that amendment made in Cenvet Credit Rules 2004 which come into force on 7.7.2009 was clarificatory amendment as there is nothing to suggest in the Amending Act that amendment made in Explanation 2 was clarificatory in nature. Wherever the legislature wants to clarify the provision, it clearly mentions intention in the notification itself and seeks to clarify existing provision. Even, if the new provision is added then it will be new amendment and cannot be treated to be clarification of particular thing or goods and/or input and as such, the amendment could operate only prospectively. In our opinion, the view taken by the Tribunal is based on conjectures and surmises as the Larger Bench of the Tribunal used the expression that intention behind amendment was to clarify. The coverage under the input from where this intention has been gathered by the Tribunal has not been mentioned in the judgment. There is no material to support that there was any legislative intent to clarify any existing provision. For the same reason, as mentioned above, the decision of the Apex Court in Sangam Spinners Limited Vs. Union of India and others, reported in (2011) 11 SCC 408 would not be applicable to the facts of the instant case.

    9. Mr. Ravani has also vehemently urged that since jetty was constructed by the appellant through the contractor and construction of jetty is exempted and, therefore, input credit would not be available to the appellant as construction of jetty is exempted service. The argument though attractive cannot be accepted. The jetty is constructed by the appellant by purchasing iron, cement, grid etc. which are used in construction of jetty. The contractor has constructed jetty. There are two methods, one is that the appellant would have given entire contract to the contractor for making jetty by giving material on his end and then make the payment, the other method was that the appellant would have provided material to the contractor and labour contract would have been given. The appellant claims that he has provided cement, steel etc. for which he was entitled for input credit and, therefore, in our opinion, the appellant was entitled for input credit and it cannot be treated that since construction of jetty was exempted, the appellant would not be entitled for input credit. The view taken contrary by the Tribunal deserves to be set aside.

    10. For the reasons given above, this Tax Appeal succeeds and is allowed. The denial of input credit to the appellant by the respondent is set aside. The appellant would be entitled for input credit. The question is answered in favour of the assessee appellant and against the department. No order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mundra Ports & Speci... v. Commissioner Of Cent...
    (Apr 29, 2015)